NHL trade grades: Penguins, Kraken soak up sellers' market in 2 deals with Jets
The Athletic has live coverage of the 2025 NHL trade deadline.
Winnipeg Jets get: Defenseman Luke Schenn
Pittsburgh Penguins get: 2026 second-round draft pick, 2027 fourth-round draft pick
Winnipeg Jets get: Forward Brandon Tanev
Seattle Kraken get: 2027 second-round draft pick
James Mirtle: I had a front-row (press box) seat when the Maple Leafs acquired Luke Schenn at the trade deadline two years ago for a third-round pick.
At the time, it felt like he would be simply a bit part, depth addition to a contending Toronto team. Instead, he stepped into a top-four role alongside Morgan Rielly and was one of the Leafs best players as they finally made it out of the first round of the playoffs.
Advertisement
And Toronto tried to bring him back in the offseason, only to get outbid on the generous three-year deal Schenn landed in Nashville.
Schenn, 35, is two years older than that postseason with the Leafs, and what he brings isn't flashy. But he also won't be expected to do as much with the Jets, filling primarily a third-pair slot and PK duties.
His game is a perfect fit for the postseason and this team, given he brings size and physicality, not to mention the experience of two deep Stanley Cup runs with the Lightning in 2020 and 2021. And his underrated ability to make a nice, no-nonsense play to break out of his zone has been a big part of his late-career resurgence over the past few years.
The only downside for the Jets is they didn't get any of the deal retained, as $2.75 million is a hair high to pay for another year beyond this one. Credit to the Penguins, meanwhile, for flipping Schenn for a better pick outlay than what the Canucks got for him two years ago.
I'm less bullish on the Tanev addition if only because the Jets really could have used a higher level add up front. They were in hard on some of the bigger fish, such as Brock Nelson, and Tanev is certainly not that.
What he is, however, is an incredibly hard worker who brings a strong checking game and elite penalty killing – something the Jets need to upgrade given they sit 15th. His underlying numbers at even strength have taken a dip as he's aged, but some of that has been the challenging environment in Seattle the past few seasons.
Tanev started his career in Winnipeg and was part of their big playoff run in 2018, so the fit in that respect should be seamless. And it feels possible this turns into more than just a rental situation, too, which would boost this grade.
Jets grade: B
Penguins grade: A-
Kraken grade: A-
Sean Gentille: Way back on Wednesday night, when the Penguins acquired Tommy Novak from Nashville for Michael Bunting, Luke Schenn's involvement in the deal screamed 'quick flip.'
Advertisement
Contenders will always make room for big, tough, high-character Cup-winners. The Penguins, as they've laid plain over the last few months, are no contender. And for as much as Kyle Dubas gassed up Schenn in a round of post-trade emails with Pittsburgh media, smart money should've always been on Schenn winding up somewhere else.
'(We) feel that having Luke's defensive play, character, leadership, toughness and spirit is something we need here to help push our program through this phase and preserve our culture and standards as we work to return to contention,' Dubas said.
They'll miss out on that, it seems, while adding two draft picks to their cache. Dubas, should he desire, can now select 10 players in the first round of the next three drafts. This market favors sellers, and he's taking full advantage.
Schenn, meanwhile, re-surfaces on one of the best teams in the league. The Jets got themselves a physical right-shot defenseman who can kill penalties and clear the net-front. In a vacuum, that's fine — it's certainly a player profile that they can use. Given how the Western Conference is shaping up, he should help the Jets along the way.
Still, they need to be careful about how much they put on Schenn's plate. He's 35 years old now and was never going to win any foot races in the first place.
You could say something similar about Tanev. He can still skate and still seems like a player who can be a factor over the course of a playoff run, but his overall game has dipped over the past two years. Seattle's defensive numbers are worse with him on the ice. I'm not sure that's how Winnipeg, in a perfect world, would've spent a second-round pick, though the state of the market might say otherwise. If this is what it takes for a true Cup contender to get better, what other choice do they have?
Jets grade: C-
Penguins grade: A
Kraken grade: A
(Photos: Ethan Miller and Alika Jenner / Getty Images)
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
NBC Sports
an hour ago
- NBC Sports
Bryce Huff thankful he landed with 49ers
Edge rusher Bryce Huff is happy to be back with 49ers defensive coordinator Robert Saleh. Huff had 10 sacks playing for Saleh in 2023 when Saleh was the head coach of the Jets and turned that into a three-year deal with the Eagles as a free agent. Huff was not able to replicate that success in Vic Fangio's defense and he dealt with an injury before being inactive for the team's Super Bowl win. After a mutual agreement to have Huff stay away from the offseason program as both sides looked for a trade, the Eagles dealt Huff to the 49ers last month. On Wednesday, Huff said he had his eyes on a reunion throughout the process. 'I had a few places in mind that I definitely wanted to get traded to,' Huff said, via 95.7 The Game. 'All I was doing is just working out, staying in my routine. Thankfully, it was to San Francisco.' Saleh said, via that Huff brings 'speed off the edge' to the defense and that opposing coaches have to 'account for his presence on the field' while discussing why the team made the move for Huff. Those traits served Huff and Saleh well in their first run together and the coming months will show if the second time will be the charm as well.
San Francisco Chronicle
2 hours ago
- San Francisco Chronicle
Healthier Panthers are nearing full strength in the Stanley Cup Final against the Oilers
FORT LAUDERDALE, Fla. (AP) — The bumps and bruises and worse started to pile up midway through the Florida Panthers' third consecutive trip to the Stanley Cup Final. Matthew Tkachuk only returned for the playoff opener after sitting out the final two months of the regular season with the injury he suffered at the 4 Nations Face-Off in February and seems to still be gutting through it. Sam Reinhart and Niko Mikkola each missed time during the Eastern Conference final, and A.J. Greer's injury he tried playing through eventually sidelined him. 'It's very hard to win a Cup with unhealthy bodies,' Greer said. The Panthers found that out the hard way two years ago when they were the skating wounded. Tkachuk had a broken sternum, Aaron Ekblad had a broken foot, two shoulder dislocations and a torn oblique muscle, Radko Gudas had a high ankle sprain and they lost to Vegas in five games in the final. While the Edmonton Oilers looked to be in better shape going into this series with the notable exception of injured forward Zach Hyman, Florida has gotten healthier. Coach Paul Maurice said Reinhart is 'back to full health,' Tkachuk, Mikkola and Greer are making a difference and the defending champions are two wins away from hoisting the Cup for a second year in a row. 'It's always good to have a full team that's healthy," fourth-liner Tomas Nosek said after practice Wednesday. "It's been good so far, and hopefully it stays that way.' The Panthers will have their ideal lineup for Game 4 on Thursday night in Sunrise after that same group waxed Edmonton 6-1 earlier this week to take a 2-1 lead in the final. Other than do-it-all defenseman Seth Jones, no one played more than 23 minutes in Game 3. That balance, after so much overtime hockey early in what looked to be an evenly matched series, combined with an extra day between games, makes them rested and ready. 'We've been, I think, great the whole playoffs," center Anton Lundell said. 'It doesn't really matter when we play. It's always fun to play, so we don't really care. But obviously now we have had a couple days off, so it's fun to get the energy back and prepare." Reinhart scoring Monday night was his first goal since being out for two games in the Eastern Conference final, ending a drought that dated to the second round against Toronto. He had six shots in Game 2 and has been steadily progressing. 'I'm not worried about him,' Maurice said. 'I think his game is getting stronger — quite a bit stronger.' So is Tkachuk's, even if it's clear the tough winger is not moving as well as he does when 100%. But he had an assist and was noticeably better in Game 3, which Maurice called Tkachuk's best of the playoffs. 'It took him a while to build out,' Maurice said. 'The speed of the Carolina series was probably a really, really good thing. Some of these injuries I'm sure they're dealing with it, you can't condition them and rehab them at the same time. They need some time. And he was out for such a very long time that I would say the last month, but certainly the last three weeks, he's back to form now.' That spells trouble for the Oilers, playing without Hyman and with top-line forward Ryan Nugent-Hopkins dealing with an undisclosed injury that has him relegated him to game-time-decision uncertainty. Their longest-tenured player not being 100% is a major blow after Nugent-Hopkins, Connor McDavid and Hyman were such an effective trio getting to this point. Coach Kris Knoblauch foreshadowed a lineup change that may or may not be injury related. Either way, his team's depth is being tested. The same has been the case for the Panthers, who have used 22 skaters in the playoffs following 30 during the season. They've grown accustomed to shuffling players in and out and chugging along like some of the NHL's best teams have to do. 'With our depth this year, even when guys are injured or guys are out of the lineup, there's just so much depth on our team that guys can fill in seamlessly and it doesn't change our lineup that much,' Bennett said. "That's definitely a huge factor for us.' ___
Yahoo
2 hours ago
- Yahoo
Jets Fans Monitoring Allen Lazard's Status After Aaron Rodgers Signing
Jets Fans Monitoring Allen Lazard's Status After Aaron Rodgers Signing originally appeared on Athlon Sports. The Aaron Rodgers era of New York Jets football is nearly indistinguishable from the history it promised to change. Rodgers was traded to an organization with the sport's longest playoff drought, no long-term prospects under center, and a history of defunct decision-makers doing their best with poor ownership. Advertisement Head coach Robert Saleh and general manager Joe Douglas were fired before the 2024 season ended. New York still doesn't have a franchise quarterback, and for all of the chaos, urgency, and optimism, it has yet to make the playoffs since 2010, when Aaron Rodgers won the Super Bowl and 2025 starter Justin Fields was 11 years old. There is no shortage of gripes to be had with Rodgers in his two-year stint. His Achilles injury obviously wasn't his fault. But being the de facto general manager and adding several ineffective Green Bay Packers was. One such move was signing receiver Allen Lazard, a signing made before Rodgers signed but with the clear implication that he'd be recruiting him to East Rutherford. After two seasons and 841 yards, he might be on the move again. Jets fans are monitoring a potential trade after Rodgers signed with the Pittsburgh Steelers, hoping to recoup draft capital for the veteran receiver. Advertisement "Allen Lazard is a reliable veteran wide receiver. The Iowa State product has been a valuable target during his seven-year career, but could be looking for a new team soon," Bryce Lazenby wrote for Sporting News. "The reason Lazard could be on the outs in New York is because his old friend, Aaron Rodgers, finally has a new team. Lazard has always been on the same team as Rodgers, and the duo have undeniable chemistry. It's possible Lazard requests out, with his eyes set on Pittsburgh. "The Jets don't have the deepest receiver room, but they could prefer to give all of the targets to the younger guys anyway. Plus, if the team trades Lazard, it could save over $2 million." It makes more sense for New York to trade Lazard than cut him, given the dead cap they'd incur. However, the Jets might not be in a rush to move on from him. They negotiated a new contract in the offseason, taking him from an initial mark of four years and $44 million down to one year and $2.5 million. Keeping him around (or trading him to his preferred destination) would be good politics post-negotiation, and it lets him have a say in that development. He was also surprisingly efficient. In 2024, his 37 catches, 530 yards, and six touchdowns weren't all that impressive. But he managed the 13th-most expected points added per target and the 33rd-most total expected points added among receivers with at least 50 targets (per nfelo). Advertisement That's more than enough to keep around in an ancillary role, especially at his new number. Lazard reeks of Rodgers-era resource management, but there's a world in which he redefines his tenure in 2025. Related: Jets' Glenn Speaks Out On Fields' 'Man's Man' Leadership Related: Jets Coach Reveals Update on Fields' Progress This story was originally reported by Athlon Sports on Jun 11, 2025, where it first appeared.
