
Welsh Government wants to more than double fines for common traffic offence
They say the current penalty 'insufficiently reflects the seriousness of the potential risk'
The Welsh Government wants to let councils more than double the fine that can be issued to drivers who leave their engine running while stationary. Currently there is provision in the law for councils to fine drivers who fail to comply with a request from an authorised person telling them to running their vehicle engine while stationary on a public highway.
Under 2003 regulations a stationary idling offence can only be committed in relation to emissions however Welsh Government say it is also taking account the potential impacts that noise pollution can have on people.
The current fine is £20 but if not paid within a specified period that rises to £40. It comes after a major change with the 20mph law in Wales.
However, in a consultation about air quality, the Welsh Government say they believe "the penalty amount of £20 insufficiently reflects the seriousness of the potential risk of pollution to public health and is too low to act as sufficient deterrence".
The consultation also says it wants to give Welsh councils the ability to set their own fines. "It is proposed to introduce a new penalty range and to provide local authorities with flexibility to determine a suitable penalty level to reflect local needs. The proposed range is £50 to £100, which would bring penalty amounts for this offence more in line with penalties for other environmental offences."
The consultation document reads: "Stationary engine idling, the practice of leaving an engine running when a vehicle is not moving, is an unnecessary contributor to air pollution and noise. It also wastes fuel and increases costs to drivers.
"Idling can be a particular concern in some locations, such as outside schools where children may be disproportionately exposed to vehicle emissions, and to residents regularly impacted by noise.
"We believe that the penalty level insufficiently reflects the seriousness of the potential risk of pollution to public health and that the current fixed penalty level is set too low to act as viable deterrence.
"This amount was set in legislation more than 20 years ago and has not increased with inflation in that time. We believe that providing local authorities with flexibility to select a higher penalty amount for stationary engine idling will better enable them to undertake efficient and effective enforcement action to help reduce instances of the offence which in turn will help improve the air quality in your community." For our free daily briefing on the biggest issues facing the nation, sign up to the Wales Matters newsletter here.
It adds: "Our focus is on supporting and encouraging drivers and we see penalties as a tool of last resort."
As well as the consultation on statutory idling there is a second on a delivery plan about wider air quality proposals.
That consultation reads: "Air pollution poses significant risks to human health, nature, and the wider environment affecting both individuals and communities across Wales. Raising awareness of these impacts is crucial to empowering people to make informed choices that contribute to cleaner air and healthier surroundings."
The focus of that plan is "national communication campaigns, educational resources, and guidance for local authorities to develop their own air quality awareness initiatives".
It adds: "By providing clear, accessible information, we hope to encourage positive action and reduce behaviours that contribute to pollution."
Welsh Government says it will give £575,000 over the next three years to help raise awareness and change behaviour.
Article continues below
The consultation on air quality closes on September 30 while the one on idling finishes on October 28.

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Wales Online
9 hours ago
- Wales Online
E-scooters explored for Wales as trial opens but there's a catch
E-scooters explored for Wales as trial opens but there's a catch Cardiff and Swansea are among the areas that have expressed an interest A new window has opened for councils to apply for e-scooter trials (stock image) (Image: Mike Kemp) Officials are "exploring" whether electric scooters can be brought to Wales. E-scooters are illegal on public roads in the UK except in areas where there is a trial. Rental schemes have been taking place in parts of England since 2020 but there has yet to be a trial anywhere in Wales. Last year WalesOnline revealed Cardiff and Swansea councils had formally expressed an interest in launching trials. Now, for the first time in years, the UK's Department for Transport has opened a window for councils to apply for trials in new areas — yet there is a catch for those in Wales. The Welsh Government's transport s ecretary Ken Skates told us: 'We would consider any Welsh local authority interest to pursue participation in a trial of public rental electric scooters. Before any trial could commence a change in road legislation would need to be made.' When we contacted Swansea council, its spokesman suggested any e-scooter plans are on the backburner until the Welsh Government makes a tweak to legislation. "I'm told the reopened applications for trials are in England, not Wales," he said. Cardiff council, meanwhile, is planning to launch an electric bike hire scheme across the city in early 2026. But its spokesman told us it could add e-scooters to the offering pending "legal changes being made to allow them to be used on public land in Wales". The UK Government told us its transport department is "engaging with our Welsh counterparts to explore whether it will be possible to open e-scooter trials in Wales, as they would need to pass some legislation to enable this". Any councils interested should engage with the Welsh Government in the first instance, the UK Government added. Harry Foskin, from the UK's biggest e-scooter operator Voi, said a mix of e-scooters and e-bikes would be an "affordable, easy and safe addition" to transport options in Wales, adding: "They're good for health, come without any carbon or air pollution, and don't add traffic to the roads. "In the Valleys, for instance, shared e-bikes and e-scooters could help people reach stations along the South Wales Metro as part of an integrated transport system. "In city and town centres they can help people hop about to work, to appointments, to shops when the car is impractical and the next bus might be too far away." He called on the Welsh and UK Governments to "work collaboratively" with councils to "unlock the full potential" of e-scooters in Wales. Last month the UK Government extended e-scooter trials until 2028. Voi said the latest trial period 'had to be the last' before a permanent legalisation, as uncertainty was damaging investment. The UK Government has been widely criticised for repeatedly extending the trials without making a final decision on whether e-scooters will be made fully legal, or only available in hire schemes, or any other option. Supporters of e-scooters say they are a low-emission, fun and relatively cheap mode of transport. But the illegal use of privately owned e-scooters has been common for years in Wales, without the guardrails of regulation. While scooters used in the English trials are limited to 15.5mph, private ones often have higher speed limits, no lighting, and have been known to explode due to mishandled batteries. One of the criticisms of e-scooters — even those used in the trials — has been illegal pavement riding. Guide Dogs Cymru's Andrea Gordon, who has been blind all her life, previously told us that nearly three quarters of people with sight loss who have encountered an e-scooter have had a negative experience. Voi said it has worked "very closely" with charities for blind people and has integrated their suggestions into how it educates riders. Last year its e-scooters' accident rates dropped by 70%, to the same level as the company's e-bikes, it said. At the time of writing there are rental e-scooter trials in 18 regions of England. A report by the Department for Transport found there had been "concerns about the behaviour" of some riders and that pavement riding has caused "particular concern" among visually impaired people. But it also pointed to the green transport option increasingly being used for "purposeful journeys". And riders in trial areas had over time shifted away from more dangerous illegal scooters. Article continues below


Wales Online
11 hours ago
- Wales Online
Why the M4 was shut completely one way at the Prince of Wales Bridge
Why the M4 was shut completely one way at the Prince of Wales Bridge There were long delays this morning after an incident on the bridge with all traffic held at one point There were long queues on the M4 on Wednesday morning (Image: Traffic Wales) Drivers faced long delays on the M4 eastbound on Wednesday morning (August 6) due to a collision on the Prince of Wales Bridge. The eastbound carriageway was closed between J23 (Monmouthshire) and J22 (Redwick) at around 8am and did not re-open fully until around 10.30am. All traffic was held at 8.25am and all lanes were closed while emergency services responded to the incident. The collision involved three cars and a motorcycle. Minor injuries were reported, Gwent Police said. Follow our live coverage of the incident here. The closure caused long delays of up to two hours for drivers heading east, with queues of 11 miles building up back to J24 at Coldra. Traffic Wales said the disruption was "severe". Why did the eastbound section of the bridge shut completely? According to Traffic Wales, the collision occurred on the M4 Prince of Wales Bridge J23 and J22 at around 8am on Wednesday. The collision, which involved a motorcyclist and three cars, occurred on the eastbound carriageway. Initially, two lanes on the M4 eastbound were closed, before all traffic was held on the bridge at 8.25am. The carriageway was completely blocked until shortly before 9.30am, when lanes two and three re-opened. Lane one remained closed for accident recovery work, but traffic was able to pass. All lanes were re-opened at 10.20am. The westbound section of the bridge remained open throughout the incident. Police and paramedics attended the scene. For our free daily briefing on the biggest issues facing the nation, sign up to the Wales Matters newsletter here A spokesperson for Gwent Police said on Wednesday morning: "We received a report of a road traffic collision on the M4 between junctions 23 and 22 at around 7.50am on Wednesday, 6 August. "Officers and paramedics are currently at the scene. Article continues below "The collision involved three cars and a motorcycle. "Minor injuries have been reported, and the incident is ongoing."


North Wales Live
13 hours ago
- North Wales Live
Woman drives from England to Wales but spots 'problem' with Welsh road users
A woman who recently travelled from England to Wales was left stunned by one significant contrast she encountered. Claire Hannah, hailing from Wigan, confessed she had to venture into an area of Wales by car, but was taken aback by a notable distinction regarding Welsh motorists. In a frank video posted on TikTok, she revealed she experienced quite the surprise upon entering our nation, as she was astounded by just how leisurely people drive here, despite there being a crucial justification for it. Obviously, Claire is referring to the 20mph speed restriction, which has been implemented across certain areas in Wales. The 20mph default regulation took effect in September 2023, notwithstanding considerable resistance and a petition bearing hundreds of thousands of signatures. Fresh statistics reveal it has extended journey durations in Wales, whilst causing a reduction in average speeds. Nevertheless, certain routes are scheduled to revert to 30mph following the Government's announcement that councils could choose to reinstate some roads back to 30mph in September 2024. Despite this development, Claire recently discovered what it's actually like having to adhere to the 20mph restriction, and she was amazed by how challenging it must be for Welsh drivers to manage. In her footage, she remarked: "I've just driven to somewhere in Wales. How hard is it to stay at 20mph? It's awful. "And everybody else does as well, and it's kind of like - you know when everybody drives well slow in the snow? That's what it's like, but it's really hard driving at 20mph." Since the video went live, it has racked up hundreds of views with dozens of motorists weighing in on the contentious speed restrictions. One resident declared: "I live in Wales and it's a nightmare and horrible for the environment." Another chimed in with: "Think everyone in Wales hates it." A third observer noted: "I'm surprised at how many 20mph roads there are in England. Noone seems to complain there." Meanwhile, a fourth contributor added: "It's difficult. Some areas in England have it too." One person also shared a heartbreaking account, stating: "A local woman in my town in Wales was knocked down on the high street and has life changing injuries, and that was doing 20mph." Despite the heated debate surrounding the speed restrictions, recent figures reveal that approximately 54% of Welsh drivers now stick to 24mph or below, a dramatic rise from merely 20.8% prior to the implementation - a transformation anticipated to cut both collision rates and injury severity. Mean speeds have climbed marginally between winter 2023/24 and winter 2024/25. Typical journey durations across 15 monitored routes - tracked during both rush hour periods in either direction - lengthened in 57 out of 60 instances. Nevertheless, in 44 of these cases, the additional time amounted to no more than two minutes. Simultaneously, journey time consistency has improved in 45 scenarios, delivering more predictable travel periods. Whilst it's premature to make definitive conclusions about trends in pedestrian and cyclist casualties, there has been an 11.8% decrease in overall road casualties in the four quarters since the law was implemented.