SNP members call for 'reparative action' after Israel meeting minutes revealed
It came to light that the Scottish Government had called Israel a "critical friend", despite publicly denouncing the atrocities it has carried out amid the genocide in Gaza.
READ MORE: UK Government facing legal action over refusal of medical evacuations from Gaza
Simon Barrow, national secretary of the [[SNP]] Trade Union Group (the party's largest affiliate body), said "no regime involved in trying to eradicate the people of Gaza" could be considered 'critical friend' by Scotland.
'For many months, trade unionists across Scotland have spoken and acted in strong solidarity with the Palestinian people, with all those in Israel who are opposing their government's war crimes, and against the genocide in Gaza," Barrow said.
He added: 'SNP trade unionists stand with them. No regime involved in trying to eradicate the people of Gaza and deny statehood, justice and dignity to the Palestinians can possibly be considered a 'critical friend' by Scotland, and we reject any notion of excuse towards, appeasement of, or complicity with the horrors taking place in real time.
'We hope that the First Minister will make all that abundantly clear, and will take appropriate reparative action in the light of the disclosures by The National, and its commendable and responsible journalism and commentary on Israel-Palestine, [[Gaza]] and the Middle East.'
Among the details revealed in the Sunday National by The Ferret were that an unnamed Scottish Government official had said: 'Transparency is obviously a good thing, but it takes up such a lot of our time.'
While Swinney has publicly referenced the 'killing and suffering of civilians', the minutes suggest that Robertson adopted a more reserved tone with Grudsky, noting that 'every effort must be taken to reduce civilian casualties'.
In a 'profound apology' issued to delegates at the SNP conference on September 1 last year, after heavy criticism from within the party, Robertson said one of the Scottish Government's priorities for the meeting was to express its support for an 'end of UK arms being sent to Israel'.
There is no mention of this in the minutes released.
The SNP have been approached for comment.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Leader Live
18 minutes ago
- Leader Live
It is not my job to dictate what you can create, says Swinney on eve of festival
He addressed invited guests at the headquarters of the Edinburgh International Festival as the capital's festival season is set to begin. Mr Swinney told the audience on Thursday he would be a protector of freedom of speech in his time in the top job. 'I also know that freedom of expressing is under greater and greater attack, both at home and abroad,' he said. 'I want to ensure that Scotland, the birthplace of the Enlightenment, remains a country of robust debate and inquiry. 'I firmly believe that art and culture must be able to challenge us, to ask us tough questions, and to force us to look at things from different perspectives. 'And, yes, it must, at times, be allowed to shock and offend us, but it can also heal us. 'Let me be absolutely clear – as First Minister, I will always protect freedom of speech in our country. 'It's not the First Minister's job to tell you what to create, nor would I ever seek to do so.' Mr Swinney added that his and his Government's role is to assist artists in any way they can. The First Minister went on to make a plea to the crowd and to wider society – with a particular nod to tech firms – to look at how the arts can be better supported financially as the Government looks to boost funding to £100 million annually in the coming years. 'I'm asking that from crowdfunding to patronage, to philanthropy to local authority support and much more, we all ask ourselves how can we do more to support the arts from the grassroots up?' he said. 'How can we better support emerging artists that don't necessarily fit the current mould? 'And how, in particular, can Scotland's emerging businesses in new sectors become the new generation of patrons of the arts and culture in Scotland? 'How do we incentivise a new guard of custodians and investors in Scotland's creative economy?' Speaking to journalists after his speech, Mr Swinney said he is open to discussions about new legislation to support the cultural sector. He said there is a sense that local authorities 'might not have a particularly explicit statutory duty to support artistic and cultural activity', suggesting this area 'might need to be strengthened'.
The Herald Scotland
19 minutes ago
- The Herald Scotland
It is not my job to dictate what you can create, says Swinney on eve of festival
Mr Swinney told the audience on Thursday he would be a protector of freedom of speech in his time in the top job. 'I also know that freedom of expressing is under greater and greater attack, both at home and abroad,' he said. 'I want to ensure that Scotland, the birthplace of the Enlightenment, remains a country of robust debate and inquiry. John Swinney spoke at the Edinburgh International Festival Hub (Jane Barlow/PA) 'I firmly believe that art and culture must be able to challenge us, to ask us tough questions, and to force us to look at things from different perspectives. 'And, yes, it must, at times, be allowed to shock and offend us, but it can also heal us. 'Let me be absolutely clear – as First Minister, I will always protect freedom of speech in our country. 'It's not the First Minister's job to tell you what to create, nor would I ever seek to do so.' Mr Swinney added that his and his Government's role is to assist artists in any way they can. The First Minister went on to make a plea to the crowd and to wider society – with a particular nod to tech firms – to look at how the arts can be better supported financially as the Government looks to boost funding to £100 million annually in the coming years. The First Minister attended an event on the eve of the start of Edinburgh's festival season (Jane Barlow/PA) 'I'm asking that from crowdfunding to patronage, to philanthropy to local authority support and much more, we all ask ourselves how can we do more to support the arts from the grassroots up?' he said. 'How can we better support emerging artists that don't necessarily fit the current mould? 'And how, in particular, can Scotland's emerging businesses in new sectors become the new generation of patrons of the arts and culture in Scotland? 'How do we incentivise a new guard of custodians and investors in Scotland's creative economy?' Speaking to journalists after his speech, Mr Swinney said he is open to discussions about new legislation to support the cultural sector. He said there is a sense that local authorities 'might not have a particularly explicit statutory duty to support artistic and cultural activity', suggesting this area 'might need to be strengthened'.
Scottish Sun
19 minutes ago
- Scottish Sun
John Swinney insists he pushed whisky tariffs issue with Donald Trump after President appeared to rubbish the claim
The meeting had raised hopes Mr Trump could drop the hefty US import tariffs on Scotch whisky WHISKY BUSINESS John Swinney insists he pushed whisky tariffs issue with Donald Trump after President appeared to rubbish the claim Click to share on X/Twitter (Opens in new window) Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) JOHN Swinney insisted he pushed the issue of whisky tariffs with President Trump just a day after the US chief appeared to rubbish the claim. Donald Trump told reporters he and the First Minister 'did not really discuss' the issue of levies on the key export. Sign up for the Politics newsletter Sign up 3 The First Minister insisted he pushed the issue of whisky tariffs with President Trump Credit: Getty 3 Donald Trump told reporters he and the First Minister 'did not really discuss' the issue Credit: Reuters This was despite insistence from the SNP leader and senior aides that the chat had 'opened the window' to a possible exemption to punishing tariffs on the sector as part of the US/UK trade deal. The meeting had raised hopes Mr Trump could drop the hefty US import tariffs on Scotch whisky, which is costing the industry here £4million a week. Asked about Mr Trump's comments, Mr Swinney said: 'I've seen what President Trump said about the whisky issue and he said that we didn't talk about it much. That's different from not at all. 'So yes, we talked about it. I had a conversation with President Trump over dinner which lasted at least an hour and a quarter, maybe even longer, so we talked about a lot of things, including whisky.' We told how Mr Trump had also made the questionable claim there was no crime in Scotland, despite evidence to the contrary. Asked about this, Mr Swinney said: 'I think I made it clear to President Trump that we had lower crime in Scotland than we used to have but we still have crime.' He also failed to rush to the defence of his predecessor Ms Sturgeon who the US leader had labelled 'terrible' in a slapdown on Wednesday. Mr Swinney said: 'I am not able to determine all the things that the President says.' The First Minister, speaking at an event with the Edinburgh International Festival on the eve of the start of the Fringe, also insisted he believed the SNP would secure a majority at the Holryood election next year. The Nats chief had earlier set the party on a collision course with the UK Government over independence, claiming a majority would spark a second vote. Five moments you missed from a weekend with Donald Trump in Scotland However polling suggests the SNP could fall well short of a majority which has only ever been achieved once in 2011. Pushed on whether this was just a trick to boost his vote knowing how unlikely it was, Mr Swinney said: 'Of course I believe in it, I wouldn't have put it forward if I didn't.' Asked if he was 'delusional' to think he would get a majority at next year's Holyrood election, Mr Swinney insisted it is the 'reliable way' to get a second independence referendum. He also appeared to hit out at Humza Yousaf and Ms Sturgeon for their past indy wheezes, including claiming a majority of SNP MPs or a Holyrood pro-indy majority would deliver a referendum. The First Minister said: 'If people look at the circumstances of the last 15 years it is clear that the only moment in which there was a referendum on independence followed the election of a majority of SNP MSPs. 'Other things have been tried, if I can put it as delicately as that, and they haven't worked.' Scottish Tory deputy leader Rachael Hamilton said: 'Scots are sick and tired of the SNP focusing on independence, when they should be cutting sky-high taxes and fixing the public services they've broken. 'But, as usual, John Swinney is more interested in appealing to diehard nationalists than delivering on the priorities of ordinary Scots.'
