'You don't even know basics': Pilots' Association objects to Air India crash probe report; says 'not happy with investigation, unfairly blames crew'
Speaking to news agency PTI, ALPA India president Sam Thomas said, "The timing of the release of document was middle of the night, it doesn't have any signatures, one sentence is misleading, there is no altitude of aircraft given, these are elementary mistakes terms like full authority digital engine control was written 'dual engine control', so you don't even know the basics."
"We are not happy with the investigation, it is going in direction of blaming the pilots, that is our objection," he added.
These remarks come after India's Aircraft Accident Investigation Bureau (AAIB) released its preliminary report into the June 12 plane Air India crash.
The report, released late Saturday night, revealed that both engine fuel switches had moved to the "CUTOFF" position seconds after takeoff, leading to a loss of thrust and the eventual crash that killed 260 people.
According to the AAIB's preliminary findings, 'the engine 1 and engine 2 fuel cutoff switches transitioned from RUN to CUTOFF position one after another with a time gap of one second,' just three seconds after the aircraft became airborne.
The report did not offer any blame or conclusions but noted a cockpit exchange in which one pilot asked the other why he had cut off the fuel, to which the other replied he had not.
No further details of the cockpit dialogue were disclosed.
ALPA India, which represents Indian pilots under the global ALPA-I network, strongly criticised the preliminary crash report, alleging procedural flaws and a rushed attempt to blame the pilots.
Earlier in a statement, ALPA had said that, "The tone and direction of the investigation suggest a bias toward pilot error. We categorically reject this presumption and insist on a fair, fact-based inquiry."
ALPA has formally requested the AAIB to be included in the investigation process as observers "to provide the requisite transparency."
It also criticised the bureau for releasing documents "without any responsible official signature or attribution."
Another Indian Commercial Pilots Association (ICPA) said it was deeply disturbed by speculative narratives and particularly the reckless and unfounded insinuation of pilot suicide.
"The Indian Commercial Pilots' Association (ICPA) expresses its unwavering support for the flight crew of Air India flight Al 171. In the aftermath of this incident, we are deeply disturbed by speculative narratives emerging in sections of the media and public discourse, particularly the reckless and unfounded insinuation of pilot suicide," the ICPA said in the statement.
"Let us be unequivocally clear: there is absolutely no basis for such a claim at this stage, and invoking such a serious allegation based on incomplete or preliminary information is not only irresponsible, it is deeply insensitive to the individuals and families involved," it added.
The association highlighted the rigorous psychological and professional screening processes that pilots undergo, alongside regular training to maintain the highest safety standards and mental fitness requirements.
They stated that suggesting pilot suicide without verified evidence undermines ethical reporting and professional dignity.
ICPA urged media outlets and commentators to exercise restraint and show respect for proper investigative procedures.
" The ICPA remains committed to defending the integrity and well-being of our members and calls on all to uphold the principles of fairness and factual reporting," the pilots' association added.
The Air India Flight 171 crash claimed the lives of 241 out of 242 people on board, which included 230 passengers and 12 crew members, only one passenger survived. On the ground, 19 people were killed and 67 others were injured.
Stay informed with the latest
business
news, updates on
bank holidays
and
public holidays
.
AI Masterclass for Students. Upskill Young Ones Today!– Join Now
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Indian Express
3 minutes ago
- Indian Express
Daily Briefing: Highlights of the UK-India trade deal
Good morning, Prime Minister Narendra Modi, who is visiting London, has signed the landmark free trade agreement with his British counterpart, Keir Starmer. The Comprehensive Economic and Trade Agreement (CETA) comes against growing volatility triggered by US President Donald Trump's tariffs. The CETA promises to enhance bilateral trade, provide Indians with greater access to British products, ranging from cosmetics to cars, and allow for tariff-free access to 99% of Indian imports to the UK. Here's a look at some significant gains for India and the UK: 👉 The UK will eliminate import duties of up to 20% on job-creating sectors such as textiles, footwear, gems and jewellery. 👉 Indian food sectors, including seafood, dairy, and meat, will enjoy zero duties. Tariffs on tea and coffee have also been scrapped. 👉 In a first, India has allowed UK firms to participate in government tenders, giving them Class Two status under 'Make In India' rules, which require 20-50% domestic value addition. 👉 India has also halved the import tariffs on Scotch whisky, from 150% to 75%. Premium brands like Chivas Regal, Ballantine's, Glenlivet, Glenfiddich, and Johnnie Walker are set to become more affordable. This gives Scotch distillers access to the world's largest whisky market by volume; however, the Indian alcoholic beverage industry has raised concerns over potential dumping. Also read: The history behind Scotch whisky 👉 You may see more British luxury vehicles on the roads as the CETA slashes duties on internal combustion engine cars to 30-50%. However, the benefit will be quota-based and apply to a limited number of vehicles. The duties will be further reduced gradually over the years. Zero-emission cars will also see reduced tariffs, depending on their cost, benefiting automakers like Jaguar Land Rover, a manufacturer of SUVs. 👉 Lastly, the UK and India have also agreed to ease the exchange of services. They will now require temporary employees to pay social security contributions only in their home countries, which would mean greater take-home salaries. Where the chips fall: The abrupt resignation of Jagdeep Dhankhar as Vice-President hints at growing differences between the ruling BJP and the man it once welcomed as 'kisan putra' after his election in 2022. His acceptance of the Opposition's impeachment motion against Justice Yashwant Varma, much to the government's chagrin, may not have been the sole reason for his exit, but was probably the last straw, writes contributing editor Neerja Chowdhury. The fallout from Dhankhar's exit is still unfolding, but Chowdhury opines that the next Vice President is unlikely to be someone outspoken. 🎧 For more on Dhankhar's resignation, tune in to the latest '3 Things' podcast episode, where we discuss the developments with our political reporter, Liz Mathew. Fall and fall: On Thursday, the Enforcement Directorate (ED) searched over 35 locations in Mumbai linked to industrialist Anil Ambani, as part of a money laundering probe into an alleged Rs 3,000 crore bank loan fraud. The latest setback to the Reliance Anil Dhirubhai Ambani Group comes at a time when it was looking to recover from a years-long turbulent journey marked by debt defaults, financial losses, and insolvency proceedings in the wake of the Ambani brothers' split. Data loss: The April security breach at the Indian Council of Agricultural Research (ICAR), the country's apex organisation in the sector, resulted in the loss of 'crucial data' related to recruitment and research projects. Here's what an ICAR committee report states. Rules of the game: The National Sports Governance Bill, introduced by Sports Minister Mansukh Mandaviya in the Lok Sabha on Wednesday, proposes two significant changes to how sports are governed in the country. It will establish a National Sports Board with broad powers to oversee the functioning of federations, as well as a National Sports Tribunal to resolve disputes. My colleague, Mihir Vasavda, spoke with eminent sports lawyer Nandan Kamath about the key aspects of the Bill and why it was necessary. Smokescreen? The Maharashtra House cleared a Special Public Security Bill earlier this month to curb 'Left Wing Extremism (LWE)'. Columnist Suhas Palshikar points out the gaps in the legislature's language, which could leave social activists vulnerable and criminalise dissent. Read. ♟️ The Women's Chess World Cup has reached an interesting stage, with the final battle set between two Indian candidates. The battle is also intriguing because on one side is a young, ambitious 19-year-old who just defeated a former world champion, and on the other is the first Indian woman to become a grandmaster. At 38, Koneru Humpy is twice the age of Divya Deshmukh, who just completed the first of three norms required to become a grandmaster — and India's fourth woman grandmaster. That's all for today, folks! Happy weekend-ing! Sonal Gupta
Mint
3 minutes ago
- Mint
When will India-UK FTA be implemented? Piyush Goyal shares crucial update
India and the United Kingdom signed a Free Trade Agreement (FTA) on Thursday. When will it come into force? Union Minister of Commerce Piyush Goyal said it may take a few months. Goyal told news agency ANI that the Union Cabinet's approval in India had already happened the day before. "In the UK, it goes through the Parliament. So, I think it will take a few months," he said. The minister added, "But with this certainty, now the industries and businesses can begin their planning and ready their supply chains, work on approvals and ordering..." "Due to bipartisan support between both sides, I think it will be approved soon and implemented too," he said. India and the UK signed the Comprehensive Economic and Trade Agreement (CETA) on Thursday, taking a major step toward building a stronger economic partnership. The agreement was signed by Commerce and Industry Minister Piyush Goyal and Secretary of State for Business and Trade Jonathan Reynolds in the presence of the two Prime Ministers. CETA secures unprecedented duty-free access for 99 per cent of India's exports to the UK, covering nearly the entire trade basket. This is expected to open new opportunities for labour-intensive industries such as textiles, marine products, leather, footwear, sports goods, toys, and gems and jewellery, alongside fast-growing sectors like engineering goods, auto components, and organic chemicals. The services sector will also see wide-ranging benefits. The agreement provides greater market access in IT and IT-enabled services, financial and legal services, professional and educational services, and digital trade. Indian professionals, including those deployed by companies to work in the UK across all service sectors and professionals deployed on contracts such as architects, engineers, chefs, yoga instructors, and musicians, will benefit from simplified visa procedures and liberalised entry categories, making it easier for talent to work in the UK. India has also secured an agreement on the Double Contribution Convention. This will exempt Indian professionals and their employers from social security payments in the UK for up to three years, improving the cost competitiveness of Indian talent. The agreement has been designed to make trade more inclusive. Women and youth entrepreneurs, farmers, fishermen, startups, and MSMEs will gain new access to global value chains, supported by provisions that encourage innovation, promote sustainable practices, and reduce non-tariff barriers The bilateral trade between the two countries stands at nearly USD 56 billion, with a joint goal to double this figure by 2030.
India Today
3 minutes ago
- India Today
Narendra Modi breaks Indira Gandhi's record, becomes 2nd longest serving PM
Prime Minister Narendra Modi has crossed yet other political milestone, overtaking Indira Gandhi's record to become India's second longest serving Prime Minister in a single uninterrupted term. On July 25, 2025, PM Modi completed 4,078 days in office, pushing past Indira Gandhi's 4,077-day consecutive tenure between January 1966 and March achievement marks a historic chapter in PM Modi's political journey. Beginning as Gujarat's Chief Minister in 2001, PM Modi has now headed elected governments — both at the state or national level — for nearly 24 years, a feat unmatched by any other Indian Prime Modi, currently on his United Kingdom and Maldives visit, also holds the unique distinction of being the first and only Prime Minister born after India gained independence in 1947 and remains the longest serving Prime Minister from a non-Hindi speaking state. He is India's longest serving non-Congress Prime Minister and the first non-Congress leader to complete at least two full terms in office. He is also the only non-Congress Prime Minister to have secured a clear majority on his own in a Lok Sabha election and the first sitting Prime Minister since Indira Gandhi to be re-elected with a political track record includes leading his party to three consecutive national election victories — a feat previously achieved only by Jawaharlal Nehru. Counting his tenure as Chief Minister, PM Modi has won six consecutive elections as the face of his party: three in Gujarat and three at the national level.- Ends
