Where did gerrymandering come from? You can thank — or blame — a former Mass. governor

Boston Globe

5 days ago

Write to us at
. To subscribe,
.
TODAY'S STARTING POINT
American democracy owes Massachusetts a lot. The first shots of the Revolutionary War were fired here and the state's constitution became a model for the nation's. But Massachusetts is also the home state of a more notorious political tradition: partisan gerrymandering.
The term refers to state legislatures drawing voting maps designed to advantage one political party. Gerrymandering has been in the headlines lately because the Republicans who control the Texas legislature are trying to redraw congressional districts to cost Democrats US House seats before next year's midterm elections. Their Democratic counterparts have fled the state in hopes of blocking the measure from passing.
But the term's origins might be less familiar to you — and say a lot about how American politics has and hasn't changed over time.
Advertisement
Elbridge Gerry, former governor of Massachusetts.
Painting by James Bogle / Wikipedia
What's in a namesake
Elbridge Gerry was a staunch proponent of American democracy. Born in Marblehead in 1744, Gerry vocally opposed Britain's dominion over the colonies and used his merchantman's wealth to help supply the Revolution.
Yet after independence, as with other Founding Fathers, Gerry's partisan allegiances started to
Advertisement
It was that partisan feeling that linked Gerry's name to the term we still use today. Gerry's victory brought his fellow Democratic-Republicans majorities in the state legislature. But in case future elections went poorly, the party wanted to make sure that its control would continue. So it drew a jigsaw of erratically shaped districts to dilute the opposing Federalists' power. The redrawn districts either 'packed' Federalist voters into fewer districts or 'cracked' Federalist strongholds into different ones.
Gerry signed his party's gerrymandering proposal into law, though the practice existed in the US
The cartoon's origins have been disputed. But
The March 26, 1812, edition of the Boston Gazette carried Tisdale's drawing (above) and merged it with the sitting governor's name. The term 'Gerry-mander' was born.
What's old is new
Gerrymandering is a reminder that many of the flaws of American democracy have been with us almost from the start. Federalist-aligned newspapers reprinted Tisdale's drawing, and observers immediately perceived Gerry's gerrymander as unfair. The term quickly entered the political lexicon and went national.
Advertisement
Then as now, both dominant parties gerrymandered — and criticized each other for it. An 1878 article in the Globe
A new era
Yet the rest of Gerry's story also suggests how things have changed.
The redistricting plan he signed helped spur voters to throw him out in the next election. (He later served as James Madison's vice president.) Yet even as today's voters
Gerrymandering worked for Gerry — his party held the Massachusetts Senate in 1812 even as he lost the governorship — but tailoring districts to the results of the last election can be risky. Turnout, changing coalitions, and President Trump's deep unpopularity mean that 2026 may look very different than 2024. Still, after three consecutive House elections in which only a handful of seats determined control, it may be enough.
There is a solution: having independent commissions, rather than state legislators, draw maps. But in practice, large Democrat-controlled states have embraced such commissions more often, effectively tying the party's hands while most Republican-controlled states gerrymander unabated. In 2021, House Democrats proposed legislation that would have banned partisan redistricting for congressional districts nationwide;
Advertisement
Read more:
Governor Greg Abbott of Texas says he will
🧩
1 Down:
94°
POINTS OF INTEREST
Interlocking BU logos for Baylor University (left) and Boston University (right).
Sportslogos.net
Student visa issues:
The nation's colleges could have
Graduate programs at risk:
After decades of expanding graduate education, Massachusetts colleges have a problem: the Trump administration has
Litigious logos:
Baylor University, a private Christian university in Texas,
Crowded field:
The race for District 7 Boston city councilor has drawn 11 candidates, the most of any race on the Sept. ballot.
Conflicting goals:
Trump views his meeting with Vladimir Putin in Alaska Friday as a step toward a ceasefire between Russia and Ukraine. But that's not Putin's goal,
Advertisement
Another delay:
Trump extended a tariff truce with China that was set to expire early Tuesday morning for another 90 days, once again delaying a potential showdown between the world's two biggest economies. (
No grand jury releases:
A federal judge in Manhattan won't allow the release of grand jury transcripts from the Justice Department investigation into convicted sex offender Ghislaine Maxwell, Jeffrey Epstein's ex-girlfriend. (
Journalists' killings:
Global outrage is growing over the targeted killing of Al Jazeera journalist Anas al-Sharif in Gaza who Israel said was affiliated with Hamas. Funerals for him and four colleagues who were also killed in the airstrike were held Monday. (
Rolling in the deep:
Scientists have discovered the deepest living animal ecosystem ever found, 6 miles below the surface of the Pacific Ocean. Light cannot reach those depths, so the creatures rely on chemical energy. (
BESIDE THE POINT
By Teresa Hanafin
🇨🇦
O Canada:
Chappell Roan sings of heartbreak in her new single 'The Subway' and contemplates
🎥
4 stars:
'Highest 2 Lowest' is a love letter to a trifecta of things that director Spike Lee adores: New York City, director Akira Kurosawa, and actor Denzel Washington. Critic Odie Henderson says it's
💍
The Big Day:
Emma Grazier and Andrew Shepherd wed in Albuquerque
Advertisement
☄️
Showtime:
The impressive
⛺️
Spectacle Island:
This former dump has become one of the jewels of the Boston Harbor islands. Stan Grossfeld captured the excitement of the
📞 No more beeps and static:
AOL is ending its dial-up internet service, and after we all get over the shock that it still existed, we need a global farewell party where all the music
🟩
Don't dwarf the Monster:
A Newton writer has a plea for Red Sox owner John Henry: Do not diminish the famed
Thanks for reading Starting Point.
This newsletter was edited by
❓ Have a question for the team? Email us at
✍🏼 If someone sent you this newsletter, you can
📬 Delivered Monday through Friday.
Ian Prasad Philbrick can be reached at