ICJ opens hearings on Israeli obligations on Gaza humanitarian crisis
The hearings, which began on Monday in The Hague and will run throughout the week, follow a request last year from the United Nations General Assembly asking the court to assess Israel's responsibility to ensure the provision of essential supplies to Gaza.
Since the start of the war 18 months ago, Israel has blocked aid, leaving Palestinians facing severe shortages of food, water, fuel and medicine.
Over the next five days, 38 countries – including the United States, China, France, Russia and Saudi Arabia – will address the 15-judge panel to consider how Israel's actions comply with international law.
The League of Arab States, Organisation of Islamic Cooperation and African Union will also present their arguments about Israel's obligations to ensure aid reaches Gaza.
Top Palestinian official Ammar Hijazi told the judges that Israel was blocking aid to use as a 'weapon of war'.
No food or medical supplies have reached the 2.3 million residents of the Gaza Strip since March 2 when Israel imposed what has become its longest ever blockade of the territory. It was followed two weeks later by the collapse of a two-month ceasefire.
'These are the facts. Starvation is here. Humanitarian aid is being used as a weapon of war,' Hijazi said.
The ICJ has been tasked by the UN with providing an advisory opinion 'on a priority basis and with the utmost urgency'.
While no immediate ruling is expected, the court's advisory opinion will likely shape future international legal approaches.
However, it is nonbinding, meaning its impact depends on whether states choose to enforce or ignore it.
The ruling 'will likely be ignored by Israel, as it has done with other judgements from the ICJ, the International Criminal Court and other international legal bodies,' Al Jazeera's Rory Challands said, reporting from The Hague.
However, he added that 'the tide of pressure is mounting' on Israel as a growing list of international courts have ruled against its actions.
What the UN is saying, Challands noted, is that 'Israel basically has a twofold obligation here under international law. It has an obligation as an occupying power in the Palestinian territories … That includes children's education and welfare systems, medical facilities, including UN-established hospitals, and humanitarian relief operations. If it doesn't do those things, then it's in contravention of its obligations under international law.'
'It also has an obligation as a signatory to the UN Charter, because under that, the UN has immunities and exemptions that set it apart from other institutions and other multilateral organisations', Challands continued.
The ICJ will consider the positions of both state actors and international organisations in its deliberations.
However, it will not hear from Israeli representatives directly. Rather, Tel Aviv has submitted written advice and objections.
Israeli Foreign Minister Gideon Saar responded to the opening of the hearings by branding them 'part of a systematic persecution and delegitimisation of Israel' in comments to reporters in Jerusalem.
'It is not Israel that should be on trial. It is the UN and UNRWA,' he insisted, referring to the UN agency for Palestinian refugees, which Israel is preventing from delivering aid to Gaza.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Al Jazeera
2 hours ago
- Al Jazeera
N Korea says S Korea ‘cannot be a diplomatic partner' as US drills continue
North Korean leader Kim Jong Un's sister has again dismissed peace overtures from South Korean President Lee Jae-myung, declaring that Pyongyang will never see Seoul as a partner for diplomacy, according to state media. The report by KCNA on Wednesday came as South Korea and its ally, the United States, continued their joint military drills, which includes testing an upgraded response to North Korea's growing nuclear capabilities. Kim Yo Jong, who is among her brother's top foreign policy officials, denounced the exercises as a 'reckless' invasion rehearsal, according to KCNA, and said that Lee had a 'dual personality' by talking about wanting to pursue peace while continuing the war games. She made the comments during a meeting on Tuesday with senior Foreign Ministry officials about her brother's diplomatic strategies in the face of persistent threats from rivals and a rapidly shifting geopolitical landscape, KCNA reported. 'The Republic of Korea [ROK], which is not serious, weighty and honest, will not have even a subordinate work in the regional diplomatic arena centred on the DPRK [The Democratic Republic of Korea],' Kim said, using the official names for the two countries. 'The ROK cannot be a diplomatic partner of the DPRK,' she added. The statement followed the latest outreach by Lee, who said last week that Seoul would seek to restore a 2018 military agreement between the two countries aimed at reducing border tensions, while urging Pyongyang to reciprocate by rebuilding trust and resuming dialogue. Since taking office in June, Lee has moved to repair relations that worsened under his conservative predecessor's hardline policies, including removing front-line speakers that broadcast anti-North Korean propaganda and K-pop. In a nationally televised speech on Friday, Lee said his government respects North Korea's current system and that Seoul 'will not pursue any form of unification by absorption and has no intention of engaging in hostile acts'. But he also stressed that South Korea remains committed to an international push to denuclearise North Korea and urged Pyongyang to resume dialogue with Washington and Seoul. Kim Yo Jong, who previously dismissed Lee's overtures as a 'miscalculation', described the latest gestures as 'a fancy and a pipe dream'. 'We have witnessed and experienced the dirty political system of the ROK for decades… and now we are sick and tired of it,' she said, claiming that South Korea's 'ambition for confrontation' with North Korea has persisted both under the conservative and liberal governments. 'Lee Jae-myung is not that man to change this flow of history' she continued, adding that 'the South Korean 'government continues to speak rambling pretence about peace and improving relations in order to lay the blame on us for inter-Korean relations never returning again'. Kim Yo Jong's comments follow Kim Jong Un's statements, carried by KCNA on Tuesday, which called the US-South Korea military exercises an 'obvious expression of their will to provoke war'. He also promised a rapid expansion of his nuclear forces as he inspected his most advanced warship being fitted with nuclear-capable systems. The North Korean leader last year declared that North Korea was abandoning longstanding goals of a peaceful unification with South Korea and rewrote Pyongyang's constitution to mark Seoul as a permanent enemy. His government has repeatedly dismissed calls by Washington and Seoul to revive negotiations aimed at winding down his nuclear and missile programmes, which derailed in 2019, after a collapsed summit with US President Donald Trump during his first term. Kim has also made Moscow the priority of his foreign policy since Russia's full-scale invasion of Ukraine, sending troops and weapons to support President Vladimir Putin's war, while also using the conflict as a distraction to accelerate his military nuclear programme.
Qatar Tribune
5 hours ago
- Qatar Tribune
QRCS, talabat raise over QR 300,000 for Gaza
Tribune News Network Doha A joint campaign co-implemented by Qatar Red Crescent Society (QRCS) and talabat, the leading on-demand delivery platform in the MENA region, has successfully raised over QR 300,000 for Gaza relief efforts. The one-month campaign received a stronger-than-expected response from talabat customers, who chose to redeem and convert their reward points into donations on the talabat app. This contribution will go to QRCS, in support of its ongoing efforts to provide the blockade with every possible form of relief assistance, including water, food and medical care, amid such an unprecedented humanitarian calamity. In a statement, Faisal Mohamed Al-Emadi, Secretary-General of QRCS, expressed his sincerest gratitude to the benevolent people of Qatar, who made the campaign a remarkable success with their donations and compassion. 'It was another impressive episode of solidarity and support from the people of Qatar towards their Palestinian brothers and sisters,' said Al-Emadi. 'Even the smallest donation can make a real difference in the lives of the affected people of Gaza.' This is not the first time QRCS and talabat join hands for charity. In November 2024, a similar campaign raised over QR 1.1 million in donations, to support relief interventions for the war victims in both Gaza and Lebanon.
Qatar Tribune
5 hours ago
- Qatar Tribune
Israel attacks displacement shelters to force Palestinians to southern Gaza
Agencies Gaza Since announcing plans to invade northern Gaza and expel Palestinians again to the south, Israel has attacked displacement shelters in the Gaza City neighbourhood of Zeitoun, according to an investigation by Sanad, Al Jazeera's verification unit. Since August 13, Sanad has found that Israel stepped up the bombardment and shelling of Zeitoun, and often directly hit displacement shelters. The siege and ongoing violence have compelled thousands of Palestinians to close their tents in the camps and flee further south, according to satellite imagery obtained by Sanad. The indiscriminate bombardment of civilian homes and displacement shelters is part of a broad pattern of Israeli war tactics that make no distinction between civilians and fighters. Human rights groups, United Nations experts and numerous legal scholars believe Israel's nearly two-year war on Gaza amounts to genocide. Israel's Western allies – who have long defended it from criticism by claiming it has the 'right to defend itself' – are becoming increasingly alarmed at the humanitarian crisis unfolding in the enclave. Many are calling on Israel to end the war and warning that its plan to seize northern Gaza could further exacerbate the suffering of civilians. The mass displacement and bombardment of Zeitoun encapsulate the atrocities resulting from Israel's invasion. There are about 11 displacement shelters in Zeitoun, each sheltering 4,000 to 4,500 besieged and hungry Palestinians. Most live on just 3.2sq km (1.2sq miles), which makes up just 32 percent of the pre-war size of Zeitoun. At the start of the war, Israel dug trenches in and around the neighbourhood, claiming it was creating a 'buffer zone', and built the Netzarim Corridor, which has split Gaza into two zones. Israel's recent bombardment of the neighbourhood is terrifying civilians into fleeing south, leading to another cycle of forced displacement that may amount to ethnic cleansing due to Israel's attempt to destroy all livable facilities and structures. According to Sanad, there is clear evidence that Israel is pursuing that policy in and around Zeitoun. Between August 11 and 16, sources documented Israel's attack on al-Falah School in Zeitoun and a tent camp on al-Lababidi Street. Both the Majida al-Wasila school in the Nassr neighbourhood and tents in the Sheikh Ajilin neighbourhood were also hit. This pattern of direct attacks on tents and school shelters – the last refuge for hundreds of thousands of Palestinians – may amount to war crimes and crimes against humanity, since these structures are protected under international humanitarian law.
