Apple beats US appeal claiming it shortchanged customers on iCloud storage
(Reuters) -A U.S. federal appeals court on Wednesday rejected claims by Apple customers that the iPhone maker gave them less iCloud data storage than they paid for when upgrading.
In a 3-0 decision, the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in San Francisco said reasonable consumers in the proposed class action would not have been misled by Apple's promises about storage capacity in its iCloud+ plans.
The plaintiff Lisa Bodenburg said she paid $2.99 a month for 200 GB of storage, believing Apple would add it to the 5 GB that all iCloud customers receive, and was shortchanged because Apple gave her only 200 GB of total storage, not 205 GB.
Circuit Judge Milan Smith, however said Bodenburg "received exactly what Apple promised her" when the Cupertino, California-based company offered "incremental" or "supplemental" storage, on top of the 5 GB she got for free.
He cited dismissals of other cases based on "unreasonable assumptions," including that Diet Dr. Pepper would aid in weight loss, and the net weight on a lip balm label failed to reveal that the dispenser's design left some balm inaccessible.
"Apple's statements are not false and deceptive merely because [they] may be unreasonably misunderstood by an insignificant and unrepresentative segment of consumers," Smith wrote.
Lawyers for Bodenburg did not immediately respond to requests for comment. The decision upheld a May 2024 dismissal by U.S. District Judge Trina Thompson in San Francisco.
The case is Bodenburg v Apple Inc, 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals, No. 24-3335.
(Reporting by Jonathan Stempel in New YorkEditing by Marguerita Choy)
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Express
2 hours ago
- Daily Express
Preserving habitat around mantanani
Published on: Saturday, July 26, 2025 Published on: Sat, Jul 26, 2025 By: Hayati Dzulkifli Text Size: Dr Kasim (3rd left) and Johnny (2nd right) showing the signed MoU documents while two researchers and another look on in the event at UMS, recently. Kota Kinabalu: Universiti Malaysia Sabah (UMS) and a Sabah-based JSK Mantanani Island Resorts Sdn. Bhd. signed a Memorandum of Understanding (MoU) to collaborate in marine biodiversity research, education in and around Mantanani Islands, off Kota Belud. The partnership marks a significant milestone in a journey that began in 2023, when the company took bold steps to address the ongoing poaching of nesting sea turtles on the island. Driven by concern over declining turtle numbers, the company sought technical guidance from UMS through its Borneo Marine Research Institute (IPMB) for an integrated conservation programme. Managing Director Datuk Johnny Wong Chen Yee said the company island resort is not just about providing a memorable escape but deeply rooted in sustainable tourism and responsible stewardship of the environment. He said Mantanani, a jewel in the crown of Sabah's Marine biodiversity is one of Malaysia's most breath-taking natural treasures. 'However, as we all know, these precious ecosystems are facing unprecedented challenges — Climate change, unsustainable practices and pollution. 'We must actively participate in their preservation and restoration. 'Through this partnership, JSK Mantanani Island Resort and UMS will embark on a collaborative journey focused on two critical areas: Marine Life and Habitat Restoration,' he said at the signing. Johnny represented JSK Mantanani Island Resort Sdn Bhd while UMS Vice Chancellor Prof. Datuk Dr Kasim Mansor for UMS at Chancellory building recently. Johnny said as Sabah continues to position itself as a global eco-tourism hub, such partnership is vital in ensuring marine biodiversity thrives in tandem with responsible development. The collaborative initiatives will encompass a range of vital activities, including: Seagrass restoration: Rejuvenating these crucial underwater meadows that serve as nurseries for countless species and act as significant carbon sinks. Sea turtle conservation: Protecting these magnificent creatures through monitoring nesting sites, rescuing injured turtles, and raising awareness about their plight. Coral reef rehabilitation: Working together to propagate and transplant corals, restoring the vibrant underwater gardens that are vital to marine life. Research and monitoring of marine biodiversity: Understanding the health of our marine ecosystems to inform effective conservation strategies. Community engagement: Empowering local communities with the knowledge and tools to become stewards of their own environment. Educational programs for their guests and the public: Raising awareness about the importance of marine conservation and inspiring action. 'We will soon launch a dedicated Wildlife Gallery at the resort, exhibiting educational specimens provided by the Sabah Wildlife Department. 'We are also proud to share that our turtle hatchery centre can hold up to 1,000 eggs – a vital step in protecting and increasing the local turtle population,' he said. Johnny said with support and advice from UMS marine scientists, his company obtained formal approval from the Sabah Wildlife Department to launch a turtle conservation initiative He said several JSK staff members were trained and appointed as Honorary Wildlife Rangers, enabling legal authorities to monitor beaches, relocate turtle nests, and manage the JSK Turtle Hatchery. 'This initiative bore fruit quickly, where two green turtle (Chelonia mydas) nests have been protected to date, achieving a hatching success rate of over 90 per cent. 'Protecting Mantanani's natural heritage is core to our values. With UMS as our scientific partner, we can ensure that our efforts are effective, sustainable, and backed by solid data,' he said. Prof. Datuk Dr Kasim said the partnership is more than conservation, it's about building a resilient, informed, and science-driven approach to marine stewardship. 'We're proud to support JSK in becoming a model for private sector-driven conservation,' he said. * Follow us on our official WhatsApp channel and Telegram for breaking news alerts and key updates! * Do you have access to the Daily Express e-paper and online exclusive news? Check out subscription plans available. Stay up-to-date by following Daily Express's Telegram channel. Daily Express Malaysia
The Star
4 hours ago
- The Star
Cybersecurity demands proactive identity verification to counter AI threats
Cybersecurity is a race to outpace scammers, and secure identity verification must be at the forefront, says Jen Liang, CEO of Australia-based IDMeta Group. During the Cybersecurity Summit 2025 on Friday (July 25), Liang said artificial intelligence reshapes fraud tactics, with deepfakes posing a growing threat, making identity verification the foundation of digital trust. "Fraudsters use AI to manipulate IDs, mimic voices, and create deepfake videos, but we also use AI for fraud detection. Our biometric technology can detect deepfakes not just at onboarding but during live interactions," he said during the panel discussion titled "Digital Trust and Resilience: Strengthening Cyber Confidence in Malaysia." He highlighted cases where people unwittingly engaged with deepfakes on video calls. In 2024, a finance employee at a multinational company in Hong Kong was deceived into transferring $25mil after fraudsters used deepfake technology to impersonate the company's CFO during a video conference call. "It's really concerning. Fake meetings are being set up with deepfakes that are 85% to 95% accurate," he said. Liang said the challenge lies in staying ahead of cybercriminals and adapting faster than they do. "Cybersecurity has always been about staying one step ahead. The difference now is the tools are far more powerful for both sides." He emphasised the importance of scalable, secure identity verification in sectors like fintech and gaming. "Fintech and gaming are typically the spaces we're very much involved in. Verification is critical when onboarding customers securely and ensuring they are who they say they are. It's also key to preventing scams and fraudulent accounts, which is especially important today," he said. Operating in multiple jurisdictions, Liang acknowledged that navigating data privacy laws and compliance is one of the company's greatest challenges. "Every country has its own regulatory framework. In Australia, the privacy act is very strict." He noted that both Australia and Indonesia require in-country data servers, with no allowance for cross-border storage. "The Philippines is moving in that direction too, but they don't yet have the infrastructure to support it. Without local data centres like Google or Amazon Web Services, requiring in-country servers could overwhelm their current systems," he said. Liang added that while regulations are becoming more standardised, such as biometric validation and email screening, enforcement is key. "It's not just about laws being in place. It's about how consistently those laws are enforced." He also acknowledged Malaysia's evolving digital policy landscape. "On this trip, we've had conversations with several stakeholders here. The direction is there, but the execution and development are still maturing. It's something we're keeping a close eye on," he said. In response to a question on educating youth about cyber threats, Liang stressed the need to empower them to navigate digital ecosystems responsibly. "Young people today are far more experiential. They have broad access to information, and they're not afraid to challenge what they're told. We just need to provide them a wider scope of guidance, not control," he said. Other speakers echoed Liang's concerns, particularly around resilience and preparedness in the face of rising threats. Amal Wikramasinghe, Head of Governance Risk and Compliance - Cybersecurity and Data Privacy at Axiata Group, described how the company managed a rare and unforeseen third-party outage that impacted four of its operating companies. He emphasised the need for real-time crisis communication and damage assessment protocols. Zainol Zainuddin, CTO of NTT DATA eCommerce Solutions, warned that infrastructure resilience is only as strong as an organisation's cybersecurity culture. He highlighted how phishing, still the most common entry point for hackers, thrives in organisations where awareness is treated as a checklist, not a mindset. "Even the best technology won't protect you if your people don't know how to spot a phishing email. You have to create a blame-free, transparent culture where mistakes can be reported early," he said. Moderator Jaco Benadie, Partner, Technology Consulting – Cyber at Ernst & Young Consulting Sdn Bhd, summarised that building digital trust requires a proactive, resilient strategy that spans technology, people, and culture, while prioritising user privacy and navigating cross-border regulatory challenges.
The Star
7 hours ago
- The Star
Pakistan says it's close to US trade deal, Washington gives no timeline
U.S. Secretary of State Marco Rubio and Pakistani Deputy Prime Minister and Foreign Minister Ishaq Dar shake hands for photographers assembled at the State Department in Washington, D.C., U.S., July 25, 2025. REUTERS/Jonathan Ernst WASHINGTON (Reuters) -Pakistani Foreign Minister Ishaq Dar said on Friday the United States and Pakistan were "very close" to a trade deal that could come within days, but comments from the U.S. after Dar met with Secretary of State Marco Rubio mentioned no timeline. "I think we are very close to finalizing a deal with U.S. Our teams have been here in Washington, discussing, having virtual meetings and a committee has been tasked by the prime minister to fine-tune now," Dar said in a discussion at the Atlantic Council think tank in Washington. "It's not going to be months, not even weeks, I would say (just) days," he said. Under U.S. President Donald Trump, Washington has attempted to renegotiate trade agreements with many countries that he threatened with tariffs over what he calls unfair trade relations. Many economists dispute Trump's characterization. The U.S. State Department and Pakistan's foreign ministry, in separate statements after Rubio's meeting with Dar, said the two stressed in their discussion the importance of expanding trade and ties in critical minerals and mining. A post by Rubio on X after the meeting and the State Department's statement mentioned no timeline for finalizing a trade deal. The Pakistan foreign ministry also said Dar "appreciated the pivotal role" by Trump and Rubio "in de-escalating tensions between Pakistan and India by facilitating a ceasefire." The State Department statement did not mention India. Trump has repeatedly taken credit for the India-Pakistan ceasefire he announced on social media on May 10 after Washington held talks with both sides. India disputes Trump's claims that the ceasefire resulted from his intervention and trade threats. India's position is that New Delhi and Islamabad must resolve problems directly with no outside involvement. An April 22 militant attack in India-administered Kashmir killed 26 men and sparked heavy fighting between the nuclear-armed Asian neighbors in the latest escalation of a decades-old rivalry. India struck Pakistan on May 7 and the two nations exchanged hostilities, killing dozens across three days. The ceasefire was declared on May 10. New Delhi blamed the April attack on Pakistan, which denied responsibility and called for a neutral investigation. Washington condemned the attack but did not blame Islamabad. (Reporting by Kanishka Singh in Washington; Editing by Tom Hogue)
