Gold Guitar winner criticises awards, says ‘brown faces' were treated unfairly
Country singer and 2024 Gold Guitar main prize winner Amy Maynard has vowed publicly to never return to the ceremony and its host town of Gore, after facing what she believes were racially-charged micro-aggressions. She said the ceremony has a history of failing to recognise te reo Māori, and hopes her experience could push the Gold Guitar organisers to create a safer environment for Māori performers and punters. But the organisers say they'd rather sort out their differences in private.
Aotearoa's premier country music awards, the Gold Guitar Awards, have been held every year since 1974 (excluding 2020) in Gore, as the last hurrah in the Tussock Country Music Festival schedule. Its honourees include the likes of Tami Neilson and Kaylee Bell, and in 2024, Maynard picked up the ceremony's senior award.
Maynard told The Spinoff she had spent most of the festival last year – her first time at the ceremony – keeping to herself, and focusing on performing in several spots across the awards circuit.
Returning this year as a one-off performer and attendee, Maynard says the environment at the awards was 'really disheartening'. She said that in her experience, the awards' security were more likely to reprimand 'brown faces' for actions such as singing, dancing or talking during performances. Her 16-year-old son, dressed in baggy clothing, was also stopped multiple times and questioned about why he was at the awards.
It was not just staff, but attendees that Maynard said made the awards feel unwelcoming. While one singer performed a reo Māori waiata, Maynard said an older Pākehā couple made disparaging comments about the choice of song.
When The Spinoff called the Gold Guitar office, convener Phillip Geary answered. 'I don't want to comment in a public forum,' Geary replied, when asked about Maynard's experience.
In 2012, a Gore District Council employee left their job after criticising the Gold Guitar Awards. She had competed in the Gold Guitar Young Ambassador Awards, and wrote on Facebook that she 'kicked ass at everything and then didn't win, go figure … I think I was too brown for them bro'. At the time, Geary said he didn't believe Green needed to resign. 'With the way social media is these days, we've got to expect stuff like this. We're not overly concerned about it.'
'As a Māori woman in this industry, it's hard when you're constantly fighting this uphill battle,' Maynard told The Spinoff. 'These people have built this idea of what you're going to be in their minds'.
Maynard also criticised the awards' policy that bars anyone other than the slated performer from appearing onstage. Maynard requested her mother and daughter sing with her, as 'you should be allowed to provide and perform the show that you would like to put on for people … for me, that includes highlighting and showcasing my family, because whakawhanaungatanga is always going to be something I'm huge about'. The response from the awards was that it would 'set a bad precedent'.
The rule affected another act, Sharon Russell and Lesley Nia Nia, who had won the previous year's classic award. Russell had travelled to the ceremony without Nia Nia, who could not attend for personal reasons, but with her grandson as a replacement. Maynard claims Russell was told she couldn't perform and her act was replaced.
Maynard shared these experiences in a long social media post, which The Spinoff understands the Gold Guitar organisers have seen. Television personality Mike Puru, who MC'd the event, left a message of support on Maynard's post promising to take her comments to the ceremony's board. 'I'm so sorry that happened – I had no idea … I'm saddened by all of that, especially being a Māori fella from Gore,' Puru wrote. 'I know what you mean.'
In the last year, against the backdrop of the Treaty principles bill and Toitū Te Tiriti hīkoi, Maynard said she had noticed anti-Māori rhetoric had become more 'vocal'. The singer, who lives in Hamilton, said she doesn't feel comfortable returning to Gore or to the Gold Guitar Awards.
'I hope this opens a conversation for them.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Spinoff
10 hours ago
- The Spinoff
Infinity Sessions, reviewed: Neil Finn, Don McGlashan, The Beths, Tom Scott and LEAO
Roundhead Studios is midway through a 10-night livestreamed musical extravaganza to help Make Us Feel Good About Life. Here are reviews from those who were in the room for the first week. Watch the next five Infinity Sessions live on The Spinoff from 7.30pm this Wednesday-Sunday. Night one: Don McGlashan with Motte and SJD The Mufgal express roared out of the station on Wednesday night with an intimate, uplifting performance by one of Aotearoa's most beloved and brilliant songwriters. Don McGlashan treated a room full of reverent Roundheadheads to a sweep of treats from a shimmering 'Lucky Stars' and a haunting 'White Valiant' to the soulful beauty of 'Anchor Me' and the twisted beauty of 'The Heater'. Master of bathos, of extracting the profound from the ordinary, McGlashan – expertly accompanied by Anita Clark aka Motte – was very clearly having a bloody good time up there. He was joined by host/impresario Neil Finn for 'Andy', The Front Lawn's hymn of personal loss, and then came that other great song of inexplicable loss, of national tragedy, the Mutton Birds' 'A Thing Well Made'. Overwhelming. Motte began the night with a perfectly stalactite set, and SJD delivered a mesmeric synth followup. Appearing with all three was drummer-genius Chris O'Connor. This latest, epic series of Infinity Sessions takes place in the downstairs studios at Roundhead, but what is lost in in-the-round dynamics and chandeliers is more than made up for in intensity and intimacy: across two rooms, for a couple of weeks in winter, this is New Zealand's most exciting place to be. An exquisite start to a very special fortnight. / Toby Manhire Night two: Neil Finn with Vera Ellen Neil Finn misses David Bowie. 'The world went to shit when he died,' he said after opening his set on Thursday night with 'Quicksand', an esoteric epic from Bowie's 1971 album Hunky Dory. Following Vera Ellen's tight opening set, Finn moved on to simpler sentiments, the crowd joining him for a cover of Carole King's 'You've Got a Friend'. Swapping guitar for piano, Finn aired out the lesser-known track, 'Faster than Light'. Everything, he said, has to be reinvented daily, including old songs. Long-time collaborator Victoria Kelly joined him on mellotron for the achingly beautiful 'Gentle Hum'. With the mood elevated, Finn had no trouble getting us to do our part and the room hummed along soulfully. From Kelly's entrance onward, the stage filled with musicians. Finn could easily settle into elder statesman mode, but instead, he was impish, clearly relishing the chance to share the spotlight with Ellen, Ben Lemi, De Stevens, Tiare Kelly, Audrey May Banach-Salas, and Joshua Worthington-Church. By the time 'She Will Have Her Way' closed the night, it's hard to know who's having more fun – us or the extraordinary assembly in front of us. At the start of the night, Finn dedicated the evening to 'the innocent victims of war'. The Infinity Sessions are his bid to make us feel good about life; 'little acts of goodness', he calls them. In a world gone 'to shit', it's tempting to be cynical about that, but after weeping through Don McGlashan the night before and bouncing around at Finn's show, there's something urgent about the rallying cry underpinning these sessions. Music won't end war, but it does grow our capacity for joy and appreciation, and tolerance of other people. Sometimes, it really feels like those muscles are atrophying. Neil Finn isn't having a bar of it. / Anna Rawhiti-Connell Night three: The Beths with Chelsea Prestiti What an absolute treat to see The Beths in such a cosy setting on the eve of an album release and world tour. Chelsea Prestiti warmed up the crowd with jazzy, samba-inspired beats and a captivating, semi-psychedelic vocal number. Chlöe Swarbrick then took the stage for a surprise intro – 'When it feels like there are no words left, there is art, there is music, there is joy and there is… THE BETHS.' The band ripped into the show with the eponymous track from their soon-to-be-released record 'Straight Line Was A Lie'. But not before telling us they were kinda nervous. 'No Joy', another new one, came soon after and featured a few recorder solos (unexpected, amazing). The Beths, lead-vocalist Liz Stokes said, were not only debuting new music for us but also testing out their world tour gear. Well loved tunes 'Silence Is Golden' and 'When You Know You Know' had the crowd jumping up and down, getting sweaty and head bang-y. 'Now that everyone's excited, let's play a sad song,' Stokes said as the rest of the band left the stage for a huge vibe shift, 'It's not sad, just complicated … it's called 'Mother Pray for Me'.' It was beautiful, totally rocked me. I cried four distinct tears and heard many sniffles. 'Mosquito' was similarly heartfelt, calling to mind the Auckland floods. The emotional range of the night was lovely, the crowd was friendly and considerate, even if a few super fans sang a little too loudly. 'Thanks for coming to this weird thing,' Stokes said towards the end. I'm so happy I did. It really did make me feel good about life. One of the younger people in attendance said it was her very first gig. What a stellar start to a world tour, and that young person's life of live music. / Liv Sisson Night four: Tom Scott with Sarvi 'You never know what you're going to get with Tom [Scott]' said the guy wearing a black parka standing next to me in the reception area. On one side of us, there was an old statue of a cheetah. On the other side, a cougar. The paint was flaking off both. Past the decorative pinball machine and inside the downstairs live room, the small crowd was treated to the mellow sounds of Sarvi (who also happens to be Scott's partner). Accompanied by a four piece band, Sarvi effortlessly delivered six tracks that transported you to a nondescript jazz lounge in the mid 20th century. During the changeover, the crowd was ushered into the lobby, where Scott and Roundhead Studios owner Neil Finn provided their musings on life, politics, and knocking on your neighbour's door looking for your lost cat. Back inside the live room, gold ribbons shimmered light as Scott confirmed the sneaking suspicions that he'd be debuting music from his new album. Titled Anitya – which is Sanskrit referring to impermanence or transience – Scott likened the album to his first daughter. 'I don't rap on any of this', he warned, before letting out a small vocal scale. The music was a mix of muted drumming, stabbing warped guitar solos, back-up vocals with high autotune pitch from the likes of Lui Tuiasau, and Scott's singing. It's different for Tom Scott, but then again, it's also not. There are lines about 'cheap small talk' with a father-in-law, falling out of love, and knowing when it's time to leave. For those familiar with Scott's catalogue, Anitya is just another seemingly inevitable evolution. / Liam Rātana Night five: LEAO with Neil Finn and Hun Lynch There's a comfort in a band having a truly distinct sound, so much so that even though LEAO opened their set with two new songs, they felt immediately familiar. The twang of the slide guitar and the energetic strumming from frontman David Feauai-Afaese got the intimate session off to a warm start. Feauai-Afaese introduced each song and complained about the heat (it's stuffy in the small studio and someone had fainted already during opening act Hun Lynch, who was great despite the delays). For anyone unfamiliar with LEAO's sound, I'd recommend catching a live gig as an introduction. There's just no way to hear 'Taeao' for the first time performed live and not fall in love. The recorded singles are strong but singing live, with dual microphones for the layered vocals, and the bass turned up add something intoxicating to the Samoan rock sound. All that helped by Feauai-Afaese's affable nature and yelp for joy when the band 'nailed' a new song. At the end of the set, Feauai-Afaese looked exhausted and happy to set his guitar down. But his mum was in the front of the crowd and called for an encore. 'If mum says it, we have to do it,' he laughed as he picked the guitar up again. LEAO ended on a joyous rendition of 'Musika Malie' and, as is the law of Samoa, got a siva circle going in front of the stage. A beautiful way to spend a cold Sunday night. / Madeleine Chapman
The Spinoff
15 hours ago
- The Spinoff
RNZ at a crossroads after scathing independent review
Last week's review has exposed RNZ National's weaknesses – and left its leadership facing pressure to deliver a turnaround, writes Catherine McGregor in today's extract from The Bulletin. A blistering review RNZ National's failings were laid bare last week in a withering review by former news boss Richard Sutherland. Commissioned by RNZ chief executive Paul Thompson, the report painted a picture of a broadcaster that has lost its way – culturally, strategically, and on air. Sutherland described a widespread belief among staff that live radio was a 'sunset activity' rather than a growth opportunity, and said the quality of broadcast talent was variable: 'some people shouldn't be on air' at all. His interviews with more than 50 staff revealed blame-shifting, low ambition and confusion about who the audience is. The consequences are showing in the ratings: RNZ National has shed nearly a quarter of its listeners since 2019, dropping from over 616,000 to fewer than 470,000. If that trend continues, the audience could fall below 340,000 by 2030 – a disaster for a public broadcaster whose flagship radio division was once regarded as untouchable. Kerton's cutting critique For radio veteran Bill Kerton, none of this was revelatory. Writing in The Spinoff, he dismisses the review as too little, far too late. What angers him most is that Thompson even needed to outsource such advice, having told Sutherland he sought 'independent, frank guidance' for a station-wide reset. 'I had to re-read that note,' Kerton writes. 'Where was RNZ's chief strategy officer? Busy doing what?' He lambasts RNZ as bloated and directionless, and suggests the $30,000 review raised such obvious issues they could have been summarised by Thompson's 'office cleaner' in a few sentences. The fixes are achievable, he says – sharper programming and stronger talent, including a marquee hire – but he doubts RNZ's bureaucracy has the speed or will to deliver. A more sympathetic view Anna Rawhiti-Connell, by contrast, is a fan of Sutherland's frankness. In The Spinoff this morning she highlights his 'bold' proposal to target listeners aged 50 to 69, a move that cuts against the grain of public media's 'all things to all people' ethos and the wider industry's obsession with chasing younger audiences. Anna acknowledges the risks of defining the core audience as older and potentially shrinking, but also appreciates the clear-eyed approach. Focusing on a single age bracket is 'a blunt instrument, and there will be criticism that it lacks nuance,' she notes. But, 'the first step in being audience-first … is to define that audience. Sutherland has done that. I'm not sure much more nuance is required at this point.' A political target As Kerton notes, the report could easily become a political football: 'A $30,000 report into a massively over-resourced government asset…is exactly what New Zealanders are utterly sick of reading about.' Newsroom's Mark Jennings says RNZ has few friends in the coalition: Act questions its very existence, while Winston Peters still harbours grudges over a 'perceived lack of reporting on his party's successes'. Already on the outs with many in government, RNZ is now an even more attractive target for 'flailing' Paul Goldsmith. The media minister's 'one achievement seems to have been getting walked over by Google and Facebook', writes Jennings, proving himself no more effective than his hapless predecessor Melissa Lee, who lasted only six months in the job. 'If the same rules applied, [Goldsmith] should also be handing the portfolio over to the next hopeful.' Who could be RNZ National's saviour? Attention now turns to talent – or the lack thereof. Both Sutherland and media commentators say RNZ desperately needs a 'get' to reinvigorate its lineup. But as the Herald's Shayne Currie notes (paywalled), many of the top names are locked down: Mike Hosking, Heather du Plessis-Allan and Ryan Bridge are welded to Newstalk ZB, while Jack Tame is tied to both TVNZ and ZB. Hiring Paddy Gower, Rebecca Wright, Tova O'Brien or Duncan Garner could be a slightly easier ask. 'But the search for outside talent also highlights RNZ's failure to develop more of its own presenters into top performers,' writes Jennings. Emile Donovan and Alexa Cook are rising stars, says Currie, though perhaps not yet ready to anchor flagship programmes. For now, RNZ's challenge is finding the right hire at the right time – a decision that will determine whether the station can turn its slide around.
Otago Daily Times
18 hours ago
- Otago Daily Times
Polyfest returns
REPORT & PHOTO: NINA TAPU The best of Māori and Pasifika culture was brought to the ILT Stadium Southland stage for the first day of the Murihiku Polyfest yesterday. More than 8000 performers — including pupils from Te Kura O Rimu School (pictured) — will perform over the week to bring the sights and sounds of Polynesia to Southland. Over 1000 spectators, including whānau and friends, filled the auditorium armed with cameras and video recorders, cheering on their tamariki. More than 120 schools from across the region will be taking part in the annual festival, now in its 16th year.
