Was Robinson's criticism of Amorim fair?
We asked for your views on Paul Robinson's criticism of Ruben Amorim's post-match speech against Aston Villa.
Here are some of your comments:
Dave: Robinson clearly doesn't understand the point here. Amorim was brought in halfway through the season when he wanted to start at the end of the season, and is dealing with a team devoid of talent, some players with attitude problems and three attackers out on loan. Why would you drop all your principles and your system as soon as you come in just because it would paper over the cracks?
Scotty: Who cares what Paul Robinson thinks? Amorim will come good next year. This team needs to be stripped and rebuilt and not only has Ruben spoke the truth throughout his time at United, so far he's not been afraid to call out players and make it clear he won't change his style.
Colin: Robinson is right. You play to the strengths of the squad until you can get the pieces in place to play the formation and style you prefer.
David: It feels like Amorim can't win with the pundits. Robinson is criticising him, but what is he expected to say? He apologised, admitted the season was a disaster and said better times are coming. Does Robinson expect him to stand in front of the fans and say how great everything has been? I'm sure he'd be criticised if he did that, too.
Martyn: Completely agree. Amorim did very well in Portugal but his huge shortfalls have been found out in the Premier League. One-dimensional tactics, unable to find ways to change and influence a match with substitutions, similar players brought on with same formation and tactics and he does not change things that aren't going well.
Joe: Not sure what ex-goalkeeper Paul Robinson's management credentials are but Manchester United have been broken for over a decade. I, for one, buy into Amorim's approach and not falling into the quick-fix solution like every predecessor post Fergie. Fixing culture and bad leadership takes time.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
19 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Delap picks Chelsea - what next for Man Utd?
As ever with these situations, Manchester United can draw a positive out of a negative. They felt earlier last week it was coming towards the end game in their pursuit of Delap, and it was between them and Chelsea. Now they know they have lost out. Advertisement The positive is, with the decision made, they can move on. That is in stark contrast to 2022, when then manager Erik ten Hag delayed for months in a fruitless attempt to sign Frenkie de Jong and United ended up panicking at the end of the transfer window and spent £150m on Casemiro and Antony. But that does not answer the pertinent question: who now? Delap fitted their template of an improving, hungry young player, with scope to reach a high standard - at a set fee. Rasmus Hojlund - who is four days younger than Delap - fitted the same criteria, apart from the last one. And it has not worked out. Advertisement Nothing I have seen on their post-season trip to Asia makes me feel United have the answer to their goalscoring issues within the club. In fact, it is quite the opposite. The 'safe' but expensive options are Brentford's Bryan Mbeumo and Crystal Palace's Jean-Philippe Mateta. But Mateta is 27 and Mbeumo will be at the Africa Cup of Nations for a month with Cameroon. After that, it is a risk. Former United striker Danny Welbeck scored 10 goals in the Premier League at the age of 34. Is there any merit in bringing him back and taking some of the pressure off Hojlund - or has Ruben Amorim concluded the 22-year-old Denmark international will never be good enough? If so, it is back to Europe to sign another promising forward with no guarantee it will work.
Yahoo
22 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Ange Postecoglou proud of bringing ‘glory' back to Tottenham
Ange Postecoglou says his overriding emotion is pride despite being sacked as Tottenham boss. Postecoglou masterminded the club's first trophy in 17 years when he guided Spurs to Europa League glory with a 1-0 win over Manchester United on May 21. Advertisement The long-awaited silverware came amid heightened speculation over his future, following a 17th-placed Premier League finish which represents Tottenham's worst top-flight position since they were relegated in 1977. The outpouring of affection that followed from fans flipped the narrative around Postecoglou's future, with the Australian serenaded on multiple occasions at a subsequent trophy parade in front of an estimated 220,000 supporters. Further chants in support of Postecoglou came in a final-day 4-1 loss to Brighton before several Spurs players backed him to stay, but Daniel Levy has dismissed the head coach who earned him much-craved silverware. Advertisement Postecoglou, via a statement from his agency CAA Base, said: 'When I reflect on my time as manager of Tottenham Hotspur my overriding emotion is one of pride. 'The opportunity to lead one of England's historic football clubs and bring back the glory it deserves will live with me for a lifetime. 'Sharing that experience with all those who truly love this club and seeing the impact it had on them is something I will never forget. 'That night in Bilbao was the culmination of two years of hard work, dedication and unwavering belief in a dream. There were many challenges to overcome and plenty of noise that comes with trying to accomplish what many said was not possible. 'We have also laid foundations that mean this club should not have to wait 17 more years for their next success. I have enormous faith in this group of players and know there is much more potential and growth in them. Advertisement 'I sincerely want to thank those who are the lifeblood of the club, the supporters. I know there were some difficult times but I always felt that they wanted me to succeed and that gave me all the motivation I needed to push on. 'It's important to acknowledge the hard working people at Spurs who gave me encouragement on a daily basis. 'And finally, I want to thank those who were with me every day for the last two years. A fantastic group of young men who are now legends of this football club and the brilliant coaches who never once doubted we could do something special. 'We are forever connected. Audere est Facere. Ange.'
Yahoo
26 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Chiesa ‘shocked' by Juventus cull and stark Thiago Motta warning
Federico Chiesa reveals what Thiago Motta told him before his move to Liverpool and why he was 'shocked' by some of the decisions made at Juventus this season. The winger sat down with the Corriere dello Sport for a lengthy interview and you can read the rest of his comments here. Advertisement He made the transfer to Liverpool late last summer for a minimal fee of €12m plus bonuses, as Juve did not want to risk losing him as a free agent with the contract running down. Although Chiesa was bitterly criticised by fans for that departure, he insists it was not what he wanted at all. Chiesa felt pushed out of Juventus Italy forward Federico Chiesa gestures during the UEFA Euro 2024 Group B football match between Italy and Albania at the BVB Stadion in Dortmund on June 15, 2024. (Photo by FRANCK FIFE / AFP) (Photo by FRANCK FIFE/AFP via Getty Images) 'Thiago Motta was clear with me: I don't need you, find another club. I told him that I was ready to fight for my place, to prove I could still be of use to Juventus, but there was nothing to be done. It's his choice,' explained the Italy international in the Corriere dello Sport. Advertisement His was only one of many changes to the squad over the last 12 months, which saw some legends of the locker room shoved aside. 'Everyone knew Szczesny and Rabiot were not part of their plans, but seeing Fagioli and Danilo pushed out shocked me. Dani was such a strong reference point in the dressing room, it was a choice I simply did not understand, nor agree with.' Juventus forward Federico Chiesa reacts during the Italian Serie A football match between Genoa and Juventus at the Luigi Ferraris stadium, on December 15, 2023. (Photo by Marco BERTORELLO / AFP) (Photo by MARCO BERTORELLO/AFP via Getty Images) The transformation was off the field too and isn't finished yet, because Thiago Motta was sacked on March 23, failing to even see out a complete season in Turin. Both Chiesa and Danilo made their feelings clear on the matter. Director of sport Cristiano Giuntoli has also now been axed, just two years after he was poached from Napoli. MILAN, ITALY – OCTOBER 27: Thiago Motta, Head Coach of Juventus, interacts with his players Danilo and Nicolo Fagioli during the Serie A match between FC Internazionale and Juventus at Stadio Giuseppe Meazza on October 27, 2024 in Milan, Italy. (Photo by) Chiesa won the Premier League with Liverpool and reached the Champions League quarter-finals, where they were eliminated by eventual winners Paris Saint-Germain. Advertisement 'PSG really dominated us in the first leg, even if we won the match, but things went differently in the second leg and they won. It's a very strong team, with such intensity. In the Final, once they were 2-0 up after 20 minutes, it was over. You could see Inter were psychologically crushed.' Inter were eventually defeated 5-0 on the night in Munich.
