Rape accused bishop Zondo's request for judge to recuse himself denied
'The application for my recusal as the presiding judge in the trial of the applicant is hereby refused,' Mosopa said.
The judge said he could not recuse himself based on unsubstantial grounds and emphasised that he was not biased and that he did not fail in upholding his oath.
'I do not have an interest in the outcome of this matter,' he said.
The application comes after Zondo's several applications, including an application for a discharge of some counts in terms of section 174 of the Criminal Procedure Act.
In the discharge application, Zondo's advocate Piet Pistorius argued that the evidence against him was plotted. Mosopa denied this application, saying Zondo had a case to answer.
Zondo faces 10 charges in which he is accused of raping seven women — mostly members of his church.
According to testimonies heard in court, Zondo's alleged modus operandi was to lure women into his office to pray for them, only to sexually assault or rape them.
The court heard witnesses who gave their accounts in open court and in camera of how they were allegedly raped in Zondo's office.
In another instance, Zondo allegedly raped a former member of his church and her child.
One witness recounted how Zondo raped her and later told her: 'Thanks for trusting me with your body.'
A sister of one of the alleged victims testified on Tuesday that the pastor put his genitals in the victim's mouth.
Pretorius asked that the matter be stood down for him to reflect and consider the judgment, if necessary, and take instructions from his client.
The matter has been postponed to a provisional date on May 22 for Pretorius to take instructions on the judgment.
TimesLIVE
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
TimesLIVE
5 hours ago
- TimesLIVE
Food Influencers hit by car mid-vlog while inside a restaurant
YouTube food influencers NinaUnrated and Patrick Blackwood captured the moment a car crashed into them inside a restaurant. It happened while the pair were filming a vlog at the restaurant in Houston in the US. They were taken to the hospital for minor injuries and reports said the incident was a "freak accident". TimesLIVE
Daily Maverick
2 days ago
- Daily Maverick
After the Bell: New reform tracker helps answer the question, ‘Will SA be okay?'
Finally, we are getting a live report card to help us answer this question. Last week, I was asked to be MC at the two launches of the Business Leadership SA Reform Tracker. It has a rather grand title. But, unlike so many other names in the economic and political space, it does what it says on the tin. It is tracking our reforms. Not quite minute by minute, but not far off. As someone who identifies as a 'journalist' and watches everything that happens as much as I can, I'm often asked certain questions by people I bump into, or audiences I speak in front of. The questions are wide-ranging, from 'who should I vote for' to 'should I emigrate', to 'will our economy start to grow now that…' I could go on. But in reality, they're the same question. Everyone who asks me one of those questions is asking something much more fundamental. They're asking, really: 'Will South Africa be okay?' It was a question summed up incredibly well by my old journalistic colleague and friend, Jan-Jan Joubert. He wrote a very well-researched answer and published it as a book. There is something almost peculiar to the South African middle class about this question. I don't think people in New Zealand or, dare I say it this particular Monday, Australia ask themselves this. Or people in the UK or Spain — despite the fact that in both those countries there are serious economic and political problems. But, considering the era of State Capture we have come from, I think it's fully understandable. I mean, look around. In Johannesburg, the mayor blames the DA for the state of the city while he himself has not appointed a finance head, or someone to actually manage the roads. That pothole that you see twice a day? There is actually no one in charge of fixing that right now. Our economy is still growing incredibly slowly, and it seems that people are putting more energy into arguing about the definition of employment than actually making changes that will result in more jobs. Just this weekend we saw a liar, someone who was central to the Guptas, who has been able to use the Hawks to have his ex-wife literally locked up in jail, still mouthing off about the state of the ANC? Malusi Gigaba should be in court. Not being given interview after interview as the chairperson of a portfolio committee in Parliament. But as we all know, there are virtually no Zondo prosecutions. And institutions such as Transnet are still battling to recover from State Capture. Progress However, it's important to note that there is progress. Finally, we are getting a live report card to help us answer the question: 'Will South Africa be okay?' Last week, I was asked to be MC at the two launches of the Business Leadership South Africa Reform Tracker. It has a rather grand title. But, unlike so many other names in the economic and political space, it does what it says on the tin. It is tracking our reforms. Not quite minute by minute, but not far off. Now, when I was at school, my reports were written in quite dry, dull text. They were very different from my tests, in which red was a prominent feature. Here, you get red, yellow and green. So at a glance, you can see how we are doing. But you can also click on each little tile and read what has been written about that sector. It might be that there is progress but still work to do; the story might be a lot more complicated than a single colour can indicate. And, wonderfully, there is also a way for you, perhaps as someone working in one of these sectors, to send some feedback. You might know that something has changed, or that in fact there has been more progress than the tracker is showing. Now, as a journalist, it's tempting to look for the red and start to get a little stroppy with a few politicians. Journalistic instincts But Dr Stuart Theobald, the founder and chairperson at Krutham who put the whole thing together, tells me that we should just wait a little before people like me go back to our journalistic instincts. He acknowledges that, yes, some reforms have stopped because of political problems, or opposition. And some have just failed. But some have been stopped deliberately, because the reform no longer makes sense. In other words, yes it's stopped — but for a good reason. So, if you are interested, it does make sense to actually go a little deeper into each sector, just to see how things really are. I know that one of the reasons you really read this is because you are searching for an answer to that question: 'Will South Africa be okay?' I mean, there is a lot to be worried about. Just as there is in the US, or China, or many, many other places right now. It might be worth just checking in with this tracker from time to time. Perhaps put it on your browser dashboard or something.
The Citizen
2 days ago
- The Citizen
Emotional Mapisa-Nqakula might apply to have charges withdrawn as corruption case postponed
The former speaker had her bail conditions extended. Former National Assembly speaker Nosiviwe Mapisa-Nqakula's corruption case has been postponed, while her defence team has indicated it may seek to have the charges dropped. Mapisa-Nqakula appeared in the Gauteng High Court in Pretoria on Monday. This followed a partial victory in April when she succeeded in compelling the state to disclose parts of the case docket. Mapisa-Nqakula corruption case: Defence requests more time During Monday's proceedings, her new lawyer, Advocate Cronje Kriel, informed Judge Mokhine 'Papi' Mosopa that he had not had sufficient time to study the docket, which consists of 26 arch lever files, as he only received it last week. 'At this stage, we are working on a docket that we have not finalised and we haven't perused it,' he said. ALSO READ: Mapisa-Nqakula's legal team accuses state of 'hiding something' in corruption case Kriel also revealed that the defence intends to subpoena bank statements linked to the money laundering and corruption charges against his client. He estimated the process would take six weeks. Mosopa, however, expressed concern about further delays in a case that has already faced setbacks. 'Six weeks is a very long time,' he remarked. Possible representations to NDPP State prosecutor Paul Louw told the court that the defence plans to make representations to the National Director of Public Prosecutions (NDPP), Shamila Batohi, to determine whether there is a case to answer. A representation is a formal request made to the National Prosecuting Authority (NPA) by an accused person to challenge the decision to prosecute. If successful, it can lead to the withdrawal of charges. Louw asked for the case to be provisionally postponed until 21 November. 'This is for the defence to take instructions and possibly to make representations and for a result to those representations,' he said. READ MORE: Mapisa-Nqakula no longer holds diplomatic status, court hears as she seeks relaxation of bail conditions The defence confirmed that the matter would again face another postponement when it returns on that date. Mosopa noted that the state was not opposed to the subpoena of bank records or the filing of representations. Therefore, he granted the postponement, while addressing Mapisa-Nqakula directly. 'Please take this time to consult with your counsel so that on the 21 of November we have a clear direction,' the judge told Mapisa-Nqakula. The former speaker, who appeared emotional in court, had her bail conditions extended. During proceedings, she appeared to be wiping tears from her eyes. Mapisa-Nqakula bribes Mapisa-Nqakula faces 12 corruption charges along with a single count of money laundering. The charges relate to allegations that, while serving as defence minister from June 2012 to August 2021, she solicited and received R2 million in bribes from defence contractor Nombasa Ntsondwa-Ndhlovu. She allegedly received the bribes between December 2016 and July 2019. Mapisa-Nqakula unsuccessfully attempted to block her arrest, with the Gauteng High Court in Pretoria dismissing her interdict application in April 2024. She then decided to hand herself to the police. Her request for assistance with her legal bill for the corruption case was rejected by the Department of Defence. Mapisa-Nqakula resigned from Parliament as the speaker shortly after her home was raided by law enforcement. NOW READ: Mapisa-Nqakula being 'punished' for Phala Phala probe
