Ousted vaccine panel members say rigorous science is being abandoned
U.S. Health Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. abruptly fired the entire Advisory Committee on Immunization Practices, accusing them of being too closely aligned with manufacturers and of rubber-stamping vaccines. He handpicked replacements that include several vaccine skeptics.
In a commentary published Wednesday in the New England Journal of Medicine, the former panel members wrote that Kennedy — a leading voice in the anti-vaccine movement before becoming the U.S. government's top health official — and his new panel are abandoning rigorous scientific review and open deliberation.
That was clear, they said, during the new panel's first meeting, in June. It featured a presentation by an anti-vaccine advocate that warned of dangers about a preservative used in a few flu vaccines, but the committee members didn't hear from Centers for Disease Control and Prevention staffers about an analysis that concluded there was no link between the preservative and neurodevelopmental disorders.
The new panel recommended that the preservative, thimerosal, be removed even as some members acknowledged there was no proof it was causing harm.
'That meeting was a travesty, honestly,' said former ACIP member Dr. Yvonne Maldonado, a pediatric infectious diseases expert at Stanford University.
The 17 discharged experts last month published a shorter essay in the Journal of the American Medical Association that decried Kennedy's 'destabilizing decisions." The focus was largely on their termination and on Kennedy's decision in May to stop recommending COVID-19 vaccines for healthy children and pregnant women.
In the new commentary, the ousted committee members took it one step further and prescribed some steps that could be taken to maintain scientifically sound vaccine recommendations.
'An alternative to the Committee should be established quickly and — if necessary — independently from the federal government," they wrote. 'No viable pathway exists to fully replace the prior trusted and unbiased ACIP structure and process. Instead, the alternatives must focus on limiting the damage to vaccination policy in the United States.'
Options included having professional organizations working together to harmonize vaccine recommendations or establishing an external auditor of ACIP recommendations. There are huge challenges to the ideas, including having access to the best data, the authors acknowledged.
There's also the question of whether health insurers would pay for vaccinations that are recommended by alternative groups but not ACIP.
They might pick and choose which vaccines to cover, said the University of North Carolina's Noel Brewer, another former ACIP member.
For example, they might pay for vaccines that offer more immediate cost savings for health care, like the flu vaccine.
'But maybe not ones that have a longer-term benefit like HPV vaccine,' which is designed to prevent futures cancers, Brewer said.
Officials with the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services did not immediately respond to a request for comment.
___
The Associated Press Health and Science Department receives support from the Howard Hughes Medical Institute's Science and Educational Media Group and the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation. The AP is solely responsible for all content.
Solve the daily Crossword
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CBS News
2 minutes ago
- CBS News
Canadian wildfires fueling poor air quality in Michigan may not stop until snowfall, officials say
Smoke from Canadian wildfires has given Southeast Michigan some of the worst air quality on earth, and there doesn't seem to be any end any time soon, according to the Michigan Department of Natural Resources. Officials said they've sent several crews to assist in controlling the massive wildfires, and they don't expect them to stop until Canada sees some snow. "They probably won't go out until we get snow. That will be the kicker," said DNR resource protection manager Jeff Vasher. Hundreds of miles away from where these fires are burning, summer has looked hazy in Michigan. The DNR says there's only so much firefighters can do to stop them. "They don't have a lot of people to put these fires out, and they're so big they can't get any equipment in like we can here. Everything is hoses and pumps. There's no rain in the long-term forecast to help them out," Vasher said. Vasher said roughly 3 million acres of land are burning in Saskatchewan, Manitoba, and western Ontario, which is equivalent to roughly three-quarters of all public land in Michigan. "We all help out each other, and right now, Manitoba needs our help, so Minnesota, Wisconsin, and us we've been putting crews together to send up every two weeks," Vasher said. CBS News Detroit issued 18 NEXT Weather alert days in 2025 alone for wildfire smoke. Doctors say it puts those with underlying lung issues at risk. "Young children with asthma, elderly patients with COPD or other underlying lung issues," said Dr. Rahul Mehta, emergency medicine chair at Trinity Health Oakland. Mehta gave some advice on how to prepare for these conditions for those at risk. "If you have a child, adult, relative with COPD or asthma, make sure they have their inhaler with them. Do they need to be out for prolonged periods? Can they go in?" he said.
CNN
2 minutes ago
- CNN
The best knee braces, according to physical therapists and orthopedists
Knee braces quick picks Compression knee brace: Copper Fit Freedom Knee Compression Sleeve Patella support knee brace: Bauerfiend GenuTrain Knee Support Brace Wraparound knee brace: BioSkin Wraparound Patella Stabilizer Hinged knee brace: DonJoy Performance Hinged Knit Knee Brace If you're recovering from an injury or just looking for a bit of stability during activity, the best knee brace for your needs should keep you feeling comfortable, supported and safe. But finding the right brace can be tricky depending on the type of support your joint needs. Not to worry. We spoke to orthopedic surgeons and physical therapists about a range of knee brace designs and options so you can be on the mend quickly. While this list can certainly serve as a starting point for your quest for better joint support, you'll definitely want to consult your primary health care provider before making a decision on the right knee brace for you. Bonus: They'll also be able to offer some exercises to help with knee pain to maximize your recovery and ultimate comfort. Copper Fit Freedom Knee Compression Sleeve 'This is a good brace for general support for daily activity or with aerobic activity,' Dr. Sudheer Reddy, a board-certified orthopedic surgeon at Shady Grove Orthopaedics, said. He recommends the sleeve since it's comfortable to wear and slim enough to fit under clothing. Since it features grippy bands around the top and bottom to make sure it stays in place while you move, it's an especially great option for active folks who tend to sweat. It's also a budget-friendly find, coming in under $15. DonJoy Drytex Sport Hinged Knee Sleeve Reddy likes this knee brace because of the stability its hinges provide and because it's made with DonJoy's Drytex fabric. He called the fabric 'an alternative to neoprene' (which some wearers may find causes hot spots) and noted that it allows for greater breathability, which is ideal for higher sweat activities like running. Its hinges on both sides create crucial stability, but you'll still experience flexibility without feeling restricted. DonJoy Performance Hinged Knit Knee Brace Alexandra D'Annibale, a physical therapist at Spear Center, recommends this brace because it's designed with a four-way stretch material that will accommodate your joints as you move throughout the day. It features removable plastic hinges, which promote both medial and lateral stability, but if you don't need them, you can always remove them for more of a sleeve-like fit. Its patella buttress is designed to support your kneecap, and the compressive design helps minimize swelling. Breg Recover Knee Brace 'This is a hinged knee brace that features 'drop locks' that can help restrict motion and guide rehabilitation for individuals recovering from injury or surgery,' Reddy said. "It is very good at restricting side-to-side motion at the knee that can increase chances of injury.' This brace is bulkier than other options on the market, meaning it might not create a streamlined fit under tighter clothes. But it can be locked in five different positions and has a universal fit to suit both your right and left legs. CVS Knee Support Sleeve D'Annibale explained that compression sleeves are knee braces that offer mild support and can help reduce swelling without restricting your range of motion. She recommends this simple CVS brand support sleeve that's easy to wash after wear, offers flexible support and comes in four different sizes so you can find one that fits just right. Your kneecap should sit just under the lighter part of the fabric, which helps you guide the brace into the right spot. Breg Hinged Knee Support Brace 'This is a good wraparound brace with cushioning around the patella and a breathable material,' Reddy said of this brace for mild ligament instabilities. He appreciates its adjustable straps that prevent it from sliding down and that the brace is overall easy to put on and fit around your joint. It's also washable thanks to its removable hinges. Bauerfiend GenuTrain Knee Support Brace 'Most often, I recommend the open-kneecap sleeve to support patella tracking or one of the Bauerfeind Knee Supports, which come with a gel pad that sits around the patella,' Darcie Pervier, a physical therapist and owner of Newburyport Wellness in Massachusetts, told CNN Underscored contributor Marissa Miller for this story. 'The Bauerfeind supports are made with a knit fabric that is breathable, and when fitted well, they don't slide down as easily as many sleeves." DonJoy Tru-Pull Lite Knee Brace 'Pain in the front of the knee, called patellofemoral pain, is a common problem encountered by patients,' Reddy said. 'Issues can range from arthritis of the patellofemoral joint to patellar instability ([when the] kneecap can slide out of place).' Reddy recommends this wraparound brace because of the lateral buttress strap that helps stabilize the patella during activity. The strap doesn't just secure the brace around your thigh and calf; it pulls the whole device to fit around the whole of your knee joint. Breg Fusion OA Plus Knee Brace If you're looking for something top-of-the-line, Reddy suggests this brace from Breg. 'Knee arthritis is very common in individuals. While this brace is bulkier and more expensive, it's helpful in reducing stress to the arthritic parts of the knee during activity,' he said. Reddy also likes that it has adjustable Velcro straps that help tailor fit to a person's knee and it features hinges on either side to help support the knee and allow freedom of movement during activity. Use it for low-impact activities such as walking, tennis and golf. DonJoy Performance Bionic Knee Brace Pervier told us this brace is light enough to wear while you're fairly active, but it still offers more physical support than a sleeve due to its hinges, which provide lateral support. The brace also has anti-slip technology to keep it in place while you're moving, and adjustable straps for a customized fit. Pervier notes that even though it offers decent lateral stability, this brace isn't designed for major knee injuries. BioSkin Wraparound Patella Stabilizer Knee Brace Julie Landis, a physical therapist and certified professional ergonomist, told Miller she recommends this neoprene option from BioSkin. The fabric makes the brace easy to slide on, and Landis notes the compression can help reduce pain and swelling. In addition to adjustable straps at the top and bottom of the brace, this option has a patellar tracking strap that can be positioned medially or laterally. Landis said this feature can 'help properly guide and control its movement during bending and straightening.' Mueller Sports Medicine Self-Adjusting Hinged Knee Brace If you're looking for a more budget-friendly option, this pick from Mueller Sports Medicine is under $30. Lisa Chase, an orthopedic and sports physical therapist and owner of Back 2 Normal Physical Therapy, spoke with Miller and recommends this affordable option because it offers moderate stabilization but is still comfortable and versatile. It's made from a neoprene material that's comfortable for long wear, allowing for flexibility while you move. It's another hinged option to provide lateral stability. Shock Doctor Ultra Knit Knee Support Chase told CNN Underscored that she likes this brace for athletes who need both compression and stability. This compressive brace comes in four sizes and has been designed with a moisture-wicking material. This will help wick away sweat during a grueling workout. Its patella gel buttress helps provide support and cushioning to your patella (without a cumbersome wraparound strap) so it's easy to put on and remove. Neenca Hinged Knee Brace Landis told us that she recommends this hinged brace from Neenca. If you're healing from an injury, this brace is designed to block movement, restricting your joint to a safe range of motion or maintaining it in a fixed position. The sides of this brace have two-sided locking dials, which fix the brace in place and can be unlocked to adjust your range of motion. Dr. Brace Professional Knee Brace Four adjustable straps, patella gel pads and side stabilizers round out this brace. Pervier recommends a wraparound brace for clients who may be struggling with arthritis in their hands as well as their knees, since the brace is easier than others to slide on compared to a sleeve. This pick from Dr. Brace offers both light compression and stability for the joint. If your doctor has recommended a knee brace, chances are they have walked you through what to look for to best address your unique situation. But if you're dealing with an old injury or just looking for extra support, there are lots of options on the market that can help fast-track your healing. Type of knee brace There are two types of knee braces to consider. The first is a compression sleeve, which is designed to help with swelling and offer mild support. D'Annibale noted these types of braces typically don't restrict your joint movement. The other kind is a hinged brace, which D'Annibale said is used for joint stability and protection. Hinged braces don't provide compression. Material You'll also want to consider the material of the brace. If you're looking to wear a brace while playing sports, walking, running or participating in higher-impact activities that promote sweat production, look for something washable and sweat-wicking. While neoprene is a fabric our experts called out for its comfort and breathability, Lynn J. Berman, owner and physical therapist at Spring Forward PT, noted you'll also find knee sleeves made with copper-infused material and fabric sleeves. These materials can offer sweat-wicking properties or have a more thin, streamlined design for wearing under clothes. Activity For a knee brace best suited for your purposes, D'Annibale suggests identifying what type of activity you'll be wearing it for. She noted that the style of brace will vary whether you're using it for everyday activity or for post-operation support. If you're unsure, consult a physical therapist to determine what type of support you might need before you make your purchase. The following FAQs were answered by Lynn J. Berman, owner and physical therapist at Spring Forward PT and Alexandra D'Annibale, a physical therapist at Spear Center. Are knee braces considered compression? Are knee braces considered compression? The simple answer is no. Not all knee braces are considered compression braces. Specific knee braces offer compression, so you'll have to look for one that does if that's the type of support you require. D'Annibale breaks knee braces down into two categories: compression braces (also referred to as sleeves) and hinged braces. If you're looking for something compressive, you'll typically find that terminology listed in the brace's description. Can you use a knee brace and a knee sleeve together? Can you use a knee brace and a knee sleeve together? 'Yes, wearing a compression sleeve [also known as a knee sleeve] under a knee brace is common, particularly following surgery,' D'Annibale said. She noted that the sleeve can help manage swelling while a brace offers structural support during recovery. Structural support can help limit movement of the joint so you don't overexert it while healing. How do you put on a knee brace? How do you put on a knee brace? D'Annibale said that you can put on a compression sleeve by sliding it over your foot and up your leg. She noted you'll want to position the brace so your kneecap is centered and the brace lies flat on your body without bunching anywhere. For hinged braces, she recommended beginning with straps open. Then, position the brace behind your knee, aligning the hinges with the joint. Fasten the straps in the recommended order — typically from bottom to top — ensuring a snug but comfortable fit. For this article, we consulted the following experts to gain their professional insights. Lynn J. Berman, owner and physical therapist at Spring Forward PT Lisa Chase, an orthopedic and sports physical therapist and owner of Back 2 Normal Physical Therapy Alexandra D'Annibale, a physical therapist with Spear Center Julie Landis, a physical therapist and certified professional ergonomist Darcie Pervier, a physical therapist and owner of Newburyport Wellness Dr. Sudheer Reddy, board-certified orthopedic surgeon at Shady Grove Orthopaedics CNN Underscored has a team of skilled writers and editors who have many years of experience testing, researching and recommending products, and they ensure each article is carefully edited and products are properly vetted. We talk to top experts when applicable to make certain we are testing each product accurately, recommending only the best products and considering the pros and cons of each item. For this article, writer Ellen McAlpine and contributing editor Marissa Miller spoke with orthopedic doctors and physical therapists to learn more about expert-recommended knee braces. McAlpine compiled this list of braces to help you recover, heal and stay active.
Yahoo
29 minutes ago
- Yahoo
What to know about chikungunya virus in China as US issues travel alert
The U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention has issued a travel warning following an outbreak of a mosquito-borne illness called chikungunya in China. The CDC's warning centers on Guangdong Province, where the outbreak has exceeded 7,000 confirmed cases since June 2025, according to Chinese health officials. The outbreak in Guangdong Province has been linked to monsoon flooding, which created ideal breeding conditions for mosquitoes, which spread the virus that causes chikungunya. In the new travel warning, the CDC emphasized that vaccination is available and recommended for travelers. Dr. Todd Ellerin, chief of infectious disease at South Shore Health in Massachusetts, told ABC News that travelers to the region "should absolutely take precautions" against the illness. "Wear long sleeves and pants, use insect repellent with DEET, and use mosquito netting for babies too young for repellent," said Ellerin, who is not affiliated with the CDC. Here is what to know about the illness. How common is chikungunya? Chikungunya is not a new infection. It has been around since the 1950s, with outbreaks more commonly seen in tropical areas in recent decades. Globally, there have been about 240,000 infections since the start of 2025, according to the European Centre for Disease Prevention and Control. Chikungunya is not common in the United States. The CDC says there have not been any reported locally acquired cases since 2019. What are the symptoms of chikungunya? According to the CDC, common symptoms of the virus include sudden-onset high fever, severe joint pain (especially in the hands, wrists, ankles, and feet), muscle pain, headache, fatigue and skin rash. Georgia woman describes crippling pain of chikungunya virus Most people recover without medical intervention within seven to 10 days, but in some cases, symptoms can persist for weeks or months. What is the incubation period for chikungunya? Chikungunya typically has an incubation period of less than one week, according to Ellerin. "If it's been more than a week since you left a high-risk area, you're likely in the clear," he said. How is chikungunya treated? There is no specific antiviral treatment for chikungunya. Instead, care focuses on relieving symptoms while the body recovers. The CDC recommends rest, fluids, and medications like acetaminophen for pain and fever. NSAIDs may be used once dengue, another mosquito-borne disease, has been ruled out. Deaths from chikungunya are rare, according to the CDC. Is there a vaccine for chikungunya? There are two vaccines available in the U.S. that begin offering protection within about two weeks of a single dose. Cases of mosquito-borne viruses on the rise The CDC recommends vaccination for travelers visiting areas with active outbreaks, people spending extend time abroad -- typically six months or longer -- and laboratory workers who handle the virus. What contributes to the spread of chikungunya? Climate change is a major driver of chikungunya's global spread. "Warmer temperatures and increased rainfall are helping Aedes mosquitoes expand into new regions," Dr. Krutika Kuppalli of the division of infectious diseases at the University of Texas Southwestern Medical Center told ABC News. Veer Patel, M.D., is an emergency medicine doctor at Maimonides Medical Center and a member of the ABC News Medical Unit. Solve the daily Crossword
