Islamist preacher unable to 'bury' anti-Semitism ruling
Sydney-based Al Madina Dawah Centre cleric Wissam Haddad was ordered by the Federal Court earlier in July not to repeat the perverse and racist tropes used in a series of fiery sermons from November 2023.
In the speeches, Mr Haddad - who is also known as William Haddad or Abu Ousayd - variously referred to Jewish people as "vile", "treacherous", "murderous" and "mischievous".
Justice Angus Stewart found the sermons contained "perverse generalisations" against Jewish people and included racist, anti-Semitic tropes.
The judge on Thursday ordered the preacher "pin" or "feature" corrective notices describing the court's findings to the centre's website and social media pages on Facebook, Rumble, Instagram and Soundcloud.
He has been given 21 days to comply with the order and the posts had not been made as of Thursday afternoon.
Mr Haddad objected to prominently displaying the notices, saying this would go beyond what was ordinarily ordered by the courts.
Pinning the posts would be tantamount to promoting or advertising the findings, he said.
Justice Stewart ordered the notices to be pinned for 30 days, saying the requirement was not unduly burdensome and would stop them disappearing from view.
"It will prevent them from being deliberately buried by way of successive further posts," the judge wrote.
Promoting the notices was part of their objective, he said.
"The respondents promoted the unlawful lectures and it is not disproportionate to require them to promote the corrective notice in the relatively constrained manner described above as an appropriate form of redress," he wrote in his judgment.
The notice itself highlights the "unlawful behaviour based on racial hatred" of Mr Haddad and the centre.
The three lectures - titled "The Jews of Al Medina" and published on video hosting site Rumble - were reasonably likely to offend, insult, humiliate or intimidate Jewish members of the Australian community, the notice says.
The lawsuit was brought by Executive Council of Australian Jewry co-chief executive Peter Wertheim and deputy president Robert Goot, who claimed the lectures were offensive and could incite violence towards Jewish people.
The pair said they were vindicated by Justice Stewart's findings, saying no community in Australia should be dehumanised.
"Freedom of expression should not be abused by the promotion of hateful anti-Semitism and those who wish to do so should know that conduct shouldn't be tolerated by us," Mr Goot told reporters after the judgment.
The cleric has been ordered to remove the lectures and not to repeat similar racist statements about Jewish people in public.
He will also have to pay the legal bill for Mr Wertheim and Mr Goot, which is estimated to be in the six figures.
Mr Haddad's speeches were delivered after Hamas, designated by Australia as a terrorist group, attacked Israel on October 7, 2023.
The attack sparked Israeli retaliation that has left Gaza in turmoil and tens of thousands of civilians dead.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
West Australian
an hour ago
- West Australian
US President Donald Trump announces EU trade deal with 15 per cent tariffs
President Donald Trump announced Sunday that the US reached a trade deal with the European Union, following pivotal discussions with European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen days before the August 1 tariff deadline. Mr Trump said that the deal imposes a 15 per cent tariff on most European goods to the US, including cars. Some products, including aircrafts and their components, some chemicals and pharmaceuticals, will not be subject to tariffs, Ms von der Leyen said in a briefing after the agreement was announced. She also said that the new 15 per cent tariff rate would not be added to any tariffs already in effect. The 15 per cent tariff rate is lower than the 30 per cent rate Mr Trump had previously threatened against the United States' largest trading partner, but higher than the 10% baseline tariffs the EU was hoping for. Mr Trump said that the 27-member bloc also agreed to purchase $750 billion ($1.1 trillion) worth of US energy and invest an additional $600 billion worth of investments into the US above current levels. He said that the bloc would also be 'purchasing hundreds of billions of dollars worth of military equipment,' but did not provide a specific dollar amount. 'It's a very powerful deal, it's a very big deal, it's the biggest of all the deals,' Mr Trump said Sunday alongside Ms von der Leyen. 'It's a good deal, it's a huge deal, with tough negotiations,' Ms von der Leyen said after the meeting. While questions remain about the specific details and timeline of the EU investments, the agreement marks a pivotal moment for Mr Trump, following weeks of uncertainty surrounding the US-EU trade talks. Mr Trump during a press conference before his meeting with the European leader said that there was a 50-50 chance they would reach a framework of a deal. Brussels had been preparing for a no-deal scenario if the trade talks devolved ahead of August 1. Lawmakers had approved a major package of counter-tariffs, which would have targeted a range of US goods. The bloc also considered deploying the EU's 'Anti-Coercion Instrument,' a move seen as the trading bloc's 'trade bazooka.' Ireland's Prime Minister said the agreement 'brings clarity and predictability to the trading relationship between the EU and the US,' according to a statement. 'It does mean that there will now be higher tariffs than there have been and this will have an impact on trade between the EU and the US, making it more expensive and more challenging,' Ireland's Department of the Taoiseach said. Still, the agreement 'creates a new era of stability,' the statement continued. The US-EU trade relationship was valued at 1.68 trillion euros when taking into account both services and goods trading in 2024, according to the European Council. While the EU recorded a surplus on goods trading, it noted a deficit in the services realm. This left the EU with an overall trade surplus of around 50 billion euros with the US last year.
The Advertiser
2 hours ago
- The Advertiser
Syria set to hold parliamentary election in September
Syria is expected to hold its first parliamentary election under the new administration in September, the head of the electoral commission has told state news agency SANA. Voting for the 210-member People's Assembly is scheduled to take place between September 15 and 20, said Mohamed Taha, who is overseeing the electoral process, on Sunday. President Ahmed al-Sharaa has received a draft electoral law that amends a previous decree and raises the number of seats from 150 to 210. A third of the seats will be appointed by the president. The government has pledged broad representation and said it will allow foreign observers to monitor electoral committees overseeing the vote. Officials said areas outside government control, including Kurdish-held regions in northern Syria and the Druze-majority province of Sweida, would continue to have seats allocated based on population. The new assembly is expected to lay the groundwork for a broader democratic process, which critics say currently lacks sufficient participation from minority groups. It will also be tasked with approving landmark legislation aimed at overhauling decades of state-controlled economic policies and ratifying treaties that could reshape Syria's foreign policy alliances. In March, Syria issued a constitutional declaration to guide the interim period under Sharaa's leadership. The document preserves a central role for Islamic law while guaranteeing women's rights and freedom of expression. It raised concerns of civic groups and Western nations about the concentration of power among the country's Islamist-led leadership. Syria is expected to hold its first parliamentary election under the new administration in September, the head of the electoral commission has told state news agency SANA. Voting for the 210-member People's Assembly is scheduled to take place between September 15 and 20, said Mohamed Taha, who is overseeing the electoral process, on Sunday. President Ahmed al-Sharaa has received a draft electoral law that amends a previous decree and raises the number of seats from 150 to 210. A third of the seats will be appointed by the president. The government has pledged broad representation and said it will allow foreign observers to monitor electoral committees overseeing the vote. Officials said areas outside government control, including Kurdish-held regions in northern Syria and the Druze-majority province of Sweida, would continue to have seats allocated based on population. The new assembly is expected to lay the groundwork for a broader democratic process, which critics say currently lacks sufficient participation from minority groups. It will also be tasked with approving landmark legislation aimed at overhauling decades of state-controlled economic policies and ratifying treaties that could reshape Syria's foreign policy alliances. In March, Syria issued a constitutional declaration to guide the interim period under Sharaa's leadership. The document preserves a central role for Islamic law while guaranteeing women's rights and freedom of expression. It raised concerns of civic groups and Western nations about the concentration of power among the country's Islamist-led leadership. Syria is expected to hold its first parliamentary election under the new administration in September, the head of the electoral commission has told state news agency SANA. Voting for the 210-member People's Assembly is scheduled to take place between September 15 and 20, said Mohamed Taha, who is overseeing the electoral process, on Sunday. President Ahmed al-Sharaa has received a draft electoral law that amends a previous decree and raises the number of seats from 150 to 210. A third of the seats will be appointed by the president. The government has pledged broad representation and said it will allow foreign observers to monitor electoral committees overseeing the vote. Officials said areas outside government control, including Kurdish-held regions in northern Syria and the Druze-majority province of Sweida, would continue to have seats allocated based on population. The new assembly is expected to lay the groundwork for a broader democratic process, which critics say currently lacks sufficient participation from minority groups. It will also be tasked with approving landmark legislation aimed at overhauling decades of state-controlled economic policies and ratifying treaties that could reshape Syria's foreign policy alliances. In March, Syria issued a constitutional declaration to guide the interim period under Sharaa's leadership. The document preserves a central role for Islamic law while guaranteeing women's rights and freedom of expression. It raised concerns of civic groups and Western nations about the concentration of power among the country's Islamist-led leadership. Syria is expected to hold its first parliamentary election under the new administration in September, the head of the electoral commission has told state news agency SANA. Voting for the 210-member People's Assembly is scheduled to take place between September 15 and 20, said Mohamed Taha, who is overseeing the electoral process, on Sunday. President Ahmed al-Sharaa has received a draft electoral law that amends a previous decree and raises the number of seats from 150 to 210. A third of the seats will be appointed by the president. The government has pledged broad representation and said it will allow foreign observers to monitor electoral committees overseeing the vote. Officials said areas outside government control, including Kurdish-held regions in northern Syria and the Druze-majority province of Sweida, would continue to have seats allocated based on population. The new assembly is expected to lay the groundwork for a broader democratic process, which critics say currently lacks sufficient participation from minority groups. It will also be tasked with approving landmark legislation aimed at overhauling decades of state-controlled economic policies and ratifying treaties that could reshape Syria's foreign policy alliances. In March, Syria issued a constitutional declaration to guide the interim period under Sharaa's leadership. The document preserves a central role for Islamic law while guaranteeing women's rights and freedom of expression. It raised concerns of civic groups and Western nations about the concentration of power among the country's Islamist-led leadership.
The Age
3 hours ago
- The Age
A target of Latham's disparaging messages, Abigail Boyd is directing her anger elsewhere
'This was a private message that he [Latham] didn't actually intend for me to see, so I have accepted his apology.' Instead, her anger is reserved for the premier. After passing the lower house with support from progressive crossbench MPs including Alex Greenwich after he moved amendments, Labor's bill has been blocked in the upper house thanks to a voting bloc comprising Coalition, progressive crossbenchers including the Greens and Animal Justice Party, and Latham. While this masthead previously reported the government had worked hard to lobby Latham to support its workers' compensation bill, Labor has sought to capitalise on the accusations against him by focusing on the Coalition for working with the former One Nation MP on amendments to the legislation. The amendments include changes to the definition of sexual harassment to include whether a perpetrator knew 'or should reasonably know' their actions were sexual harassment. Minns has urged the Coalition to 'cut that string', while Treasurer Daniel Mookhey has said the change to the definition of sexual harassment would mean a victim would have to 'prove their perpetrator deliberately wanted to hurt them'. Loading That, said Boyd, is an example of 'stunning hypocrisy' because it is Labor's bill that creates definitions of sexual harassment, bullying and racial discrimination that injured workers would have to meet. The bill has also been criticised by unions, in part because of what they say will be the disproportionate impact on female-dominated industries such as nursing from changes that would make it harder for people with psychological injury to receive workers' compensation. In a statement, a spokesman for Minns said the government 'totally rejects' the assertion its criticisms of the Coalition and Greens were hypocritical, and it was a 'belated political response from the Greens and Abigail Boyd after months of the government calling out Greens-Latham co-operation'. Minns' repeated attacks on the Coalition have raised eyebrows among MPs because of Labor's willingness to lobby Latham on bills and, in some cases, work with him on specific amendments to legislation. His description of Latham last month as a 'shameful bigot' following remarks made against anti-domestic violence campaigner Rosie Batty, independent MP Alex Greenwich and the Jewish community also came after the MP opposed the workers' compensation reform. 'I sat there and watched them trying to win over Mark Latham to supporting their bill,' she said. 'This idea that they won't work with him is laughable. If they had his vote, or if they needed it, we would not be hearing any of the criticism we are at the moment.' Boyd, who has long had an antagonistic relationship with Latham over her push for changes to the culture inside NSW parliament, met Minns in February last year to raise the issue of Labor's 'track record on dealing with sexism in the parliament' after becoming fed up with the 'permissiveness' of some MPs, including Latham. That included, she said, voting against a motion she moved to have parliamentary standing orders updated 'to require respectful behaviour in both Houses'. Labor subsequently supported the referral.
