Expert: Inaction, weak enforcement to blame for unresolved bus safety issues
There is no need for the government to reinvent the wheel to ensure better bus safety, an expert said, pointing out that decade-old plans introduced after past crashes were not properly implemented.
Wan Agyl Wan Hassan, founder of transport think tank MY Mobility Vision, said the Road Transport Department (RTD) and the now-defunct Land Public Transport Commission (SPAD) had developed multiple plans and initiatives to tackle bus safety issues.
"The problem is that, for the most part, they remain plans, largely due to a failure to implement or enforce the rules."
He cited SPAD's 2015 mandate for public service buses to be equipped with GPS tracking systems, allowing real-time monitoring by bus companies. A failure to comply would breach licensing conditions.
"If this has been implemented and enforced, why do drivers seem unafraid of speeding?" he told the New Straits Times.
Wan Agyl also called into question RTD's Kejara demerit system.
"When you have a demerit system, a driver should be suspended after several infractions or whatever threshold is set by the authorities," he said.
"In the case of the Gerik bus crash, the driver had 18 summonses, 13 of which were for speeding."
He said one of the root problems in enforcing rules was that authorities were "working in silos" and there was a lack of transparency.
"Every time there is a major crash, we read in the news that the driver had outstanding summonses, but what was done with that information before the crash?" he asked.
"The RTD, police and Land Public Transport Agency (APAD) should have access to the number of summonses a driver and a bus company receive from each agency.
"This should be marked in the Kejara system immediately. Right now, the demerit is recorded after a summons is paid. This is wrong."
He said summonses should be recorded when issued and once a driver or company accumulated a certain number of demerits, their licences should be suspended.
"In the interest of safety, these summonses should be visible to the public, so they can check and make the right choice when selecting a bus service."
Wan Agyl, a former SPAD group operations head of policy and planning, said as far back as 2013, the agency had proposed introducing a driver information system, which would allow users to check a driver's record.
"We can implement that now with QR codes. For example, put a bus driver's information on the bus, then people can scan the QR code to find out if he has any summonses," he said.
"If there is improved transparency, drivers would be more careful and companies would select their drivers more carefully.
"We just need the political will to execute what has already been studied, debated and agreed upon."
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
New Straits Times
7 hours ago
- New Straits Times
Gerik crash sparks call for mandatory telematics in transport sector
KUALA LUMPUR: The government must make it mandatory for bus and logistics operators to install a telematics system linked to a driver database as part of their licensing conditions, following the tragic bus crash involving Universiti Pendidikan Sultan Idris (UPSI) students. Road safety and sustainable transport activist Shahrim Tamrin said this requirement should form part of a broader initiative to develop the Performance Monitoring Hub System (PMHS) for public transport and logistics operators. This follows Transport Minister Anthony Loke's announcement that the Land Public Transport Agency (Apad) will develop a database system for express and tour bus drivers, complete with their past records, to improve the safety of public land transportation. "It has been music to our ears that drivers with so many summonses are still allowed to drive heavy vehicles, including lorries, express buses, stage buses, and tour buses," he said in a statement. Shahrim, who is also a former board member of the Malaysian Institute of Road Safety Research (Miros), said systemic failures over the years involving the transport and home ministries, including the Road Transport Department (RTD), Apad, and the police, had allowed high-risk drivers to slip through the cracks due to the lack of a centralised database for Public Service Vehicle (PSV) and Goods Driving Licence (GDL) holders. He said the now-defunct Land Public Transport Commission (Spad) had attempted to address this issue with the introduction of the Driver Information System (DIS) in 2013 for taxi drivers. "The DIS allowed driver screening based on merit or demerit, tracked traffic and criminal offences, and enabled public verification of a driver's status. "In 2017, Spad tried to implement a centralised database system — known as the Drivers and Commercial Vehicles Information System (DCVIS) — based on the DIS template for taxis, to cover heavy vehicles in the transportation and logistics sector, including express buses, tour buses, lorries, haulage, and stage buses." He said the plan was to integrate the system with an RFID-enabled telematics device in the vehicle so that only drivers with clean records could start the journey. "In other words, if the system found that the drivers or the vehicles had many outstanding summonses, it wouldn't start the engine. "Spad wanted to design DCVIS as a system that prioritised safety from within. "However, the plan was halted when the commission was disbanded in phases at the end of 2018," he said. As such, Shahrim said it was timely for Apad and the Transport Ministry to revive the project halted eight years ago. "I urge the government not to stop at just a driver database system. "This is also an opportunity for Apad and RTD to develop a comprehensive tracking (telematics) and record management system for heavy vehicle operators." He also called on the relevant authorities, including RTD and the police, to collaborate on a comprehensive telematics-linked driver and vehicle monitoring system based on the original DCVIS blueprint, and urged political will at the highest level. "This is where the cabinet Committee on Road Safety and Traffic Congestion, chaired by Deputy Prime Minister Datuk Seri Ahmad Zahid Hamidi, can step in. "It's time to address this once and for all to make our roads safer," he said. Shahrim also urged for the integration of the Kejara demerit system into Apad's proposed database for a more holistic approach.
New Straits Times
7 hours ago
- New Straits Times
18 school vans seized in Negri Sembilan crackdown
SEREMBAN: Eighteen school vans were seized by the Negri Sembilan Road Transport Department (RTD) during a state-wide crackdown targeting serious breaches that could endanger the safety of students. The operation, known as Ops Khas Van Haram, uncovered various infringements, including vehicles operating without permits, expired motor vehicle licences, and lapses in insurance and roadworthiness certificates. The crackdown was carried out yesterday in response to public complaints and intelligence reports. Negri Sembilan RTD director Hanif Yusabra Yusuf said the operation, which ran from 5am to 3pm, uncovered 26 vans operating without valid permits. "This operation was launched in response to public complaints and intelligence regarding a rise in the use of private vans for illegal commercial purposes," he said in a statement. "This includes transporting school pupils. Such activities not only violate the law but also pose serious safety risks to passengers," he added. Enforcement teams inspected 57 vehicles suspected of operating illegally across Seremban, Rembau, Kuala Pilah and Jempol. "A total of 22 summons notices were issued for various infractions. More significantly, 18 vans were seized under provisions of the Road Transport Act 1987 for further investigation," Hanif said. He added that the most common breach was the misuse of motor vehicle licences, with 26 cases recorded. Other violations included 10 cases involving expired motor vehicle licences and eight cases where vehicles were operating without valid insurance. Hanif said six vans were found with expired Puspakom inspection certificates, casting serious doubt on the roadworthiness of the vehicles. "In terms of driver qualification, we also detected four cases of individuals driving without a Public Service Vehicle (PSV) licence, and one case involving an expired PSV licence," he said.
New Straits Times
10 hours ago
- New Straits Times
Fatal heavy vehicle crashes expose systemic safety flaws
KUALA LUMPUR: Fatal crashes in Teluk Intan and Gerik involving heavy vehicles that failed safety audits underscore systemic flaws that are all too familiar, said transport and road safety experts. Transport policy expert Wan Agyl Wan Hassan said the revelations on the fatal crash involving a lorry and a Federal Reserve Unit (FRU) truck, as well as the bus accident in Gerik, Perak, that killed 15 Universiti Pendidikan Sultan Idris students, were hardly shocking. "They are devastatingly familiar. We've seen violations that should have triggered red flags and suspensions, yet somehow, these vehicles were still allowed to operate. "The crash in Teluk Intan involving FRU personnel and the Gerik bus tragedy are not isolated lapses. "They are evidence of a system that is structurally broken," said Wan Agyl, founder of transport think tank MY Mobility Vision. Yesterday, the task force probing the FRU accident released its preliminary report, showing that the tipper lorry involved was significantly overloaded. The report, released on the Transport Ministry's website, said investigations uncovered gaps in the safety management and operational practices of the vehicle. Transport Minister Anthony Loke said the operator of the bus involved in the Gerik crash had failed to comply with all seven mandatory safety audit criteria under the Road Transport Department's (RTD) Inspection and Safety Audit. He said a comprehensive audit conducted by the RTD found the operator had neglected critical safety protocols. LACK OF INSTITUTIONAL ACCOUNTABILITY Wan Agyl said what was most troubling is that the tipper lorry and the bus had already been flagged as non-compliant before the crashes. This, he said, shows that these were not hidden risks but known risks and direct threats to life. He said the main issue lies in the lack of system-wide enforcement, real-time risk detection and institutional accountability. He said multiple agencies — including RTD, the Land Public Transport Agency (Apad), Puspakom, Malaysian Institute of Road Safety Research and Occupational Safety and Health Department — operate in silos, where data is not shared promptly. GOVERNMENT VEHICLES MUST SET GOLD STANDARD He proposed five steps to overcome issues involving heavy vehicles, including centralising enforcement under a single lead agency with full authority over planning, licensing, inspections and compliance — much like a reformed version of the now-defunct Land Public Transport Commission (SPAD). He also proposed making safety audits binding instead of cosmetic. "If companies fail RTD's audit, their operating licence should be suspended immediately; no exceptions. "Passing these audits must be a condition to stay on the road," he said. He added that GPS tracking and tamper-proof safety technology for commercial vehicles should be mandated, including speed limiters and dashcams with live data access by authorities. No operator, he said, should be allowed to "switch off" visibility. "As I've mentioned many times, there should also be a reform of RTD's demerit system and integrate it with a national digital registry of high-risk drivers and operators, so patterns of repeat offences are flagged early before tragedy occurs." He said government vehicles should be treated equally, noting that the FRU truck had no seatbelts or headrests. "Government fleets must set the gold standard in compliance." NOT ISOLATED INCIDENTS Echoing the same sentiment, Universiti Putra Malaysia's Road Safety Research Centre head, Associate Professor Dr Law Teik Hua, said the recent fatal crashes are not isolated incidents but rather symptomatic of broader, systemic failure in Malaysia's transport enforcement and regulatory ecosystem. While each case may involve specific failings, such as overloading, missing seatbelts or poor vehicle maintenance, Law said they collectively point to deep-rooted issues in enforcement consistency, compliance monitoring and institutional accountability. He said oversight by agencies such as RTD, Apad and Puspakom frequently lacked coordination and consistency. "Overloaded lorries, non-compliant vehicles and unsafe driving practices often go undetected until after accidents occur. "Enforcement efforts tend to be reactive rather than preventive." He said many regulations, particularly those governing vehicle safety features, inspection protocols and cargo limits, have not kept pace with real-world transport risks. "For example, mandatory seatbelts for all government vehicles or real-time monitoring systems are not uniformly enforced. "There is also little integration of enforcement data across agencies, allowing high-risk drivers or repeat offenders to continue operating without triggering red flags. "A lack of public transparency further undermines accountability." Transport analyst Dr Rosli Azad Khan said the government should consider forming an independent road safety oversight commission to audit RTD, Puspakom and commercial vehicle operators without conflict of interest. "This commission must have access to the vehicles' database in the same way that traffic police have to enforce the law and compliance," he said. He called for public whistleblower channels to encourage the public and employees in transport companies to report unsafe practices, with legal protection for whistle-blowers. "There must be zero tolerance for heavy vehicles that fail safety inspections to be on the road," he said. He added that heavy vehicle operators with failed safety audits should be made public to pressure companies to comply. Transparency, he said, would give passengers and road users safety information.
