National Awards jury member Pradeep Nair says he objected to 'propaganda' film The Kerala Story, was dismissed by others
Pradeep Nair on raising objections against The Kerala Story
Pradeep, who was part of the 11-member jury for the Feature Film category, disclosed that The Kerala Story was selected by a majority vote, despite his strong opposition. 'As a Malayali on the panel, I raised serious objections. I questioned how a film that defames a state like Kerala and serves as propaganda could be considered for a national honour,' he said.
He added that his objections were dismissed by the other jury members, 'I even conveyed my concerns directly to the jury chairperson. However, I was the only one who labelled it as propaganda. Others argued that, even if it was controversial, it addressed a relevant social issue.'
Christo Tomy's Ullozhukku was also in contention for Best Direction but was passed over in favour of The Kerala Story. Pradeep revealed that some jury members dismissed Ullozhukku as 'just a family drama' compared to what they saw as the 'social urgency' of The Kerala Story. Ullozhukku went on to win Best Malayalam Film and Best Supporting Actress for Urvashi.
About The Kerala Story
The Kerala Story became a lightning rod for controversy upon its release. Directed by Sudipto Sen and produced by Vipul Shah, the film follows a group of women from Kerala who are coerced into converting to Islam and joining the Islamic State. The makers claimed the film was inspired by real-life incidents and alleged that 32,000 women from Kerala had been radicalised and recruited by ISIS.
However, the Kerala government stated that the claims were unfounded and accused the film of spreading misinformation. The film faced calls for a ban in states like West Bengal, while other states, such as Uttar Pradesh and Madhya Pradesh, made it tax-free.
Despite widespread criticism and backlash, the film, featuring Adah Sharma, Yogita Bihani, Sonia Balani, and Siddhi Idnani, went on to earn ₹302 crore worldwide and become a box office success.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Hindustan Times
4 hours ago
- Hindustan Times
Bigg Boss Malayalam Season 7: Mohanlal-hosted show begins with plenty of dramatic events, first eviction
A week ago, the eagerly anticipated Bigg Boss Malayalam Season 7 got underway. During the first few days, there were a lot of dramatic incidents and intense arguments between the players as they all tried to lay out their game strategies. In case you haven't seen it yet, JioHotstar and OTTplay Premium offer the popular reality show. Mohanlal Round-up of BBMS7 Week 1 Aneesh, first captain of BBMS7 To select a captain, Bigg Boss asked contestants to pick a name of the contestant who should not have been on the show. Additionally, the 'undeserving' individual in the programme had to be smeared with shaving cream. Aneesh got the most foam on his face. In an unforeseen turn of events, however, Bigg Boss revealed that the first captain will be the person who encountered most opposition. Akbar named Renu Sudhi 'septic tank' The participants were tasked with naming each other on the third day during a task. Akbar decided to refer to Renu Sudhi as a "septic tank." Renu, who was deeply offended, informed Noora that this was the first time she had ever been referred to as such. In the midst of this, Akbar apologised to Renu. Aneesh receives backlash from housemates During the first week of the show, there were several instances of misogyny, mostly because of Aneesh T. A. However, he has been clashing with a number of the female competitors and often ignoring their conversations or simple salutations. He has been outspoken about his male chauvinism since the beginning of the show, which has irritated many. Shanavas advises Gizele on her dressing Shanavas caused another issue when he recommended that Gizele Thakral, another housemate, dress more modestly in order to adhere to Malayali cultural standards. Since then, viewers have been talking about the incident. Gizele received additional praise for handling this situation well. Munshi Ranjeet evicted from the house Munshi Ranjeet was ousted from the house after he garnered fewer votes from the viewers. Due to his role in Asianet's hit series Munshi, Ranjeet is a household name among Malayalis. Mohanlal praised his nuanced performance throughout the first week at home. Meanwhile, the Malayalam superstar also hinted at another housemate being kicked out in the middle of the next week.
India Today
21 hours ago
- India Today
You can't question the jury: Shoojit Sircar on SRK, Kerala Story National Awards row
Amid ongoing debate over Shah Rukh Khan winning Best Actor and 'The Kerala Story' being adjudged Best Film at the recent National Film Awards, filmmaker Shoojit Sircar has emphasised that the final decision rests entirely with the appointed jury. He said that their decision should not be an interview with Hindustan Times, he said, 'I feel that there is no point debating this from the outside. You leave it to the jury. We might agree to disagree on many things, but finally, what matters is, who is the jury there. Because that jury is going to be your final word, and you leave it to their sensibility. You can't question what award they have given. I think we would rather question that before they start. Who is the jury? What are their sensibilities?"advertisementThe 'Piku' and 'Sardar Udham' director is currently serving on the jury of the Indian Film Festival of Melbourne (IFFM) for the second year in a row, selecting the Best Short Films at the event. Though he usually avoids such roles, Sircar said he made an exception for IFFM. 'IFFM is very dear to me. The organisers are dear friends and this particular festival is almost like a family affair. This is my fifth or sixth visit there. I normally don't participate in juries and being a judge. But for this, I made an exception,' he the process of judging cinema 'very difficult,' he outlined his approach, 'Before we start, we tell everyone that there are certain elements that they should take into consideration. There are technicalities where you can really possibly judge the craft. Then, you should celebrate the film that really makes a difference. And then, the voice and vision of the director are very important.""You look at films that bring a lot of social change and have a long-lasting impact. Of course, there are technicalities to look into it, in terms of cinematography, editing, direction, actors, everything,' the filmmaker a moment from his own career when 'Sardar Udham' did not make the panorama selection for the 2021 International Film Festival of India, Sircar said, 'When Sardar Udham's panorama selection didn't happen, I was asked the same things. I will say what I said then: 'Whatever the jury has decided, I have to accept it'.'The 2025 Indian Film Festival of Melbourne runs from August 14 to August 24.- EndsMust Watch
Indian Express
a day ago
- Indian Express
Shoojit Sircar defends National Film Awards jury amid controversy over Shah Rukh Khan and The Kerala Story wins: ‘You can't question what…'
After the National Film Award winners were announced recently, many people expressed disappointment over Shah Rukh Khan winning the Best Actor award and The Kerala Story bagging the Best Film award. In a recent interview, Shoojit Sircar defended the National Film Awards jury, stating that it's the panel's call. During a conversation with Hindustan Times, Sircar stated, 'I feel that there is no point debating this from the outside. You leave it to the jury. We might agree to disagree on many things, but finally, what matters is, who is the jury there. Because that jury is going to be your final word, and you leave it to their sensibility. You can't question what award they have given. I think we would rather question that before they start. Who is the jury? What are their sensibilities?' Shoojit Sircar is also a part of the jury of the Indian Film Festival of Melbourne (IFFM), for the second consecutive year. He is responsible for choosing the Best Short Films at the festival. Ahead of IFFM 2025, Shoojit spoke about the experience of judging and said, 'IFFM is very dear to me. The organisers are dear friends and this particular festival is almost like a family affair. This is my fifth or sixth visit there. I normally don't participate in juries. But for this, I made an exception,' he said. ALSO READ | 'How is Shah Rukh Khan Best Actor and Vijayaraghavan a Supporting actor?' Urvashi slams National Film Awards jury: 'Not pension money' However, the director mentioned that judging cinema is 'very difficult'. 'Before we start, we tell everyone that there are certain elements that they should take into consideration. There are technical aspects that allow you to genuinely assess the craft. Then, you should celebrate the film that really makes a difference. And then, the voice and vision of the director are very important. You look at films that bring a lot of social change and have a long-lasting impact. Of course, there are technicalities to look into it, in terms of cinematography, editing, direction, actors, everything,' Shoojit explained. 'When Sardar Udham's panorama selection (for the 2021 International Film Festival of India) didn't happen, I was asked the same things. I will say what I said then: 'Whatever the jury has decided, I have to accept it',' he concluded.
