logo
Property owners challenge City's new proposed fixed charges in court

Property owners challenge City's new proposed fixed charges in court

IOL News22-07-2025
Mayor Geordin Hill-Lewis at a council meeting where he tabled the draft budget for 2025/2026.
Image: City of Cape Town/Supplied
THE constitutionality of the City's decision to link certain fixed charges to property values in its amended Budget for 2025/26 will come under the spotlight when the South African Property Owners Association (SAPOA) hauls the DA-led administration to court.
The organisation has taken issue with the City's cleaning tariff, the fixed water charge, and the fixed sanitation charge, saying these three items of the budget were in fact property rates imposed outside of the legislation which governs the imposition of such rates.
However, Mayor Geordin Hill-Lewis believes that the court application is an attempt to go back to a system of regressive taxation which hits ordinary families, and the poor, the hardest.
SAPOA's membership currently comprises more than 90% of the country's commercial and retail property industry, including some of the largest property-owning companies in South Africa.
The properties owned by their membership include the V&A Waterfront (co-owned by Growthpoint), Canal Walk Shopping Centre (owned by Hyprop), Cape Gate Shopping Centre (owned by Hyprop), Table Bay Mall (owned by Hyprop), Tyger Valley Shopping Centre (co-owned by Pareto), Blue Route Mall (owned by Redefine), Gugulethu Square (owned by Vukile), Atlantis City Shopping Centre (owned by Vukile), Sable Square Shopping Centre (owned by Spear), and Cavendish Square (owned by Old Mutual).
In his founding affidavit, SAPOA chief executive Nilesh 'Neil' Gopal said that the board resolved to take legal action to have the budget declared unconstitutional and invalid.
Video Player is loading.
Play Video
Play
Unmute
Current Time
0:00
/
Duration
-:-
Loaded :
0%
Stream Type LIVE
Seek to live, currently behind live
LIVE
Remaining Time
-
0:00
This is a modal window.
Beginning of dialog window. Escape will cancel and close the window.
Text Color White Black Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan
Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Background Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan
Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Transparent Window Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan
Transparency Transparent Semi-Transparent Opaque
Font Size 50% 75% 100% 125% 150% 175% 200% 300% 400% Text Edge Style None Raised Depressed Uniform Dropshadow Font Family Proportional Sans-Serif Monospace Sans-Serif Proportional Serif Monospace Serif Casual Script Small Caps
Reset
restore all settings to the default values Done
Close Modal Dialog
End of dialog window.
Advertisement
Next
Stay
Close ✕
'They contravene the applicable constitutional and national legislative framework applicable to the imposition of rates and the levying of tariffs for municipal services,' he said in papers.
Gopal added that while they acknowledge the city's rebates that they offer, it mostly is to aid pensioners and isn't sufficient to offset the impact the tariffs will have on them.
'These reductions and rebates do not detract from the fact that the three items are unlawful and should not have been introduced in the first place: A reduction or a rebate cannot save a charge which was unlawfully imposed,' he said.
Gopal maintained that the continued rise in municipal costs had a significant detrimental effect on the costs of occupancy faced by tenants in commercial/retail properties.
'My point is that the systems of exemptions, reductions, and rebates established by the City under the Cleaning Tariff (as well as the Fixed Water Charge and the Fixed Sanitation Charge) are different from the Rates Act. It relies, however, on the General Valuation Roll ("GV Roll') established under the Rates Act. It is an impermissible parallel system of rates.
'For all these reasons, the Cleaning Tariff, while purporting to be a service, is a rate, but an unlawful one, because it does not comply, or even follow the scheme let alone the letter of the Rates Act,' he added.
The relief SAPOA is seeking is to have the budget declared invalid.
However, the order of invalidity should be suspended for two months to allow the city to deal with the revenue shortfall that will result from the invalidity of the three items.
Hill-Lewis said the city cannot agree that wealthy property owners should be charged the same as lower-income or middle-class households.
'This would be regressive, would place a disproportionate burden on ordinary families, and would be patently unfair.
'The city's budget protects homes under R2,5m and extends rates relief to many more middle-class homes, all while preserving the city's critical infrastructure and service investments,' said Hill-Lewis.
If SAPOA were to succeed in their argument, the effect would be 'to have ordinary families effectively subsidising the wealthiest property owners', said Hill-Lewis.
'Fixed charges linked to property value are a lawful, fairer, and equitable way for Capetonians to contribute within their means to our city's infrastructure programme and fixed service costs. Cross-subsidising – where the better off among us help to fund services for the less fortunate – is the only sustainable way to ensure a working city of hope for all,' said Hill-Lewis.
The Cape Town Collective Ratepayers' Association (CTCRA), an association with 56 ratepayer associations and civic organisations from across Cape Town, has thrown its weight behind SAPOA's decision, saying: 'This case is not just of importance to the ratepayers of Cape Town. If left unchallenged, there is a realistic possibility that other municipalities in South Africa will adopt CoCT's methods. It is critical that the rule of law, fairness in service delivery, and constitutional accountability are upheld – not just for our city, but for the nation.'
Cape Times
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Gayton's new man, but who really is Liam Jacobs?
Gayton's new man, but who really is Liam Jacobs?

IOL News

time2 hours ago

  • IOL News

Gayton's new man, but who really is Liam Jacobs?

The Patriotic Alliance (PA) President, Gayton McKenzie, announced the appointment of rising star Liam Jacobs to replace the suspended Member of the Mayoral Committee (MMC) for Transport, Kenny Kunene. Image: Supplied Liam Jacobs, at just 24 years old, is quickly becoming a notable figure in South African politics. Recently recommended by Patriotic Alliance (PA) president Gayton McKenzie to replace Kenny Kunene as the Member of the Mayoral Committee (MMC) for Transport in Johannesburg, Jacobs is on the verge of stepping into a prominent leadership role in one of the country's largest cities. Born in 2001 in Kimberley, Northern Cape, Jacobs showed an early interest in politics and community service. He pursued his studies at the University of Pretoria, where he completed an honours degree in Politics, Economics, and Philosophy. His academic background reflects a strong foundation in understanding governance, economic issues, and philosophical questions about society and leadership. Jacobs began his political journey through student activism, eventually becoming the Federal Leader of the Democratic Alliance Student Organisation (DASO) in October 2022. In this role, he was recognised for championing inclusivity and pushing for greater youth representation in political decision-making. His leadership in DASO positioned him as a rising star within the Democratic Alliance (DA), South Africa's official opposition party. Following the 2024 general elections, Jacobs was elected as a Member of Parliament for the DA, serving on the Portfolio Committee on Sports, Arts, and Culture. Despite this promising start, Jacobs became disillusioned with the DA. Video Player is loading. Play Video Play Unmute Current Time 0:00 / Duration -:- Loaded : 0% Stream Type LIVE Seek to live, currently behind live LIVE Remaining Time - 0:00 This is a modal window. Beginning of dialog window. Escape will cancel and close the window. Text Color White Black Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Background Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Transparent Window Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Transparent Semi-Transparent Opaque Font Size 50% 75% 100% 125% 150% 175% 200% 300% 400% Text Edge Style None Raised Depressed Uniform Dropshadow Font Family Proportional Sans-Serif Monospace Sans-Serif Proportional Serif Monospace Serif Casual Script Small Caps Reset restore all settings to the default values Done Close Modal Dialog End of dialog window. Advertisement Next Stay Close ✕ Ad loading He publicly expressed feeling used and frustrated by the party's internal politics and dynamics. In June 2025, he announced his departure from the DA, declaring his move to the Patriotic Alliance with the words, 'I am finally home.' The PA, under the leadership of Gayton McKenzie, has been growing in influence, particularly in urban centres like Johannesburg. McKenzie welcomed Jacobs warmly, highlighting his leadership potential and commitment. Following Jacobs' defection, McKenzie recommended him to Johannesburg Mayor Dada Morero to fill the MMC for Transport position, a critical role responsible for managing and improving the city's transport infrastructure. McKenzie expressed confidence in Jacobs, stating, 'This is your chance now to show people that you can lead. You have shown people your heart. Do not disappoint them.' Jacobs' appointment is still pending, as Mayor Morero consults with coalition partners before filling the vacant mayoral committee positions of transport and finance. Beyond politics, Jacobs has demonstrated a strong commitment to community activism. In late 2023, during a severe water crisis in Kimberley, he filed a formal complaint with the South African Human Rights Commission, advocating for improved access to clean water for residents. This action reflected his dedication to addressing pressing social issues and holding authorities accountable. If appointed MMC for Transport, Jacobs will face significant challenges. Johannesburg struggles with issues such as deteriorating roads, traffic congestion, and public transport inefficiencies. Addressing these problems will require strong leadership, innovative thinking, and effective coordination with various stakeholders. For a young politician who has already experienced the complexities and challenges of South African party politics, this new role offers an opportunity to demonstrate his capability and commitment to public service. As he prepares to take on this responsibility, many will be watching to see if Liam Jacobs can translate his passion and energy into tangible improvements for Johannesburg's residents. Would you like me to help draft statements or interviews from Jacobs or others for this story?

Gayton's new man, but who really is Liam Jacobs?
Gayton's new man, but who really is Liam Jacobs?

The Star

time3 hours ago

  • The Star

Gayton's new man, but who really is Liam Jacobs?

Sifiso Mahlangu | Published 12 minutes ago Liam Jacobs, at just 24 years old, is quickly becoming a notable figure in South African politics. Recently recommended by Patriotic Alliance (PA) president Gayton McKenzie to replace Kenny Kunene as the Member of the Mayoral Committee (MMC) for Transport in Johannesburg, Jacobs is on the verge of stepping into a prominent leadership role in one of the country's largest cities. Born in 2001 in Kimberley, Northern Cape, Jacobs showed an early interest in politics and community service. He pursued his studies at the University of Pretoria, where he completed an honours degree in Politics, Economics, and Philosophy. His academic background reflects a strong foundation in understanding governance, economic issues, and philosophical questions about society and leadership. Jacobs began his political journey through student activism, eventually becoming the Federal Leader of the Democratic Alliance Student Organisation (DASO) in October 2022. In this role, he was recognised for championing inclusivity and pushing for greater youth representation in political decision-making. His leadership in DASO positioned him as a rising star within the Democratic Alliance (DA), South Africa's official opposition party. Following the 2024 general elections, Jacobs was elected as a Member of Parliament for the DA, serving on the Portfolio Committee on Sports, Arts, and Culture. Despite this promising start, Jacobs became disillusioned with the DA. He publicly expressed feeling used and frustrated by the party's internal politics and dynamics. In June 2025, he announced his departure from the DA, declaring his move to the Patriotic Alliance with the words, 'I am finally home.' The PA, under the leadership of Gayton McKenzie, has been growing in influence, particularly in urban centres like Johannesburg. McKenzie welcomed Jacobs warmly, highlighting his leadership potential and commitment. Following Jacobs' defection, McKenzie recommended him to Johannesburg Mayor Dada Morero to fill the MMC for Transport position, a critical role responsible for managing and improving the city's transport infrastructure. McKenzie expressed confidence in Jacobs, stating, 'This is your chance now to show people that you can lead. You have shown people your heart. Do not disappoint them.' Jacobs' appointment is still pending, as Mayor Morero consults with coalition partners before filling the vacant mayoral committee positions of transport and finance. Beyond politics, Jacobs has demonstrated a strong commitment to community activism. In late 2023, during a severe water crisis in Kimberley, he filed a formal complaint with the South African Human Rights Commission, advocating for improved access to clean water for residents. This action reflected his dedication to addressing pressing social issues and holding authorities accountable. If appointed MMC for Transport, Jacobs will face significant challenges. Johannesburg struggles with issues such as deteriorating roads, traffic congestion, and public transport inefficiencies. Addressing these problems will require strong leadership, innovative thinking, and effective coordination with various stakeholders. For a young politician who has already experienced the complexities and challenges of South African party politics, this new role offers an opportunity to demonstrate his capability and commitment to public service. As he prepares to take on this responsibility, many will be watching to see if Liam Jacobs can translate his passion and energy into tangible improvements for Johannesburg's residents. Would you like me to help draft statements or interviews from Jacobs or others for this story?

CoCT invested R9.5 billion in infrastructure in 24/25 financial year, says Hill-Lewis
CoCT invested R9.5 billion in infrastructure in 24/25 financial year, says Hill-Lewis

Eyewitness News

time6 hours ago

  • Eyewitness News

CoCT invested R9.5 billion in infrastructure in 24/25 financial year, says Hill-Lewis

CAPE TOWN - Cape Town Mayor Geordin Hill-Lewis said the city had invested R9.5 billion in infrastructure in the 2024/2025 financial year, an all-time record for a South African metro. Hill-Lewis said that the money spent represented 92 percent of its full infrastructure budget. The mayor addressed the city council on Wednesday, saying that the only way for Cape Town to avoid some of the crises in other South African cities was to invest in infrastructure at a higher level. "It's one thing to announce new record infrastructure budgets every year, in our quest to invest in a better city, but those records mean little if the budgets just stay as numbers on a page. They actually have to be spent." Hill-Lewis told council that spending the allocated budget was no easy task. "I'm very pleased to let you know that our city spent 92.3 percent of our capital budget ... that is R9.5 billion." The mayor said that the safety and security directorate had the best percentage, with 99 percent of its R472 million budget spent.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store