logo
Judge gives ex-officer nearly 3 years in Breonna Taylor raid, rebuffs DOJ call for no prison time

Judge gives ex-officer nearly 3 years in Breonna Taylor raid, rebuffs DOJ call for no prison time

Chicago Tribune4 days ago
LOUISVILLE, Ky. — A federal judge on Monday sentenced a former Kentucky police officer to nearly three years in prison for using excessive force during the deadly Breonna Taylor raid five years ago, rebuffing a U.S. Department of Justice recommendation of no prison time for the defendant.
Brett Hankison, who fired 10 shots during the raid but didn't hit anyone, was the only officer on the scene charged in the Black woman's death in 2020. He is the first person sentenced to prison in the case that rocked the city of Louisville and spawned weeks of street protests over police brutality five years ago.
U.S. District Judge Rebecca Grady Jennings sentenced Hankison at a hearing Monday afternoon in which she said no prison time 'is not appropriate' for Hankison. She also said she was 'startled' that there weren't more people injured in the raid.
She sentenced him to 33 months in prison as well as three years of supervised probation. Hankison will not report directly to prison. Jennings said the Bureau of Prisons will determine where and when he starts his sentence.
Jennings expressed disappointment with federal prosecutors' sentencing memo filed last week, saying the Justice Department treated Hankison's actions as 'an inconsequential crime,' and said the memo was 'incongruous and inappropriate.'
Civil rights attorney Ben Crump, who helped Taylor's family secure a $12 million wrongful death settlement against the city of Louisville and was present Mondya, had called the Justice Department recommendation 'an insult to the life of Breonna Taylor and a blatant betrayal of the jury's decision.'
He said Monday afternoon that he had hoped Hankison would get more time. But, he said: 'We are grateful that he is at least going to prison and has to think for those 3 years about Breonna Taylor and that her life mattered.'
And afterward, before a crowd gathered outside the courthouse, Crump yelled: 'Say Her name.' The crowd yelled back: 'Breonna Taylor!'
Hankison fired his weapon the night of the March 2020 botched drug raid, his shot flying through the walls of Taylor's apartment into a neighboring apartment without hitting or injuring anyone.
The 26-year-old's death, along with the May 2020 police killing of George Floyd in Minneapolis, sparked racial injustice protests nationwide that year.
Last week, the U.S. Justice Department recommended no prison time for Hankison, in an abrupt about-face by federal prosecutors that has angered critics after the department spent years prosecuting the former detective.
The Justice Department, which has changed leadership under President Donald Trump since Hankison's conviction, said in a sentencing memo last week that 'there is no need for a prison sentence to protect the public' from Hankison. Federal prosecutors suggested time already served, which amounts to one day, and three years of supervised probation.
Prosecutors at his previous federal trials aggressively pursued a conviction against Hankison, 49, arguing that he blindly fired 10 shots into Taylor's windows without identifying a target. Taylor was shot in her hallway by two other officers after her boyfriend fired from inside the apartment, striking an officer in the leg. Neither of the other officers was charged in state or federal court after prosecutors deemed they were justified in returning fire into the apartment. Louisville police used a drug warrant to enter the apartment, but found no drugs or cash inside.
A separate jury deadlocked on federal charges against Hankison in 2023, and he was acquitted on state charges of wanton endangerment in 2022.
In their recent sentencing memo, federal prosecutors wrote that though Hankison's 'response in these fraught circumstances was unreasonable given the benefit of hindsight, that unreasonable response did not kill or wound Breonna Taylor, her boyfriend, her neighbors, defendant's fellow officers, or anyone else.'
On Monday, the Louisville Metro Police Department arrested four people in front of the courthouse who it said were 'creating confrontation, kicking vehicles, or otherwise creating an unsafe environment.' Authorities didn't list the charges those arrested would face.
'We understand this case caused pain and damaged trust between our department and the community,' a police statement said. 'We particularly respect and value the 1st Amendment. However, what we saw today in front of the courthouse in the street was not safe, acceptable or legal.'
A U.S. Probation Office presentencing report had said Hankison should face a range of 135 to 168 months imprisonment on the excessive force conviction, according to the memo. But federal prosecutors said multiple factors — including that Hankison's two other trials ended with no convictions — should greatly reduce the potential punishment.
The memorandum was submitted by Harmeet Dhillon, chief of the Justice Department's Civil Rights Division and a Trump political appointee who in May moved to cancel settlements with Louisville and Minneapolis that had called for overhauling their police departments.
In the Taylor case, three other ex-Louisville police officers have been charged with crafting a falsified warrant, but have not gone to trial. None were at the scene when Taylor was shot.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Ghislaine Maxwell to meet with DOJ again today over Epstein case
Ghislaine Maxwell to meet with DOJ again today over Epstein case

USA Today

time18 minutes ago

  • USA Today

Ghislaine Maxwell to meet with DOJ again today over Epstein case

The Department of Justice's talks with Jeffrey Epstein's co-conspirator Ghislaine Maxwell will extend into a second day, a senior official said, as the Trump administration battles fervent calls to release more documents related to the government's investigation of Epstein's crimes. Deputy Attorney General Todd Blanche posted July 24 on social media that he would again meet with Maxwell, the former British socialite serving a 20-year prison sentence in Tallahassee, Florida, for trafficking a minor to Epstein for sexual abuse. "Today, I met with Ghislaine Maxwell, and I will continue my interview of her tomorrow," Blanche wrote on X, adding, "The Department of Justice will share additional information about what we learned at the appropriate time." Talks between the Justice Department and Maxwell come as the Trump administration faces mounting pressure to reverse its pledge not to release any more documents related to the Epstein case, an announcement that prompted fierce backlash from the president's most loyal followers. Epstein, the wealthy financier, hanged himself in 2019 in a Manhattan jail cell, an autopsy concluded, while awaiting trial on sex-trafficking charges. His case has long been the subject of conspiracy theories, considering his rich and powerful friends and the circumstances of his death. Maxwell was Epstein's girlfriend for years and has been accused of recruiting minors for the disgraced financier's predation. Her lengthy relationship with Epstein and role in his efforts to sexually target minor girls raises the question of whether she knows of others who could have been involved in a sex-trafficking ring with Epstein. She maintains her innocence and is appealing her 2021 sex-trafficking conviction. DOJ's first meeting with Maxwell was 'very productive,' lawyer says After meeting with Blanche on July 24, David Markus, the Miami attorney representing Ghislaine Maxwell, called the meeting "very productive." Markus spoke with reporters outside the U.S. Courthouse in Tallahassee after he and Maxwell met for hours behind closed doors to field questions from Blanche about the notorious Jeffrey Epstein case. He thanked Blanche for meeting with them and 'for being so professional with all of us.' 'He took a full day and asked a lot of questions, and Ms. Maxwell answered every single question,' Markus said. 'She never stopped. She never invoked her privilege. She never declined to answer. She answered all the questions truthfully, honestly and to the best of her ability.' Prosecutors left through a back entrance without taking questions, and Maxwell was returned to FCI Tallahassee, the low-security women's prison where she has been incarcerated for the last three years. Contributing: Aysha Bagchi and Josh Meyer, USA TODAY; Reuters

Trump administration news, latest on Epstein files, DOJ meeting with Ghislaine Maxwell
Trump administration news, latest on Epstein files, DOJ meeting with Ghislaine Maxwell

CNN

time19 minutes ago

  • CNN

Trump administration news, latest on Epstein files, DOJ meeting with Ghislaine Maxwell

Update: Date: 11 min ago Title: Trump is traveling to Scotland today Content: President Donald Trump departs the White House this morning for a five-day visit to Scotland, where he's expected to meet with UK Prime Minister Keir Starmer and visit his golf properties in Aberdeen and Turnberry. Trump and first lady Melania Trump will next visit the UK in September for a state visit at the invitation of King Charles. Protests expected: Several protest groups, ranging from trade unions and climate justice campaigners to sections of the American diaspora and Palestinian and Ukrainian advocacy groups, are planning to demonstrate against the US president under the umbrella of the 'Stop Trump Coalition.' Protests are scheduled for Saturday in Edinburgh, Aberdeen and Dumfries. Scotland has a long history of protesting Trump. Read more here. Update: Date: 27 min ago Title: Here's what we know about Epstein's accomplice Ghislaine Maxwell Content: British socialite Ghislaine Maxwell was the ex-girlfriend-turned social companion of Jeffrey Epstein. Maxwell was sentenced in 2022 to 20 years in federal prison for carrying out a years-long scheme with Epstein to groom and sexually abuse underage girls. She has attempted to appeal her conviction. Deputy Attorney General Todd Blanche met with Maxwell yesterday and said he'll interview her again today. The meeting comes after a judge declined to release grand jury documents from the criminal probe into Epstein and amid growing backlash against President Donald Trump and his administration for not releasing more information on the Epstein case. More on Maxwell's relationship with Epstein: Update: Date: 27 min ago Title: Trump's deputy attorney general says he will meet with Ghislaine Maxwell again today Content: Deputy Attorney General Todd Blanche said he would continue his interview with Ghislaine Maxwell today after they met for hours in Florida yesterday. 'Productive day today with the Deputy Attorney General Todd Blanche and Ghislaine Maxwell,' her lawyer David Markus said of the meeting. 'He took a full day and asked a lot of questions.' The former Epstein associate answered every question posed to her during the meeting, according to her lawyer. 'She never invoked a privilege. She never declined to answer. She answered all the questions truthfully, honestly and to the best of her ability,' Markus said. He wouldn't comment on the substance of the meeting 'for obvious reasons,' he added. Blanche said the Justice Department 'will share additional information about what we learned at the appropriate time,' in a post on X. Blanche's meeting came with the backdrop of fierce public backlash, including from members of President Donald Trump's base, over the administration's perceived lack of transparency surrounding documents related to Epstein's case.

Analysis: Timeline suggests Trump team changed its tune on Epstein files after Trump was told he was in them
Analysis: Timeline suggests Trump team changed its tune on Epstein files after Trump was told he was in them

CNN

time21 minutes ago

  • CNN

Analysis: Timeline suggests Trump team changed its tune on Epstein files after Trump was told he was in them

The news Wednesday that Attorney General Pam Bondi told President Donald Trump back in May that his name appeared in the Jeffrey Epstein files isn't that surprising, in context. We've known the two men had a relationship dating back decades, and we've seen Trump's name appear in various previously released Epstein-related materials. Being in the documents isn't proof of any wrongdoing. But the news is significant in another way: It adds to questions about precisely why the administration changed its tune on the Epstein files. That doesn't mean there's been a cover-up of any actual Epstein-related misconduct by Trump; there remains no real evidence of that. But the administration clearly started downplaying the Epstein information – in a rather abrupt shift – around the same time Trump was told his name appeared in the files. What's more, sources familiar with the review told CNN the files appeared to include several unsubstantiated claims about Trump and others that the Justice Department found not to be credible. In other words, extensive disclosures could have at least created problems for Trump. And the administration appeared to abruptly move away from such disclosures. We'll get to the full timeline in a second. But a few key things stand out: While we don't know the precise date in May that Bondi briefed Trump, the efforts to downplay Epstein conspiracy theories and previous promises for disclosure really kicked off on May 18, when top FBI officials Kash Patel and Dan Bongino appeared together on Fox News and suddenly said Epstein had indeed died by suicide. News of that May briefing contradicts Trump's claim from July 15 that Bondi hadn't told him he was in the files. When asked, Trump told reporters: 'No, no, she's given us just a very quick briefing.' If this is a nothingburger, why hide that? Elon Musk's later-deleted claim that Trump wasn't releasing the Epstein files because he was in them was lodged June 5, after the May briefing. Trump's recently launched, baseless claims that powerful Democrats 'made up' the Epstein files would fit with his tendency to deflect and distract when there's something he doesn't want out there. Prior to May, the administration had repeatedly promised extensive disclosures. Bondi in early March said Americans would 'get the full Epstein files,' subject to some redactions, and that 'everything's going to come out to the public.' Trump said on April 22 that '100% of all of these documents are being delivered.' But by late May and early June, Patel and Bongino for the first time indicated there wasn't much to the information and walked back those promises. On May 29, Bongino suggested it amounted to 'nothing.' On June 4, he downplayed the case as a 'hot potato for folks.' On June 6, Patel went further than the administration had before in suggesting disclosures would be limited to avoid re-victimizing people, saying, 'Not doing it. You want to hate me for it, fine.' The administration ultimately did not release substantial new documents, saying in its July 7 memo that it 'found no basis to revisit the disclosure of those materials' and citing how many of them were under court seal. The administration did hype the files in one big way in early May. Bondi said on May 7 that the information included 'tens of thousands of videos of Epstein with children or child porn.' By June 6, Patel appeared to walk back Bondi's claim. The DOJ's memo a month later did not back it up. And now, the full timeline. Feb. 21: Attorney General Pam Bondi is asked by Fox News about an Epstein 'client list,' and she responds by saying that it's 'sitting on my desk right now to review.' (The administration has since claimed she was referring to other documents.) Feb. 26: Bondi on Fox hypes a release of documents set for the following day, calling it 'breaking news,' and saying it will include 'a lot of information.' Feb. 27: The White House invites right-wing social media influencers to the White House and gives them binders of Epstein-related documents. But the documents are mostly old news, and some influencers cry foul. March 1: Bondi tells Fox that Americans will 'get the full Epstein files,' subject to redactions to 'protect grand jury information and confidential witnesses.' March 3: Bondi tells Fox's Sean Hannity that DOJ has received a new 'truckload of evidence' from the FBI. She adds that 'everything's going to come out to the public.' March 14: Bondi repeats on Fox Business Network that she has received a new 'truckload of documents.' She adds that 'we will get out as much as we can, as fast as we can, to the American people, because they deserve to know.' March 23: Bondi tells Fox News that 'we are releasing all of these documents as soon as we can get them redacted to protect the victims …' April 22: President Donald Trump is asked in the Oval Office about when the Epstein files will be released and says, '100% of all of these documents are being delivered.' May 7: Bondi claims there are 'tens of thousands of videos of Epstein with children or child porn.' Her public claim comes shortly before the release of a secretly recorded video in which she made a similar claim. Sometime in May: Bondi briefs Trump about the Epstein files and tells him his name appears in them, among several other high-profile figures, CNN has confirmed. The files appeared to include several unsubstantiated claims, including about Trump, that the DOJ found to be not credible, sources said. (The precise date of this briefing isn't clear, but White House officials noted Wednesday that Trump's name was already in the binders Bondi handed out earlier this year.) May 18: For the first time, the administration begins downplaying the Epstein conspiracy theories. FBI Director Kash Patel and Deputy Director Dan Bongino appear together on Fox News and say Epstein indeed died by suicide. This despite both of them having promoted the conspiracy theories before joining the FBI. May 19: White House press secretary Karoline Leavitt says the administration is 'committed to releasing those files,' but defers to the Justice Department on timing. May 29: Bongino on Fox again downplays the significance of what will soon be released. 'There is nothing in the file at this point on the Epstein case,' he says. 'And there's going to be a disclosure on this coming shortly.' He says the administration will release video of the jail on the day of Epstein's death that backs up that assertion. June 4: Bongino is pressed on Hannity's show about the lack of Epstein disclosures. He downplays the case as a 'hot potato for folks' and then alludes to his own evolution on the subject: 'I'm not paid for my opinions anymore. I work for the taxpayer now. I'm paid on evidence. That's it.' June 5: Elon Musk claims while lashing out at Trump that the 'real reason' the president is not releasing the Epstein files is because '@realDonaldTrump is in the Epstein files.' He provides no evidence for his claims and later deletes the post, while expressing regret for some of the things he said about Trump. June 6: Patel appears on Joe Rogan's podcast and downplays the looming disclosures again. 'We're gonna give you everything we can,' Patel says, before adding that 'we're not gonna re-victimize women. We're not going to put that sh*t back out there. It's not happening, because then he wins. Not doing it. You want to hate me for it, fine.' Patel also appears to contradict Bondi's claim about 'tens of thousands of videos of Epstein with children or child porn,' telling Rogan the videos from Epstein's island are 'not of what you want.' July 6: Axios breaks the news that the DOJ has officially concluded that Epstein died by suicide and there was no 'client list,' despite Bondi's comments in February. July 7: The DOJ releases an unsigned memo laying out these conclusions. DOJ says it won't release any further documents because much of it is under court-ordered seal. 'Through this review, we found no basis to revisit the disclosure of those materials and will not permit the release of child pornography,' the memo says. The memo also undercuts Bondi's claims of 'tens of thousands of videos' of Epstein 'with children or child porn.' July 8: Trump for the first time lashes out at people still asking questions about Epstein, calling those questions a 'desecration.' He tells reporters: 'Are you still talking about Jeffrey Epstein? This guy's been talked about for years.' He cites recent deadly floods in Texas and adds: 'I mean, I can't believe you're asking a question on Epstein at a time like this.' The president will go on to make similar comments over the next two weeks, including baselessly suggesting various powerful Democrats are behind the Epstein files. July 15: Trump is asked about whether Bondi told him his name was in the files and denies it. 'No, no, she's given us just a very quick briefing and – in terms of the credibility of the different things that they've seen,' he says. July 23: We learn Trump is indeed in the files.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store