9 people plead not guilty in a Texas elections probe involving 'vote harvesting'
HOUSTON (AP) — Nine people, including a former mayor and city council member and the chief of staff to a state representative, pleaded not guilty on Wednesday to felony charges brought forth in a rural Texas county by Republican Attorney General Ken Paxton as part of a widening elections investigation that is being criticized by Latino rights activists as being politically driven.
The nine people appeared either in person or by Zoom during a court hearing in Pearsall, Texas, before state District Judge Sid Harle.
All of the nine people, who were indicted in late June, have been charged with what is known in Texas as vote harvesting, a felony that often involves payment for collecting and dropping off other people's absentee ballots.
In May, six other people, including Frio County Judge Rochelle Camacho, the top elected official in the county, were indicted as part of Paxton's investigation.
One of the individuals who pleaded not guilty on Wednesday was Juan Manuel Medina, who is the chief of staff for state Rep. Elizabeth Campos. Medina is also former chairman of the Democratic Party of Bexar County, where San Antonio is located.
Medina's lawyer, Gerry Goldstein, declined to comment on Wednesday. 'I'm going to do my talking in the courtroom,' Goldstein said.
On Wednesday, Goldstein filed a motion to dismiss the indictment against Medina, who is accused of providing compensation as a third party to two people for vote harvesting in February 2024.
In the motion to dismiss, Goldstein said the vote-harvesting statute is overbroad, vague and 'restricts Constitutionally protected rights to speech and to participate in the election and voting process in violation of the First Amendment.'
Goldstein said in the motion that the vote-harvesting statute 'would appear to punish a broad range of protected speech, including non-coercive voter assistance and core political expression, without requiring any actual voter fraud, coercion, or intimidation.'
'This indictment charges Medina in a capacity that is not a crime and the indictment should be dismissed,' Goldstein said in his 20-page motion.
The vote-harvesting charges are third-degree felonies and carry up to 10 years in prison. The other people who were indicted in June are: Cecilia Castellano, a former candidate for state representative; Frio County Commissioner Raul Carrizales; former Dilley Mayor Mary Ann Obregon; former Dilley City Council member Inelda Rodriguez; Petra Davina Trevino, a former candidate for Pearsall city council; Pearsall school district trustee Mari Benavides; Susanna Carrizales; and Rachel Leal.
Attorneys for Raul Carrizales, Susanna Carrizales, Castellano, Obregon and Rodriguez did not immediately return calls seeking comment. Attorneys for Benavides, Leal and Trevino could not immediately be reached for comment.
Paxton's office and 81st Judicial District Attorney Audrey Gossett Louis, whose office presented the case to a grand jury with the Texas Attorney General's Office, did not return a call or email seeking comment.
Last month, Paxton said that any elected official 'trying to cheat the system will have to answer for it.'
'Under my watch, attempts to rig elections and silence the will of the voters will be met with the full force of the law. I will continue to fight to ensure Texas has free and fair elections,' Paxton said in a statement.
The indictments were the latest development in an investigation that Paxton started after the 2020 election to root out voter fraud, which is rare and typically occurs in isolated instances. Texas has tightened its voter laws in recent years and increased penalties that Democrats and opponents say are attempts to suppress turnout among Black and Latino voters.
A federal appeals court last year upheld the state's law that tightened voter restrictions and increased penalties for vote harvesting.
___
Follow Juan A. Lozano: https://twitter.com/juanlozano70
Solve the daily Crossword
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
Trump Says He'll Get Rid of Mail-In Ballots and Voting Machines by 2026 Midterms After Chatting with Putin
Trump released a lengthy rant on mail-in voting just days after Russian President Vladimir Putin reportedly questioned the practice NEED TO KNOW President Donald Trump went on a lengthy social media rant against mail-in voting on Monday, promising to end the practice before the 2026 midterm elections Trump falsely claimed that the U.S. is the "only country in the world" that uses mail-in voting, calling it "highly inaccurate, very expensive and seriously controversial" The president's latest diatribe on voter fraud comes after a recent meeting with Vladimir Putin in which the Russian president reportedly told Trump that mail-in voting "rigged" the 2020 election President Donald Trump went on a lengthy social media rant about mail-in voting hours before hosting an international diplomatic summit at the White House. "I am going to lead a movement to get rid of MAIL-IN BALLOTS," he wrote on Truth Social, "and also, while we're at it, Highly 'Inaccurate,' Very Expensive, and Seriously Controversial VOTING MACHINES, which cost Ten Times more than accurate and sophisticated Watermark Paper, which is faster, and leaves NO DOUBT, at the end of the evening, as to who WON, and who LOST, the Election." "We are now the only Country in the World that uses Mail-In Voting," he falsely claimed. "All others gave it up because of the MASSIVE VOTER FRAUD ENCOUNTERED. WE WILL BEGIN THIS EFFORT, WHICH WILL BE STRONGLY OPPOSED BY THE DEMOCRATS BECAUSE THEY CHEAT AT LEVELS NEVER SEEN BEFORE, by signing an EXECUTIVE ORDER to help bring HONESTY to the 2026 Midterm Elections." Despite his lengthy post, Trump is unable to unilateraly eliminate mail-in voting. States are granted the power to decide the "times, places and manner" of their elections, and only Congress has the ability to overturn a state's voting law. However, it's clear what motivated the president's recent diatribe. After his meeting with Russian President Vladimir Putin in Alaska on Friday, Aug. 15, Trump told Fox News' Sean Hannity that the two leaders had discussed the 2020 presidential election. Trump has repeatedly and falsely blamed his loss to Joe Biden on voter fraud — even calling for an investigation days before the election — and he claimed to Hannity that Putin agreed, pointing to mail-in voting. "Vladimir Putin said something -- one of the most interesting things. He said, 'Your election was rigged because you have mail-in voting,' " Trump told Hannity. "He said, 'Mail-in voting, every election -- no country has mail-in voting. It's impossible to have mail-in voting and have honest elections.' And he said that to me because we talked about 2020. He said, 'You won that election by so much.' ""[He said] it was a rigged election," Trump added. "You can't have a great democracy, mail-in voting." Contrary to the Putin claims parroted by Trump, International IDEA reported in October 2024 that 34 countries in the world allow at least some type of mail-in voting. Twelve countries — including Canada, Germany, South Korea and more — allow it for all voters, while 22 allow it for some voters. In fact, Russia itself allows remote electronic voting — defined as "voting without voting using a paper, using special software" — as of May 2020, when Putin signed a law introducing it on the federal level. 'Putin wants to sow chaos in the American electoral system,' said Brookings Institute senior fellow Fiona Hill on Face the Nation on Sunday, Aug. 17. '[He] just, basically, used his time with President Trump to push that along…It's a diversion.' The post also came hours before Trump was set to meet with Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy and other European leaders to discuss tariffs and brief them on what was discussed during his meeting with Putin on Friday. Last week, the president claimed that there would be "severe consequences" if Putin refused to stop the war in Ukraine following their sit-down. However, following the nearly three-hour meeting, Trump announced that he'd failed to secure an agreement from the Russian president. 'There's no deal until there's a deal,' he said, after Putin claimed the two world leaders had reached "an understanding," per The Associated Press. California Gov. Gavin Newsom — whom many believe is angling for the Democratic presidential nomination in 2028 — has recently been copying Trump's cadence and capitalization in X posts from his press office account designed to provoke the MAGA crowd. Never miss a story — sign up for to stay up-to-date on the best of what PEOPLE has to offer, from celebrity news to compelling human interest stories. In his response to the president's post on mail-in voting, however, Newsom kept things more straightforward. "Trump knows he is going to LOSE in 2026," he wrote. "His plan to rig new Congressional seats is going to backfire — thanks to California. Now, he's clamoring for other ways to cook the results,""This man reeks of DESPERATION," Newsom added. "Let's keep up the pressure." Read the original article on People
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
Guernsey County Board of Elections certifies candidates for Nov. 4 general election
CAMBRIDGE ‒ The Guernsey County Board of Elections has released the names of candidates certified for the Nov. 4 general election. The board certified the candidates on Aug. 14. Cambridge Cambridge City Council president ‒ Jeff Leonard (Republican) Cambridge City treasurer ‒ Michael Sikora (Democrat) Cambridge City Council at-large (three to be elected) ‒ Tim Evancho (Republican), Ernest Gardner Jr. (Republican), Thomas Laughman II (Democrat) Ward 1 ‒ Steve Mourer (Democrat) Ward 2 ‒ Kim McMillen (Democrat) Ward 3 ‒ John Wolverton (Democrat) Ward 4 ‒ Mike Zaleski (Republican) Villages Byesville council (four to be elected) ‒ Heath Dawson, Donald Gadd, Tom Miller, Marj Warner Cumberland mayor ‒ Derek Brown Cumberland council (four to be elected) ‒ Gary Stevens Fairview council (four to be elected) ‒ Lora Cunningham, Connie Gibbons, Greg Gibbons, Ashley McConnell, James Steele Lore City council (four to be elected) ‒ no one filed Old Washington council (four to be elected) ‒ Thomas Allen, Kenneth LePage, Greg Shepherd, Justin Shepherd Pleasant City council (four to be elected) ‒ Joyce Bayly, Sydney Regan, Melanie Scurlock, Christopher Willis Pleasant City Board of Public Affairs (one to be elected) ‒ no candidate filed Quaker City council (four to be elected) ‒ Leota Alwine, Don Burkhart, Kimberley Canel, Savannah Conrad, Brandon Gardine, Ray Lucas Senecaville mayor ‒ Patrick Endly Senecaville council (four to be elected) ‒ Debbie Endly, Rebecca Forbes School boards Cambridge City (three to be elected) ‒ David Evancho, Heath Hayes, Dave Peoples East Guernsey (three to be elected) ‒ Brandon Lippert, Darcy Wakefield Dower, Tom Yeckley Rolling Hills (two to be elected) ‒ Alan Folkert, Frank Mathews, Lacey McCombs This article originally appeared on The Daily Jeffersonian: Guernsey County Board of Elections certifies fall election candidates
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
California Democrats introduce redistricting legislation
California Democrats unveiled legislation Monday to move forward with their plan to counter a Republican redistricting proposal in Texas with new congressional maps in the Golden State. 'We decided as a delegation that we could not just stand there and allow [President] Trump to distort the next election, and continue to harm the people who we represent. And so we have worked to try and identify a map that is consistent with the goals that we believe in,' Rep. Zoe Lofgren (D-Calif.) said at a press conference. Lofgren confirmed that Democrats have identified five GOP-held seats that could, if the maps are adopted, flip into the Democrats' column. A draft of the map dropped Friday. 'Unlike the Republicans in Texas, we're not just doing this in secret. We are revealing the proposed maps. The Legislature will talk about their process. … We are going to put it to [the voters] to decide,' Lofgren said. The legislation introduced Monday is part of an effort, spearheaded by California Gov. Gavin Newsom (D), to put redistricting before voters in a special election this fall, allowing the Legislature to bypass California's independent redistricting commission and redraw lines mid-decade. The legislation includes a state constitutional amendment and a call for a special election on Nov. 4. 'Donald Trump lit this fire when he pressured Texas to change the rules in the game. California is answering that attack not by breaking democracy but by protecting it,' California Assembly Elections Chair Gail Pellerin said at the press conference, stressing that 'the bills we are introducing today only take effect if another state rigs the rules.' Proponents have underscored that the new maps would only be triggered by moves in red states and that they would only hold for the '26, '28 and '30 elections, before the authority to redraw reverts to the independent commission. Newsom has explained that the Legislature is introducing a constitutional amendment 'that includes new maps that will be done in a transparent way, to request of the voters on a special election on November 4th to move forward with mid-decade redistricting, which in essence will neutralize, or neuter, whatever happens in Texas.' 'We won't move forward – it's a trigger – unless Texas or other Republican states move forward. It will be temporary. It will be done on an emergency basis. It will also be done in a way that reinforces our commitment to nationwide independent redistricting,' Newsom said in a video shared Monday to social platform X. A bill and a constitutional amendment introduced in the state Assembly deal with the proposed maps and the system changes, and a bill in the state Senate handles funding for the special election, according to the Assembly's redistricting webpage. The state Legislature, where Democrats boast supermajority control, reconvened Monday afternoon after a summer break and is expected to move quickly to set up a special election in November. Meanwhile, Texas state House Democrats who fled the state to stall a GOP redistricting plan returned to the state Legislature Monday, all but ensuring the Lone Star State maps advance — which would trigger the California changes, assuming Golden State voters approve the plan. Copyright 2025 Nexstar Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.
