Indonesia should adopt EVs, draw lessons from failed methanol project in China, experts say
Indonesia should consider embracing electric vehicles (EVs) as an alternative to its plan to construct a costly methanol production facility, after a failed similar venture in China, according to energy finance specialists.
Advertisement
The ageing vehicle fleet in Southeast Asia's biggest economy may not be suitable for methanol fuel blends as the country's humid climate can cause
fuel condensation, the Ohio-based Institute for Energy Economics and Financial Analysis said in a report on Wednesday.
While a methanol-blended fuel could reduce emissions and improve performance, these benefits were offset by lower energy content and higher material corrosion, it said, noting the risks flagged in a 2021 white paper by the International Council on Clean Transportation. EVs offered a more sustainable solution, the non-profit institute added.
'Expanding the use of EVs, particularly motorcycles, offers a lower-risk, less complex and cost-effective solution than blending methanol,' said Ghee Peh, the institute's Asia-based specialist, who wrote the report. 'Neighbouring countries, such as Vietnam, have already built EV charging networks.'
Ghee Peh, an Asia-based energy finance specialist at the Institute for Energy Economics and Financial Analysis. Photo: Handout
Indonesia was building a US$1.2 billion coal-based methanol plant in East Java, aimed at boosting biodiesel output, with target completion in 2027, the institute said, citing a Jakarta Post report. The nation faces a 2 million tonne annual deficit in methanol output. The government has not provided details of the plant's gas source.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
South China Morning Post
6 hours ago
- South China Morning Post
Is Tesla stalling on India? Market entry appears in doubt after minister questions intent
Tesla's long-anticipated push to manufacture cars in India appears to be stalling, after a senior minister cast doubt on the company's intent – raising fresh questions about whether the electric vehicle giant is ready to commit to one of the world's fastest-growing car markets. Advertisement The remarks have highlighted a mismatch between India's policy efforts to attract global carmakers and Tesla's hesitant approach to committing new manufacturing investment – even as analysts believe the firm is still positioning itself for a longer-term play in the country. Speculation over the US electric vehicle giant's expansion had mounted in recent months following favourable import duty cuts, alongside the opening of a Tesla showroom in Mumbai. But in comments that undercut the excitement, India's Minister for Heavy Industries H.D. Kumaraswamy told reporters in Delhi on Monday that Tesla was 'more interested' in establishing showrooms and 'not interested' in manufacturing in India. The statement quickly sparked debate on social media, where some users argued that Tesla might be delaying its entry because it already had ample production capacity elsewhere. Others suggested the high price point of its cars limited the company's addressable market in India. A Tesla showroom showcases a Model Y vehicle. Tesla CEO Elon Musk has previously cited India's high tariffs as a key obstacle to entering the market. Photo: TNS India has taken notable steps to court Tesla. In its February budget, the government slashed tariffs on luxury vehicles priced above US$40,000 from 125 per cent to 70 per cent. It had earlier offered a separate pathway for carmakers to pay just 15 per cent in import duties – if they committed to investing at least US$500 million and building a local factory.
South China Morning Post
9 hours ago
- South China Morning Post
How Trump's tariffs could benefit Asean in the long run
US President Donald Trump's tariffs – especially the ultra-high 'reciprocal tariffs' that he says will be reintroduced on July 8 for any country that has not struck a trade deal with his administration – have sent countries around the world scrambling to respond, adapt and limit the fallout. The Association of Southeast Asian Nations' 10 members – Brunei, Cambodia, Indonesia, Laos, Malaysia, Myanmar, the Philippines, Singapore, Thailand and Vietnam – have been among the most proactive. Advertisement Their leaders quickly recognised that, after decades of spectacular gross domestic product growth, Asean is an economic force that the Trump administration would have to reckon with in a serious way. In 2000, Japan was the world's second-largest economy, some eight times larger than Asean; today, it is only 1.1 times larger, and by 2030, Asean's economy will overtake it. In 2010-2020, Asean contributed more to global economic growth than the European Union did. Asean owes much of this progress to open trade. Between 2003 and 2023, its trade with the rest of the world exploded. But the real secret to Asean's success is strong and competent leadership, exemplified, in the grouping's early years, by Singaporean prime minister Lee Kuan Yew , a Cambridge-educated lawyer, and Indonesian president Suharto, a Javanese military leader and mystic. It was their unlikely partnership that kept Asean together. Asean's leaders have upheld relative peace and stability in their countries, while cultivating a culture of consultation and consensus in guiding regional relations. This stands in stark contrast to the experiences of many other developing countries and regions. Advertisement
South China Morning Post
12 hours ago
- South China Morning Post
Malaysia orders telecoms firms to hand over user data, raising privacy concerns
The Malaysian government has ordered the country's telecommunications firms to hand over detailed records of phone calls and internet usage, according to industry sources, raising concerns about the state's use of data as it broadens its controls over online activity. In April, the Malaysian Communications and Multimedia Commission sent a letter to telecoms companies instructing them to send detailed call and internet logs for the first three months of this year, apparently for the government's Mobile Phone Data project, two industry sources confirmed. Non-compliance would be considered an offence under the Communications and Multimedia Act, which carries a penalty of a 20,000 ringgit (US$4,700) fine or six months' jail, the commission said in the letter seen by This Week in Asia. 'They are asking for call records, IP call records, location, latitude and longitude,' one source said. 'We have asked MCMC about transparency and accountability for the use of the data. We don't know if MCMC will make a public statement that such an exercise is under way.' The MCMC did not immediately respond to a request for comment. Prime Minister Anwar Ibrahim 's administration imposed mandatory licensing for social media platforms in January in a bid to stamp out scams, online gambling and child sex exploitation targeted at Malaysians.
