People with mental illness can languish in jail. This Pennsylvania county thinks a new mobile clinic can help.
Every year, hundreds of Pennsylvanians languish in jail because they're considered mentally unfit to stand trial, despite conditions that can worsen their state and plunge them deeper into the criminal justice system.
To avoid that scenario, Allegheny County has created the state's first mobile competency restoration clinic. The program will assess and treat people who have been charged with a crime, but can't aid in their own defense because of a mental or behavioral health issue.
The move expands access to this treatment, which is generally available only at two state hospitals. Supporters hope it can become a model for other counties, where as of now, people deemed 'incompetent' to stand trial can wait months for a bed.
The county also plans to change how local courts handle cases involving competency issues, a move intended to prevent people from getting lost in the system, especially for low-level crimes.
These announcements come two years after a Spotlight PA investigation identified serious issues with Pennsylvania's competency system.
The 2023 investigation found that the legal process meant to help people instead routinely traps them in jail, where they may deteriorate further.
The story highlighted one woman, Rachel Bridgeman, whose precarious mental health trapped her in the Allegheny County Jail while she awaited treatment, despite the minor, nonviolent charges she faced.
Allegheny County officials say the new clinic will ensure people like Bridgeman aren't incarcerated just because they need competency restoration, a specific type of psychiatric therapy that helps them understand their legal situation.
'I think there's a lot of agreement where we don't always have a lot of agreement on these cases,' said Erin Dalton, director of the Allegheny County Department of Human Services.
'People see that this isn't good for anyone.'
The county's public defense office and other advocates for criminal defendants see the program as a step forward.
But advocates said the changes could go further, citing the county's ongoing practice of holding people in jail before their competency can be determined. They also expressed concern that the court will refer people to the program who are not able to regain their competency.
'I think we are cautiously optimistic that, if this is well-intentioned with the competency docket or mobile office restoration, that it will be employed legally,' said Sarah Linder Marx, a deputy director in the Allegheny County public defender's office.
'But we are definitely approaching it with a healthy level of skepticism,' she said.
Outside Allegheny County, just two places — Torrance and Norristown State Hospitals — provide the specific therapy needed to both improve someone's mental health and help that person understand their legal situation.
Both hospitals have a limited number of beds, which has created a backlog of people waiting for treatment. They often sit in jail.
On average, Allegheny County has about 125 people waiting for competency restoration annually, according to county officials. But Torrance has about 100 beds to serve all of Western Pennsylvania.
In 2023, a Spotlight PA analysis found most individuals undergoing competency assessments or waiting for restoration faced misdemeanors that could stem from experiencing mental health issues in public.
'We don't want people held on low-level offenses who we think are safe to be supported in the community,' Dalton said. 'And now the district attorney and the judges and everyone have another option which they just haven't had before.'
Centurion, a private prison health care company, has signed a one-year, $1.9 million contract with Allegheny County to provide competency restoration therapy both within the county jail and in community settings.
The team is mobile, with no fixed home base, said Debbie Scovill, who oversees behavioral health care in the Allegheny County Jail.
'So, a lot of their services are done at the jail,' Scovill said. 'They do have some partners in the community, like if they have a desire to run a group or to do meetings with patients, they can use spaces at those partnering agencies to do some boots on the ground in locations, but they are pretty much mobile.'
The itinerant design was intentional, said Jenn Batterton, who manages collaborations between the justice system and the county human services department.
People may be at different phases of involvement with the justice system, she said, 'but the hope is that now more often, we'll be able to serve them in the least restrictive setting, so neither Torrence nor the jail, but in the community.'
The program will serve only Allegheny County for now, but others may soon follow suit. Both Bucks and Delaware Counties are pursuing similar programs.
In concert with the new effort, the Fifth Judicial District of Pennsylvania will next month debut a separate docket, or calendar of cases, dedicated to cases involving competency issues.
Gathering these cases in one place will help expedite them and ensure people get needed care sooner, Allegheny officials argued.
Both the mobile restoration team and the new competency-focused docket are promising, said Samantha Sridaran, who leads a team focused on cases involving mental health within the Allegheny County Office of the Public Defender.
'I've had several conversations with [the mobile competency restoration team],' Sridaran said. 'I think they have really great ideas about how to really, actually, truly help our clients in the long term.'
But Sridaran, Linder Marx, and other advocates for criminal defendants told Spotlight PA they worry about unintended, criminal consequences of any court-ordered program.
'If things don't go well, we are still encapsulating people in the criminal legal system, and there's always potential things may escalate even further,' Linder Marx said. 'I just don't want this to be employed as a weapon against individuals, if it were to not work as intended.'
Sridaran has also seen judges order competency restoration for people who cannot be restored: those who have unchangeable conditions such as intellectual disabilities, traumatic brain injuries, or cognitive impairment.
And Allegheny County has still not resolved an underlying issue that imposes a 'behavioral hold' on individuals who are suspected to be incompetent to stand trial, effectively keeping them in jail while someone without a mental health condition may have walked free. The county public defender's office has argued is illegal.
Ideally, these individuals would be evaluated within 48 or 72 hours by the court system's behavioral assessment unit. But advocates said the delay can be longer; in the 2023 investigation, Spotlight PA found Bridgeman waited two weeks.
'The public defender's office's position is that no one should be incarcerated because they're incompetent,' Linder Marx said. 'That's not in line with the spirit or intent of … our laws. That's not a reason to incarcerate somebody.'
If you learned something from this article, pay it forward and contribute to Spotlight PA at spotlightpa.org/donate. Spotlight PA is funded by foundations and readers like you who are committed to accountability journalism that gets results.
Copyright 2025 Nexstar Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
38 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Trump administration seeks more Pa. voter information, raises potential legal concerns
This article is made possible through Spotlight PA's collaboration with Votebeat, a nonpartisan news organization covering local election administration and voting. Sign up for Votebeat Pennsylvania's free newsletters here. The U.S. Justice Department is asking Pennsylvania to turn over its complete voter rolls, a request that appears to encompass voters' personal information, including Social Security and driver's license numbers. The request, which Pennsylvania officials received in a letter this week, is part of a recent push to get states to turn over voter registration information, which the federal government says is aimed at enforcing election law. But one expert told Votebeat and Spotlight PA that the federal government is likely asking for more information than it needs, and that it would be potentially illegal for states to turn over this kind of personal data. The letter, sent to Secretary of the Commonwealth Al Schmidt on Aug. 4, was first reported by The Philadelphia Inquirer. It asks the state for a copy of its voter rolls — which it had not requested in its previous communications with Pennsylvania about election security — as well as information on the state's answer to a survey about election administration. 'We write to you as the chief election official for the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania to 'Request information regarding the Commonwealth's procedures for complying with the statewide voter registration list maintenance provisions of the National Voter Registration Act,' the letter said. Justin Levitt, a professor at Loyola Law School in California and former civil rights official in the Justice Department, said he thinks the request oversteps the federal government's authority. The letter cites the National Voter Registration Act, which provides for voter registration information to be public. But the law doesn't say that 'all fields' in the voter rolls can be made public, as the letter requests. Pennsylvania's voter rolls are available online and can be downloaded for $20, although that version does not contain personal information such as driver's license and Social Security numbers. Levitt noted that courts have repeatedly ruled that the law doesn't require the release of private information. Levitt said the Justice Department doesn't need specific voters' information, as the letter requests, to ensure that states are complying with the NVRA. 'Knowing whether or not Justin Levitt is on the rolls and Justin Levitt's Social Security number tells you nothing about whether a state has a general program of list maintenance,' he said. The Justice Department recently sued Orange County, California, in part for redacting driver's license and Social Security numbers in responding to a department request for voter registration information. Releasing those parts of the voter rolls has also been met with legal resistance in the past in Pennsylvania, based on privacy concerns. Levitt said another issue with the letter is that the department has not disclosed publicly or to Congress why it is seeking this data, which it is required to do under the Privacy Act of 1974. In a statement to Votebeat and Spotlight PA, Harmeet Dhillon, assistant attorney general for civil rights, said clean voter rolls and election safeguards are 'requisites for free, fair, and transparent elections.' 'The DOJ Civil Rights Division has a statutory mandate to enforce our federal voting rights laws, and ensuring the voting public's confidence in the integrity of our elections is a top priority of this administration,' the statement said. The letter from federal officials also seeks information about some answers from Pennsylvania to the Election Administration and Voting Survey. The U.S. Election Assistance Commission conducts that survey of election officials every two years to collect data on various aspects of election administration, including list maintenance. Previously reported communications between the Justice Department and Pennsylvania did not mention EAVS data, but the Aug. 4 letter asks Schmidt to explain the state's survey responses, including why it reported fewer-than-average duplicate registrations and why so few voter registration applications came from military recruitment offices. Additionally the letter asks for the voting history of any noncitizen, person with felony conviction, or individual deemed incompetent who was removed from the rolls since the 2022 midterm election. The letter asked the Department of State to respond within 14 days. As of Thursday evening, a spokesperson for the department said it had not yet responded. Carter Walker is a reporter for Votebeat in partnership with Spotlight PA. Contact Carter at cwalker@ Copyright 2025 Nexstar Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.
San Francisco Chronicle
3 days ago
- San Francisco Chronicle
Wounded Pennsylvania troopers recovering after chaotic shooting that left gunman, neighbor dead
A man fatally shot his neighbor in rural Pennsylvania and then unleashed a hail of gunfire on first responders, wounding two state troopers, running an EMT off the road and sniping a police drone from the sky, officials said. The chaotic scene unfolded Thursday morning after Thompson resident Lori Wasko's boyfriend called police to report gunfire. Police arrived to find the 57-year-old woman dead and her 61-year-old neighbor, Carmine Faino, lying in wait to ambush them. One of the wounded troopers commandeered a tractor trailer to block the roadway and prevent other motorists from driving into harm's way as police say Faino continued to shoot, targeting a police drone as he holed up near a propane tank that officials feared could be used as a bomb. He also fired at an SUV driven by an emergency worker before being shot and killed by police. The Susquehanna County coroner's office said an autopsy was conducted Friday morning on Faino, but the results were not immediately available. Police have not said what led to the shootings. 'I don't want to speak to his motive leading up to this. I would say you can draw certain conclusions from the standpoint that we believe Faino shot our victim prior to our arrival and then from a position of tactical advantage fired dozens and dozens of rounds,' state police Col. Christopher Paris said. He said Trooper Joseph Perechinsky applied a tourniquet to his injured colleague, Trooper William Jenkins, and, despite his own injuries, ordered the driver of a tractor trailer to block the road. Perechinsky was 'still thinking at that point in time, after being shot twice in the chest, what can I do to secure this location? What can I do to make sure nobody else gets hurt?' Paris said. Gov. Josh Shapiro called the two troopers heroes and said Perechinsky 'saved lives.' 'He acted decisively. He acted thoughtfully. And the work he did today exemplifies the absolute best of the Pennsylvania State Police,' Shapiro said. A spokesperson for Geisinger, a hospital network where the two wounded troopers are being treated, said in an email that, as of late Friday morning, Jenkins was listed in good condition and Perechinsky in fair condition. Both had been wearing ballistic vests and are 'lucky to be alive,' Paris said. The shooting happened in Thompson Township, some 163 miles (262 kilometers) north of Philadelphia. The township has long been without its own police force and, like much of Susquehanna County, relies on the state police for emergency response, which is free to local taxpayers. About one-quarter of Pennsylvanians — largely in rural areas — receive some sort of police coverage from the state police. Erika Mills, who lives near the site of the shooting, said the lack of a local police department has left the area less safe and more vulnerable to crime. She also said it made the response to the shootings more difficult. 'They know they have a large window of time before state police could be on scene,' she said. ___
New York Post
5 days ago
- New York Post
No self-serve gas in New Jersey: Letters to the Editor — Aug. 7, 2025
The Issue: A new bill that would introduce self-service pumps to New Jersey's gas stations. Tommy Behnke's article about Jerseyites pumping their own gas is laughable ('Let Jersey Pump!' PostOpinion, Aug. 3). First of all, most of us like having the gas attendant pump the gas. I don't know about you, but I like not having to stand in the rain, cold or snow to pump gas. Advertisement Second, gas prices might be discounted for self-service for a short period to keep customers, but would soon be brought back up to normal prices. Have you ever seen cheaper prices at the supermarket for self-check out? Plus, the removal of full service puts people out of work. Lastly, just look at New York, where everyone pumps their own gas. The prices are not cheaper for anyone doing self-service, so let's leave well enough alone. Walter Wayne Advertisement Morris Plains, NJ Hey, Tommy, wake up! This is Jersey. Gas stations won't lower prices for self-serve customers as you claim. They will instead raise prices for attendant-pumped gas. Didn't you see 'The Sopranos'? I got a bridge to sell you. Dan Hopkins Washington Township, NJ Advertisement The price per gallon of gasoline has little to do with how it's pumped into a vehicle's tank. New Jersey, now and for a long while, has the most reasonably priced gas in the region. New Yorkers and Pennsylvanians — who reside near the Garden State and have self-service gas — drive there to tank up. Also, millions of Americans can remember when all gas stations provided full service. Outdated? Since when is convenience outdated? Try being elderly or handicapped and needing to pump your own gas. The Motorist Fueling Choice and Convenience Act, while promising choice at the pump, offers no reassurance that it isn't a camel's nose under the tent for universal self-service. Advertisement Ron Wasserman Freehold, NJ I often drive from Rockland County to New Jersey just to get gas, not only because I don't have to pump it myself, but because it's cheaper. The editorial suggests that pump-it-yourself gas will save customers money. But won't it simply encourage Jersey to increase its gas tax to New York and other states' levels? Catherine Ricks Kant New City The Issue: The announcement of the new LA-based California Post, which will launch early next year. Thank you for putting a big smile on my face. I can't wait until you come out with the Los Angeles counterpart to the New York Post ('Coast to coast Post,' Aug. 5). Advertisement There's so much corruption here in the city for you to expose. For example, I know of an apartment building that was sold for $6 million then resold for $9 million a month later to be made into a homeless shelter. I'd love to know whose pockets got lined. Ed Autumn Culver City, Calif. Dear New York Post Editors: I'm wishing you the best, but you have your work cut out for you. Advertisement Common-sense journalism in California? With the politicians they have in place, it makes you wonder if they can even read over there. The pols are taking a beautiful state and turning it into a dumpster fire! Nobody wants to visit — much less live — there, so good luck bringing some sanity to the state. And don't forget your hometown. It looks like we need help, too. Kenneth P. Lebeck Plainview Advertisement I spend a lot of time in southern California. Having The California Post on sale at my local Ralphs or Albertsons is a dream come true. I can only imagine the first California Post headline: 'Stuck on the 405? Read The Post or watch the Bassmaster.' Eric Walters Staten Island Want to weigh in on today's stories? Send your thoughts (along with your full name and city of residence) to letters@ Letters are subject to editing for clarity, length, accuracy, and style.
