HC orders BMC to form team to identify, remove encroachments on footpaths
'This is not an isolated incident as many cases of this kind are reaching the court,' the division bench of justices GS Kulkarni and Arif Doctor said. 'For ages, the municipal corporation would not be taking any action or its officers taking selective action, and again such encroachments being restored, appears to be the rule.'
In their petition, the housing societies alleged that the footpath outside their premises was encroached by temporary tin/ plastic tenements that were being used for residential and commercial purposes.
Advocate Priti Shah, appearing for the housing societies, told the court that the tenements were constructed about a year ago and no action was taken against them despite repeated complaints to civic authorities.
The judges took serious note of the encroachments, and asked if the BMC and its officers could turn a blind eye to encroachments when footpaths had been constructed at considerable public expense so that people did not have to walk on busy roads and be vulnerable to accidents.
'We cannot hear from the municipal corporation that it has become impossible for its officers to perform the duties and responsibilities cast on them in law,' the court said.
Encroachments cannot come up without the tacit consent of concerned ward officers and municipal officers who do not take action against encroachments or persons interested in encroachments deprive Mumbaikars of basic public facilities for the convenience of a few, the court said.
'Actions as the law would mandate need to be taken against them,' the court stated.
The court also stressed on the need for appropriate hawking zones, saying plots belonging to municipal corporations or the state government that have been encroached upon could be utilised for such purposes.
The court directed the BMC to submit an action taken report on the aforesaid observations on July 14, the next date of hearing.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Indian Express
2 hours ago
- Indian Express
Kerala IT firm CEO, who accused ex-employee of extortion, faces sexual harassment complaint from her
An alleged extortion case against a woman former employee of an IT firm and her husband has taken a turn with the CEO of the same company and his three colleagues now facing a case of sexual harassment on the complaint of the woman. A day after Kochi infopark police registered the case against the CEO of Litmus 7 Systems Consulting Private Limited, Venu Gopalakrishnan, on Wednesday, he sought pre-arrest bail from the High Court. The HC restrained the arrest of his colleagues Jacob P Thamby, Eby Paul and Bimalraj Haridas till the government prosecutor files instructions from the police. However, the HC has not given any relief to 51-year-old Venu booked for criminal intimidation, insulting modesty of woman and sexual harassment. The CEO and others faced the case a week after his former colleague and her husband were arrested on charges of extortion. After obtaining bail, the couple filed complaints with police higher ups, leading to registration of FIR against Venu and others. Last month, Venu, in his complaint, had alleged that the couple had accused him of having an affair with the woman and threatened him with a rape case to extort money . He alleged that on July 23, she contacted the three staff members of the company and asked them to come to a hotel in Kochi where the couple allegedly demanded Rs 30 crore to settle the matter. The couple allegedly sought an assurance in writing from Venu and asked him to transfer `10 crore to her account and two cheques for the remaining amount. On July 28, Rs 50,000 was transferred from Venu's account to that of the woman's. The next day, the couple were arrested by the police on charges of extortion and remanded in judicial custody. Days later after they got bail, the couple complained to police alleging sexual harassment by Venu when she worked with him. She said she joined the company in February 2024 and quit after getting married earlier this year, but she alleged that her former employer continued to pester her. She alleged that when she and her husband were about to lodge a complaint against the CEO, the three representatives of the company came for mediation. She alleged that the staff told her Venu was ready to apologise and asked the couple to come to a hotel on July 29, where they were arrested. The couple, in their complaint, said Venu transferred Rs 50,000 to her bank account without information her. In her complaint, she gave details about the alleged incidents of sexual harassment.
Hindustan Times
3 hours ago
- Hindustan Times
Protestors tear Dadar kabutarkhana plastic cover, feed pigeons despite HC order
STRAP: Hours later, the leaders backtracked and claimed the vandals were 'outsiders' Protestors tear Dadar kabutarkhana plastic cover, feed pigeons despite HC order MUMBAI: Despite the order by the chief minister and an upcoming Bombay high court hearing, a 1,000-strong mob of the Jain community descended on the Dadar Kabutarkhana on Wednesday morning. With women taking the lead, they began attacking the plastic covering thrown over the kabutarkhana with knives and blades even as the police tried in vain to stop them. Damage done, they proceeded to pour sacks of chana for the pigeons on the traffic island in direct contravention of the court order and BMC rules. Hours later, however, the Dadar Kabutarkhana Trust and the Jain community backtracked and claimed they were not responsible for the vandalism. 'On Tuesday night, we sent out messages to say the protest had been postponed, as our meeting with the CM was favourable,' said trustee Sandeep Doshi, displaying the alleged message. 'It was outsiders who came and caused the havoc. Then the crowd's anger took over, all to make us look bad politically.' Vijayraj Parmar, chairman of the Shantinathji Maharaj Jain Derasar Trust opposite Dadar Kabutarkhana, parroted this, saying the 'protestors' were not from Dadar. 'But they saw hundreds of pigeons dying after the feeding stopped, and wanted to stop it immediately,' he said. However, many shopkeepers in the area and BMC officials clearly stated the protestors were from the Jain community, having shown their allegiance to the cause of pigeon feeding, including holding a protest march last Sunday. Eyewitnesses reported seeing the protestors coming from 9.30 am, waiting at the Jain temple for a bit before getting riled up and moving in for the attack. By the time the police could control the crowd, the damage was already done. 'We were taken by surprise,' said an official from G North ward. 'Initially, we were informed that the protest had been called off. But the crowd turned up and tore off the plastic covering. As this is a sensitive issue, we will wait to hear the Bombay high court's order on Thursday.' Puran Doshi, a former corporator, also parroted the account that the protestors were not locals and went on to call the HC order 'misguided'. 'Pigeons are one among the many causes of pulmonary diseases, and yet the head of the pulmonary department at KEM hospital has only zeroed in on pigeons, and not many other things that are harmful,' he said. 'The Maharashtra government and BMC are acting in the interests of the towers around the kabutarkhana. I will demand an inquiry into this.' Sandeep Doshi also skirted around the established medical science fact that pigeons feathers and droppings are proven to cause health issues. 'Smoking and alcohol too are injurious to health, yet the government just prints warnings on them and allows their sale,' he said. 'Similarly, they should put warning boards at the kabutarkhana that people with respiratory issues should keep their distance.' Citizens of Mumbai were outraged at the show of force at the kabutarkhana in clear contravention of the law. 'They openly tore down the BMC's makeshift shed and fed pigeons—in full view of the media and police and in direct violation of Bombay high court orders. Where are the FIRs?' demanded Chetan Kamble, a Dadar resident and founder of NGO Chakachak Dadar who was present at the spot. 'When the law is defied so brazenly, and no action is taken, it sends a dangerous message: that some groups are above the law. The police were mute spectators throughout. Public health, court orders and civic governance cannot be sacrificed at the altar of appeasement.' The Andheri Lokhandwala Oshiwara Citizens Association (LOCA) termed the events of Wednesday 'hooliganism' and asked for the perpetrators to be booked for obstructing civil servants from performing their duty and damaging public property. Photos of the Jain temple with netted balconies irked those on social media, questioning why the temple was allowing pigeons to flourish but leaving them out of their premises. Chief minister Devendra Fadnavis on Wednesday reacted to the attack only by saying that the government was trying to find a middle ground. 'We will place a few measures before the court so that this tradition will not be disrupted and at the same time there won't be any health issues,' Fadnavis told reporters in Chhatrapati Sambhaji Nagar. NCP (SP) legislator Rohit Pawar, who was at Dadar Kaburtarkhana and supported the aggressive protest of the Jain community, emphasised that alternatives needed to be found. 'The pigeons could die, as feeding was completely stopped suddenly,' he said. 'This injustice to birds has no place in the Jain and Hindu communities. 'The BMC should come out with a solution. Rohit astutely added that no one wanted to insult the court. 'They were all trying to save the lives of pigeons,' he said.
Hindustan Times
3 hours ago
- Hindustan Times
BMC to send fresh recommendation on heritage tag for Savarkar Sadan, HC told
MUMBAI: The Brihanmumbai Municipal Corporation (BMC) on Wednesday informed the Bombay high court that its Mumbai Heritage Conservation Committee (MHCC) will send a fresh recommendation to the state government regarding granting heritage status to Savarkar Sadan, which was once the residence of Hindutva ideologue Vinayak Damodar Savarkar. BMC to send fresh recommendation on heritage tag for Savarkar Sadan, HC told The bench of chief justice Alok Aradhe and justice Sandeep Marne was hearing a public interest litigation (PIL) filed by Abhinav Bharat Congress, urging inclusion of the building among heritage structures in the city based on a 2010 recommendation of the heritage conservation committee. The need for a fresh recommendation arose after the urban development department informed the court last month that files pertaining to the case, including the heritage committee's 2010 recommendation, had been destroyed in the fire at the state secretariat in 2012. Despite efforts to search for or recreate the destroyed files, they could not be traced, the department told the court via an affidavit dated July 28. BMC's heritage committee would hold a fresh meeting and submit its recommendation on heritage status for Savarkar Sadan, following which the state government would take a final decision, the affidavit said. On Wednesday, after the BMC informed the court that its heritage conservation committee would send a fresh recommendation to the state government, the court directed the civic body to file its affidavit and posted the matter for further hearing after three weeks.
