Roll muddle
EC's assurances about the efficiency of its Special Intensive Revision of Bihar's voter roll aside, the ground reality is that many ordinary voters are confused, more so since state poll commission is in overdrive just months before elections.
Bad timing | The issue's bigger than opposition concerns. The main problem is the rushed schedule. Not only is monsoon the wrong time for such a revision in the flood-prone state, it is distressing for residents, stressful for poll workers, and inaccuracies can be costly. First booth level officer's multiple visits to each potential voter's residence – first to give a pre-filled or empty form then to collect it with or without documents on a case-to-case basis. Second, given Bihar's patchy documentation, getting hold of documents can be tough. Third, if a potential voter fails to ensure BLO has his/her form and documents, they won't be included in the new voter roll. Fourth, BLOs must collect, verify, collate, scan ID documents and upload all of it within weeks for an estimated 7cr people. Fifth, having a month for 'claims & objections' after the draft roll is published on Aug 1 misses the point. It means voters must make themselves available away from their work in other districts and states, first for BLOs in July, then in Aug if excluded. How many Bihari workers have that luxury?
Faulty logic | EC has cited rapid urbanisation, migration, and inclusion of undocumented immigrants for springing this on Bihar. The first is unrelated to the emphasis on birth certificates. For the second, residency proof is required to remove inter- and intra-district duplication. What acceptable residency document does a migrant show in his work-town? As for the third, whether the issue can be fixed by Sept 30 (deadline for final voter roll) and is big enough in Bihar to offset the high probability of disenfranchising ordinary voters is debatable.
Facebook Twitter Linkedin Email
This piece appeared as an editorial opinion in the print edition of The Times of India.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
29 minutes ago
- Time of India
Election Commission holding regular dialogue with parties: CEC on criticism from opposition
With opposition parties accusing the Election Commission of ignoring their concerns, Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar on Saturday asserted that the poll panel maintains a regular dialogue with political parties and 5,000 such meetings have been held in the past four months, beginning from the assembly level. Replying to queries from reporters in Firozabad, where he came to attend a private programme, Kumar said that after voters, political parties are the next important stakeholders for the EC. He was asked about the recent criticism from opposition parties, including their allegations that their concerns related to poll-bound Bihar are being overlooked by the EC. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Brain tumor has left my son feeling miserable; please help! Donate For Health Donate Now Undo "The Election Commission keeps having a regular dialogue with various political parties. In the last four months, all-party meetings were organised in every assembly constituency, in every district and also with every state chief electoral officer. "In all, 5000 such meetings were held in which 28,000 people, including leaders of political parties, participated." Live Events The CEC said that not only this, the Election Commission itself has been meeting all national and state parties. "Five national parties and four state parties have met. If there is any issue, then all-party delegations also come, and the EC meets them," he said. The Chief Election Commissioner also said that in the electoral process, the voters are the most important, but after them, "our political parties are the most important stakeholders. Referring to the Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of the electoral rolls in Bihar, where assembly elections are due later this year, CEC Gyanesh Kumar said that whoever is in the voter list of 01.01.2003 in Bihar will be considered eligible from the primary point of view under Article 326 of the Constitution. In other words, people whose names are in that list will not be required to submit any supporting documents, and when voter IDs are to be made for their children, they too will not be required to give documents for their parents. The Election Commission has said it will soon upload the 2003 Bihar electoral roll on its website to facilitate the nearly 4.96 crore voters whose names figure on it to extract the relevant portion to be attached with the enumeration form for the special intensive revision of the voters' list. According to the instructions issued by the poll authority to its Bihar poll machinery, the 4.96 crore voters -- 60 per cent of the total electors --- who were listed in the 2003 special intensive revision need not submit any supporting document to establish their date or place or birth except the relevant portion of the electoral roll brought out after the revision. The other three crore -- nearly 40 per cent -- will have to provide one of the 11 listed documents to establish their place or date of birth. "The basic exercise is to identify each and every individual of the remaining three crore voters before their names are included in the list," a functionary explained. Special intensive revision will ensure that no eligible elector is left out of the electoral rolls and no ineligible one is part of it, Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar had earlier told PTI. Bihar, as of now, has more than 7.89 crore voters spread across 243 assembly seats. Polls in the state are due later this year.
India Gazette
an hour ago
- India Gazette
Union Minister Chirag Paswan defends voter list revision, calls it
Patna (Bihar) [India], July 5 (ANI): Union Minister Chirag Paswan on Saturday defended the Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of electoral rolls being undertaken in Bihar, urging political stakeholders not to view the exercise through a partisan lens. He described the process as a routine yet crucial measure to ensure the accuracy and integrity of voter data. 'Don't make this just a political issue. This is a process of sanitisation which has been followed from time to time. It is important to follow it,' Paswan said, emphasising that the exercise is aimed at maintaining a clean and credible electoral system. Paswan noted that the names of deceased individuals and non-local residents often appear in voter rolls. 'It has been seen many a time that slips are being issued even for those people who died decades ago. It is also seen that sometimes the names of non-locals are also on the voter list,' he stated. He added that his party remains available to assist citizens facing genuine difficulties during the revision drive 'So, an effort has been made to simplify the process. Still, if someone comes to us with an issue, we try to help them after speaking to the Administration. We are so concerned about intruders. So, we will have to adopt this process gradually,' he added. Meanwhile, the Special Intensive Revision (SIR) exercise being undertaken in Bihar ahead of the upcoming Assembly elections is progressing smoothly on the ground, with Booth Level Officers (BLOs) completing their first round of visits to nearly 1.5 crore households across the state. According to official data, more than 87 per cent of Enumeration Forms have already been distributed during the door-to-door verification drive, which is being carried out as part of the Election Commission's ongoing efforts to update and verify the electoral rolls. According to the Election Commission, the first visit of the Booth Level Officers (BLOS) to nearly 1.5 crore households in the state was completed today and over 87 per cent Enumeration Forms (i.e. 6,86,17,932) out of the total of 7,89,69,844 (nearly 7.90 crore) electors in Bihar who are enrolled as on June 24, 2025, have been distributed during the Special Intensive Revision (SIR) exercise being conducted in the state. The remaining houses could be locked, or belong to deceased electors, migrants, or those who may be travelling. Since the BLO shall be visiting the houses of the electors three times during the exercise, these figures are likely to increase further. The partially filled forms are also available for download on the ECI portal, as well as on the ECINET App. Electors can upload the filled forms themselves on the ECINET App. Besides, 1,54,977 Booth Level Agents (BLAS) appointed by various political parties are also providing active support in the SIR process. As on July 2, BJP has appointed 52,689 BLAS, followed by 47,504 of RJD, 34,669 of JD(U), 16,500 of INC, 1913 of Rashtriya Lok Jan Shakti Party, 1271 of CPI(ML)L, 1153 of Lok Jan Shakti Party (Ram Vilas), 578 of CPI(M), 270 of Rashtriya Lok Samta Party besides others such as BSP (74), NPP (3) and AAP (1). Each BLA can submit up to 50 certified forms per day. Nearly five per cent filled-up and signed forms, i.e. nearly 38 lakh forms have already been received by the BLOS, who are working sincerely with the sole motto - Inclusion First, which has been repeatedly emphasised upon by the Commission. As per SIR, to have one's name included in the Draft Electoral Roll to be published on August 1, 2025, the strict condition for an elector is to sign and submit the pre-printed form. Enumeration Form before 25th July 2025. Simultaneous verification of the uploaded forms has also been started. Despite apprehensions from some quarters, SIR will ensure that all eligible persons are included. Based on the documents attached or not attached, along with the signed Enumeration Form, eligibility verification of each name included in the draft rolls will be conducted continuously upon receipt. Verification will commence vigorously from August 2, 2025, onwards, following the publication of the draft electoral rolls. Based on the published Draft of Electoral Rolls, Claims and Objections will be received from any political parties or any member of the public from 2nd August 2025 onwards. The final electoral rolls will be published on September 30, 2025. Appeals can also be filed thereafter with the DM and the CEO. (ANI)
The Wire
3 hours ago
- The Wire
Tejashwi Yadav Ups the Ante, Says ECI has Hurt Bihari Pride by Asking Voters to Prove Citizenship
With Yadav turning the ECI's attempt to revise electoral rolls as an affront to Bihari pride, the controversy now appears set to become one of the biggest polarised political debates in the run-up to the assembly polls. Bihar leader of opposition and the RJD's chief ministerial face Tejashwi Yadav. Photo: PTI New Delhi: Days after an INDIA bloc delegation accused the Election Commission of India (ECI) of being hostile towards their concerns over the hurried exercise to revise electoral rolls in poll-bound Bihar, the state's leader of opposition Tejashwi Yadav who is also the chief ministerial face of the Rashtriya Janata Dal (RJD), on Friday (July 4) termed the 'Special Intensive Revision' (SIR) as an attack on Bihari identity. Yadav said that by singling out Bihar residents for a 'citizenship' test, the ECI has hurt the state and its people's pride. 'In the whole country, only Biharis, each and every Bihari, have been forced to prove their citizenship? Why should only Biharis and Bihar have to prove their citizenship,' an aggressive Yadav asked. Yadav asks whether the current electoral rolls are 'fake' 'It doesn't matter if you are Hindu, Muslim, Sikh or Christian, or belong to forward, backward, Dalit or extremely backward castes, everyone in Bihar will have to prove their Indian citizenship,' Yadav said. With Yadav turning the ECI's attempt to revise electoral rolls as an affront to Bihari pride, the controversy now appears set to become one of the biggest polarised political debates in the run-up to the assembly polls. Yadav asked whether the current electoral rolls were 'fake', and if the ECI believes that it was indeed 'fake', then elections held in Bihar before 2025 should also be declared fraudulent. He said that apart from the poor, around 4.5 crore migrants from Bihar also stand to lose their voting rights as a result of the SIR. He said that even if people now engage themselves in getting their lost documents, it will only encourage corruption and bribery at the regional level. Yadav said that the ECI's decision to conduct a 'Special Intensive Revision', an exercise to revise electoral rolls only months ahead of the assembly polls is a 'big conspiracy'. हर बिहारी, केवल बिहारी ही अपनी नागरिकता का सबूत देगा। जबकि इसी वोटर लिस्ट से 2024 का मतदान हुआ है। अगर ये लिस्ट फर्ज़ी है, तो सरकार भी फर्ज़ी हुई! आख़िर क्यों केवल बिहारी और बिहार अपनी नागरिकता साबित करे? ये बड़ी साज़िश है। - श्री @yadavtejashwi! #TejashwiYadav #Bihar — Office of Tejashwi Yadav (@TejashwiOffice) July 4, 2025 He appealed to people of Bihar to strengthen the INDIA bloc to take on the forces 'who wish to end the Constitutional rule, who want to remove people from voters' list, and those who want to end democracy itself'. On Wednesday (July 3, 2025), a 20-member delegation from INDIA bloc met the election commissioners, including the chief election commissioner Gyanesh Kumar, in New Delhi to voice their concerns about SIR. The INDIA bloc led by RJD, Congress, and the Left told the ECI that the limited time frame to conduct such an exercise may lead to 'mass disenfranchisement' of nearly 1 crore voters of Bihar. After the meeting, they said that the ECI officials were hostile towards their concerns, and had termed their interaction with the poll body as 'disappointing' and 'unfriendly'. Earlier, they had expressed concerns over logistical problems like poor availability of birth certificates among a large section of people, high migration rates and a historical crisis in documentation process in the state that could lead to a chaotic situation in the run-up to the assembly polls. According to the ECI, the SIR will help it identify 'illegal immigrants' and non-permanent residents of Bihar. It has announced that people will have to show documents and identity proof other than Aadhar, EPIC voters cards, and ration cards to become eligible voters. In such circumstances, birth certificates of people and their parents as proof of their places of birth, matriculation certificates, land records, or other property documents will be accepted. However, several ground reports have already said that in a state like Bihar with poor literacy rates, high school dropout rates, extreme landlessness, and all-round poverty, the SIR could lead to further problems than addressing loopholes in the electoral rolls. Given how the INDIA bloc is now upping its ante and taking on the ECI with aggression, the SIR is set to become the talking point in the run-up to the assembly polls, and may become a polarising issue. The opposition will likely battle it out with greater intensity on the electoral ground surely but it remains to be seen how the National Democratic Alliance (NDA) constituents like Nitish Kumar's Janata Dal (United), Chirag Paswan's Lok Janshakti Party, or Jitan Ram Manjhi's Hindustani Awam Morcha respond. Most of the NDA parties, including the BJP, have maintained conspicuous silence on the matter until now, although it is clear that the SIR may also affect their voter base. However, Rashtriya Lok Morcha (RLM) leader Upendra Kushwaha, who is also an ally of the BJP- NDA in Bihar has raised concerns about SIR. Kushwaha has said that it should be ensured by the ECI that no genuine voter is left out from the voter list. The Wire is now on WhatsApp. Follow our channel for sharp analysis and opinions on the latest developments.
