US court reinstates $81 million award against Boeing in trade secrets case
The 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals overturned, opens new tab a California judge's decision to throw out a jury verdict for Zunum, rejecting his finding that the information Boeing allegedly stole was not entitled to trade-secret protection.
A spokesperson for Boeing declined to comment on the appeals court's decision. Zunum attorney Vincent Levy of Holwell Shuster & Goldberg said that the decision "affirms what we have said from the start — that Zunum had an enormous opportunity to remake air travel, but Boeing took that opportunity away."
Washington State-based Zunum was founded in 2013 to develop small electric commuter aircraft that can travel up to 1,500 miles. Boeing's venture capital arm invested $5 million in the startup in 2017.
Zunum said in a 2020 lawsuit that it planned to begin selling its planes in 2022 but halted development after Boeing allegedly blocked its access to capital. The complaint said that Boeing developed its hybrid commuter aircraft using Zunum's trade secrets.
A federal jury last May awarded Zunum nearly $81.2 million from Boeing for trade secret theft and $11.6 million for tortious interference, but reduced the total award to $72 million based on damages that it said Zunum could have mitigated.
U.S. District Judge James Robart later set the final award at $81 million, but overturned the verdict last August after determining that Zunum did not adequately identify its secrets or show that they derived their value from being kept secret.
The 9th Circuit said on Thursday, however, that Zunum had provided "sufficient specificity" for the jury to find that its secrets were legally protectable as well as "not generally known, not readily ascertainable, and valuable."
The appeals court also ordered the case to be assigned to a new judge after Robart revealed that his wife had acquired Boeing stock through a retirement savings account during the litigation.
The case is Zunum Aero Inc v. Boeing Co, 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals, No. 24-5212.
For Zunum: Vincent Levy of Holwell Shuster & Goldberg
For Boeing: Moez Kaba of Hueston Hennigan
Read more:
Boeing hit with $72 mln verdict in EV aircraft trade secrets case
Boeing should pay more than $300 mln after US verdict, EV aircraft maker says
Boeing convinces US judge to overturn $72 mln trade-secrets verdict
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mail
32 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
Travel chaos as Air Canada suspends ALL operations
Air Canada has cancelled hundreds of flights and suspended all operations following a massive strike by unionized flight attendants. The airline was forced to ground planes after 10,000 staff walked out amid a bitter contract dispute. The industrial action began on Saturday at around 1am ET and immediately saw all 700 flights per day the airline offers cancelled. Around 130,000 people could be impacted for every day the strike continues. Air Canada is the foreign carrier with the largest number of flights to the U.S. Flight attendants are seeking changes which would see them be paid for time spent on the ground between flights and helping passengers board. The feud escalated Friday, after the union turned down the airline's request to enter into government-directed arbitration, which would eliminate its right to strike and allow a third-party mediator to decide the terms of a new contract. Canadian Union of Public Employees spokesman Hugh Pouliot confirmed the strike has started after no deal was reached and operations were halted shortly after. Air Canada said it planned to begin locking flight attendants out of airports as the walkout commenced. Canada's Federal Jobs Minister Patty Hajdu met with both the airline and union on Friday night and urged them to work harder to them to reach a deal 'once and for all'. 'It is unacceptable that such little progress has been made. Canadians are counting on both parties to put forward their best efforts,' Hajdu said in a statement posted on social media. Pouliot, the spokesman for the union, earlier said the union had a meeting with Hajdu and representatives from Air Canada earlier Friday evening. 'CUPE has engaged with the mediator to relay our willingness to continue bargaining - despite the fact that Air Canada has not countered our last two offers since Tuesday,' he said in a email. 'We´re here to bargain a deal, not to go on strike.' A complete shutdown will impact about 130,000 people a day, and some 25,000 Canadians a day may be stranded abroad. Air Canada operates around 700 flights per day. Montreal resident Alex Laroche, 21, and his girlfriend had been saving since Christmas for their European vacation. Their $8,000 trip with nonrefundable lodging is on the line as they wait to hear from Air Canada about the fate of their Saturday night flight to Nice, France. The length of the strike is yet to be determined, but Air Canada Chief Operating Officer Mark Nasr has said it could take up to a week to fully restart operations once a tentative deal is reached. Passengers whose travel is impacted will be eligible to request a full refund on the airline's website or mobile app, according to Air Canada. The airline said it would also offer alternative travel options through other Canadian and foreign airlines when possible. But it warned that it could not guarantee immediate rebooking because flights on other airlines are already full 'due to the summer travel peak.' Laroche said he considered booking new flights with a different carrier, but he said most of them are nearly full and cost more than double the $3,000 they paid for their original tickets. 'At this point, it´s just a waiting game,' he said. Laroche said he was initially upset over the union´s decision to go on strike, but that he had a change of heart after reading about the key issues at the center of the contract negotiations, including the issue of wages. 'Their wage is barely livable,' Laroche said. Air Canada and the Canadian Union of Public Employees have been in contract talks for about eight months, but they have yet to reach a tentative deal. Both sides say they remain far apart on the issue of pay and the unpaid work flight attendants do when planes aren´t in the air. The airline´s latest offer included a 38 percent increase in total compensation, including benefits and pensions over four years, that it said 'would have made our flight attendants the best compensated in Canada.' But the union pushed back, saying the proposed 8 percent raise in the first year didn´t go far enough because of inflation.
Daily Mail
an hour ago
- Daily Mail
Once neglected Midwest city revs back to life as an ultramodern hotspot
Detroit was once in such bad shape it was forced to declare bankruptcy. Now, it is experiencing somewhat of a miracle. Home to a major music movement and the birthplace of the American car, this Midwest city had $1 homes for sale in [TK year]. Now, it's being reborn as an affordable hotspot with booming job and housing markets.
Daily Mail
2 hours ago
- Daily Mail
Playboy ditches Hollywood roots for flashy new Miami Beach headquarters
Playboy Enterprises is officially leaving Los Angeles and moving its global headquarters to Miami Beach. The men's magazine company, once synonymous with the late Hugh Hefner's iconic mansion, announced the shocking relocation Wednesday. CEO Ben Kohn blamed the move on the Golden State's 'anti-business' approach as he revealed the company is Florida-bound. 'We are excited to move the company to the city of Miami Beach, which has been phenomenal to deal with, very pro-business,' Kohn said. 'When you look at the cost of doing business in California against the cost of doing business in Florida, and you combine that with the energy of Miami Beach, it made all the sense in the world for Playboy to move there.' Playboy is set to take over the penthouse of The RIVANI, a high-end luxury office complex in Miami Beach developed by Robert Rivani, who has reportedly invested over $100 million in the project. 'Miami Beach is one of the most iconic and fastest-growing cities in the world. It's a global hub for culture, creativity and business - exactly the kind of energy that complements Playboy's next chapter,' Rivani told Fox News Digital. 'Playboy is bringing a new twist to the brand with a hospitality component that [we] can't wait to experience,' the high-profile developer added. The company also plans to open a reimagined Playboy Club at the site, featuring a restaurant and members-only space. The men's lifestyle and entertainment brand has also announced plans to build new multimedia studios to support its growing digital content and creator licensing business in the new location, Fox Business reported. 'Content is key to our strategy. We plan on building a content team in Miami with moving the magazine as we've relaunched the magazine and the Playmate franchise, basing all of that in Miami,' Kohn said. 'And then we have a massive licensing business on a global basis, and we plan on building a significant licensing team in Miami as well.' While Playboy did not disclose how many employees are affected by the move, it confirmed plans to complete the transition by next year. The company currently operates out of a Wilshire Boulevard office in Westwood, Los Angeles. Miami Beach city officials have welcomed the move as a win for local economic development, and even sent local city commissioners to compete with other U.S. cities for months to land the deal. The relocation comes amid a growing wave of high-profile corporate exits from California. In recent years, Tesla, Chevron, Charles Schwab, and In-N-Out have all shifted major operations to states like Texas and Tennessee, citing lower taxes, lighter regulations, and lower operational costs. California holds the nation's highest personal income tax rate at 13.3 percent, including on investment profits, which Kohn and other critics have argued stifles growth, The Los Angeles Times reported. For Playboy, the move also marks a return to its South Florida roots. The brand opened its second-ever Playboy Club in Miami in 1961 and later operated the Playboy Plaza Hotel on Miami Beach in the 1970s. Founded in 1953, Playboy rose to prominence as a lifestyle and entertainment brand featuring Marilyn Monroe in its first issue. Soon after, it became a pop culture force throughout the 1960s and 70s, known not just for its provocative imagery but also for publishing literary fiction and interviews with figures like Martin Luther King Jr. and Jimmy Carter. But, in recent years, Playboy has shifted focus from print to digital content, fashion, brand licensing, and sexual wellness, with the print magazine ceasing regular publication back in 2020. More recently, the company reported a $7.7 million net loss in the most recent quarter, but tallied a 13 percent increase in revenue driven by licensing, according to Fox Business. As Playboy prepares to settle into its new Miami Beach headquarters, Rivani framed the move as symbolic of a broader trend. 'The move is part of a larger migration of influential companies leaving L.A. and New York for South Florida,' he said. 'When people think of Miami Beach, they think of iconic brands, an unbeatable lifestyle and endless possibilities - and Playboy's arrival amplifies all of that.' Meanwhile, Kohn says the company is 'excited' for the impending move. 'Given Florida and Miami's pro-business stance, leaving California, which is anti-business and a very difficult place to do business as an employer, we're excited to be relocating,' Kohn told Fox News Digital.
