Bruce Lehrmann claims police destroyed exonerating evidence and pending rape trial should be abandoned, court hears
Lehrmann's solicitor, Zali Burrows, told Brisbane district court on Thursday that Queensland Police had been unable to access a hard drive that contained extensive case files.
The included audio of Lehrmann taken before his arrest in 2023 and a full download of the complainant's mobile phone.
Sign up: AU Breaking News email
Burrows' claims are to be tested at a hearing on 26 September, with Judge Deborah Richards ordering that Lehrmann would not face a potential trial on two counts of rape until at least 2026.
The 30-year-old appeared by phone for the mention of his case.
Judge Benedict Power previously directed the defence and prosecutors to agree on a nominal start date for the trial.
But Burrows on Thursday said that would be premature for multiple reasons.
'There is an application for a permanent stay of proceedings on the basis of destruction of exculpatory material,' she said.
'The officer in charge of this investigation has lost material that was stored on a personal hard drive that contained materials from the course of the investigation.'
Burrows said the hard drive contained audio recordings involving witnesses and Lehrmann, copies of statements and video recordings.
'(The officer) claims the hard drive malfunctioned for unknown reasons,' she said.
'Defence has sought access to the hard drive for an independent interrogation by our own experts but we are told the hard drive has now been destroyed.'
Lehrmann, who is on bail, is accused of raping a woman twice during the morning of 10 October 2021.
They met during the previous night at a strip club in Toowoomba, west of Brisbane.
The former ministerial staffer to Liberal senator Linda Reynolds was charged in January 2023 and is yet to formally enter a plea.
But his former solicitor previously told a magistrate Lehrmann intended to contest the charges.
Sign up to Breaking News Australia
Get the most important news as it breaks
after newsletter promotion
Crown prosecutor Peter Blake-Segovia did not respond to Burrows' submissions about the officer's hard drive or her claims that police were providing her copies of evidence in a 'piecemeal' manner.
Richards said there was no room in this year's calendar for another trial.
'I don't have a calendar for next year yet. You are off the hook for a trial date at this stage,' she said.
Barrister Michael Bonasia, representing the Queensland police commissioner, told Richards his client had been served a subpoena by Burrows for copies of all materials in the case.
'There's an application for any claims of privilege for documents sought under the subpoena,' he said.
Richards ordered a hearing on the subpoena claims on 28 August and a hearing on 26 September for Burrows' application to permanently stay proceedings, which if granted would halt the trial before it started.
'On 29 October … (a date) will be listed for the trial if it's still on foot,' the judge said.
Lehrmann's bail was continued.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
BBC News
4 minutes ago
- BBC News
Gareth Ward: Convicted rapist fighting to remain in parliament in Australia
An Australian politician convicted of rape is fighting - from his jail cell - to remain a member of the New South Wales (NSW) Ward was last month found guilty of sexually assaulting two young men, aged 18 and 24, at his home between 2013 and 2015, and is now in custody pending NSW House of Representatives had planned to expel the 44-year-old this week after he refused to resign following the guilty lawyers for Ward - who plans to appeal his conviction - say they will seek an injunction, at a Supreme Court hearing on Friday, to stop the independent member for Kiama from being forced out. "He's got no shame," NSW Premier Chris Minns told local radio station 2GB on repeated calls for Ward to resign from state parliament, saying it's the "first and most obvious choice"."It's an unconscionable situation to have someone who's currently sitting in jail in Silverwater, convicted of serious sexual offences, who is demanding to remain a member of parliament and continue to be paid," Minns said. Ward resigned as a state government minister and from the Liberal Party when the accusations emerged in 2021, but refused to leave parliament and was re-elected as the member for Kiama in NSW government had previously considered voting to expel Ward - who has been a state MP since 2011 - but legal advice indicated it could risk prejudicing his is due to be sentenced next month, for three counts of indecent assault and one count of rape.
The Independent
an hour ago
- The Independent
Man jailed for threatening police with ‘gun' made from Primark bag
A man has been jailed after he threatened two police officers with a fake firearm he made from a brown paper bag. CCTV footage showed Matthew Sylvester, 37, chase a police car and point a fake gun at the officers, who assumed in the dark that the weapon was real. Police constables Dan Arthur and George Oliver responded to a report of a man who was using a trolley to try and break into a shop in Telford town centre at around 10pm on 22 February. West Mercia Police said that the officers didn't realise 'the wannabe burglar' was preparing for police arrival, using a jumper to cover his face in a nearby trolley park where he forged an object to mimic a gun. When he spotted the patrol car enter the car park, he immediately charged at the officers with his imitation firearm. The officers moved away from Sylvester, only to find themselves stuck behind the car park barriers. He went to the passenger side of the car, where he threatened PC Oliver and kicked the vehicle. The officers quickly called for backup as they couldn't see in the dark that Sylvester was not holding a gun. The 37-year-old moved to open the boot of the police car, before the two officers got out of the car and pursued him on foot, as Sylvester ran in the direction of a housing estate. Before he could leave the car park, the two officers tackled him to the floor and removed the jumper covering his face, where Sylvester - who is known to the police - was revealed. Police established quickly that the firearm was a brown paper bag that Sylvester had folded up to look like a handgun. The suspect, of no fixed abode, was arrested at the scene for offences including having an imitation firearm and assaulting an emergency worker. Chief Inspector Matt Sanders said: 'When officers are sent to an ongoing incident they are going into the unknown. That night, PC Arthur and PC Oliver responded to an attempted burglary, and came face-to-face with a man whose clear intention was to cause harm and distress to police. 'Sylvester's actions were calculated, going to great lengths to ensure officers were called to the scene, including threatening members of the public and trying to break into a shop. "He covered his face with a jumper to ensure he wasn't recognised by officers before manipulating an object to look like a small firearm so he could threaten whoever was responding. 'The bravery and professionalism shown by both PCs that evening was nothing short of extraordinary. "Fortunately, neither officer sustained any injuries, and Sylvester was swiftly arrested thanks to the quick thinking and actions of both officers that night, along with those who also came to their aid.'No-one should come to work and face violence, and we thank our officers that day for their bravery and dedication to keeping communities safe.' He was later charged with a number of offences including two counts of assaulting an emergency worker, possession of an imitation firearm to cause distress, possession of class A drugs and attempted burglary. Sylvester pleaded guilty to all charges at Shrewsbury Crown Court halfway through a week-long trial on Wednesday last week. On Friday, he was sentenced to 16 months for imitating a firearm, and three months for assaulting two emergency workers to run consecutively. He was also given four months for causing fear and violence and one month for possession of a class A drug (cocaine). Both are to run concurrently.
The Independent
an hour ago
- The Independent
Grand jury declines to indict former Atlanta police officer in church deacon's death
A grand jury on Monday declined to indict an former Atlanta police officer on manslaughter charges in the death of a church deacon who died in a struggle with the officer following a minor car crash. After hearing the case, Fulton County grand jurors rejected criminal charges against Kiran Kimbrough, said Jeff DiSantis, a spokesperson for Fulton County District Attorney Fani Willis. Johnny Hollman Sr. died in August 2023 after he refused to sign a citation following a wreck. Family members said the 62-year-old Hollman was driving home from Bible study at his daughter's house and taking dinner to his wife when he collided with another vehicle while turning across a busy street just west of downtown. Body camera video of Hollman's arrest shows Kimbrough repeatedly demanding that Hollman sign the citation, while Hollman insists he did nothing wrong. The two men tussled and Hollman ended up face down on the ground with Kimbrough over him, pressing him down. Holloman repeatedly says 'I can't breathe,' and Kimbrough uses a Taser to shock him repeatedly. The video also shows a tow truck driver helping Kimbrough. Hollman became unresponsive and was declared dead at a hospital. An autopsy determined the death was a homicide, with heart disease also a contributing factor. Lance LoRusso, who represents Kimbrough, said prosecutors sought to indict his client for one count of manslaughter, one count of simple battery and three counts of violating his oath of office. Kimbrough testified before the grand jury, as is an officer's right under state law, LoRusso said. 'While Johnny Hollman's death was tragic, in no way did Kiran Kimbrough cause the death,' LoRusso said in a statement Monday. 'Johnny Hollman's death was caused by medical complications and his felonious, unlawful resistance of a uniformed officer performing his lawful duties.' DiSantis said Willis is conferring with prosecutors and investigators about whether to ask a new grand jury to indict Kimbrough. Hollman's family members have repeatedly called for the former officer to be criminally charged. A statement from lawyers attributed to the family said they were 'devastated' by the grand jury's decision not to indict. 'The failure to hold this officer accountable is another painful reminder of how little value is placed on his life by some citizens,' the statement said. 'Our faith and our fight for justice will not waver.' Atlanta officials fired Kimbrough, saying he should have agreed to Hollman's request to speak to a supervisor. A civil service board upheld the firing, and the Atlanta City Council agreed to settle a lawsuit by Hollman's family alleging excessive force for $3.8 million. The family also sued the tow truck driver and his employer, saying the driver straddled Hollman's head and neck for at least 20 seconds and appeared to 'sit with his full body weight' on Hollman's head and neck while Kimbrough handcuffed Hollman. Atlanta and some other police departments have enacted policies saying that officers should no longer arrest people who refused to sign citations. State lawmakers passed a bill that would have enacted such a policy statewide earlier this year, but Gov. Brian Kemp vetoed it because he opposed a provision unrelated to collecting signatures from people named on citations.
