Prime Video's new No. 1 show is a charming comedy-drama — and it's pure binge-worthy fun
Prime Video's latest original series 'Overcompensating' landed just last week (on Thursday, May 15), and — within days — this comedy-drama shot straight to the top of the platform's most-watched list.
Created by and starring Benito Skinner, 'Overcompensating' follows a former high school football star and homecoming king who's trying to figure himself out in college while still pretending he already has it all together.
The show captures that awkward in-between phase of life with chaotic humor and some moments that will have you covering your eyes and cackling at the same time.
And viewers are clearly eating it up, because 'Overcompensating' has already claimed the No. 1 spot on Prime Video less than a week after release (snatching first place from 'Reacher').
With only eight episodes, it's a quick watch, but the kind that leaves you wishing you had more the second it ends. Here's everything to know about 'Overcompensating' before adding it to your watchlist.
'Overcompensating' follows Benny (Benito Skinner), a former high school football star and homecoming king who's now a freshman at Yates University. Though he seems like the picture of confidence, Benny is secretly struggling to come to terms with who he really is.
When he meets Carmen (Wally Baram), a fellow freshman determined to leave her outsider past behind, the two form an unlikely and chaotic friendship. Together, they navigate the ups and downs of college life, including hook-ups, parties, bad decisions, and worse hangovers, all while trying to figure out who they want to be.
Get instant access to breaking news, the hottest reviews, great deals and helpful tips.
As Benny tries to maintain the image he built back home, things get increasingly complicated with new friends, unexpected feelings, and awkward situations that force him out of his comfort zone.
'Overcompensating' isn't exactly a new formula in the world of comedies. College misadventures, identity crises, chaotic friendships are all familiar territory.
But the show's charm isn't in trying to do something radically new. It's in how confidently it leans into the absurdity of early adulthood, and how sharp, self-aware, and funny it is while doing it.
From the first episode, the series embraces messiness in all forms: emotional, sexual, and social. It thrives in the kind of secondhand embarrassment that comes from watching a character try so hard to hold it all together while everything around them spins out. Whether it's Benny dodging honest conversations or Carmen going all-in on her rebrand, the show nails the chaotic energy of freshman year.
One of the smartest things 'Overcompensating' does is keep its episodes short and snappy since most clock in at around 30 minutes, which makes it dangerously easy to fly through the entire season in one sitting.
Some side plots are stronger than others, and the tone occasionally wobbles between heartfelt and outright farce.
The pacing never drags, and the humor, while broad at times, rarely feels forced. There's also a nice rhythm to the way the show builds its world: campus legends, unconventional side characters, chaotic parties — they all weave together to make Yates University feel like a place you've either lived through or wish you hadn't.
That said, it's not a perfect show. Some side plots are stronger than others, and the tone occasionally wobbles between heartfelt and outright farce.
But for the most part, 'Overcompensating' hits where it counts, especially in the lead performances from Skinner and Baram, whose characters become best friends and form one of the show's central emotional anchors.
I'm not alone in my praise either because 'Overcompensating' has a solid rating of 94% on Rotten Tomatoes, with audiences scoring it 79%.
The site's critics consensus reads: 'As ribald as any self-respecting campus comedy but with a disarmingly sweet core, Overcompensating has nothing to make up for as it proves creator-star Benito Skinner to be the real deal.'
So, should you stream 'Overcompensating' on Prime Video? If you're in the mood for a fast-paced, funny binge-watch that doesn't take itself too seriously but still has something to say, then absolutely. It's a fun ride and a refreshingly honest one. For more streaming recommendations, see what's new on Prime Video in May 2025.
Stream "Overcompensating" on Prime Video now.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Tom's Guide
3 hours ago
- Tom's Guide
7 top new movies to stream this week on Prime Video, Hulu, Disney Plus and more (June 10-16)
This week is packed with a bunch of new movies hitting the best streaming services. They include Prime Video's original crime-comedy "Deep Cover," which sees an improv teacher and two of her students pose as hardened criminals to infiltrate London's criminal underworld. There's also the release of "Snow White" on Disney Plus and Rami Malek's "The Amateur" getting a digital streaming release. Hulu and HBO Max will have new movies to watch, too, but the title I'm most intrigued about is "Echo Valley," a new thriller arriving on Apple TV Plus. If you're looking to stream something new this week, I'll be sharing all the top new movies across streaming services. Plus, be sure to check out all the top new TV shows you'll want to binge-watch this week as well. Fresh off a string of intriguing genre projects, Rami Malek stars in 'The Amateur,' a grounded, slow-burn espionage thriller that does things a little differently than your usual spy fare. Directed by James Hawes, this cerebral thriller plays it cool, focusing less on gadgets and globe-trotting and more on grief and obsession. Malek plays a CIA codebreaker devastated by a personal tragedy. When red tape blocks him from getting justice, he takes matters into his own hands by forcing his way into the field and setting off a chain reaction of internal conflict and covert danger. And no, this isn't an action-packed Bond riff. It's a tight, deliberately-paced character study that asks how far someone's willing to go when pushed to the edge. Also starring Rachel Brosnahan, Jon Bernthal, and Laurence Fishburne, 'The Amateur' might not be flashy, but the slow-brewing tension and restrained performances make it a satisfying watch for those who like their thrillers smart and serious. Buy or rent on Amazon from June 10 Get instant access to breaking news, the hottest reviews, great deals and helpful tips. 'Clown in a Cornfield' tries to lean into the campy slasher vibes its title promises, but despite the blood and greasepaint, it never quite sticks the landing. Based on the cult YA novel by Adam Cesare, the movie follows a group of teens who find themselves stalked by a deranged killer clown called Frendo in the middle of rural America. Sounds like it should be a blast, right? Unfortunately, this one's a real misfire. In a year full of inventive horror flicks, 'Clown in a Cornfield' stands out for all the wrong reasons. The tone is all over the place, the characters are incredibly annoying, and there's just too much cringe humor. It doesn't even manage to hit that sweet spot of being 'so bad it's good.' Still, if you're a slasher completionist, there are a few silver linings: Some of the kills are enjoyably gnarly, and the clown costume design is weirdly fun to look at. Buy or rent on Amazon from June 10 Disney's live-action 'Snow White' finally arrives on Disney Plus, and while it doesn't quite reach the heights of the studio's strongest remakes, it's not without its merits. Directed by Marc Webb and starring Rachel Zegler as the iconic princess, this retelling makes a clear effort to modernize the story with updated themes and some fresh musical choices. However, despite a few visually striking moments and Zegler's natural screen presence, 'Snow White' does struggle to justify its existence. Much of the charm that made the original an enduring classic is nowhere to be found, and it turned out to be far less compelling than the social media uproar might have led you to expect. But for younger viewers or die-hard Disney fans, there's just enough appeal to make it worth a watch. It may not be a classic in the making, but it offers a soft, visually pleasing experience that's easy to put on for a cozy night in. Watch on Disney Plus from June 11 'Deep Cover' is one of Prime Video's more intriguing original releases this year. The premise: a team of improv comedians goes undercover. And based on the trailer, this crime comedy looks like a wild, over-the-top dive into London's offbeat criminal scene with plenty of laughs along the way. Kat (Bryce Dallas Howard) is an improv teacher stuck in a rut and wondering if her big break has passed her by. That changes when a mysterious undercover cop (Sean Bean) presents her with an unexpected opportunity: help him pull off a risky infiltration of London's criminal underworld. Sensing her moment, Kat ropes in two of her most eager students (Orlando Bloom and Nick Mohammed) to pose as hardened criminals, diving headfirst into a world far beyond the stage. Watch on Prime Video from June 12 'Absolution' quietly dropped in theaters last November, but it finds new life this month as it hits Hulu. Liam Neeson plays a fading mob enforcer battling memory loss and years of regret, trying to make peace with his estranged daughter while dodging the violent fallout of his past. Directed by Hans Petter Moland, 'Absolution' doesn't do anything new, but it leans hard into the noir vibes — bleak lighting and just enough grit to keep you hooked. Neeson does what Neeson does best, growling his way through emotional monologues and brutal fight scenes, even if the material feels a little too familiar. It's not a must-watch, and at times it drags, but there's something satisfying about its stripped-down simplicity. If you're a fan of Neeson's late-career crime roles, this one fits comfortably in the rotation. Watch on Hulu from June 13 I thought I had made a mistake by reading the reviews before watching 'Cleaner,' since I usually avoid doing that. But going into this action-thriller with low expectations actually helped me enjoy it, and I ended up pleasantly surprised. 'Cleaner' centers on Joey (Daisy Ridley), a former soldier turned high-rise window cleaner working on One Canada Square in London. During a gala hosted by a major energy corporation, eco-terrorists seize the building, using sleeping gas to take around 300 hostages. High above the chaos, suspended outside on a glass platform, Joey and her autistic brother accidentally witness the attack and become the building's unlikely lifeline. Don't expect anything groundbreaking when going into this thriller. Unfortunately, it leans a little too heavily on familiar tropes from better movies to truly stand out, but there's still plenty of fun to be had along the way. Watch on HBO Max from June 13 There's just something about a slow-burn psychological thriller with a messy mother-daughter dynamic that always pulls me in, and based on the 'Echo Valley' trailer, this looks like exactly that kind of story. Julianne Moore stars as Kate, a former competitive rider now living a quiet, grief-tinged life training horses in rural Pennsylvania. Things take a sharp turn when her daughter Claire (Sydney Sweeney) shows up one night, bloodied and clearly in shock. She says she's done something awful… and that's when the real unraveling begins. Written by 'Mare of Easttown' creator Brad Ingelsby, I'm expecting morally murky choices, emotional gut punches, and characters who don't fit neatly into 'good' or 'bad.' Throw in Domhnall Gleeson as a cryptic figure from Claire's past, and it's even more intriguing. Watch on Apple TV Plus from June 13
Yahoo
5 hours ago
- Yahoo
‘Etoile' Canceled at Amazon After One Season — Despite Two-Season Order
Amazon's Prime Video has canceled Étoile after a single season — even though the streamer had initially asked for two. The news comes about six weeks after the series, from Marvelous Mrs. Maisel creators Amy Sherman-Palladino and Daniel Palladino, premiered its full eight-episode season. Étoile is set in the world of ballet and centers on the heads of historic but struggling companies in New York and Paris (played by Maisel alum Luke Kirby and Charlotte Gainsbourg) who decide to swap their principal dancers. More from The Hollywood Reporter 'The Better Sister' Stars React to Murder Mystery Reveal: "They Totally Threw Me Off and I Was There" 'Lee Soo Man: King of K-Pop' Director and Subject Talk New Prime Video Documentary "It's Just for the Pure Love of This Art Form": 'THR Frontrunners' Panel With 'Étoile' Showrunners Amy Sherman-Palladino and Dan Palladino Prime Video gave the show a two-season, straight-to-series order in 2023 as The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel was in its final season. Such deals often have contingencies, however, by which a streamer or network can opt out after part of a multi-season order. That was the case with Étoile. In the three weeks of Étoile's release for which data is available, the show has not dented Nielsen's top 10 streaming charts. That would make a second season of the pricey series, which filmed on location in New York and Paris, a tough sell. Amazon MGM Studios, which produces the show and where the Palladinos have an overall deal, is also going through a leadership change: Former studio head Jen Salke, who greenlit Étoile, left Amazon in late March (though she struck a producing deal on her way out). TV chief Vernon Sanders and film boss Courtenay Valenti continue to run their respective divisions, now reporting directly to Mike Hopkins, head of Prime Video and the studio, rather than Salke. Along with Kirby and Gainsbourg, Étoile stars Gideon Glick, Lou de Laâge, David Alvarez, Ivan du Pontavice, Taïs Vinolo, David Haig, LaMay Zhang and Simon Callow. Sherman-Palladino and Palladino executive produced the series with Dhana Rivera Gilbert. Scott Ellis was co-EP. Deadline first reported the news. Best of The Hollywood Reporter 'The Studio': 30 Famous Faces Who Play (a Version of) Themselves in the Hollywood-Based Series 22 of the Most Shocking Character Deaths in Television History A 'Star Wars' Timeline: All the Movies and TV Shows in the Franchise
Yahoo
6 hours ago
- Yahoo
Jeremy Clarkson pub staff walk out after 'too many problems'
Staff at Jeremy Clarkson's pub in the Cotswolds, The Farmer's Dog, walked out after facing "too many problems". The former Top Gear and Grand Tour host bought The Windmill in Asthall near Burford for around £1m. He set about renovating the spot and renamed the watering hole The Farmer's Dog in recognition of his pets and his nearby farm, Diddly Squat. The Chadlington-based farm is the subject of the Prime Video show Clarkson's Farm which was initially released in 2021. READ MORE: Jeremy Clarkson announces new venture after Clarkson's Farm series four Its fourth series has had a staggered release over the past few weeks with eight new episodes in total. These new programmes show Mr Clarkson's decision to buy the Cotswolds pub as well as featuring the grand opening which took place last August. The final episode of the new season, released on Friday (June 6), exposed the challenges that The Farmer's Dog's opening faced across the August bank holiday. Problems saw several members of staff walk out from the pub, which was addressed in a candid conversation between Mr Clarkson and land agent Charlie Ireland READ MORE: Jeremy Clarkson BANS customer from Cotswolds pub after complaint The Farmer's Dog pub in the Cotswolds. (Image: NQ) He said: "We've lost two waitresses. We lost a pot washer. After one day." The Express adds in a report that pressure mounted during a pub meeting with senior team members Sue and Rachel. They told Jeremy: "Everyone is exhausted, even when we say go for a break, there is no staff room. "The kitchen is about to go pop, those chefs have had it.... It might be worth popping into the kitchen." Despite the initial problems and hectic opening, the pub has found its feet and has been regularly welcoming healthy numbers of punters to the site with a full team on hand to meet the demand.
