‘Great Mughals' show in London reinforces colonial perspectives that museums claim to be questioning
The continued privileging of opulence – isolated from the complex political, intellectual, and religious histories that undergird it – risks reiterating the very colonial imaginaries that museums now claim to be interrogating.
The exhibition's title alone signals a retreat into a historiographical mode that foregrounds aesthetic excess as the defining feature of the Mughal period. This is, of course, not without precedent. British colonial scholarship long deployed the visual richness of the Mughal court as a rhetorical device to simultaneously admire and diminish – to portray it as decadent, ornamental, and politically effete.
By reproducing this frame without critical engagement, the Victoria and Albert Museum misses an opportunity to reframe Mughal visuality within the evolving debates around decolonial museology and postcolonial historiography.
Closing soon - The Great Mughals: Art, Architecture and Opulence @V_and_A and The 80s: Photographing Britain @Tate Britain, both in my #TopPicks for @Londonist >> https://t.co/NmcCowqd0j #LondonArtCritic #LondonExhibitions pic.twitter.com/W3ioYkXuWt
— Tabish Khan (@LondonArtCritic) April 28, 2025
Structurally, the exhibition is organised around the conventional imperial triad of Akbar, Jahangir, and Shah Jahan – figures who have long dominated narratives of Mughal art. Yet this familiar periodisation reproduces a monolithic view of dynastic succession, marginalising other regions, actors, and modalities of artistic production.
Moreover, the geographical framing remains opaque: a gesture toward Gujarat by dedicating a section on objects that point towards the proliferation of trade and cultural exchange in this region during the Mughal period, for instance, acknowledges the region's importance in early modern global trade but fails to meaningfully connect it to the broader Mughal visual economy. The result is a fragmented inclusion that appears more curatorial convenience than conceptual necessity.
The exhibition design, while visually restrained, offers little in the way of critical provocation. A linear spatial logic and uneven lighting suggest an aestheticised encounter rather than an interpretive one. While many of the objects on display – albums, textiles, architectural fragments – are remarkable in their own right, the interpretive framing tends to rely on their intrinsic beauty rather than on a nuanced curatorial argument.
This places undue weight on the objects themselves to 'speak', without sufficient engagement with the methodological questions their display should raise.
More of the The Great Mughals: Art, Architecture and Opulence show at the V&A. Pieces of the pietra dura panels from the Taj Mahal show this arduously intricate technique of filling carved surfaces of marble panes with semi precious stones. pic.twitter.com/uu8kP07WlZ
— Nasser Rabbat (@nasserrabbat) January 5, 2025
Notably absent are holdings from major collections of Mughal painting and manuscript culture in Iran and Russia, which could have complicated the national and imperial boundaries often presumed in exhibitions of this kind. In this sense, 'The Great Mughals' presents a selective and at times insular vision of a profoundly transregional empire. The absence of such material not only limits the exhibition's scholarly reach but also undermines its claim to comprehensiveness.
For audiences in the Global North, the exhibition may pass as a well-appointed foray into South Asian splendour. But for scholars attuned to the politics of cultural representation, the elisions are conspicuous.
As decolonisation becomes a watchword across museums in Europe and North America, it is no longer sufficient to mount exhibitions that celebrate aesthetic brilliance while leaving intact the systems of knowledge that rendered those aesthetics legible through colonial frames. To do so is to focus on cosmetic changes instead of questioning the underlying structure.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Economic Times
40 minutes ago
- Economic Times
Two men asked famous Bollywood actress on a date at the same time. Confused, she let her cat decide. Now one of them is her husband
Synopsis Radhika Apte, now embracing motherhood after welcoming her daughter in December 2024, has an intriguing love story. Her marriage to Benedict Taylor began unconventionally when a cat chose him over another suitor via a tuna-based test. Read on to know what happened in detail! Radhika Apte tied the knot of love and together with long-time boyfriend Benedict Taylor in 2012. Bollywood actor Radhika Apte is currently embracing the new phase in her life, motherhood, with the birth of her daughter in December 2024. While fans were very happy after the announcement, it was Radhika's old viral clip about her quirky first date that caught everyone's attention. She once revealed how a cat and a can of tuna helped decide her romantic fate. The cat did, and the rest, as they say, is history. Yes, you read it. In 2022, during her appearance on The Kapil Sharma Show , Radhika Apte recalled a funny story from her dating days. She shared that two men had asked her out on the same day, leaving her uncertain about whom to choose. To settle the dilemma, she and her roommate devised an unusual plan involving a neighbourhood cat that often visited their home. They placed tuna fish out for the cat, deciding that if it ate the fish, she would go out with Benedict Taylor. The cat did, and that whimsical decision led to the start of her relationship with Benedict, who is now her husband. Radhika frequently travels to London to spend time with love story with British avant-garde musician Benedict Taylor began in 2011 when the actress was in London studying contemporary dance. The two formed an instant connection, and despite the challenges of a long-distance relationship, they managed to stay strong. In 2012, the couple tied the knot in a quiet ceremony in Northern England, later celebrating with close friends and family in marriage wasn't always easy. Radhika has been candid about the emotional toll of managing a long-distance relationship, describing it as "heartbreaking" at times. Still, both she and Benedict made consistent efforts to meet frequently, bridging the miles between India and the UK. Benedict Taylor is no stranger to Indian audiences. A noted experimental violinist and composer, he has made a mark through his work in Indian cinema. His projects include acclaimed films such as Udta Punjab, Newton, Ghoul, Laal Kaptaan, and popular series like Kohrra and Heeramandi . He also collaborates with Naren Chandavarkar in the musical duo 'Naren & Benedict,' composing scores for films, theatre, and dance productions. On the professional front, Radhika Apte continues to impress. She was last seen in Sister Midnight, released in India on May 30, 2025. The film, directed by Karan Kandhari, received critical praise for its bold ahead, Radhika is set to star in Last Days, an English-language biographical drama based on the life of American missionary John Allen Chau. Directed by Justin Lin, the film premiered at the Sundance Film Festival in January 2025 and is scheduled for a theatrical release in the United States on October 24.
Time of India
2 hours ago
- Time of India
Famous Bollywood screenplay writer behind 4 blockbusters once slept in chawls, danced for the rich at parties
Shagufta Rafique , the creative mind behind celebrated films such as Aashiqui 2 and Murder 2 , has lived a life as intense and turbulent as the stories she scripted. While audiences know her for crafting emotional dramas and suspenseful narratives on the big screen, her personal story carries the weight of survival, heartbreak, and resilience. Independence Day 2025 Modi signals new push for tech independence with local chips Before Trump, British used tariffs to kill Indian textile Bank of Azad Hind: When Netaji Subhas Chandra Bose gave India its own currency A Childhood Marked by Poverty and Uncertainty In an interview with Filmfare , Shagufta revealed that she never knew her biological parents. She was raised by Anwari Begum, a once-recognized actress from the old film industry. People around them often speculated that Shagufta was actually the child of Anwari's daughter, born from a relationship before marriage. Some even whispered that she had been abandoned on the streets before Anwari took her in. Despite the rumors, the truth about her parentage remained a mystery throughout her life. Anwari initially provided for Shagufta alone, but circumstances shifted dramatically when financial difficulties consumed their household. Forced to sell personal belongings such as bangles and utensils to cover basic expenses, the once-comfortable life dissolved into hardship. At the tender age of 12, Shagufta began performing dance numbers at parties to contribute financially. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Brain tumor has left my son feeling miserable; please help! Donate For Health Donate Now Undo These events, often held in hidden apartments, carried the ambience of informal brothels where wealthy men brought their mistresses and companions. Shagufta remembered vividly how she would collect currency notes scattered across the floor, unaware of the larger implications of her surroundings. Entering a Darker World at Seventeen By the age of 17, the challenges intensified. As Shagufta admitted during a conversation with Pakistan's Geo TV, she entered sex work, a decision born not from desire but from desperation. Her mother knew of her choice and strongly disapproved, yet the immediate need for money pushed Shagufta forward. With her earnings, she could afford food luxuries like chicken and prawns and even purchased gold bangles for Anwari. She described feeling like the 'provider of the house,' making around Rs. 3,000 each night. For the next decade, this became her way of life. Though it weighed heavily on her spirit, the income secured their survival. Eventually, acquaintances suggested she try her luck in Dubai, where dancing in bars offered another opportunity to earn. The Dubai Years and a Guardian Angel Arriving in Dubai, Shagufta began singing and dancing for audiences in bars. She admitted to Geo TV that the environment initially terrified her—the sight of people smoking and drinking unsettled her, and for days, she barely earned anything. Soon after, however, she encountered a 45-year-old man who showered her with generosity and affection. Within a week, he proposed marriage. Though they never married, Shagufta viewed him as her savior, a figure who protected her and gave her the courage to dream of a different future. Her time in Dubai lasted a few years until tragedy struck back home. In 1999, her adoptive mother Anwari was diagnosed with cancer, prompting Shagufta to return to India to care for her. Discovering Writing as a Lifeline After enduring years of pain and loss, a turning point arrived in 2002 when Shagufta met filmmaker Mahesh Bhatt . Speaking to Filmfare, she recalled how she longed to transform her harsh memories into stories. Having endured life in cramped chawls and slept on grimy mattresses used by others before her, she wanted to give voice to the suffering she had witnessed and experienced. Bhatt recognized her potential and gave her the encouragement she needed. 'I had slept in chawls, on dirty pillows; on dirty mattresses, where several girls had slept before and entertained multi millionaires… I wanted to write it all down," she told Filmfare. Her screenwriting journey formally began in 2006 when she contributed scenes to Mohit Suri's Kalyug, a film that echoed some fragments of her own past. From there, her career gained momentum as she wrote scripts for notable projects such as Woh Lamhe, Awarapan, Raaz: The Mystery Continues, Murder 2, and eventually, the highly successful Aashiqui 2. Each screenplay reflected her ability to pour raw emotion into fictional characters, creating stories that resonated deeply with audiences. Later Work and Legacy Shagufta Rafique later extended her writing talent beyond Bollywood, contributing to television. Her most recent credited work was the Pakistani TV drama Lambi Judai. Her story, however, remains more compelling than any script she could compose. From the despair of poverty to the harsh realities of sex work, and finally to recognition as a writer in Indian cinema, Shagufta transformed tragedy into art. Through resilience and creativity, she proved that even the most painful beginnings can lead to powerful new chapters.
Hindustan Times
3 hours ago
- Hindustan Times
With the Bayeux Tapestry that tells of their long rivalry, France and Britain are making nice
BAYEUX, France — For centuries, the storytelling masterpiece has been a source of wonder and fascination. In vivid and gruesome detail, the 70-meter embroidered cloth recounts how a fierce duke from France conquered England in 1066, reshaping British and European history. With the Bayeux Tapestry that tells of their long rivalry, France and Britain are making nice The Bayeux Tapestry, with its scenes of sword-wielding knights in ferocious combat and King Harold of England's famous death, pierced by an arrow to an eye, has since the 11th century served as a sobering parable of military might, vengeance, betrayal and the complexity of Anglo-French relations, long seeped with blood and rivalry but also affection and cooperation. Now, the medieval forerunner of today's comic strips, commissioned as propaganda for the Normandy duke William known as 'the Conqueror' after he took the English throne from Harold, is being readied for a new narrative mission. Next year, the fragile artistic and historic treasure will be gingerly transported from its museum in Bayeux, Normandy, to star in a blockbuster exhibition in London's British Museum, from September 2026 to July 2027. Its first U.K. outing in almost 1,000 years will testify to the warming latest chapter in ties across the English Channel that chilled with the U.K.'s acrimonous departure from the European Union in 2020. The loan was announced in July when French President Emmanuel Macron became the first EU head of state to pay a state visit to the U.K. since Brexit. Bayeux Museum curator Antoine Verney says the cross-Channel trip will be a home-coming of sorts for the tapestry, because historians widely believe that it was embroidered in England, using woolen threads on linen canvas, and because William's victory at the Battle of Hastings was such a major juncture in English history, seared into the U.K.'s collective consciousness. 'For the British, the date — the only date — that all of them know is 1066,' Verney said in an interview with The Associated Press. Moving an artwork so unwieldy — made from nine pieces of linen fabric stitched together and showing 626 characters, 37 buildings, 41 ships and 202 horses and mules in a total of 58 scenes — is further complicated by its great age and the wear-and-tear of time. 'There is always a risk. The goal is for those risks to be as carefully calculated as possible,' said Verney, the curator. Believed to have been commissioned by Bishop Odo, William the Conqueror's half-brother, to decorate a new cathedral in Bayeux in 1077, the treasure is thought to have remained there, mostly stored in a wooden chest and almost unknown, for seven centuries, surviving the French Revolution, fires and other perils. Since then, only twice is the embroidery known to have been exhibited outside of the Normandy city: Napoleon Bonaparte had it shown off in Paris' Louvre Museum from late 1803 to early 1804. During World War II, it was displayed again in the Louvre in late 1944, after Allied forces that had landed in Normandy on D-Day, th, of that year had fought onward to Paris and liberated it. The work, seen by more than 15 million visitors in its Bayeux museum since 1983, 'has the unique characteristic of being both monumental and very fragile,' Verney said. 'The textile fibers are 900 years old. So they have naturally degraded simply due to age. But at the same time, this is a work that has already traveled extensively and been handled a great deal.' During the treasure's stay in the U.K., its museum in Bayeux will be getting a major facelift costing tens of millions of euros . The doors will close to visitors from Sept. 1 this year, with reopening planned for October 2027, when the embroidery will be re-housed in a new building, encased on an inclined 70-meter long table that Verney said will totally transform the viewing experience. How, exactly, the treasure will be transported to the U.K. isn't yet clear. 'The studies required to allow its transfer to London and its exhibition at the British Museum are not finished, are under discussion, and are being carried out between the two governments,' Verney said. But he expressed confidence that it will be in safe hands. 'How can one imagine, in my view, that the British Museum would risk damaging, through the exhibition, this work that is a major element of a shared heritage?' he asked. 'I don't believe that the British could take risks that would endanger this major element of art history and of world heritage.' Leicester reported from Paris. This article was generated from an automated news agency feed without modifications to text.
