Cracks in Indian community can be solved with unity
COMMENT | Why Indian Malaysians mourn wrong heroes
Prominority: There is no sincere interest group or strong ethical political party representing Indian Malaysians in the policymaking body.
The community is like a headless chicken.
Until Indian Malaysians organise themselves into a single voice and a cohesive society, policy designers will not be inclusive and will sideline them until the kingdom comes.
Indian Malaysians should organise themselves before finding fault with the ruling government.
Many pundits can list all the problems faced by Indians, but no one gives strategies for elevating the standard of living.
No satisfactory solutions in sight.
Falcon: Call it whatever you like, be it the Madani plan, the 13th Malaysia Plan or another plan.
The fact remains that nothing is going to change for Indian Malaysians from cradle to grave!
Be they life's challenges, systemic prejudices, racism or a place at the bottom of the social and economic barrel and food chain?
More so, when those claiming to represent Indian Malaysians only enrich themselves every which way!
What awaits is natural death, illness or, to some, death in a hail of bullets from assassins?
Former Klang MP Charles Santiago, please do not act naive or self-righteous. You should know, after all, you are a politician yourself!
A Little Bit Crazy: Alamak Charles! Don't depend on the government or anybody else to help the local Indian community.
We Chinese have learned the lesson hard, we help ourselves, we donate, and take our savings to help our community, culture and schools.
Start with small donations, here and there, build your schools, teach your youths, and advise your Indian gangster leaders not to ruin your own people.
Tell them to change their ways. Chinese politicians in small towns used to be gangsters; now, after 60 years, they are almost completely gone.
Don't depend on other races, especially Malay communities, to help you. They have their own problems and no time for you.
YellowFalcon7173: The problem with Indians in this country is that there is no unity amongst them.
The Tamil community here do not want to assimilate with the other Indian communities such as the Telugus, Sindhis, Bengalis and Malayalis. They even chant slogans to that effect.
Even in India, the different communities assimilate and consider themselves Indian first and only then their different communities.
In Malaysia, this division is even reflected in the political parties, which only want to propel Tamils (even then, based on caste).
If you cannot speak Tamil, you do not have a chance in political parties. So the other Indian communities shy away from politics.
Even then, if you see the majority of poor Indians, they are from the Tamil community.
This shows how the political parties have failed their community, whilst the other Indian communities have focused on business and education and established themselves.
Get rid of this ego, get rid of identifying yourselves based on your community and then see how it will propel the Indian community.
A good example is the Chinese. Even though there are Hokkiens, Hakka and so on.
When it comes to business, education and politics, they identify themselves as Chinese.
Spinnot: @YellowFalcon7173 yes, although the Chinese community here have many clan associations based on dialects, regional origins and even surnames, guild associations, state Chinese Chambers of Commerce, state Chinese Assembly Halls, they are all under a national umbrella body, Hua Zong (The Federation of Chinese Associations Malaysia), which is non-partisan.
RR: Each community leader must take care of their own community.
The Chinese are a good example.
Nonetheless, in a multiracial, multireligious nation, there must be a sincere commitment and political will of the government of the day to assimilate all races as Malaysians by giving equal and equitable opportunities to all and ensuring that no section of the people is left behind.
This should be the ideology and policy of a truly democratic government and country.
Chefoo: Which Indian leader genuinely cares for his community?
The Indian community have the highest number of political parties in Malaysia, and every one of these so-called leaders is fighting not to uplift the community but for their power and positions.
Don't blame the government, but blame yourself for being backwards and harping on the government for handouts.
The Chinese have shown how they can progress without much help from the government.
The above is a selection of comments posted by Malaysiakini subscribers. Only paying subscribers can post comments. In the past year, Malaysiakinians have posted over 100,000 comments. Join the Malaysiakini community and help set the news agenda. Subscribe now.
These comments are compiled to reflect the views of Malaysiakini subscribers on matters of public interest. Malaysiakini does not intend to represent these views as fact.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Sun
9 hours ago
- The Sun
China aided Pakistan with live intel in India conflict, says army official
NEW DELHI: China gave Islamabad 'live inputs' on key Indian positions during Pakistan's deadly conflict with its neighbour in May, the deputy chief of India's army said on Friday, calling for urgent upgrades to the country's air defence systems. The nuclear-armed rivals used missiles, drones and artillery fire during the four-day fighting - their worst in decades - triggered by an April attack on Hindu tourists in Indian Kashmir that New Delhi blamed on Islamabad, before agreeing to a ceasefire. Pakistan has denied involvement in the April attack. India fought two adversaries during the conflict, with Pakistan being the 'front face' while China provided 'all possible support', Lieutenant General Rahul Singh said at a defence industry event in New Delhi. 'When the DGMO (director general of military operations) level talks were going on, Pakistan ... said that we know that your such and such important vector is primed and it is ready for action ... he was getting live inputs from China,' he said. Singh did not elaborate on how India knew about the live inputs from China. The Chinese foreign and defence ministries, and Pakistan army's public relations wing did not immediately respond to Reuters requests for comment. India's relationship with China was strained after a 2020 border clash that sparked a four-year military standoff, but tensions began to ease after the countries reached a pact to step back in October. India had earlier said that although Pakistan is closely allied with China, there was no sign of any actual help from Beijing during the conflict. Regarding the possibility of China providing satellite imagery or other real-time intelligence, India's chief of defence staff had said such imagery was commercially available and could have been procured from China or elsewhere. Pakistani officials have previously dismissed allegations of receiving active support from China in the conflict, but have not commented specifically on whether Beijing gave any satellite and radar help during the fighting. Beijing, which welcomed the ceasefire in May, has helped Pakistan's struggling economy with investments and financial support since 2013. The Chinese foreign minister also vowed support to Pakistan in safeguarding its national sovereignty and territorial integrity when he met his Pakistani counterpart days after the ceasefire. Singh said that Turkey also provided key support to Pakistan during the fighting, equipping it with Bayraktar and 'numerous other' drones, and 'trained individuals'. Ankara has strong ties with Islamabad, and had expressed solidarity with it during the clash, prompting Indians to boycott everything from Turkish coffee to holidays in the country. Turkey's defence ministry did not immediately respond to a Reuters request for comment. - Reuters
Malaysiakini
10 hours ago
- Malaysiakini
Hadi's son-in-law demands apology from Sim
PAS leader Zaharudin Muhammad has initiated legal action against Human Resources Minister Steven Sim for allegedly slandering him. This was in regard to a statement made by Sim last week, where the DAP deputy secretary-general criticised Zaharudin's controversial remarks about the promotion of the army's first Chinese lieutenant general.
Free Malaysia Today
10 hours ago
- Free Malaysia Today
Halt ‘syndicate recruitment' of Bangladeshi workers, Santiago tells govt
A Bangladeshi official said Dhaka could impose a moratorium on sending its nationals to Malaysia unless the current agreement on worker recruitment is amended. (Bernama pic) PETALING JAYA : Former Klang MP Charles Santiago has called on Malaysia to heed Bangladesh's call to get rid of the 'syndicate' system used to recruit Bangladeshi migrant workers. Asif Nazrul, an adviser to Bangladesh's expatriates' welfare and overseas employment ministry, said yesterday that Dhaka could impose a moratorium on sending its nationals to Malaysia unless the current agreement on worker recruitment is amended. Santiago, the co-chair of Asean Parliamentarians for Human Rights, said Bangladeshi workers are forced to pay between RM20,000 and RM30,000 to secure jobs in Malaysia, forcing them into debt before they even set foot in the country. He said recruitment syndicates are able to charge such high fees as the current 'toothless' memorandum of understanding on the recruitment of Bangladeshi workers does not provide for any fines or licence revocations. 'What we need is a binding bilateral labour agreement. Without one, syndicates will keep trafficking workers, industries will keep bleeding cash, and Malaysia will keep facing global disgrace. 'There is no recourse for workers who are forced into slavery like conditions. A binding pact means real penalties, transparency, and zero costs for workers. 'The government owes it to workers, employers, and the public to show real leadership and fix a fundamentally flawed system that breeds corruption,' he said in a statement. In 2021, Malaysia and Bangladesh signed an MoU on the recruitment of Bangladeshi workers, which is effective until December 2026. The agreement stipulates that a list of recruiting agencies be provided for Malaysia to select from. In a report in Bangladesh's The Daily Star yesterday, Asif said the agreement, which was signed by Bangladesh's previous government, should be amended as it allowed a syndicate of recruiting agencies to operate. 'Now that we've taken over, everyone is saying the syndicate system must be abolished,' he was quoted as saying, referring to the interim government under Muhammad Yunus. 'If they refuse, we have two options – follow their terms and send workers through 25, 50 or 100 agencies, or stop sending workers altogether.' He also said Malaysia is expected to recruit 30,000 to 40,000 workers from Bangladesh over the next year.
