Parents could be prosecuted for truancy, but principals say it won't work
Photo:
RNZ / Samuel Rillstone
Parents who repeatedly refuse to send their children to school are more likely to be prosecuted as the government cracks down on truancy, but principals say prosecution is not the solution.
A primary school principal in Whangārei had earlier called for exactly this - in 2019 Hora Hora primary's Pat Newman called for more prosecutions for parents who deliberately fail to send their kids to school.
But six years on, he had changed his mind.
Newman told
Morning Report
prosecuting parents wouldn't work.
"This move, in my view, is about looking tough rather than actually doing something effective about it. Attendance is just a symptom, it's not a cause.
"I listened to the Minister this morning and he said it's not about punishing children, but if you are talking about fines of up to $3000 a day, then I can't see how that's not actually punishing children."
Hora Hora primary's Pat Newman.
Photo:
RNZ / Sam Olley
When asked why the change of heart, Newman said he called for prosecution in 2019 out of frustration, but had since embarked on a "really successful campaign".
"It's about communities and families and looking at how we can get these kids to school. It's about kids not at school because they are shifting because of the house rentals, or shifting because of jobs.
"Threatening to fine people, what are we going to do when we go from $300 a day to $3000, do we put them in jail then?"
Newman said the government should give schools the truancy budget money and let the them do "something effective".
"We are already running two buses at our own cost to get kids to school... to help kids who can't get to school, get to school."
If given extra money Newman said he would put on more buses, which was helping attendance at his school.
Principal of Kaitaia College Louise Anaru told
Morning Report
the schools and communities were best placed to make decisions about truancy.
"I think it's not a one size fits all.
"For our school for instance, what works for our communities and where we get the best engagement is when we all sit around the table together with our parents, whānau, student and we come up a really robust attendance plan together."
In the 16 years Anaru had been a principal, she said had not come across a situation where a prosecution was necessary.
She said she had also not come across people calling for the prosecution of parents.
Associate Education Minister David Seymour says the Ministry of Education is proactively contacting schools and truancy officers.
Photo:
RNZ / Samuel Rillstone
Associate Education Minister David Seymour said the Ministry of Education was proactively contacting schools and truancy officers to ensure parents condoning truancy were referred to the Ministry to be considered for prosecution.
The rules were not changing, but the government was ramping up enforcement because schools and truancy officers said it was needed, Seymour said.
"There are some parents who just refuse to cooperate, don't care about their kids' futures, and the people working at the coalface have told me it would be helpful if they had another sanction that they could bring into play."
They wanted a "coercive power" that would ensure parents took school attendance seriously, Seymour said.
No parent had been prosecuted for refusing to ensure their kids attended school for more than five years, he said.
"The previous government ceased to pursue prosecutions, I think that was a mistake," he said.
"We're making it clear that the Ministry of Education is back in business and will respond to requests from schools to take prosecutions."
When a parent is referred to the ministry for condoning truancy, staff would decide whether to prosecute, and it would then be a matter for the courts, he said.
Parents
faced fines
of up to $300 for a first offence and $3000 for a second or subsequent offence.
Seymour said 90,000 students were chronically absent.
"We are not going to prosecute the parents of 90,000 students. This is an option for people working at the frontline ... if they have someone who is more of a 'won't' than a 'can't'."
The ministry would not prosecute parents of students who were "genuinely engaging" with the school, or those who were absent because of chronic illness or health conditions associated with a disability.
Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero
,
a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
RNZ News
an hour ago
- RNZ News
Body of Northland kayaker found
Photo: RNZ / REECE BAKER The body of a Northland kayaker missing since yesterday has been found. The man had failed to return home after going paddling on the Ruakākā River, south of Whangārei, on Monday morning. The discovery of his upturned kayak near Marsden Point Road later that day heightened fears for his safety. Sergeant Simon Craig, of Northland police, said officers started searching the river on Monday afternoon with the help of Surf Life Saving New Zealand, and found his body near the Princes St boat ramp. Craig said police would conduct enquiries into the man's death on behalf of the Coroner. It was not immediately clear when the body had been found. On Monday evening Patuharakeke Te Iwi Trust Board declared a rāhui over the Ruakākā River, from the rivermouth to the Biller Road bridge. The rāhui applied to all river and estuary activities until 3pm on Thursday, 14 August.
RNZ News
an hour ago
- RNZ News
Man dies after single-vehicle car crash on Auckland's Southern Motorway
Photo: NZTA / Waka Kotahi A person has died after a single-vehicle crash on a section of Auckland's State Highway 1 on Monday morning. Emergency services were called to the crash near the Te Irirangi on-ramp in Manukau shortly before 8am. The man was found dead at the scene. The left northbound lane has since been cleared and the northbound on-ramp at Te Irirangi Drive is open again. Enquiries into the crash are ongoing. Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
RNZ News
2 hours ago
- RNZ News
Christopher Luxon shrugs off polls showing tight electoral race
Prime Minister Christopher Luxon has shrugged off two polls showing a tight electoral race , promising to stay the course with the coalition's plan to fix the economy. The Taxpayers' Union-Curia poll on Monday showed Labour overtaking National as the most popular party and no clear path to power for either side. TVNZ's 1News-Verian poll was more forgiving to the coalition parties, returning them to government. But it also saw Luxon sink to just 20 percent as preferred prime minister, a two-year low. On his way into a morning caucus meeting on Tuesday, Luxon told reporters the polls would not be a topic of conversation in the meeting, nor should they be. "No, no, not at all," he said. "I'm not focused on polls or talking about myself. What I'm focused on is New Zealanders and making sure we've got the right long term economic plan in place." Prime Minister Christopher Luxon said the polls would not be a topic at Tuesday's caucus meeting. (File photo) Photo: RNZ / Mark Papalii Luxon said his MPs continued to be provided internal polling through "a regular process" and discussed them "from time to time" in line with "normal practice". Asked whether he was meeting his own high standards, Luxon said the government was dealing with a challenging international environment. "We've inherited a really difficult recession," he said. "It's a very difficult time, but we are very, very clear minded and very, very focused on fixing the economy." Luxon said global confidence had been knocked by the United States' tariff regime but New Zealand had to "power through that". The faltering economy and cost-of-living crisis featured in both polls as key concerns for voters. Recently, the Auckland Chamber of Commerce has advocated a cut to the corporate tax rate, while the Taxpayers' Union is calling for an emergency mid-year Budget. Luxon previously dismissed such calls, and on Tuesday, he maintained the coalition's current focus on manufacturing and construction was the right approach. "We are doing everything we can. If you think about $6 billion worth of infrastructure projects starting before Christmas, that is a lot of jobs, it's a lot of tradies." He also pointed to relief on the horizon with the Reserve Bank expected to deliver further interest rate cuts this year. Speaking on Tuesday morning, Labour leader Chris Hipkins said the polls demonstrated New Zealanders were losing faith in National's ability to deliver on its promises. Labour leader Chris Hipkins. (File photo) Photo: RNZ / Mark Papalii He accepted, however, that Labour had more work to do, given neither poll had returned the party to the Beehive. Asked whether the party's support was helped or hindered by Labour's lack of policy, Hipkins said the government "would desperately love more things to attack". "We'll put further policy out there, but my focus right at the moment is holding the government accountable for their promises." Any comprehensive fiscal plan would have to wait till after next year's Budget, he said, but Labour's tax policy would be released this year. Hipkins said a final decision on tax had yet to be resolved but: "consensus is emerging." He repeatedly refused to give any details, including whether the proposal would be revenue neutral or possible parameters. "I've always said that I don't think the family home should be taxed, but I'm not announcing a policy that we haven't announced." National's campaign chairperson Chris Bishop said it was very easy for Labour to insist life should better when they had no policy solutions to offer themselves. National's campaign chairperson Chris Bishop said the government had to make tough decisions. (File photo) Photo: NZME / LDR "Life's easy when you're able to throw rocks from the side. Actually, we're the ones... in the arena, making the tough decisions across planning, across education, across infrastructure, across red tape, across fiscal policy to get this economy back on track." Bishop said the poll numbers reflected a "tough winter" but stressed that the election was not until next year: "People want the economy to be fixed. And I get that. But there is no silver bullet." He said any talk of replacing Luxon as leader was "just silly". Luxon declined to say whether the caucus would discuss the question of Palestinian statehood on Tuesday, but acknowledged there would be "nuances and differences" within the team. Luxon and Australian Prime Minister Anthony Albanese discussed Palestine during a meeting in Queenstown over the weekend. Photo: RNZ/Katie Todd Foreign Minister Winston Peters on Monday confirmed Cabinet would come to a formal decision in September over whether to recognise a state of Palestine at an upcoming United Nations summit. All three opposition parties have castigated the government for failing to make a decision, pointing out that New Zealand is now out-of-step with its like-minded partners: Australia, Canada, the United Kingdom and France. But Luxon said the complex question needed careful consideration. "It's not a race," Luxon said. "It deserves a serious weighing up of our position, and that's exactly what we're going to do." Luxon declined to say whether he would be comfortable with either coalition partner opting to "agree-to-disagree" on the decision. "I'm not going to get into hypotheticals... It's all very easy to jump to a bumper-sticker outcome or decision and not think through the consequences." Pressed on what conditions could be attached, Luxon said he would not presuppose a position but made clear Hamas would have to release hostages and disarm: "There is absolutely no role in any future Palestinian state for a terrorist organization like Hamas." Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
