‘Arrogance led to her fall': Political parties react to Nkabane's axing
Opposition parties have welcomed the dismissal of
President
'President Cyril Ramaphosa has removed Dr Nobuhle Nkabane from the role of minister and higher education and training and has, in terms of section 91 (2) of the Constitution of the Republic of South Africa, appointed Mr Buti Kgwaridi Manamela minister of higher education and training,' the presidency said in a statement.
Nkabane's axing comes two days before parliament is due to vote on the national budget, including allocations for the department of higher education, which the
The DA said her removal was a 'stunning blow against ANC cadre corruption' and signalled it would now support the higher education department's budget vote.
'Seeing one ANC minister depart cabinet under storming clouds of lies, deceit, cadre deployment corruption and a Hawks investigation is a first step to restoring our faith that the GNU will not tolerate corruption,' DA spokesperson Karabo Khakhau said.
'Our demand to President Ramaphosa was for him to take action against the seriously compromised, corrupt and nefarious in the ANC, and the firing of Nkabane is the first step for him.'
The DA had submitted evidence to parliament showing that Nkabane had issued letters terminating the contracts of board members at 21 Sector Education and Training Authorities and appointed people allegedly aligned to the ANC, including the son of Mineral and Petroleum Resources Minister Gwede Mantashe.
The party accused Nkabane of undermining governance processes and misrepresenting facts to parliament.
The Inkatha Freedom Party's (IFP's) higher education portfolio committee member, Sanele Zondo, said Nkabane had brought the axe upon herself because of her arrogance and her disregard for parliamentary processes.
'She was supposed to be disciplined. She was expected to know what to do, when to do it, and how to respond appropriately to a proper commitment. But when we asked her about the processes and procedures, she refused to cooperate,' Zondo said.
'She was arrogant and unwilling to respond publicly, even though this is a matter of public interest, she brought the axe to her head and as the IFP we welcome this decision by the president. She had been invited to explain serious governance irregularities but chose not to appear. That shows contempt for parliament's oversight role. We believe her removal is justified and overdue.'
Last week Nkabane failed to attend a scheduled meeting of the portfolio committee, where she was expected to respond to MPs' questions about the Seta board dismissals.
Her absence prompted frustration across party lines, including from ANC committee members, with the chairperson, Nompendulo Mkhatshwa, confirming that the minister had failed to offer adequate reasons for her non-attendance.
'The committee is gravely concerned about the minister's failure to engage with the committee on matters of public interest and governance. Her absence has obstructed the committee's ability to exercise its oversight duties,' Mkhatshwa said during the meeting.
ActionSA MP Malebo Kobe and the party's head of students, Thabo Malosi, also welcomed Nkabane's firing, calling her tenure a failure marked by neglect, a huge housing backlog for tertiary students, the dysfunction of the
They criticised the appointment of Manamela as a missed chance for real change and urged bold reforms such as merging South Africa's education departments, expanding NSFAS, converting illegally occupied city buildings into student housing and replacing Setas with an 'opportunity' fund.
Ramaphosa's decision to remove Nkabane comes at a politically sensitive time, with the government of national unity facing another major hurdle in parliament — the Appropriation Bill vote, which requires majority support for it to pass.
The Appropriation Bill, which authorises government spending, cannot be passed unless the National Assembly approves all 42 departmental allocations ('votes') listed in schedule 1 of the Bill, said senior parliamentary legal adviser Frank Stander Jenkins.
The DA, which had vowed not to vote for Nkabane's departmental budget because of her conduct in parliament, threatened the Appropriation Bill's process.
Should the Bill be rejected, the country could face another budget impasse similar to earlier this year, when the DA led opposition to the treasury's attempts to increase VAT sparked last-minute budget changes and political stand-offs.
The budget finally passed after Finance Minister Enoch Godongwana caved and scrapped the VAT increase.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Mail & Guardian
9 hours ago
- Mail & Guardian
Ramaphosa says talks with US on tariffs ongoing as measures are delayed for seven days
President Cyril @CyrilRamaphosa/X President Cyril Ramaphosa has expressed concern over the 30% tariff imposed by the US on South African exports, despite a seven-day reprieve from implementation of the measure which had been set to kick in on Friday. South Africa is among several countries facing punitive tariffs from the US as it moves to protect its own manufacturers and labour force. On Friday, Ramaphosa said his government was finalising a package to support companies that are vulnerable to the reciprocal tariffs, adding that the details would be announced 'in due course'. He said Pretoria had submitted a framework deal to Washington in an effort to strengthen 'mutually beneficial trade and investment ties'. 'South Africa and US trade relations are complementary in nature and South African exports do not pose a threat to US industry. Importantly, SA exports to the US contain inputs from the African continent and contribute to intra-Africa trade,' he said. Ramaphosa said his government would pursue all diplomatic avenues to safeguard the country's national interests. 'It is important that, as a country, we keep our people at work and our companies producing some of the high-quality products destined for many parts of the world.' Trump's administration claims that a lack of reciprocity in trade relations has eroded the US's manufacturing base, disrupted supply chains and weakened its defence industrial base. Earlier this week, Department of Trade, Industry and Competition said South Africa It has set up an export support desk as part of a diversification strategy 'to create resilience' in the economy. The desk is collaborating with export councils, industry associations and major exporters to the US to assist in accessing alternative markets. 'We also want to reiterate that we have no intention of decoupling from the United States either. Our view is that negotiations remain the best tool to deal with the issues that are on the table,' it said. Pretoria is still waiting for a response from Washington on its proposed framework deal, which includes substantial trade and investment incentives. These include the import of between 750 and Other elements include the import of US blueberries and a commitment by South Africa to invest $3.3 billion in US industries such as mining, metals recycling, critical minerals, pharmaceuticals and The deal includes exemptions from reciprocal tariffs in key sectors, including shipbuilding, counter-seasonal agriculture and exports by micro, small and medium enterprises with annual exports of less than $1 million. The trade department said it had been in 'intense negotiations' with the US and had signed a condition precedent document, with inputs ready for inclusion in a template expected from Washington. 'Despite the challenges that have been presented by this period, we have put our best foot forward, bringing together the subject specialists within our ranks that have dug deep to ensure that our country is adequately prepared for a number of potential scenarios,' it said.
Daily Maverick
9 hours ago
- Daily Maverick
Ramaphosa announces urgent measures to shield South African firms from Trump's tariff fallout
This comes after the Department of Trade, Industry and Competition launched an export support desk on Thursday night as one of its 'urgent interventions' to support South African exporters affected by the tariffs. South Africa is preparing a package to support companies that are vulnerable to the US tariffs, after it failed to secure a trade deal with Washington before a deadline set by US President Donald Trump. 'All channels of communication remain open to engage with the US, and our negotiators are ready pending invitation from the US,' President Cyril Ramaphosa said in a statement on Friday morning. 'In the meantime, government is finalising a package to support companies that are vulnerable to the reciprocal tariffs. The package consists of a number of measures to assist companies, producers and workers affected by the tariffs on SA exports to the US. The details of the measures will be announced in due course,' said Ramaphosa. This comes after the Department of Trade, Industry and Competition launched an export support desk on Thursday night as one of its 'urgent interventions' to support South African exporters affected by the tariffs. On Thursday, Trump signed an executive order placing new tariff rates on dozens of countries, hours before the 1 August 2025 deadline he had set for deals to be made. Some countries received modified tariff rates, while South Africa's remained at the 30% previously proposed by the US. (Source: The Outlier) According to the executive order, the higher import duty rates will take effect seven days from the date of the order. 'All applicable exceptions published in the previous US executive order are set to remain in force, and these exceptions covered products such as copper, pharmaceuticals, semiconductors, lumber articles, certain critical minerals, stainless steel scrap and energy products,' said Ramaphosa. South African officials have been working frantically for months to secure a trade deal with the US to avert Trump's punishing tariffs. South Africa proffered a proposed framework deal to US trade representatives in Washington in May, before Ramaphosa and Trump met at the White House. Representatives were later told they needed to revise this proposal, in accordance with the Trump administration's new template for US trade with sub-Saharan Africa, which they were told would be shared ' soon '. Earlier this week, it appeared the country was still waiting for this template. In his statement, Ramaphosa said the department was in 'constant contact' with the US on its framework deal. He said trade relations between SA and the US were 'complementary in nature' and that South African exports 'do not pose a threat' to US industry. 'South Africa will continue to pursue all diplomatic efforts to safeguard its national interests. It is important that as a country we keep our people at work and our companies producing some of the high-quality products destined for many parts of the world. 'To this end, government will intensify its diversification strategy to create resilience of our economy, and is working with export councils and industry associations, as well as top exporters to the US with a view to assist with alternative markets,' he said. Call to renew 'intensive negotiations' Dr Boitshoko Ntshabele, the CEO of the Citrus Growers Association, told Daily Maverick the 30% tariff 'will be felt most acutely in rural communities in the Northern and Western Cape, the two provinces from which we export to the US'. Ntshabele said it was still possible to reach a trade deal with the US before 7 August, and called on Ramaphosa to renew 'intensive negotiations'. 'The category of seasonal fresh produce offers clear mutual benefits to both countries. South African citrus is exported to the US during the northern hemisphere's summer months. This secures continued supply in the category and in no way threatens domestic US growers. 'It is notable that Brazilian orange juice has been exempted from US tariffs. Fresh South African citrus plays a significant role in keeping America healthy, keeping citrus consumers in the category, and in avoiding possible citrus price increases. 'We have passed the middle of the southern hemisphere's citrus season, and local citrus growers have managed to accelerate a limited number of shipments to the US in the past weeks, which has mitigated some of the effects of the tariff on the current season's US exports. But should a beneficial trade deal not be concluded, our next export season will feel the full effect of the tariff.' Ntshabele welcomed the department's emergency measures, but said that without a deal, 'Our growers in the Western and Northern Cape will face a potentially devastating scenario, especially since the US citrus market's appetite for our produce until very recently offered the potential for creating many more local citrus jobs.' 'No company can compete with 30% tariffs' The Congress of South African Trade Unions (Cosatu) on Friday said it was 'extremely concerned' about the impact of the 30% tariff on all South African goods, barring minerals. 'We fear the devastation this will wreak upon farmworkers in the citrus industry from the Western Cape to Limpopo, to motor manufacturing workers from the Eastern Cape to Gauteng. No company can compete with 30% tariffs. Many may close,' said Cosatu in a statement. Daily Maverick reported previously that Trump's punishing tariffs would kneecap South African industries, including the automotive sector and the citrus industry. 'This calamity has been made worse as South Africa has been unfairly made a global skunk with comparatively far better tariffs of 15% announced for neighbouring states, economic sector competitors and most of the world, ironically including many regimes with dubious understandings of the rule of law and real human rights abuses and genocides, who will now have a real advantage over South African exports,' Cosatu added. In a statement on Friday morning, DA spokespersons on Trade, Industry and International Relations, MPs Toby Chance and Ryan Smith, said that the commencement of the 30% tariffs on SA goods was a 'devastating outcome' for the country. 'Both the departments of Trade, Industry and Competition, and International Relations and Cooperation should hang their heads in profound shame today. This 'no deal' scenario is due to sheer negligence, failed diplomacy and ineptitude,' they said. The Nelson Mandela Bay Business Chamber said that the imposition of the 30% tariffs was a 'big blow for local businesses, especially in the automotive and agricultural sectors'. 'The Eastern Cape economy is likely to be the most adversely affected in the country by these developments. 'We are deeply concerned about the impact these developments may have on our automotive industry, which is anchored by the Original Equipment Manufacturers (OEMs) which undertake completely knocked down assembly in South Africa. These OEMs are responsible for creating well over a 100,000 jobs at their own operations and within their components supplier networks. 'Furthermore it is estimated that the knock-on employment impact of these OEMs and components manufacturers results in over 500,000 formal jobs being created across the entire automotive supply chain. Around 40% of automotive employment in the country is located in the Eastern Cape,' the chamber said in a statement. DM
Daily Maverick
9 hours ago
- Daily Maverick
Emfuleni crisis highlights local government debt as Treasury cracks the whip
The closure of the Emfuleni Local Municipality offices due to unpaid rent highlights the local government debt crisis, something Treasury hopes to fix by withholding grants from defaulting municipalities. Residents of Emfuleni were unable to make payments or lodge enquiries at the municipality's Vanderbijlpark offices this week after they were locked due to the failure to pay the monthly R6.4-million rent. According to the DA's Emfuleni caucus leader, Duncan Mthembu, this is a 'powerful symbol' of a nationwide crisis of municipal dysfunction and ballooning debt. Freedom Front Plus Councillor Hein van der Lith said the property owner had closed the building, which has more than 100 offices, twice previously this year and three times in 2024. He said the closure follows a recent recommendation from the Gauteng Legislature's Committee on Cooperative Governance and Traditional Affairs (Cogta) to place the troubled municipality under administration. Emfuleni was recently identified by Finance Minister Enoch Godongwana as one of 39 municipalities that have persistently failed to pay water boards and other parties such as pension funds, medical aids, SARS, the Auditor-General, and continues to adopt unfunded budgets. The minister said he would suspend all grants to the 39 municipalities for the rest of the financial year due to their ongoing failures. The DA's Mthembu said the closure of the Emfuleni offices meant 'residents have been left confused and stuck on how to proceed in getting assistance with payments and enquiries'. Emfuleni is located in Gauteng and comprises areas such as Vanderbijlpark. Mthembu said this was 'nothing more but an abject failure in governance, and something as simple as communication. The municipality could not even inform residents of their offices' closure.' Account attached Emfuleni's problems have been compounded by Rand Water's decision to attach the municipality's bank account due to its R1.7-billion unpaid debt. Emfuleni Municipality spokesperson Makhosonke Sangweni denied that the municipality had failed to honour its payment agreement with Rand Water, describing it as 'arbitrary'. Emfuleni Finance MMC Hassan Mako said, 'The municipality is unable to access its bank account because Rand Water has attached the account, and this situation has persisted for two months.' He said the municipality had considered taking the matter to court, but the mayor refused. Mako said the municipality had formed a special purpose vehicle (SPV) with Rand Water that would manage the water and sanitation services. 'However, Rand Water seems to be more focused on delaying the launch process by continuously attaching the municipality's accounts,' said Mako. 'The SPV project requires R1.3-billion, while Rand Water is owed R1.7-billion. Nevertheless, the municipality has committed to servicing the debt in tranches so that other service providers can be paid,' said Mako. Describing the impact of having its bank account attached, Mako said, 'There is no diesel to pick up refuse. Contractors that were assisting us with cleaning illegal dumps are not paid and have left the sites. When offices are closed, it means workers are paid salaries for doing nothing, and municipal infrastructure projects are suffering.' Emfuleni also owes Eskom R8.5-billion as at the end of June 2025. 'We believe the municipality is being held ransom by Rand Water, which negatively impacts service delivery. As a collective, we urge the mayor to lead by allowing this matter to be resolved in court in the best interest of service delivery,' Mako added. Emfuleni's municipal debt came under the spotlight in a letter from Godongwana to Cogta Minister Velenkosini Hlabisa on the ongoing crisis in municipalities. Gondongwana cracks whip on debt-ridden municipalities At the end of June, Godongwana informed Hlabisa that he would invoke Section 216(2) of the Constitution against the 39 most dysfunctional municipalities for 'persistent non-compliance'. This section allows the National Treasury to stop the transfer of funds to an organ of state if it commits a 'serious or persistent material breach' of measures designed to ensure transparency and expenditure control. According to Godongwana, Treasury has outlined a strict mechanism to force compliance: if any of the 18 defaulting municipalities fail to provide proof of full payment to their respective water boards within seven days of the 30 June letter, their Local Government Equitable Share (LGES) will be stopped. This withheld equitable share will only be released in portions, with stringent conditions. The first portion must be strictly used to pay current water board accounts, with proof of payment required, before a second amount is released for arrears owed under a valid repayment arrangement. According to the letter from Godongwana, if these conditions were not met, or if evidence of payments to institutions such as SARS, pension funds and other statutory third parties is not submitted, Treasury would approach Parliament to endorse the stopping of all LGES transfers for the rest of the 2025/26 municipal financial year. Municipal financial years run from 1 July to 30 June. Treasury also plans to withhold conditional infrastructure transfers. 'It is advisable that, parallel to the LGES withholding process, Rand Water, Vaal Central, Lepelle Northern, and Magalies Water enforce their credit control policies to also attach the bank accounts of the defaulting municipalities to enforce a change in behaviour of these municipalities. The same applies to all the water boards, in order to avoid a similar situation and prevent escalating debt across water boards,' said Godongwana. Earlier this year, Hlabisa told Daily Maverick the national government was sending a message to municipalities that 'it is time to pay'. During his 2025 departmental budget vote debate speech, the Cogta minister said: 'We have concurred with Treasury to compel the payments for water boards and Eskom, and pay pension and medical aid contributions to third parties. Notably, the same principle will have to apply to all government departments who owe municipalities, they must be compelled to pay what is due to municipalities.' Municipalities across the country owe Eskom almost R110-billion. Writing in Business Live, Municipal IQ managing director Kevin Allan said the local government debt crisis was caused by poor governance, a lack of oversight, and weak administrative capacity. 'The suspension of grants, therefore, represents the Treasury's move from carrot to stick. But this approach is not without risk. Service interruptions, project delays and cash flow constraints may follow in affected municipalities. Residents could bear the brunt of deteriorating services, and protest action may escalate,' said Allan. He described Treasury's decision as 'both bold and necessary'. 'The stakes are enormous. Without intervention, the escalating debt spiral could not only collapse local government, but destabilise national service delivery and weaken the country's fiscal standing,' Allan continued. 'Above all, municipalities must get back to basics. They must adopt funded budgets, bill accurately, collect revenue diligently and prioritise creditor payments. Professionalising financial management, insulating administration from politics and enforcing accountability are not optional – they are essential. DM
