FWC chair: Miami Herald misrepresented 2022 boating tragedy investigation
This devastating accident resulted in the heartbreaking loss of a young life. Our deepest sympathies remain with the victims and their families.
Regrettably, I believe much of the Herald's reporting has been one-sided, misrepresenting the diligent and comprehensive efforts undertaken by FWC officers. The FWC is firmly committed to conducting thorough, impartial investigations of all boating accidents within its jurisdiction. This case was no exception.
The investigation was led by seasoned professionals who followed all protocols. Investigators collected physical evidence, analyzed GPS data, interviewed witnesses and consulted experts. These findings were reviewed in coordination with the Miami-Dade State Attorney's Office. Allegations that key evidence was ignored or mishandled are not supported by facts.
Contrary to the Herald's portrayal, the investigation was transparent and rooted in forensic analysis and eyewitness accounts. I feel that the Herald downplayed or buried critical context, favoring narratives that mislead the public and undermined the professionalism of our officers.
All individuals with potentially relevant information were ultimately spoken to. Many declined to speak with investigators the night of the accident, and others either did not come forward or offered information unrelated to the core findings.
The vessel's operator, George Pino, was interviewed on-site by a certified drug recognition expert who observed no signs of impairment. None of the officers on scene reported any indicators of intoxication; however, in the deposition of an FWC officer taken more than two years later, he said Pino had bloodshot eyes and smelled of alcohol. Let me note that the officer had failed to mention this to the onsite investigator or include it in his initial report.
Despite no signs of impairment, the lead investigator requested a voluntary blood draw, which Pino declined. As clarified in the U.S. Supreme Court case Missouri v. McNeely (2013), officers cannot compel blood or breath tests without probable cause. The Herald's misinterpretation of training materials to suggest otherwise is legally incorrect and purposefully misleading.
Even the Herald's own cited legal experts support FWC's approach. Tampa-area attorney Leslie Sammis stated that officers would have needed reasonable suspicion of impairment to request field sobriety exercises — and probable cause to obtain a warrant for a non-consensual blood draw. Miami attorney Michael Mirer echoed that sentiment.
FWC's final report concluded that the accident was caused by Pino's failure to maintain control and operate his boat safely. This determination was based on GPS data that contradicted his claims about evasive maneuvers.
The presence of alcohol containers, which were only discovered after the submerged vessel was recovered, does not alone constitute probable cause. Nor does Pino's admission to consuming two beers earlier in the day. The determination of impairment requires multiple indicators — none of which we feel were present.
I believe the Herald has also wrongly suggested that the absence of body camera footage from four officers indicates misconduct.
In reality, under FWC's prior policy, supporting officers categorized their videos as 'incidental,' which triggered automatic deletion after a set retention period. No officer deleted footage. While we acknowledge the policy was not aligned with our intent, we are actively revising it to ensure proper retention and supervisory review in the future.
The Herald further attempted to link this incident to a recent reconfirmation hearing where I was reappointed to the FWC Commission. Despite not a single Florida senator raising any concerns about the investigation, the Herald misleadingly implied a connection.
Any suggestion that I influenced the investigation-based on my professional relationship with Miami-Dade State Attorney Katherine Fernandez Rundle is baseless.
From the outset, the Herald's coverage has relied on speculation, mischaracterization and selective omission of facts. This undermines public trust and disrespects the seriousness of this tragedy.
FWC officers have remained focused on uncovering the truth and ensuring that justice is served for the victims and their families. I stand by the integrity of our investigation and welcome scrutiny rooted in facts — not sensationalism.
I'm committed to transparency and will continue to work with the affected families.
Justice belongs in a courtroom — not in headlines.
Rodney Barreto is the chair of the Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Miami Herald
4 minutes ago
- Miami Herald
Two Haiti police officers killed after weaponized ‘kamikaze' drone explodes
Two Haitian police officers were killed and six others injured after a weaponized drone launched by a gang-fighting task force exploded in the hills above Port-au-Prince, near where an Irish missionary and several others were abducted by armed gangs. The accident Tuesday occurred after residents in Kenscoff found a so-called kamikazi drone and 'in a gesture of good faith' carried it to police officers stationed at a nearby SWAT base, Prime Minister Alix Didier Fils-Aimé's office. The drone 'exploded at the site, claiming the lives of two police officers and seriously injuring two others,' the statement said. A kamikaze drone, also known as a suicide drone, is designed to hover over an area, crash into a target and detonate on impact. Several sources confirmed to the Miami Herald that six officers were hurt during the detonation. They were taken to a medical facility where the recently installed police chief, André Jonas Vladimir Paraison, stayed at their side during the night. The latest police deaths bring the total number of officers killed in Haiti's battles with gangs to 29 so far this year, according to statistics compiled by the National Human Rights Defense Network. Most of the deaths occurred in the fight to wrest control back from gangs. In Kenscoff, the Haiti National Police and the Kenya-led Multinational Security Support mission, which has lost two police officers during gang ambushes, have had eight of their armored vehicles taken or set ablaze since armed groups began attacking the mountaintop community in late January. In addition to forcing thousands of residents to flee their homes, gangs have set fire to homes and businesses, kidnapped, killed and raped people in the area. On Aug. 3 an attack against Sainte-Hélène Home, a local orphanage caring for disabled kids, led to the abduction of eight people, including a 3 year-old boy and longtime Irish missionary Gena Heraty, who remains captive. As word of the explosion circulated within the rank and file of Haiti's beleaguered national police force on Tuesday afternoon, witnesses reported non-stop shooting from inside the SWAT base next to the headquarters of the Haiti National Police. The seriousness of the incident and lack of clarity over what happened triggered demands for an 'urgent investigation' from local human rights advocates. Social media accounts, some of them appearing to be from police officers, have raised questions about what happened. While one account says the drone was brought to police by area residents, another claimed the drone was dropped on the police station. A source close to the prime minister's officer told the Herald the incident was 'a tragic accident.' The droe operators had lost contact with the device due to poor weather, he said. After residents found the drone they took to the police officers nearby, where the cops inspected it and took photos. About 10 minutes later the drone exploded, killing the two officers, the source added. A separate source told the Herald the drone blew up after officers attempted to remove its battery pack. The Haiti National Police, in a statement expressing condolences to the families of the victims, said it is investigating the incident but did not go into details of what happened. Earlier this year, Haiti's transition government began employing the services of Erik Prince, a former U.S. Navy seal who founded the controversial security firm Blackwater. Prince, a major donor to President Donald Trump, currently has a one-year, $50 million deal with the Haitian government through his new firm Vectus Global to deploy private military contractors to help Haiti in its fight against gangs. But the firm's use of weaponized drones has raised concerns about the escalating violence, potential civilian casualties and human rights abuses. Earlier in the day, gangs once more attacked the Saint-Hélène Home where Heraty, the missionary, serves as director. Gangs abducted two other people from the orphanage but later released them. Heraty, who has been working in Haiti since 1993, remains missing, along with two others. Sainte-Hélène Home is affiliated with Nuestros Pequeños Hermanos-NPH International, which was founded by a Catholic priest and has affiliates throughout Latin America and the Caribbean.
Miami Herald
21 hours ago
- Miami Herald
‘Psychological warfare': Internal data shows true nature of Alligator Alcatraz
A month into his detention at Alligator Alcatraz, Daniel Ortiz Piñeda faced a stark choice: continue his legal fight for asylum or give it up to hopefully put an end to his extended stay at the makeshift immigration detention camp in the Everglades. The Colombian national, with no criminal record, had the right to remain in the country while appealing the 2023 denial of his asylum request. But last week, the 33-year-old asked his attorney to drop his appeal, preferring repatriation to the possibility of indefinite detention. 'He feels like there's nothing here for him now,' Piñeda's mother said in an interview. Stories like Piñeda's have played out repeatedly at the Everglades detention camp. While it was promoted as a place where migrants with heinous criminal histories would be detained and quickly deported, records exclusively obtained by the Miami Herald and Tampa Bay Times show it was largely used during its first month in operation as a holding pen and transfer hub for immigrants who were still fighting their cases in immigration courts. Hundreds, the records note, did not have criminal convictions or pending charges. At the end of July, when the number of detainees at the site was around its peak, only one in five of the roughly 1,400 detainees at the site had been ordered removed from the country by a judge, a Herald/Times review of the records found. That means hundreds of men were being detained there without final adjudication orders, despite Gov. Ron DeSantis' claims to the contrary. The records also show that nearly two out of every five immigrants listed in early July as being detained at the South Florida facility or headed there were still recorded as detainees at the facility at the end of the month. During that stretch, immigration attorneys claimed their clients had little to no access to the courts and were largely forced to communicate about cases over recorded lines. Lawyers also alleged their clients were pressured to abandon their immigration cases — without legal consultation — and agree to be deported. It wasn't until Saturday that lawyers for the federal government said a Miami immigration court had been designated as the responsible venue for handling Alligator Alcatraz cases. The number of people at Alligator Alcatraz fluctuates daily and has dropped drastically since the beginning of the month, as a federal judge weighs whether to shut down the site. But for detainees held throughout July in chain-link cages and tents the uncertainty created mental pressure that their attorneys and families say was worse than the prospect of being deported, even to a country where they fear persecution. 'Putting people in tents in the middle of the Everglades is a great tool to make them give up their cases,' said Mark Prada, an immigration attorney. The Department of Homeland Security, which is in charge of immigrant detainees, and the Florida Division of Emergency Management, which oversees Alligator Alcatraz operations, did not respond to requests for comment. When the state seized an airstrip in the Big Cypress National Preserve and began constructing a camp to hold thousands of migrants, DeSantis said the site would serve as a 'one-stop' shop for the Trump administration's needs for detention and deportation. Detainees with final orders of removal would be held in tents and quickly deported from an on-site runway, he said. To expedite deportations, DeSantis said qualified National Guard members would work as immigration judges on the site — an idea that President Donald Trump gave a thumbs up to during a July 1 visit. But the plans have yet to be implemented and immigration attorneys have complained for weeks that their Alligator Alcatraz clients have had hearings for their cases routinely canceled in federal Florida immigration courts by judges who said they did not have jurisdiction over the detainees in the Everglades. For hundreds of detainees, that meant weeks of uncertainty living inside tents, where the lights were turned on throughout the day and the only connection to the outside world was often a recorded landline. Attorneys have complained about staff at the facility pressuring their clients to sign voluntary removal orders without consulting an attorney and, in one case, deceiving a detainee with an intellectual disability by telling him he would need to 'sign some paper in exchange for a blanket' — and then deporting him after he had signed it, court filings show. Mark Hamburger, an attorney who has had several clients at the detention camp, said the conditions created a kind of 'psychological warfare' for detainees. 'They're being put to the test,' he said. 'How long can you stand this? A lot of people are folding.' That group of original detainees included Piñeda, who was taken into custody after showing up for a scheduled immigration meeting in Miami Lakes on July 7, according to his family members. 'To have somebody detained like this, pending an appeal, when they have not committed any crimes is unheard of,' said his attorney, Osley Sallent. Piñeda told his family members that when he entered Alligator Alcatraz, the guards told him and other new arrivals, 'As soon as you come in here, you don't have any rights.' It would be days before he could shower, and he said that he hadn't received adequate medical care for an ongoing ear infection and stomach ailment. He was moved to the Glades County Detention Center west of Lake Okeechobee in early August shortly after dropping his asylum appeal. Like Piñeda, the vast majority of detainees in the facility at the end of July had no final order of removal from a judge, according to the new data. That means that the immigration cases for most men at the facility were still ongoing. While the data shows that more than 100 of those detainees had been issued expedited orders of removal – which allows the government to deport them without going through the immigration courts – immigration lawyers said that these can still be appealed in some circumstances, such as when an immigrant is seeking asylum. 'Finality is a big deal,' Prada said. 'If it is not final, there is still a process to be done.' The Herald compared the two datasets, one of roughly 750 detainees from early July and the other of roughly 1,400 people from the end of the month. Reporters also searched for all of the detainees in the first list on ICE's detainee locator system. More than 40% of the 750 detainees in the initial list were sent not out of the country but to other ICE facilities, the Herald found. Another 40% were still at the detention center. Alligator Alcatraz detainees often did not appear in ICE's locator system, the Herald found and the fate of the rest — around 150 detainees — is unclear. Some of them were likely still at Alligator Alcatraz but others may have been deported. The numbers in both data sets are snapshots in time, and fluctuate as detainees enter and leave the facility. On Tuesday, there were just shy of 400 detainees at the Everglades detention camp — far below the roughly 1,500 people the makeshift camp is able to hold. In late July, DeSantis said the federal government had deported about 100 people who were held at the detention camp and that 'hundreds' of others had been transferred to deportation hubs in other parts of the country. The state and federal governments have yet to say if any deportation flights have taken off directly from the site and to foreign soil. Attorneys have welcomed the transfers – which make it easier for them to access their clients and advocate on their behalf. At least two detainees were released on bond last week after they were moved elsewhere, according to their attorneys. One detainee trying to leave the country voluntarily had to be transferred to another facility to be deported. Fernando Eduardo Artese, 63, was one of the first detainees to arrive at Alligator Alcatraz. From the start, he wanted to leave the United States voluntarily, but the process to self-deport was not easy in the weeks he spent at the state-run site, his family said .It was only after he was transferred to the federal Krome immigration detention center in Miami that he was able to begin the process of voluntarily leaving the country. Once at Krome, Artese was deported in less than a week, his daughter, Carla Artese, told the Herald/Times. The Argentinian-Italian was sent to Italy. It's not clear whether the difference between Alligator Alcatraz's promoted and practical uses was intentional or accidental. The facility was built with near biblical speed, completed in only eight days, and from its earliest days, detainees complained of toilets that don't flush, bugs and leaky tents. Attorneys quickly flagged that they had no way to speak confidentially with their clients. A federal judge questioned the facility's operation at a hearing in July for a lawsuit related to detainees' legal access. 'A lot of it looked to me like … a new facility not having their act together or getting up and running in the right way,' U.S. District Judge Rodolfo A. Ruiz II said last month in a court hearing. But critics of the facility say that the harsh conditions endured by detainees — and the rhetoric politicians have used to describe the site — are not by accident. DeSantis says reporting about terrible conditions has been inaccurate, but he's in no rush to dispel the narrative. 'Maybe it will have the intent or the effect of deterring people from going there,' the governor said. John Sandweg, the former acting director of ICE during the Obama administration, said the construction and location of the facility makes little sense. It's not near an immigration court or ICE's existing transportation infrastructure. But with backlogs in immigration courts presenting major roadblocks to the Trump administration's stated goal of deporting one million immigrants per year, Sandweg said he believes the purpose of the facility is to encourage undocumented immigrants – whether in custody or not – to bypass the immigration courts and voluntarily leave the country to avoid the possibility of being sent there. 'I think that the real goal of Alligator Alcatraz is to instill fear,' he said. Miami Herald reporter Siena Duncan contributed reporting.
Yahoo
a day ago
- Yahoo
Hiker attacked by alligator in Collier County, third gator attack of 2025
An alligator attacked a woman in Collier County over the weekend, marking the third alligator attack the state has seen in 2025. On Sunday, August 17, the Florida Fish and Wildlife Conversation Commission responded to a call about a woman who was bitten on her arm and leg while hiking in Collier County. The victim was hiking at Bird Rookery Swamp Trail, a 12-mile hiking and biking trail in Naples. She was taken to a nearby hospital. Authorities did not provide any identification on the woman. The FWC trapped the "nuisance alligator," which will likely be euthanized. As part of its Statewide Nuisance Alligator Program, the FWC prioritized the safety concerns of the public and will address or remove alligator threats in developed areas. An alligator is deemed a nuisance if it is at least 4 feet long and believed to pose a threat to people, pets or property. More: Big Cypress' famous dark skies, animals affected by Alligator Alcatraz, critics say There are about 1.3 million alligators in Florida, so removing nuisance alligators does not have a significant impact on the state's alligator population, according to the FWC. This attack is the third in Florida this year. Florida saw its last alligator attack in May, which resulted in the death of a 61-year-old woman who was canoeing on Lake Kissimmee. Prior to that incident, an alligator attacked a woman at Tiger Lake Canal in Polk County. The victim was kayaking when the alligator bit her elbow. The location of this attack was just miles from the Lake Kissimmee attack. In September 2024, a Lee County woman was attacked by a 7-foot-3 alligator while walking her dog in North Fort Myers. The reptile bit her arm, hands and leg. The chance of a Florida resident being seriously injured in an unprovoked alligator attack is one in 3.1 million, according to the FWC. Since it started counting alligator attacks in 1948, the FWC has reported a total of 489 alligator attacks on humans as of May 2025. This article originally appeared on Naples Daily News: Collier County woman attacked by alligator, sustained major injuries
