Edinburgh Council overpaid staff to the tune of £1.78m in five years
Edinburgh Council has overpaid staff to the tune of £1,780,000 over what is believed to be five years – with councillors being asked to write off almost £140,000 in unrecovered overpayments and implement changes to reduce the burden of overpayments on staff.
In a report to councillors, officers said 1,459 staff members had been overpaid in that time – 579 of them being current staff, while 880 had already left the council.
The council report said that the bulk of the overpayments – £1.1m – were made to staff in education, including cases where 'council or school management was at fault' which risked causing staff significant financial hardship.
Some £440,000 came from the city's Place division, while £200,000 came from the Health and Social Care Partnership, £32,800 came from Corporate Services and £1,600 from the Chief Executive's Office.
Councillors are now set to consider a new pay policy, which would aim to make repaying overpaid wages less burdensome.
If councillors approve changes, employees who have been overpaid over several months will have at least as many months as they were overpaid to pay back the excess wages.
Officers also want to see £139,978.80 of overpaid wages written off, which come from 27 cases of overpayment.
All involve situations where efforts to reach employees to set up repayment plans have been unsuccessful.
According to the report, 20% of salary overpayments were due to 'processing errors', while 34% was due to issues with annual leave calculations.
And 36% were due to 'late information submitted to HR', while 4% were listed under 'system error'.
The bulk of overpayments were made to staff on grades 1 through 4 on the council's pay scale, with under a third of current employee overpayment cases and under a fifth of overpayment cases for staff who have left the organisation falling above this band.
Labour councillor Mandy Watt, convener of the Finance and Resources committee said: 'Our payroll salary and wage payments are around £550m annually, for a workforce of over 17,000 colleagues, and on average 99.5% of monthly payments are accurate.
'We've recently taken a more considered approach to overpayments, allowing more flexible and extended repayment plans to be put in place.
'Where an overpayment has been made, the new pay policy encourages colleagues to get involved in the process, so a repayment plan can be agreed which takes all the circumstances into account.
'There's also a new HR and Payroll system which gives all colleagues improved visibility of the information that's used to calculate their pay and they can view their payslip electronically each month allowing earlier discussion of any potential issues.'
The overpayment was reported in the Edinburgh Reporter last September following a Freedom of Information request.
By Joseph Sullivan Local Democracy Reporter
Like this:
Like
Related
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Record
a day ago
- Daily Record
West Lothian community centre management plans 'mired in confusion'
West Lothian Council began a review a year ago in a bid to save £1m. Community centre management committees were encouraged to buy the buildings and manage them or take out leases with the council. The future of community centres in West Lothian has become mired in confusion and the council needs to rebuild public confidence, it has been claimed. West Lothian Council began a review a year ago in a bid to save £1m. Community centre management committees were encouraged to buy the buildings and manage them or take out leases with the council. Only just over half of that saving has been identified as the plan has developed Last month the council introduced a new option - where it would take control of the bulk of community centres. Many centres fear this would mean an increase in costs for user groups leading to a drop off in use and potential closures. The recent announcement that the council could end up managing the bulk of centres has further muddied the picture, the Joint Forum of Community Councils said. The Forum has now submitted a Freedom of Information ( FoI) request for details of the financial savings, adding: 'The financial aspects of the review remain baffling.' In a statement the Forum added: 'It's unfortunate the council began this process with pre-determined solutions rather than with an open mind and a blank slate.' The Forum has called for a new discussion with the council to look at the positives thrown up by the review process. In its statement the Forum said: 'It appears the alternative solutions that centres were encouraged to submit have been dismissed for not meeting the required savings. Unfortunately, no further collective discussion or exploration of these proposals was encouraged or held.' It added: 'We've heard inspiring stories from Management Committees who, catalysed by the Review, held public meetings and attracted more volunteers for their centres. They've revitalised centre activities, encouraged new user groups, and actively engaged with their communities, generating a wealth of ideas for new initiatives and forging valuable contacts. 'Many have responded to suggestions for modernisation, exploring investment plans from their reserves and even considering updating their constitutions to move from unincorporated to incorporated charity status. 'They've also championed the need for a modern online booking system or a local community wealth-building repair and maintenance system, whether local or West Lothian-wide. 'Unfortunately, these promising initiatives are now in limbo, awaiting clear direction from the local authority. We believe a round table event would help everyone move forward and facilitate the implementation of these changes.' The Forum said the introduction of the council takeover option along with the inclusion, in January, of school community wings into the review had added to public confusion of what was trying to be achieved. Speaking to councillors at the Executive in early May, Julie Whitelaw, the head of Housing Customer and Building services stressed that the council management option had been shared with all management committees along with: 'the implications we would require to look at reduction in operating models looking at sustainable models.' She reiterated that the process was designed to keep community centres open and running. The Forum commented: 'To date, there hasn't been a West Lothian-wide consultation round table with the Centre's Management Committees that allowed for an open agenda without preconditions. 'We consider this a necessary step that must be taken. We ask that this suggestion be given full consideration. 'Community Centre management committees that have already decided to acquire or rent their centres have chosen their path and would naturally be excused from any future all-centre consultations.'
Edinburgh Live
a day ago
- Edinburgh Live
Plans for new Edinburgh bubble tea chain restaurant in busy neighbourhood
Our community members are treated to special offers, promotions and adverts from us and our partners. You can check out at any time. More info Get the latest Edinburgh Live breaking news on WhatsApp Edinburgh city centre may gain a new bubble tea shop on a busy city centre street. Plans have been lodged with Edinburgh Council to erect signage for Hey Luck Bubble Tea: Bubble Tea & Street Food at 72 South Clerk Street. The shopfront sits between Polish market, Touch of Poland, and American-style eatery, Burger Drop Edinburgh, just a few blocks from the Meadows and Holyrood Park. Hey Luck Bubble Tea would be a first for Edinburgh, which already operates two outlets in Aberdeen on George Street and Merkland Road East. The establishments sell bubble tea as well as a colourful assortment of Asian street food such as jianbing, tokoyaki, and Korean fried chicken. The premises on South Clerk Street were previously host to Oma's African Cuisine, which dissolved in June of last year. Create Studio Architecture lodged the plans with Edinburgh Council to instal the new signage, which would feature colourful lettering and a cartoon girl drinking bubble tea in its logo. Hey Luck would join the ranks of Edinburgh's numerous bubble tea establishments, such as CUPP, which opened its second location on Leith Walk in March 2025.
Daily Record
2 days ago
- Daily Record
Fed-up Edinburgh residents have had enough of 'party' Airbnb
One neighbour said: "People are going at all hours of the night and there is no real soundproofing despite the owner making modifications. It is ridiculous. He cannot get away with this." Fed-up residents who live near an Airbnb that was suspended from the site because of problem parties, are furious that it's up for rent again. The flat in the Faulburn area of Edinburgh is the only known short term let (STL) in the block. After complaints from neighbours about loud guests wreaking havoc, the property was suspended from Airbnb site for 30 days. They claimed youths were falling around the street, acting aggressively with one another and consuming alcohol at the property. But they've been left livid after discovering the flat had been listed on for several months before it reappeared on Airbnb in May 2025 when its suspension ended. Resident and business owner, Fraser Ramsay, said he had to go down to the flat last Tuesday because he couldn't sleep with the noise. He told Edinburgh Live: 'I told the man to keep the noise down or I would phone the police and he agreed to do so but then I heard him through the night again. 'It ruins your next day, I'm a business owner, and going out to working not having a good sleep isn't great. The owner of this Airbnb needs to sell up to someone who will live here long term or rent out the flat to a proper resident. 'At least if it is a permanent neighbour in the block we will be able to build relationships and have common courtesy. At the moment there is a security issue as well because these are strangers. 'People are going at all hours of the night and there is no real soundproofing despite the owner making modifications. It is ridiculous. He cannot get away with this. 'End of the day it is important this comes to an end. When it all kicks off it is horrible.' Fraser has been in regular contact with Edinburgh Council to try to get answers as to how the owner was able to re-list the property for short term rentals on Airbnb. Correspondence between the home owner and the council stated a notice had been given to the STL landlord ordering them to cease operating the Airbnb unless they are able to lodge an appeal by late June 2025. It is understood Airbnb suspended the property originally due to a party taking place at the property which is a breach of the platforms rules. However the property owner is understood to have carried out 'sound proofing' alterations to the property, which led to the ban being lifted. Airbnb protocol states the company will potentially deactivate a property if they are contacted by a relevant local authority which believes the listing is operating illegally. It is understood the council have not made contact with Airbnb regarding the above property. In a message seen by Edinburgh Live, council officials told Fraser: 'Just a quick e-mail to advise that enforcement notices were served on the property on Wednesday 21 May 2025. The property owner has until 25 June 2025 to appeal the notice. 'If he fails to do so by this date, then he would require to comply with its requirements i.e. cease the use of the property as a short term let by 25 July 2025.' Councillor Joan Griffiths Planning Convener said: 'We have issued an enforcement notice requesting that the owner of this property ceases to use it as a short term let. They have until 24 July 2025 to comply with this notice unless they appeal.' An Airbnb spokesperson said: 'We take feedback from local residents seriously, and this listing was temporarily suspended in line with our policies and the host has since taken steps to address this issue. Parties are banned on Airbnb and we may remove this listing if further policy violations occur. 'While issues on Airbnb are exceptionally rare, residents can contact us 24/7 via our neighbourhood support line and we investigate all reports received through this channel.'
