RFK Jr.'s vaccine advisors recommend RSV antibodies for infants
Why it matters: The 5-2 vote marked the first decision from HHS Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr.'s handpicked committee, which advises the CDC on immunization policy.
But the discussion reflected skepticism from some committee members about vaccine safety and administering shots to infants.
State of play: The FDA approved the Merck antibody shot for infants earlier this month. The recommendation from the Advisory Committee on Immunization Practices still has to be endorsed by the CDC, which currently lacks a full-time political leader.
Zoom in: Panel member Retsef Levi, a professor of operations management at MIT, voted against the recommendation. He questioned the safety of the antibodies for healthy infants, and said he would not feel comfortable giving them to his own children if they didn't have existing health issues.
"My objection is based on the fact that I don't feel this is ready to administer to all healthy babies," Levi said.
Vicki Pebsworth, a nurse and public health Ph.D. who's served on the board of an anti-vaccine group, also voted no.
Cody Meissner, a pediatrician who's served as a consultant to the committee on RSV vaccines prior to his appointment as a voting ACIP member, pushed back against the concerns.
"If I were your pediatrician, I would strongly recommend that your wife either receive the RSV vaccine or a monoclonal antibody at birth," Meissner said.
"These are truly remarkable products. They are safe and they're effective, and I don't think there's any further data that needs to be presented," he added.
ACIP also voted in favor of recommending that the RSV vaccine be included in the federal Vaccines for Children program, which provides no-cost shots to kids whose families would otherwise not be able to afford them.
"This is extremely important that VFC cover this product," Meissner said. "It is very important to ensure equity in our country ... It would not be right, because these are expensive products, that only families that are well insured have access to these products."
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CNBC
2 hours ago
- CNBC
FDA may pull authorization of Pfizer's Covid vaccine for children under 5, company says
Key Points The Food and Drug Administration is considering revoking its authorization of Pfizer's Covid-19 vaccine for healthy children under the age of 5, the drugmaker confirmed to CNBC. The move could leave many kids with no available shots against the virus, though Moderna's shot will be an option for those at increased risk of severe illness due to at least one underlying condition. It would add to a string of recent efforts by U.S. health agencies to change and undermine immunization policy since Health and Human Services Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr., a prominent vaccine skeptic, took the helm. In this article PFE Follow your favorite stocksCREATE FREE ACCOUNT A nurse prepares doses of the Pfizer vaccine during a COVID-19 vaccination event at Josephine's Southern Cooking in Chatham, Illinois, Dec. 30, 2021. Brian Cassella | Tribune News Service | Getty Images The Food and Drug Administration is considering revoking its authorization of Pfizer 's Covid-19 vaccine for healthy children under the age of 5, the drugmaker confirmed to CNBC on Tuesday. The move could leave many kids with no available shot against the virus, as jabs from Moderna and Novavax are cleared for more limited populations. While Covid typically causes mild symptoms in most children, others, such as infants under 1 or those with certain health conditions, can be at a higher risk of severe illness and hospitalization. If the FDA pulls the authorization, it would add to a string of recent efforts by U.S. health agencies to change and undermine immunization policy since Health and Human Services Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr., a prominent vaccine skeptic, took the helm. HHS did not immediately respond to a request for comment. The FDA told Pfizer it might not renew its longstanding emergency use authorization for children ages 6 months to 4 years, the company said in a statement. Pfizer said it has requested the authorization to remain in place for the upcoming fall and winter season and is "currently in discussions with the agency on potential paths forward." The company said that the FDA's "deliberations" are not related to the safety and efficacy of the shot, "which continues to demonstrate a favorable profile." The Guardian first reported on the FDA's potential move. Moderna is working with the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention to boost supplies of its own Covid shot for children, the Guardian reported Saturday. In July, the FDA granted full approval to Moderna's Covid vaccine for children — but only for those with one more more health conditions that may put them at increased risk of severe illness if they become infected. The shots from both Moderna and Pfizer use messenger RNA technology. Kennedy has targeted those vaccines in the past, filing a petition in May 2021 demanding that the agency revoke authorization of the jabs. Meanwhile, Novavax 's protein-based shot has never been available for children under 12. In May, Kennedy announced that the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention has removed its recommendation of Covid vaccines for healthy children and pregnant women. But in updated guidance days later, the CDC said the shots "may" be given to those kids if a doctor agreed that it was necessary. Covid vaccines during pregnancy are now listed as "No Guidance/Not Applicable," where they were previously recommended for all pregnant adults.
The Hill
2 hours ago
- The Hill
Vaccine misinformation blamed for fatal CDC shooting
Georgia law enforcement officials confirmed during a Tuesday press conference that 500 shots were fired and about 200 rounds struck six different CDC buildings. Though no employees were hurt, DeKalb County police officer David Rose was fatally shot. The alleged shooter, Patrick White, died of a self-inflicted gunshot wound. Authorities said they found documentation in his house expressing his discontent with the COVID-19 vaccinations. Chris Hosey, director of the Georgia Bureau of Investigation, said the content of the documents was more about making the public aware of his distrust of the vaccine, though no direct threats were made. The American Federation of Government Employees (AFGE) union called out vaccine misinformation for putting agency staffers at risk. In a statement following the shooting, AFGE Local 2884 demanded a 'clear and unequivocal stance in condemning vaccine disinformation by CDC and HHS leadership.' 'Their leadership is critical in reinforcing public trust and ensuring that accurate, science-based information prevails. This condemnation is necessary to help prevent violence against scientists that may be incited by such disinformation,' the organization said. Former U.S. Surgeon General Jerome Adams, who served during President Trump's first term, echoed these sentiments. In an op-ed for Stat, Adams said the shooting was a reflection of threats to public health workers brought on by a climate of 'misinformation, politicization, and inflammatory rhetoric.' Health Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr., who Adams criticized for being slow to respond to the shooting, was not named by the AFGE, but has long spread vaccine misinformation. During an interview with Scripps News this week, he defended his decision to end funding for mRNA shots and reiterated his concerns about coronavirus vaccine injuries. When asked directly about a plan to quell misinformation and prevent something like the CDC shooting from happening again, Kennedy deflected any direct link. 'We don't know enough about what the motive was of this individual, but people can ask questions without being penalized,' Kennedy said, before criticizing the federal government's messaging about the coronavirus vaccine. Kennedy previously criticized CDC during his unsuccessful presidential campaign, calling it a 'cesspool of corruption' in a post on X, saying he would 'force the public health agencies to come clean about Covid vaccines.' During his Scripps interview, Kennedy sounded a different tone. 'They work in silence, saving us all and protecting our health. They should not be the targets of this kind of violence from anybody,' Kennedy said.
USA Today
3 hours ago
- USA Today
Family sues for wrongful death in deadly listeria outbreak
A California family is suing for wrongful death in the wake of a listeria outbreak caused by nutrition shakes that led to the deaths of 14 people this year, including their relative. In February, the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) announced an investigation into an outbreak linked to Lyons ReadyCare and Sysco Imperial brand frozen supplemental shakes. At the time, Lyon Magnus LLC, the parent company, recalled 17 affected products. The contaminated shakes, distributed to long-term care facilities and hospitals, were produced by a Prairie Farms Dairy Inc. facility in Fort Wayne, Indiana. The FDA and Centers for Disease Control (CDC) declared the outbreak over on May 16. The agency reported 42 cases of listeriosis, or listeria poisoning, across 21 states, resulting in 41 hospitalizations and 14 deaths. The illnesses and deaths, which overwhelmingly (90%) occurred in people in care facilities or those who had been hospitalized before they became infected, were confirmed through whole genome sequencing as being caused by the outbreak strain associated with the shakes. Wrongful death suit alleges man died of listerosis complications The CDC began monitoring the outbreak of the disease as early as 2018, food safety lawyer Bill Marler told USA TODAY. At the beginning, epidemiologists were unable to identify the source of the illnesses. Now, with the outbreak technically over, some families are just beginning to find out their loved ones were victims, Marler said. Marler of the Marler Clark law firm said he's filed the first lawsuit related to the outbreak on Thursday, Aug. 7. It says the outbreak spanned multiple years and was likely the result of conditions within one of the manufacturing and packaging facilities. Marler said that the family who sued was not informed until July that their relative's death was caused by the outbreak. The wife and children of John Wills Sr. of Richmond, California, sued Lyon, the distributor of the shakes, and Prairie Farms Dairy Inc., the manufacturer. Their suit said Wills was recovering from a slip-and-fall injury in a local care facility when, on July 20, 2024, he was given a contaminated shake. Wills, who was previously able to move with the assistance of a mobility device, to participate in physical therapy and eat meals normally, soon developed a fever, pain and had difficulty speaking, according to the suit. After multiple hospitalizations and monitoring for infectious disease, Wills died of "complications related to his Listeria infection and other comorbid conditions" on Feb. 22, 2025. His relatives are seeking damages and payment of Wills' medical and legal fees. Marler criticized the CDC and FDA for their reporting practices, telling USA TODAY and explaining in a blog post that victims like Wills underwent various tests – including blood and spinal fluid draws – and underwent investigations that involved family interviews and reviews of purchase histories. However, they were never informed by the agencies about the cause of their illness or death. "I spoke with a family today to inform them that their husband/father died after suffering a Listeria infection," Marler said in a recent blog post shared with USA TODAY, which he confirmed was referencing Wills. "Until today, the family did not know the cause of his infection despite (the) fact that it has been known by local, state and federal officials for over a year." USA TODAY has reached out to the CDC and FDA for comment. Which states had listeria poisoning cases? A total of 21 states had known listeria outbreaks related to this recall: Alabama, California, Colorado, Connecticut, Florida, Illinois, Indiana, Maryland, Michigan, Minnesota, Missouri, North Carolina, Nevada, New York, Ohio, Oklahoma, Pennsylvania, Tennessee, Texas, Washington, and West Virginia. The 14 deaths occurred in nine states: California, Illinois, Indiana, Michigan, Minnesota, North Carolina, New York, Tennessee, Texas, and Washington. Which Lyons ReadyCare and Sysco Imperial shakes were recalled? All recalled products had "best buy" dates between 02/21/25 and 02/21/26, according to Lyons Magnus. All the contaminated products are believed to have been destroyed, the FDA notice said. What is listeriosis or listeria poisoning? Listeriosis, or listeria poisoning, is a foodborne bacterial infection most commonly caused by the bacterium Listeria monocytogenes. It is considered a serious condition and can be dangerous or life-threatening, especially to older adults, people with weak immune systems and pregnant people. Signs and symptoms of listeriosis may not appear until weeks after consumption. Persons in the higher-risk categories who experience flu-like symptoms within two months after eating contaminated food should seek medical care and tell their health care provider about eating the contaminated food, according to the U.S. Department of Agriculture. According to the USDA, symptoms include:
