Apple must pay Optis $502 million lump sum in UK patent dispute, court rules
Apple must pay a US patent holder $502 million for the use of 4G patents in devices including iPhones and iPads, London's Court of Appeal ruled on Thursday, in the latest stage of a long-running legal battle.
Texas-based Optis Cellular Technology LLC sued Apple in London in 2019 over its use of patents which Optis says are essential to certain technological standards, such as 4G.
London's High Court ruled in 2023 that Apple should pay Optis a total of $56.43 million plus interest to cover past and future sales over a set period.
But Optis argued that was far too low and challenged the decision at an appeal heard in February and March.
The Court of Appeal said in a partially-redacted written ruling that Apple should pay a lump sum of $502 million, not including interest, for the period from 2013 to 2027.
The lump sum relates to a global license to use Optis' patents.
An Apple spokesperson said they were 'disappointed by this decision and plan to appeal'.
'Optis makes no products and their sole business is to sue companies using patents they buy,' the spokesperson added. 'We will continue to defend against their attempts to extract unreasonable payments.'
An Optis spokesperson welcomed the ruling, which they said 'corrected a clearly flawed prior ruling and has made meaningful progress toward affirming the true value of our patents to Apple devices.'
'We will continue to ensure fair compensation for the Optis intellectual property that enables high-speed connectivity for millions of devices around the world,' the spokesperson added.
Thursday's ruling is the latest decision in the legal battle between Apple and Optis over the FRAND (fair, reasonable and non-discriminatory) terms to use Optis' patents.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Leaders
a day ago
- Leaders
Saudi Arabia Showcases Mining Exploration Opportunities to Leading UK Firms
The Ministry of Industry and Mineral Resources, in partnership with the Ministry of Investment, recently hosted a webinar aimed at introducing leading British mining companies to investment opportunities in Saudi Arabia's growing mineral exploration sector. This initiative is part of the Kingdom's broader strategy to accelerate resource development and attract top-tier global investors. The virtual event drew 70 participants from a wide range of UK-based mining firms, underscoring the increasing interest in Saudi Arabia's evolving mining landscape. Attendees were presented with details on the 2025 exploration program, which targets high-potential geological zones across the country. Key highlights included Saudi Arabia's streamlined licensing procedures, extensive geological data, and a robust support framework for investors. The session also outlined a suite of incentives designed to facilitate and encourage international investment in the sector. Central to the discussion was the ministry's plan to offer exploration licenses for mining areas spanning over 50,000 square kilometers in 2025. This major initiative, originally unveiled at the fourth Future Minerals Forum in January 2025, is expected to significantly expand exploration efforts and attract greater foreign investment. The webinar supports Saudi Arabia's ongoing efforts to position mining as a cornerstone of economic diversification under Vision 2030, reinforcing its commitment to unlocking the full potential of the Kingdom's mineral wealth. Related Topics : Ministry of Industry Launches Women in Mining Non-Profit Organization Saudi Arabia, Denmark Explore Investment Opportunities in Industry, Mining Saudi Mining Sector Achieves Milestone: 2,401 Licenses Issued in 2024 Saudi Arabia Unveils Six Qualified Companies for Mining Exploration Program Short link : Post Views: 1
Asharq Al-Awsat
2 days ago
- Asharq Al-Awsat
US Reportedly Pushes Vietnam to Decouple from Chinese Tech
The United States is pushing Vietnam in tariff talks to reduce the use of Chinese tech in devices that are assembled in the country before being exported to America, three people briefed on the matter said. Vietnam is home to large manufacturing operations of tech firms such as Apple and Samsung, which often rely on components made in China. Meta and Google also have contractors in Vietnam that produce goods such as virtual reality headsets and smartphones. The Southeast Asian nation has been organizing meetings with local businesses to boost the supply of Vietnamese parts, with firms showing willingness to cooperate but also warning they would need time and technology to do so, according to one person with knowledge of the discussions. The Trump administration has threatened Vietnam with crippling tariffs of 46% which could significantly limit access for Vietnam-made goods to their main market and upend the Communist-run country's export-oriented growth model. Vietnam has been asked "to reduce its dependency on Chinese high-tech," said one person familiar with the discussions. "That is part of the restructuring of supply chains and would in turn reduce US dependency on Chinese components," the person added. The ultimate objective is to speed up US decoupling from Chinese high-tech while increasing Vietnam's industrial capacity, a second person said, citing virtual reality devices as an example of Vietnam-assembled products that are too dependent on Chinese technology. All sources declined to be identified as the discussions were confidential. Reuters was not able to learn if the US has proposed numerical targets such as caps on Chinese content for "Made in Vietnam" goods or different tariff rates based on the amount of Chinese content. Apple, Samsung, Meta and Google did not reply to Reuters requests for comment. As the US-imposed deadline of July 8 nears before the tariffs take effect, the timing and scope of a possible deal remain unclear. All sources stressed that while the US has made broader requests for Vietnam to reduce its reliance on China, tackling the issue of Chinese high-tech content in exports was a key priority. Last year, China exported around $44 billion of tech such as electronics components, computers and phones to Vietnam, about 30% of its total exports to the country. Vietnam shipped $33 billion of tech goods to the United States or 28% of the US-bound exports. Both flows are on the rise this year, according to Vietnam's customs data. Vietnam's trade ministry did not reply to Reuters requests for comment. Separate sources have previously said that US demands were seen as "tough" and "difficult" by Vietnamese negotiators. The US also wants Vietnam to crack down on the practice of shipping Chinese goods to America with misleading "Made in Vietnam" labels that draw lower duties - which Vietnam is also trying to heed. The ministry said on Sunday that a third round of talks last week in Washington ended with progress, but critical issues remain unresolved. Vietnam's ruling Communist Party chief To Lam intends to meet US President Donald Trump in the United States, possibly in late June, officials with knowledge of the matter said. No date has been announced for the trip. The White House and Vietnam's foreign ministry did not respond to requests for comment on the possible visit. NOT TOO FAST Local firms attending meetings organized by the trade ministry in recent weeks expressed a general willingness to adapt, but many warned that instant changes "would destroy business", according to one of the sources. Vietnam has been slowly developing an industrial ecosystem with local suppliers but it has a long way to go before it can match China's advanced supply chains and cheaper pricing, industry executives say. "Vietnam is about 15–20 years behind China in somewhat fully replicating its supply chain scale and sophistication, but it's catching up fast, especially in key sectors like textiles and electronics," said Carlo Chiandone, a Vietnam-based supply chain expert. Abrupt changes to existing practices may hurt Vietnam's delicate relationship with China, which is both a major investor in its Southeast Asian neighbor and a source of security concerns.
Asharq Al-Awsat
5 days ago
- Asharq Al-Awsat
Apple's iPhone Sales Capture Top Spot in Chinese Market in May, Counterpoint Research Says
Apple's iPhone sales rose to the top spot in China in May, with global sales growing 15% year-on-year during April and May in the tech giant's strongest performance for the two-month period since the COVID-19 pandemic, data from Counterpoint Research showed. The increase in global sales was primarily driven by a return to growth in Apple's two largest markets, China and the United States, preliminary data from Counterpoint Research showed. The company was aided in part by tariff dodgers and also saw double-digit increases in Japan, India and the Middle Eastern markets, Reuters quoted Counterpoint as saying. "Q2 iPhone performance looks promising at the moment, but as always, swings either way are dictated by two markets - the US and China," Ivan Lam, Senior Analyst at Counterpoint Research said. Calculations based on data from the government-affiliated China Academy of Information and Communications Technology showed that April shipments of foreign-branded phones in China rose to 3.52 million units from 3.50 million a year earlier. Apple has faced increased competition from domestic rivals in China and has resorted to price cuts to stay competitive. Chinese e-commerce platforms were offering discounts of up to 2,530 yuan ($351) on Apple's latest iPhone 16 models in May.
