Vaccine injury programs elsewhere also face challenges, criticism
Similar efforts in the U.S., U.K. and Australia have come under scrutiny for allegedly failing to support families amid surging applications and desperate pleas for help.
The Australian government closed its new injury claim program and stopped accepting new applications on Sept. 30, 2024, after complaints about how applicants were treated.
Australia had reportedly paid out about C$28.5 million in injury compensation. Its program has been widely criticized at home and by the global cable news outlet, Sky News.
One veteran Australian Liberal MP has begun publicly advocating in Parliament for the injured.
'Some of them are so severely damaged'
'It's very distressing even to have these people face to face and speaking to them when you see some of them are so severely damaged,' MP Russell Broadbent told Sky News.
Story continues below advertisement
The U.K. program's administration costs were the equivalent of C$46 million as of January 2025. That sum exceeds the reported C$43.5 million spent on payouts to injured residents, The Daily Telegraph reported.
Get weekly health news
Receive the latest medical news and health information delivered to you every Sunday. Sign up for weekly health newsletter Sign Up
By providing your email address, you have read and agree to Global News' Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy
As of January 2025, more than 17,500 Britons or their families have made injury claims, but several told the BBC they felt like they had been 'airbrushed out of the pandemic.'
View image in full screen
People lined up for vaccination at St Thomas' Hospital in London on Dec. 15, 2021. Long lines formed for booster shots across England at the time as the U.K. government urged adults to protect themselves against the omicron variant. Frank Augstein / Associated Press
Some Britons have also criticized their program as too slow to assess injury cases, with thresholds made too high to qualify and payouts too low for those who get them.
The U.S. government also faces a flood of claims, but most are being rejected.
Data shows 13,836 people have filed COVID-19 injury claims under the U.S. Health Resources and Services Administration's (HRSA) Countermeasures Injury Compensation Program as of May 1, 2025.
Story continues below advertisement
The countermeasures effort exists as a separate program from its vaccine injury system to compensate people hurt during national emergencies, like COVID-19, when new vaccines or treatments are rolled out.
U.S. officials reported that of the 13,836 COVID-19-related countermeasures injury claims it has received so far, the HRSA has issued decisions in 4,413 cases, denying 4,338 claims.
To date, U.S. officials have found only 75 claims eligible for compensation. The number of claims compensated totaled just 39, according to data disclosed on June 1.
The American program has been harshly criticized, as well.
And a U.S. congressional committee has warned that without major reforms, clearing the backlog in the countermeasures program may take almost 10 years.
The U.S. program states on its website that officials assessing the majority of COVID-19 countermeasure injury claims are 'still waiting for records and documentation to be submitted.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Winnipeg Free Press
a day ago
- Winnipeg Free Press
David Nabarro, British physician who led UN response to Ebola and COVID-19, dies
GENEVA (AP) — Dr. David Nabarro, a British physician who led the U.N. response to some of the biggest health crises in recent years, including bird flu, Ebola and the coronavirus pandemic, has died. Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus, director-general of the World Health Organization, confirmed Nabarro's death on social media platform X. 'David was a great champion of global health and health equity, and a wise, generous mentor to countless individuals,' Tedros wrote Saturday. 'His work touched and impacted so many lives across the world.' King Charles knighted Nabarro in 2023 for his contributions to global health after he served as one of six special envoys to the WHO on COVID-19. He won the 2018 World Food Prize for his work on health and hunger issues. He also was a candidate for the top job at the WHO in 2017 but lost out to Tedros in the final round of voting. Nabarro left the U.N. later that year. The 4SD Foundation, a social enterprise in Switzerland focused on mentoring the next generation of leaders in global sustainable development, said its strategic director died at his home Friday in a 'sudden passing.' Other details were not immediately available. Wednesdays What's next in arts, life and pop culture. 'David's generosity and unwavering commitment to improve the lives of others will be sorely missed,' the foundation wrote on its website Saturday. Survivors include his wife, Flo, as well as his five children and seven grandchildren.
Toronto Star
2 days ago
- Toronto Star
Manitoba reaches settlement with family of woman who died after halted medical flight
WINNIPEG - The Manitoba government says it has settled a lawsuit with the family of a woman who died during the COVID-19 pandemic while in the process of being transferred out of province due to a shortage of hospital beds. Matt Wiebe, minister of justice and the province's attorney general, confirmed a settlement was recently reached with the family of Krystal Mousseau more than two years after Mousseau's mother first sued the provincial government and health agencies.
Winnipeg Free Press
2 days ago
- Winnipeg Free Press
Manitoba reaches settlement with family of woman who died after halted medical flight
WINNIPEG – The Manitoba government says it has settled a lawsuit with the family of a woman who died during the COVID-19 pandemic while in the process of being transferred out of province due to a shortage of hospital beds. Matt Wiebe, minister of justice and the province's attorney general, confirmed a settlement was recently reached with the family of Krystal Mousseau more than two years after Mousseau's mother first sued the provincial government and health agencies. Elaine Mousseau alleged that cuts to health care and improper medical decisions contributed to her daughter's death in May 2021. Mousseau was in intensive care with severe COVID-19 pneumonia and died after being taken by ambulance to a waiting airplane that was to take her to Ottawa. Details of the settlement were not made available. Wiebe says he is pleased the province has been able to reach an agreement with the Mousseau family. 'While it can't bring back their loved one or repair the harms done to their family, we hope this agreement brings them clarity and a sense of closure,' Wiebe said in a statement on Friday. 'Our government remains committed to rebuilding health care in northern Manitoba and across our province.' Mousseau died on May 25, 2021, after an aborted attempt to fly her from an intensive care unit in Brandon, Man., to a hospital in Ottawa. The province, under the previous Progressive Conservative government, sent dozens of intensive-care patients to other provinces that spring due to a shortage of beds as COVID-19 cases rose and hospitals struggled to deal with an influx of people needing care. Elaine Mousseau alleged that the government and Shared Health, the provincial body that co-ordinates many health services, failed to provide proper care. Shared Health said on Friday that any settlement is confidential in nature and it would not be commenting on the matter. Elaine Mousseau's lawyer was not immediately made available to comment on the settlement. A letter from the regional authority in western Manitoba to the family shortly after Krystal Mousseau's death, which was released publicly, said the transport team did not have a piece of equipment that would let them constantly monitor Mousseau's blood pressure, so a blood-pressure cuff was used instead. Mousseau was also being given at least one medication at the wrong rate, the letter stated. The lawsuit alleged the Tory government ignored warnings in 2019 when it privatized some air ambulance services. The government also created a scenario where hospitals couldn't deal with an influx of patients when it reduced the number of critical care beds in 2019, the lawsuit claimed. The statement of claim also alleged staff at the hospital allowed Mousseau to leave while she was in unstable condition and at severe risk. Mousseau showed high blood pressure and a sudden elevated heart rate shortly before she was put into the ambulance on the way to the airport, the statement of claim alleged. She went into cardiac arrest while in the ambulance, was sent back to hospital, and suffered another cardiac arrest and multiple organ failure before being pronounced dead the next day, the document said. This report by The Canadian Press was first published July 25, 2025.
