Wikipedia's AI Experiment Fails After Editors' Backlash: "Why Did They..."
Wikipedia has decided to halt its new experiment of AI-generated article summaries after facing criticism from its community of editors, according to a report in TechCrunch. The decision comes over a month after Wikimedia, the nonprofit that runs the online encyclopedia, announced the move, stating it aimed to utilise generative AI in specific areas where it tends to excel.
AI-generated summaries appeared at the top of every Wikipedia article with a yellow "unverified" label. Users had to click to expand and read them. The editors, however, almost immediately criticised the new feature, stating it could damage Wikipedia's credibility.
Despite being heavily trained on copious amounts of data, AI models are prone to 'hallucinations'. The editors claimed that AI-generated summaries may contain mistakes, further damaging the brand. Previously, the likes of Apple and Bloomberg have run similar experiments but had to step back as mistakes piled up.
Reacting to the rollback, social media users said Wikipedia should not have implemented the feature, while others called it out for not utilising the donated money efficiently.
"Why did they think anyone would actually want or need an AI-generated summary?" said one user, while another added: "They keep asking for money to stay afloat, and this is how they've used that money? AI? Ugh."
A third commented: "The all-consuming rot is finally coming for one of the very last bastions of the old internet and all its promises. I knew we'd get here eventually."
Also Read | Black Hole With Powerful Jet Illuminated By Universe's 'Oldest Light' Spotted
What did Wikipedia say earlier?
Amid concerns that AI could replace the editors, moderators and volunteers, Wikimedia, on April 30, announced the AI integration, claiming it was meant to reduce the workload of its human workforce, who would now focus more on quality control.
"We will use AI to build features that remove technical barriers to allow the humans at the core of Wikipedia to spend their valuable time on what they want to accomplish, and not on how to technically achieve it. Our investments will be focused on specific areas where generative AI excels, all in the service of creating unique opportunities that will boost Wikipedia's volunteers," read the statement by Wikimedia.
It said AI will also aid editors by assisting in the onboarding process of new volunteers and automating other tedious tasks.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
2 days ago
- Time of India
Solar can drive jobs, equity, climate goals — but investment still uneven
New Delhi: The Sixth Meeting of the ISA Regional Committee for Europe and the Others Region was held in Brussels with participation from 20 countries and partners to review solar energy progress and advance global collaborations under the International Solar Alliance (ISA). The meeting was chaired by Germany, the regional Vice President, and convened to align strategic priorities and assess implementation status across member nations. ISA Director General Ashish Khanna said, 'Your presence here today reflects our shared commitment to advancing the global transition to solar energy. Our focus must now turn to ensuring these advancements translate into jobs, equity, and climate resilience.' He added that $2 trillion was invested in clean energy last fiscal, with solar photovoltaics leading, but only 15% of it reached low- and middle-income countries and less than 2% was directed to Africa. Highlighting energy access challenges, Khanna said 600 million people in Africa remain without electricity access. 'ISA is mobilising $200 million to leverage more than 30 times the private investment in Distributed Renewable Energy in Africa,' he added. Tobias Rinke, Deputy Head of Division, Federal Ministry for Economic Affairs and Energy, Germany, said the alliance's membership has grown to 123 countries with doubling of active engagements since 2022. He referenced COP28 commitments, where nearly 200 countries agreed to triple renewable capacity and transition from fossil fuels. 'Solar energy plays a central role in achieving these goals,' he said. In a session with ISA Director General, IEA's Laura Cozzi said, 'AI-related infrastructure could add electricity demand equivalent to a 'new Japan' by 2030.' She said AI can optimise grid operations and improve energy access. She also announced the launch of an Energy and AI Observatory by the IEA. In a separate session, CIFF CEO Kate Hampton said the key financing challenge is the shortage of catalytic equity rather than debt. She said philanthropy can fill this gap and support country platforms with technical assistance, policy engagement, and junior equity. 'A major constraint lies in the availability of skilled professionals capable of navigating delivery, policy, and finance,' she added. European Commissioner for Energy and Housing Dan Jørgensen, in his keynote address, said the cost of solar power has dropped 82% in the EU over the past decade. He said an additional 12% global decline in 2023 made solar the fastest-growing and most affordable clean energy source today. Upcoming discussions at the meeting include topics on Catalytic Finance in Africa, ISA's STAR-Cs initiative, AI in the energy sector, and a roundtable on energy storage and green hydrogen .
NDTV
2 days ago
- NDTV
Wikipedia's AI Experiment Fails After Editors' Backlash: "Why Did They..."
Wikipedia has decided to halt its new experiment of AI-generated article summaries after facing criticism from its community of editors, according to a report in TechCrunch. The decision comes over a month after Wikimedia, the nonprofit that runs the online encyclopedia, announced the move, stating it aimed to utilise generative AI in specific areas where it tends to excel. AI-generated summaries appeared at the top of every Wikipedia article with a yellow "unverified" label. Users had to click to expand and read them. The editors, however, almost immediately criticised the new feature, stating it could damage Wikipedia's credibility. Despite being heavily trained on copious amounts of data, AI models are prone to 'hallucinations'. The editors claimed that AI-generated summaries may contain mistakes, further damaging the brand. Previously, the likes of Apple and Bloomberg have run similar experiments but had to step back as mistakes piled up. Reacting to the rollback, social media users said Wikipedia should not have implemented the feature, while others called it out for not utilising the donated money efficiently. "Why did they think anyone would actually want or need an AI-generated summary?" said one user, while another added: "They keep asking for money to stay afloat, and this is how they've used that money? AI? Ugh." A third commented: "The all-consuming rot is finally coming for one of the very last bastions of the old internet and all its promises. I knew we'd get here eventually." Also Read | Black Hole With Powerful Jet Illuminated By Universe's 'Oldest Light' Spotted What did Wikipedia say earlier? Amid concerns that AI could replace the editors, moderators and volunteers, Wikimedia, on April 30, announced the AI integration, claiming it was meant to reduce the workload of its human workforce, who would now focus more on quality control. "We will use AI to build features that remove technical barriers to allow the humans at the core of Wikipedia to spend their valuable time on what they want to accomplish, and not on how to technically achieve it. Our investments will be focused on specific areas where generative AI excels, all in the service of creating unique opportunities that will boost Wikipedia's volunteers," read the statement by Wikimedia. It said AI will also aid editors by assisting in the onboarding process of new volunteers and automating other tedious tasks.
CBS News
2 days ago
- CBS News
Barbie-maker Mattel and OpenAI partner to develop AI-powered products
Barbie-maker Mattel is partnering with OpenAI to develop generative AI-powered toys and games, as the new technology disrupts a wide range of industries, Mattel announced Thursday. Mattel billed the alliance as a "strategic collaboration to support AI-powered products and experiences based on Mattels' brands." It added that the pair would likely announce their first product later this year, as the toymaker strives to get ahead of the AI curve. The collaboration will combine Mattel's most well-known brands — including Barbie, Hot Wheels, American Girl and more — with OpenAI's generative AI capabilities to develop new types of products and experiences, the companies said. "By using OpenAI's technology, Mattel will bring the magic of AI to age-appropriate play experiences with an emphasis on innovation, privacy and safety," Mattel said in the statement. It added that any AI woven into toys or games would be used in a safe and secure manner. On the corporate front, Mattel said it plans to leverage OpenAI's business tools including ChatGPT Enterprise — an enhanced version of ChatGPT designed for businesses — to power new product development. The collaboration is yet another signal that virtually no field is insulated from disruption by AI. Mattel touts OpenAI's tools as having the ability to improve both its business operations and enhance its product development processes. Initially promoted as a way to automate mundane tasks and free up humans to do more creative jobs, generative AI tools are becoming increasingly sophisticated and capable of doing more than just rote work. OpenAI Chief Operating Officer Brad Lightcap said the company is "pleased to work with Mattel as it moves to introduce thoughtful AI-powered experiences and products into its iconic brands, while also providing its employees the benefits of ChatGPT." "With OpenAI, Mattel has access to an advanced set of AI capabilities alongside new tools to enable productivity, creativity and companywide transformation at scale," he added in a statement. Amid flagging toy sales, Mattel has leveraged its intellectual property to produce other forms of entertainment, including movies, television and mobile games. The company's studio arm has a slate of more than a dozen films planned based on its famous toy brands, following the success of its 2023 "Barbie" movie. Mattel is also among a number of large U.S. retailers that have pulled their financial guidance amid ongoing economic uncertainty. Last month, Mattel paused its full-year guidance for 2025 citing tariff-driven uncertainty. The company also said it would raise prices on some goods to offset added costs form tariffs.
