‘Shroud of secrecy' over investigation into Bruce Lehrmann rape accusations, lawyer tells court
Bruce Lehrmann's lawyer had told a court there appears to be a 'shroud of secrecy' over an investigation into allegations the former Liberal party staffer raped a woman after a night out.
Lehrmann will face trial accused of raping a woman twice during the morning of 10 October 2021, after they met at a strip club the previous night in Toowoomba, west of Brisbane.
The case was mentioned in Toowoomba district court on Thursday.
His lawyer Zali Burrows complained to Judge Dennis Lynch that the prosecution was not disclosing information she sought from its brief of evidence.
Sign up for Guardian Australia's breaking news email
'In respect to the status of the brief, there does appear to be a shroud of secrecy over the investigation of this matter,' she said.
Burrows claimed the prosecution had not confirmed if there were any police notebooks or diary entries relating to the investigation, which she said was 'pretty concerning'.
The defence also received 200 heavily redacted pages of the alleged victim's phone records out of 2200 identified in a report.
'It stands materially that it has cherrypicked the text exchanges, which is quite concerning,' Ms Burrows told Lynch.
'It's not a case of the crown determining what is materially relevant to the defence case.
'We are having issues with full-service redactions and what we view as non-disclosure of police notebooks and diaries.'
The defence has filed an application for full access to the alleged victim's unredacted phone records and disclosure of all police notebooks, diaries, emails and text messages in respect to the investigation.
Burrows expects that once this material is handed over, it will provide extra evidence for the defence's case.
At an earlier hearing, Burrows applied for a complete consolidated brief of evidence after claiming the defence was missing nine witness statements and also important CCTV recordings.
She confirmed on Thursday that this material was provided but there had been an issue with the video files.
Sign up to Breaking News Australia
Get the most important news as it breaks
after newsletter promotion
The matter was adjourned for a hearing on 20 June.
Lehrmann has not yet entered a pleas but his legal team in Toowoomba had indicated he would defend the charges.
Lehrmann, 29, was formerly employed as a ministerial staffer in the Parliament House office of Liberal senator Linda Reynolds.
The alleged victim previously told Toowoomba magistrates court she consumed cocaine with Lehrmann during a night out before consensual sex at a house in the rural city's east about 4am.
The woman said she was woken about 10am by Lehrmann sexually assaulting her.
Lehrmann's former defence barrister Andrew Hoare said at a prior committal hearing that the alleged victim was too intoxicated to remember giving consent and Lehrmann could have mistakenly believed he had consent for further sex acts.
His former solicitor Rowan King previously told Lynch their legal team would apply for the trial to be heard without a jury, with a judge determining the verdict.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mail
35 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
Kids allegedly spotted carrying lethal weapons at a busy shopping centre just days after they were banned
A popular Melbourne shopping centre was sent into lockdown on Friday evening after a group of boys were seen allegedly carrying machetes days after a ban came into effect. The group of five-to-six boys were seen arguing inside Caroline Springs Shopping Centre in the west Melbourne suburb of Caroline Springs, at about 6.40pm. A Victoria Police spokesperson told Daily Mail Australia the boys were believed to have been armed with machetes and had fled by the time officers arrived at the scene. CCTV footage obtained by Nine News showed shoppers and retailers as they scrambled to avoid the armed mob who appeared to threaten one another. 'I feel so scared... I just quickly go and shut the cafe and tell my other staff "don't leave",' witness Pawan Kaur told Nine. Witness Hung Nguyen watched on in horror as a boy pulled what he believed to be a machete from his backpack before tensions spilled over. 'I can't believe it did happen,' he said. Shoppers affected by the lockdown plastered news of the incident across social media as the events unfolded. The popular Melbourne shopping centre was plunged into lockdown following reports of a group of boys carrying machetes 'Another machete attack while I was getting my noodle on,' one TikTok user wrote in a video filmed inside the shopping centre as the lockdown announcement played over the loudspeakers. While no injuries were reported, the incident called into question the effectiveness of a ban on the sale of machetes by the Victorian government. The ban followed a clash between suspected rival youth gangs alleged to have been carrying the weapons at Northland shopping centre in Preston on May 25. Footage from inside the popular mall depicted shoppers running for cover as a group of seven males, aged between 15 and 21, squared-off. The following day Premier Jacinta Allan announced her government would bring forward the machete ban until a permanent ban takes effect on September 1. 'In Victoria, community safety comes first. We must never let places we meet become places we fear,' Ms Allan said last Monday. 'I hate these knives, and I will keep introducing as many laws as it takes to get them off our streets, out of our shops and out of our lives.' Investigations into the Caroline Springs incident remain ongoing.
The Independent
2 hours ago
- The Independent
Is this the end of the road in the hunt for Madeleine McCann? How the desperate new search unfolded in Portugal
The mystery of the missing three-year-old Madeleine McCann has preoccupied the British public since she vanished from her family's holiday apartment in Praia da Luz, in Portugal's Algarve 18 years ago. Millions of pounds have been spent on investigation after investigation amid relentless media scrutiny, but progress appeared to have all but stalled until 2020, when German investigators revealed they had identified a prime suspect – convicted rapist Christian Brueckner. So when German Federal officers this week descended on a string of abandoned buildings in a stretch of neglected wasteland near a cottage he used to rent outside Praia da Luz, armed with high-tech ground penetrating radar, the world watched. Is it possible that this time they would uncover the truth? Officials have not yet commented on what, if anything, they discovered. But as crews packed up with a few soil samples and some animal bones after three days of searches on Thursday, it seemed like they were once again leaving without answers. Not even Portuguese police, who supported the German search efforts, knew what intelligence had prompted them to suddenly target these remote locations. But without concrete evidence linking Brueckner to Madeleine's disappearance, German officers are in a race against time. The 47-year-old suspect could be freed from Sehnde prison, outside Hanover, by September as his seven-year sentence for a raping a 72-year-old American woman in Praia Da Luz in 2005 comes to an end. Brueckner, who denies any involvement in Madeleine's disappearance, has already revealed he plans to leave Germany when he's released, with suggestions he could move to the Far East or South America. Small teams of a dozen-or-so officers spent three days this week in the beating sun as they scoured derelict farmhouses and outbuildings in the stretch of scrubland just over a mile from where Madeleine was last seen. The 120-acre area, off a dramatic clifftop path along the coast between Atalaia and Lagos, is said to have once been populated by a farming community, but it has long been abandoned because it is so arid. Officers from Portugal's most senior force the Policia Judiciaria usually spend their time investigating serious organised crime, terrorism and murders, but found themselves shifting rocks and rubble in the unrelenting heat as they were drafted in to support German investigators. They used shovels and chainsaws as they battled with rock-hard ground and overgrown vegetation. They brought in a digger as they cleared rubble and detritus from inside the old structures, seemingly to clear the path to use ground penetrating radar equipment on the second day. Fire crews helped them to pump out a disused well at one derelict farm building, which was littered with graffiti. Watching them work, it was apparent that if the answer to Madeleine's disappearance lies in this outback, the odds of them finding any meaningful evidence after almost two decades are depressingly slim. The swathe of scrubland is completely devoid of shelter from the midday sun or strong winds blowing in from the coast. The vast expanse of hilltop is dotted with old buildings, barns and other structures which have fallen to wrack and ruin. Many appear to have been used by itinerants or those looking for a remote haunt to drink, with signs of old campfires outside. It was clear that it is an area so vast and inhospitable you could never search every square inch, and the search teams seemed resigned to their gruelling duties. When one local policeman was asked by a journalist what they expected to find he rolled his eyes and shrugged, before saying: 'You tell me.' In a valley less than a mile away, where Brueckner rented a run-down cottage at the time of Madeleine's disappearance, a neighbour recalled how the 'angry' young man used to have regular rows with his girlfriend. She hit out at the latest search operation, adding: 'It's a pile of rubbish, we are all so exhausted, it just goes on and on. It beggars belief.' Brueckner's former friend Helge Busching, who has testified to German police that he confessed to him a year after her disappearance, this week issued a stark warning. 'They have to find something because time is running out,' he told the Daily Mail. 'Brueckner could go free in September and, if he does, he will disappear. There has to be some hope for Madeleine's parents.' When investigators appeared to pack up and leave without answers at the end of the search on Thursday evening, there were no obvious signs of any major discoveries. Kate and Gerry McCann have not commented on the latest efforts, which come just a month after they marked the 18th anniversary of Madeleine's disappearance and what would have been her 22nd birthday. But it is not the first time their hopes will have been dashed in the long years since she vanished without a trace. Nevertheless, nearly two decades on they remain optimistic. In a statement posted on their website last month, they wrote: 'As we arrive at the 18th anniversary of Madeleine's abduction, we'd like to thank our faithful supporters once again for standing by us and never forgetting about Madeleine. 'The years appear to be passing even more quickly and whilst we have no significant news to share, our determination to 'leave no stone unturned' is unwavering. We will do our utmost to achieve this'. Whether this most recent search will ultimately produce the answers they desperately seek remains to be seen.
Daily Mail
2 hours ago
- Daily Mail
Teenager at elite Sydney private school wins HUGE payout after suing primary school over an accident at an athletics carnival that left him with lifelong injuries
A student at an elite Sydney private school has won a huge payout against his public primary school after life-changing injuries suffered at a Year 6 athletics carnival. On Friday, the now 17-year-old, a current student at Shore, secured a $275,000 judgment against Neutral Bay Primary School and, vicariously, the state of NSW. The lawsuit concerned a long-jump competition at the public school in 2019 when, at the age of 11, the boy landed on a hard surface in a sandpit and injured his back. The student, unnamed for privacy reasons, said he suffered a significant spinal injury during the long-jump, resulting in permanent back pain and impairment. He first brought the suit to the NSW District Court which, in October, dismissed his claim, finding the school had taken adequate steps to protect the students. In that instance, Judge Robert Newlinds SC found the teachers supervising the event reasonably believed the sandpit was safe and had been sufficiently sanded. Judge Newlinds ruled that while schools must take reasonable steps to keep students safe during sporting events, they cannot be expected to eliminate risks altogether. 'There will always be unfortunate consequences and injuries suffered by children at school or at play, even when there has been every reasonably precaution taken to prevent such actions,' he said. On appeal, acting Justice John Griffiths, with whom two other judges agreed, disagreed, claiming the risk of harm was foreseeable and easily avoidable. He held the school failed to ensure there was adequate sand to soften the area where the student landed and the two teachers failed to give adequate supervision. The primary judge relied on an image of a tape measure alongside the sandpit to infer there was at least was at least 20cm of sand combined with other soft-fall material. Justice Griffith disagreed with the inference, claiming the tape measure appeared to be kinked in the image and that the lower court relied too strongly on the single image. 'I am comfortably satisfied that there was a breach of duty on the part of the school in failing to take reasonable precautions to minimise the risk of injury from long jumping,' Justice Griffiths said. 'There was a breach of duty here because of the school's failure to take reasonable precautions which could have prevented [the student's] injuries. 'Those precautions were not onerous.' In determining damages, Justice Griffiths accepted the evidence of the student's doctor who claimed the injuries were 'likely to affect his future outcome'. Medical evidence held the boy suffered 'significant structural damage' to a spinal disc which, in turn, caused 'permanent structural damage' to his spine. Both courts accepted the injury interfered with his 'ability to enjoy life to date' and would 'continue to do so'. During the trial, the student suggested he might wish to follow his mother into IT or finance after school and that his back pain might make sitting all day 'quite hard'. He also raised the possibility of joining the military after school but said his experience in cadets at high school had been undermined by his injuries. Justice Griffiths decided to award a 'buffer' of $250,000 for future economic loss and an additional $25,000 for non-economic loss in the form of pain and suffering. He also rejected the school's claim the injury would have arisen regardless of the force or hardness of his landing in the pit since it arose from intra-abdominal pressure. 'It is possible [the student] may still have suffered the same injuries had there been an adequate amount of sand in his landing area,' he said. 'However, it is no "answer to the question whether something has been demonstrated as being more probable than not to say that there is another possibility open".' Ultimately, the Court of Appeal panel ruled the school had failed to protect the student from a reasonably foreseeable risk of injury. 'There are undoubted risks in school sports, but they form part of the curriculum in many primary schools and the community rightly recognises that such activities are beneficial for young children when properly supervised,' the panel ruled. 'I am comfortably satisfied that there was a breach of duty on the part of the school in failing to take reasonable precautions to minimise the risk of injury from long jumping.'
