Senior police manager alleges 'boys' club' culture among Northland detectives
Detectives from the Northland CIB team have been giving evidence this week about allegations of bullying another staff member.
Photo:
NZME
A senior police manager alleges she was met with swirling gossip, private group chats and a pervasive "boys' club" culture when she stepped into a leadership role overseeing the predominantly male detective team in Northland.
The allegations now form the basis of an Employment Relations Authority (ERA) hearing in Whangārei this week.
Bridget Louise Doell, a senior police officer with three decades of experience, was seconded to the crime area manager role in 2020, overseeing senior detectives in the criminal investigation branch (CIB) at Whangārei police station.
The role involves operational oversight of inspectors, but Doell's evidence has been that the transition was met with resistance.
Over the next three years, she claims she was sidelined by detectives, describing a toxic workplace culture marked by gossip, exclusion from key decisions, and repeated allegations of bullying.
Doell said she eventually took a secondment to Auckland because she felt she could no longer run a district while detectives were speaking negatively about her behind her back.
She filed a personal grievance against the Police Commissioner, seeking damages for humiliation.
"I felt really duped," she said through tears at the hearing.
Authority member Andrew Gane has heard evidence from several detective inspectors and former Northland district commander Superintendent Tony Hill.
Former Northland district commander Superintendent Tony Hill.
Photo:
RNZ / Simon Rogers
Doell has given a statement saying she was never formally welcomed into the role or introduced to key stakeholders, such as Mike Smith, who was the Northland Crown Solicitor at the time.
In one case, she said she tried to contact Smith for six months to discuss a case, but never heard back from him.
Smith told the authority it wasn't his decision to lay charges and, by the time a meeting was held about the case, other detective inspectors had been assigned.
Doell alleges that, when detective inspectors Shane Pilmer and Dene Begbie met the Crown on her case, they had gone over her head.
"I felt Dene interjected more than he should. He should have left it to me to meet with the Crown."
Her lawyer, Maria Dew, KC, questioned Smith on whether he had intentionally avoided her phone calls, suggesting it may have been because of disparaging remarks made by Begbie.
Smith denied the claim.
"The only conversation I could recall was he sang her praises - said she's come from Auckland, it's a step up," Smith said.
He said Begbie had suggested he meet Doell but, when pressed by Dew, Smith conceded the meeting never happened and he could not recall why.
Inspector Al Symonds gave evidence around a period in 2022 while he was acting area commander and sharing an office with Doell.
Doell returned from a conference in Auckland to find her desk broken and her personal belongings gathered in a box on the floor outside the office.
Symonds, who was temporarily in the role for only four months, gave evidence that he had moved her desk to reach cables and it had collapsed. He said he believed he needed privacy in his role and could not share an office.
Dew put to him that it was a humiliating experience for Doell, just one of many.
When Superintendent Tony Hill heard about the incident, he recognised it would have been humiliating and allegedly told Symonds to apologise. But Symonds said he never received that request and had nothing to apologise for.
It was around this time that a workplace survey was released on the Northland CIB, which highlighted its negative culture.
"I'd heard about personality clashes. It was gossip I didn't pay attention to," Symonds said.
"Had you heard anything about Bridget's behaviour?" Dew asked.
"Not specifically," Symonds responded.
The authority member asked Symonds about his view of the culture at the time, to which he responded that there was a lot of hurt going on.
"It's not Bridget that was doing that, it wasn't directed at her. There was a lot of stuff going on that I think had to be fixed," Symonds said.
The authority member then asked Symonds whether he recognised that the desk incident could have made her feel humiliated.
"Well, I can't say what she felt. It wasn't my intention."
Throughout the hearing, statements have been made about Detective Inspector Joshua Lautogo's strained relationship with Doell, including an alleged incident in which he was witnessed bad-mouthing Doell "with hate in his eyes".
The staff member who witnessed Lautogo's alleged outburst reported the incident up the chain. However, when Lautogo gave evidence, he said the incident never occurred.
Evidence was put to Lautogo that he had been making disparaging remarks about Doell, specifically in text messages to Detective Inspector Kevan Verry.
"It's born out of my frustration at the time in dealing with Bridget, and it is an example of managing up and expressing frustration to my direct supervisor," Lautogo said.
He felt as though Doell was systematically targeting him and, when he raised questions, he was misconstrued as being argumentative.
Lautogo told the authority he ended up leaving because he could no longer work with Doell.
Detective Inspectors Verry, Rhys Johnson, Geoff McCarthy and David Lynch have also given evidence.
The case finished on Friday, with a decision to be released at a later date.
-This story originally appeared in the
New Zealand Herald
.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles

RNZ News
an hour ago
- RNZ News
One seriously injured after assault in Manukau city centre
Police at the scene of Monday's night incident. Photo: RNZ / Kim Baker Wilson One person has been seriously injured in an assault in the Manukau city centre. Emergency services are responding on Manukau Station Road after being alerted about 8.15pm this evening. The injured person has been taken to Middlemore Hospital. Police are working to locate those involved.

RNZ News
2 hours ago
- RNZ News
Ōmokoroa pub confrontation ends with couple followed home, and a ‘trail of blood'
By Hannah Bartlett of File photo. Photo: SunLive Terse words outside a pub on a Saturday afternoon ended with a "trail of blood" at a Bay of Plenty property, after three men followed a couple home and beat them up. Two men have been sentenced in the Tauranga District Court over the incident. The assault began when victim Beau-Derek Toi Toi thought one of the defendants was staring at him, as Toi Toi drove past The Village Green pub on his way to the Ōmokoroa shops last July. He yelled: "What's your f***ing problem?" before getting out of his car and confronting Fletcher Shane Laurence, who was at the pub having a drink with a woman. Toi Toi believed Laurence and the woman were "staring at him". The two men exchanged words, with Laurence suggesting they "meet at the top of the hill in 20 minutes". But Toi Toi left. According to the Crown summary of facts he "did not want the verbal exchange to escalate into a fight", so he and his partner went to the laundromat and, about 20 minutes later, headed home. However, Laurence enlisted the help of two friends, and the trio followed Toi Toi and his partner Pania Pettifer home, pulling into their driveway behind them. There they began an "ongoing" attack on the couple, for which two of the three were today sentenced in the Tauranga District Court. According to the summary of facts, Samuel Sparham was wearing "black gloves with padded knuckles" as he got out of the car, driven by a man who can not be named for legal reasons, and accused Toi Toi of threatening his family. The driver and Sparham punched Toi Toi about 20 times, hitting his face and body as he was pushed up against the car. Toi Toi managed to punch Sparham once, then made his way around to the side of the house. Pettifer approached Laurence and asked him: "Are you going to f***ing hit me?" He pushed her to the ground and kept walking around the house to find Toi Toi, who was now being held by his arms by the other two men. Pettifer had followed, and Laurence again pushed her to the ground before kicking Toi Toi in the chest. As Pettifer got up and ran towards Toi Toi, Sparham pushed her over, and the three men returned to their Subaru. After getting free, Toi Toi wedged himself in a gap between the top and bottom part of the house. Laurence said to Toi Toi: "There's no problem now, eh, it's all sorted... you can't call the police because we know where you live and we're gangsters." The summary of facts stated after the attack, there was a "trail of blood" along the victims' property. An ambulance took Toi Toi to hospital where he was found to have fractures to his ribs and face, as well as swelling on his forehead. Reparation was sought by the victims for the "security cameras and dog" they'd acquired, due to feeling unsafe after the attack. The pair's victim impact statements spoke of the continued anxiety they both suffer, and are on medication for, as well as the impact it's had on their ability to sleep. They now own four dogs, and Toi Toi still has breathing difficulties because of the injuries to his nose and sinuses. They both fear bumping into the trio again, and are reluctant to go out in public. The three faced charges of injuring with intent to injure and common assault, and the driver also faced a charge of driving while disqualified. Laurence sought a sentence indication by Judge Melinda Mason, which all three accepted, in which the judge noted the aggravating factors were the multiple attackers, attacks to the head, and the extensive injuries. She did not accept the Crown's submission of victim vulnerability, or that it was an unprovoked attack. "In my view... it was not an unprovoked attack, nor was it pre-mediated, although it was ongoing," said Judge Mason. "I do not consider that to be an aggravating factor, particularly when the complainant was the initial aggressor and he was followed back." Judge Mason adopted a starting point of 26 months' imprisonment, and the defendants were allowed a 20% discount for pleading guilty. Reparation of $1152 was sought and was to be shared across the three defendants. Laurence was sentenced to 10 months' home detention, with six months' post-detention conditions. Sparham was sentenced to 17 months' imprisonment, after an uplift for offending while parole was applied, but was also given discounts for his background, prospects of rehabilitation, and remorse. He offered to pay $2500 emotional harm reparation, and the judge ordered that to be paid within 48 hours. He was currently serving another term of imprisonment, on unrelated matters, and was granted leave to apply for home detention once that sentence was complete. The third defendant's sentencing was adjourned until Friday at 11am, for reasons that can not be reported. - This story was originally published by the NZ Herald

RNZ News
3 hours ago
- RNZ News
Record-breaking amount of LSD worth more than $1 million seized
More than 40,000 tabs of LSD was found. Photo: Supplied / NZ Police A record-breaking quantity of LSD with a street value of more than $1 million has been seized. More than 40,000 tabs of the illicit substance has been found after police executed four search warrants across Auckland last week. It came as a result of an investigation into the importation and supply of class A drugs from the United States into New Zealand. Photo: Supplied / NZ Police The largest LSD seizure previously seen here was in 2000 when police seized two separate hauls of 14,000 tabs each. A 30-year-old man is facing several drug charges including for possession and supply of cocaine and LSD, while a 25-year-old man has been charged with importing cocaine. Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.