X, India spar over lawyer's 'Tom, Dick, and Harry' remark for government officials
X has long been at loggerheads with Prime Minister Narendra Modi's government over content removal requests.
The remarks were made during a hearing on the U.S. firm's challenge to a government-run website it says is a "censorship portal" that allows officials to issue content removal orders. New Delhi says the website is only to swiftly notify companies of their due diligence obligations.
India is a critical growth market for X owner Musk, who is getting closer to launching his other key ventures Starlink and Tesla in the country.
During the court hearing, X's lawyer, K. G. Raghavan, said it recently received a notice from the railways department to remove a video in which a car was being driven on a railway track. That was news, but the government found it unlawful, he told the court.
"This is the danger, My Lord, that is done now, if every Tom, Dick, and Harry officer is authorised," Raghavan told the high court in the southern state of Karnataka.
The phrase drew immediate condemnation from India's Solicitor General Tushar Mehta, who said "officers are not Tom, Dick, or Harry ... they are statutory functionaries".
"No social media intermediary can expect completely unregulated functioning," Mehta said.
India's IT ministry and X did not respond to Reuters queries.
In 2021, X, formerly called Twitter, was locked in a stand-off with the Indian government over non-compliance with legal orders to block certain tweets. It later complied, but is still locked in a court fight related to the move.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Al Etihad
3 hours ago
- Al Etihad
Nvidia reclaimed market value pole position in June
2 July 2025 22:01 (REUTERS)Nvidia (NVDA.O) reclaimed the top spot among the most valued companies worldwide in June, as its shares were supported by renewed optimism over its leadership in artificial intelligence and expectations of surging demand for its AI chipmaker's market value stood at $3.86 trillion at the end of June, about 4.3% higher than Microsoft Corp's $3.69 trillion Nvidia's market value has yet to surpass Apple Inc's (AAPL.O) record high of about $3.92 trillion set in December 2024. Apple, with a market capitalisation of $3.1 trillion, ranked as the third most valuable company at the end of last Platforms Inc (META.O), Broadcom Inc (AVGO.O), and Inc (AMZN.O) saw their market values rise by 14%, 13.9%, and 7% respectively last month, reaching $1.86 trillion, $1.3 trillion, and $2.33 market value of Tesla Inc (TSLA.O) dropped 8.3% to $1.02 trillion last month, with sentiment hit by CEO Elon Musk's feud with US President Donald Trump. "We believe both Nvidia and Microsoft will hit the $4 trillion market cap club this summer and then over the next 18 months the focus will be on the $5 trillion club ... as this tech bull market is still early being led by the AI Revolution," said Daniel Ives, an analyst at Wedbush Securities.
Zawya
6 hours ago
- Zawya
Musk's X down for thousands of US users, Downdetector shows
Elon Musk's X was down for thousands of users in the U.S. on Wednesday, according to outage tracking website There were more than 15,400 incidents of people reporting issues with the social media platform as of 9:52 a.m. ET, Downdetector showed, which tracks outages by collating status reports from a number of sources. X did not immediately respond to a Reuters request for comment. (Reporting by Jaspreet Singh in Bengaluru)
Khaleej Times
8 hours ago
- Khaleej Times
India exporters cautiously optimistic as US tariff deadline looms
Indian exporters are anxiously eyeing the possible reintroduction of Donald Trump's punishing tariffs next week, though many hold out hope for a last-minute reprieve. The US president's April 2 "Liberation Day" announcement of swingeing levies on dozens of key trading partners sent shockwaves through capitals before he announced a pause for negotiations, which ends next Wednesday. New Delhi and Washington have been locked in multiple rounds of talks, with hopes for an interim pact to avert the 26 per cent "reciprocal" tolls meted out to India. The tariffs, which came on top of 10 per cent levies across the board for every country, were imposed for what the White House says are unfair US trade deficits. While India -- the world's most populous country -- is not a manufacturing powerhouse, it still ran up a $45.7 billion trade surplus with the United States last year. And now some of its most labour-intensive exports, including electronics, gems and jewellery and shrimp, are under threat. Exporters are "optimistic" that India may be able to carve out a bilateral agreement on the "trade side at least", Ajay Sahai, Director General of the Federation of Indian Export Organisations, told AFP. But he added that it was "quite a fluid situation", suggesting one outcome could see the deadline extended, given that India is "constructively engaged" with Washington. "The feedback which I am getting suggests positive developments either way -- and we are hopeful," he added. India's seafood industry is seeing "some amount of anxiety", but also "more reason for hope", said KN Raghavan, Secretary General, Seafood Exporters Association of India. He did not give details, but said a "solution appears to be in the anvil". US officials have been upbeat about the prospect of an agreement. Trump on Tuesday raised the possibility of an agreement, saying it is "going to be a different kind of a deal". "It's going to be a deal where we're able to go in and compete," he added. "Right now, India doesn't accept anybody in. I think India is going to do that, and if they do that, we're going to have a deal for much less tariffs." His Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick said last month that a pact could be expected in the "not too distant future". However, Indian media reports on Tuesday, quoting unnamed sources, struck a more neutral tone, saying negotiators were still working to resolve key differences that had cropped up during talks. 'Alternative sources' An Indian commerce ministry official told AFP that New Delhi's unmet demands included relief from separate sectoral tariffs on steel and aluminium as well a greater access for labour-intensive exports including textiles and footwear. They have also spoken of disagreements over Washington's push to have India open up its agriculture sector and allow freer trade of American farm produce. Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman has said she was eager for a deal. "I'd love to have an agreement, a big, good, beautiful one; why not?" she told India's Financial Express newspaper, in an interview printed on Monday. Sitharaman, however, added that "agriculture and dairy" are the "very big red lines". Experts believe a smaller agreement is still possible ahead of the deadline. "The more likely outcome is a limited trade pact," said Ajay Srivastava of Global Trade Research Initiative, a New Delhi-based think-tank in a recent note. Srivastava said that under such a deal, India could cut tariffs on a range of industrial goods and offer limited access for US agricultural produce --- in return for Trump dropping the 26 percent levies. But he also warned that talks "may collapse" if Washington "continues to insist on opening India's core agriculture sectors or allowing entry of GMO (genetically modified organism) products". And seafood exporters remain on edge as talks go down to the wire. "Currently, exporters believe they can manage with a 10 percent tariff, as it can be absorbed. But if it goes back up to 25 percent to 30 percent levels, we could see American buyers finding alternative sources," Raghavan said. "They will find some other cheaper source," he added.
