I tested popular ice cream makers perfect for summer – the winner is just £45 and on offer right now
SWEET SPOT I tested popular ice cream makers perfect for summer – the winner is just £45 and on offer right now
Click to share on X/Twitter (Opens in new window)
Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window)
I HAVE been on a life-long quest to track down the perfect ice cream.
It must be sweet, but not sickly. Creamy, but not claggy.
Sign up for Scottish Sun
newsletter
Sign up
7
Natalie Clarke put six ice cream makers to the test - find out the surprising winner below
Credit: Stewart Williams
My search has taken me far and wide, and the closest I ever got to perfection was on holiday in sun-soaked Sicily, but that's not really an option without winning the lottery.
So I have accepted that if I want the perfect scoop, I must make it myself.
Luckily, there is a vast array of ice-cream makers on the market.
I tested six of them – five of those cost no more than £60, though there was a huge jump to the sixth, which came with a chilling £449 price tag. I've rated them out of five for performance and value.
For my first foray into ice-cream making, I went for strawberry flavour, using the recipe below.
Read on to find out which gadget will make you want to jump on a gondola and belt out 'Just one Cornetto', and which will have you scurrying back to the supermarket freezer section.
GILES & POSNER SORBET AND ICE-CREAM MAKER
500ml, £22.99, Amazon
7
The Giles & Posner ice cream maker lacked the airiness of the perfect scoop and had a slightly gritty texture
Credit: Stewart Williams
THIS cute gadget costs little more than four tubs of shop-bought ice cream.
But as with all the cheaper models, you have to pre-freeze the inner ice-cream bowl for at least 12 hours, otherwise you'll end up with a strawberry milkshake.
It was easy to assemble and the mixture turned into ice cream in 15 minutes. But it lacked the airiness of the perfect scoop and had a slightly gritty texture.
Dubai Ice Cream
Rating: 2/5
TIP: When you remove the ice-cream bowl from the freezer, hold it with a towel, or you'll end up with frozen fingers.
LAKELAND DIGITAL ICE-CREAM MAKER
1.8L, £44.99 (down from £49.99), Lakeland
7
Lakeland's digital ice-cream maker was solid and reliable
Credit: Stewart Williams
THIS gadget looks solid – the sort of machine you can rely on to get a job done.
The default setting on the digital screen is 40 minutes and towards the end, I worried it had overdone the churning.
But I needn't have worried, the result was a deliciously creamy scoop that looked gorgeous on a cone, with a lovely silky sheen.
And it tasted as good as it looked, with no trace of that synthetic tang that can spoil some shop-bought ice creams.
Rating: 5/5
MAGIMIX LE GLACIER ICE-CREAM MAKER
1.1L, £60, Argos
7
Magimix's ice cream maker is best for people with limited time
Credit: Stewart Williams
THIS is a compact, good-looking machine that does exactly what you ask of it.
It was no slowcoach, either. After just 20 minutes, my ice cream had reached a perfect consistency.
It tasted really good and was that perfect mix of light and creamy, while still achieving an authentic ice-cream texture.
I'd recommend this one if you have limited time, plus the clever 'feed tube' feature on the lid makes adding your ingredients a doddle.
Rating: 4/5
PROCOOK ICE-CREAM MAKER
1.5L, £49, procook.co.uk
7
Procook's machine made ice cream that looked and tasted lovely after 45 minutes
Credit: Stewart Williams
AT 1,500ml this machine has a decent capacity, but when I filled the bowl up to the top, it seemed to struggle to build up the texture.
Reducing the amount of the mixture by about a third made all the difference. After 45 minutes, the ice cream looked and tasted lovely.
But it was lighter in texture than some of the others – more along the lines of a soft serve.
If you prefer an ice cream with a little more bite, then this might not be the one for you.
Rating: 3/5
CUISINART SOLO SCOOPS ICE-CREAM MAKER
475ml, £29.99, Lakeland
7
Cuisinart's machine was small and fiddly - my stress levels started to rise with their gadget
Credit: Stewart Williams
MOST of the ice-cream makers I tested were easy and straightforward to use, but my stress levels started to rise with this machine.
It is quite small and fiddly, and the paddle kept falling off as I was assembling it. To be fair, once it was up and running it was fine, and after 25 minutes the ice cream looked ready.
As with the Procook, this one came out more like a soft serve in texture – too soft for my liking – but you can't argue with the great value for money.
Rating: 2/5
MAGIMIX GELATO EXPERT ICE-CREAM MAKER
2L, £448.79, John Lewis
7
The Magimix expert ice-cream maker produced a top-class dessert - but it costs a whopping £448
Credit: Stewart Williams
THIS sleek machine really looks the business – but it's hard to see past that hefty price tag.
With its in-built freezer system, you don't need to bother with putting the bowl in the freezer for 12 hours beforehand.
That is, of course, a huge plus. The cycle lasted 60 minutes, but the finished product was well worth the wait.
You could see instantly that this produced a top-class dessert. The texture was beautifully smooth and, as for the taste, it was like nectar from the gods.
Rating: 4/5
AND THE WINNER IS…
LET'S hear it for the wonderful Lakeland Digital machine.
The Magimix Gelato Expert delivered equally delicious-tasting results, but for sheer value for money at a tenth of the price of that one, Lakeland's brilliant gadget takes the first prize.
It produced ice cream that was divinely creamy as well as light and airy – and gorgeously flavoursome.
One bite and I was instantly transported back to the sunshine of Sicily.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Scottish Sun
2 hours ago
- Scottish Sun
First ‘Buckfast' whisky hits the market after twist on infamous tonic wine
The label features an image which looks very similar to Buckfast Abbey, near Devon. DRAM GOOD First 'Buckfast' whisky hits the market after twist on infamous tonic wine Click to share on X/Twitter (Opens in new window) Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) DRAM fans are delighted after the first Buckfast whisky hit the malt market. Glaschu Spirits Co, an independent Glasgow-based bottler, are unable to officially say the booze was matured in the notorious tonic wine. Sign up for Scottish Sun newsletter Sign up 2 The whisky is available to buy now. 2 The makers claim it's the first Buckfast-matured whisky. But the label features an image which looks very similar to Buckfast Abbey, near Devon, where Benedictine Monks brew the 'wreck the hoose juice.' A description on the Glaschu website cleverly reveals how the blend was matured without explicitly naming the tipple. It reads: "Born in Glasgow, crafted by two whisky enthusiasts with a taste for the unconventional. "United by curiosity, we sought to create a bold Highland malt with a twist. "Carefully aged seven years and finished in a Devonshire tonic wine quarter cask. "Kissed by rich fruit and herbal notes, it offers a finish unlike any other. "Filled at a robust 49 per cent, un-chillfiltered and full of character. "A dram that bridges tradition with experimentation. "Savour slowly, there's more here than meets the eye. "Time, taste, and a touch of mystery in every bottle." Moment American nuns try Buckfast for the first time on visit to Scotland It added: "Produced by Benedictine monks in a certain Devonshire abbey, this particular tonic wine is notorious in the UK (Mostly Scotland & Ireland) for its potency. "Please note however, that the name tonic wine does not imply health benefits..." The tasting notes say the whisky smells like red wine, licorice and toasted oak, 10 o'clock and that it tastes of cough syrup, berries and bad decisions It costs £65 a bottle and is available here
Glasgow Times
3 hours ago
- Glasgow Times
Neil Lennon put football on hold to enjoy Edinburgh Oasis gig
The former Celtic midfielder and manager headed to the capital yesterday evening to see the band's third Murrayfield show on their 2025 reunion tour. The Scottish Sun reports Lennon, who currently manages Dunfermline Athletic FC, was in attendance at the sold out show alongside 70,000 others. READ NEXT: Casting company searching for young actors for show based on award-winning novel They also shared a picture of him wearing an Oasis t-shirt on his way to Murrayfield. Lennon has been a long-time fan of the band and even named his son Gallagher after the famous brothers. Speaking previously about his love for the band, The Scottish Sun reports he said: "I'd just joined Manchester City in 1987 when the whole Britpop thing erupted. "I've seen Oasis 13 or 14 times, including at Maine Road, which is one of the best gigs I've ever been at. "I've met them a few times – Liam is a lot smarter than he makes out, and Noel just cracks you up every time he opens his mouth. "I named my son after them as well. He's called Gallagher."
Wales Online
3 hours ago
- Wales Online
Welsh pub has one dish top restaurant critic says he drove 147 miles thinking about
Welsh pub has one dish top restaurant critic says he drove 147 miles thinking about Masterchef judge and critic Giles Coren was blown away when he visited the Black Bear which has made the Estrella Damm Top 50 Gastropubs list four times in a row Masterchef guest judge and notable food critic Giles Coren has once again visited Wales to sample our "world-beating restaurant scene." On his most recent trip, Giles visisted some of his favourite haunts including Grain, Santos Ty Tapas and The Shed at Porthgain. But it was the Black Bear Inn in Monmouthshire, which blew him away. The pub has made it onto the Estrella Damm Top 50 Gastropubs list four times in a row. Couple Josh and Hannah Byrne moved from Bristol to Bettws Newydd to run the pub back in 2018. Since then, the small venue has garnered huge success and has become one of the best gastropub offerings in Wales. It was named in the Good Food Guide this year. You can read more about their story here. Giles was clearly very taken with the pub describing the pub's rarebit as "historic".. He praised the "exciting wines by the glass from France, Italy, and Spain" and "more exciting local beers, such as the famous Butty Bach, a smooth, malty pint from the Wye Valley Brewery." The food was equally lauded by the 56-year-old gastronome, who wrote that Josh's famous deep-fried potato skins with whipped cod's roe "soared above my expectations" and admitted that he drove 149 miles thinking about them. He described the £6.50 dish as "Really potatoey, like the mummy and daddy of the first potato chip, hot and glassy crisp, sizzling in the fishy smear. Perfect with a big slurp of the Butty." Whipped cod roe and potato skins (Image: WalesOnline/Rob Browne) Giles also sampled the terrine of chicken and wild boar (£13), which was "good and coarse and strong," and the fava bean panisses (£5), which he said "displayed Michelin-level control and precision." But the Welsh rarebit was the thing most worthy of a mention: "The Welsh rarebit (£5), my first in actual Wales, was historic: the mustardy cheese filling whipped up and risen in the bread slice like a soufflé." He added: "It puts pressure on a dish when you've driven 149 miles thinking about it, but this soared above my expectations." His high praise is bittersweet. In May, the owners of The Black Bear Inn confirmed that they would be putting the pub up for sale. The announcement came as a shock to many in the local community and further afield, given the pub's soaring success and reputation. Despite the sad news, the team has reassured customers that nothing has changed just yet. In a statement shared on social media, the owners stressed they were "not selling in a hurry" and expected the sale process to take at least a year, if not longer. To read the full review from Giles Coren, visit The Times website. Article continues below
