
Get some earplugs – and never remove wax at home: 16 ways to protect your hearing, chosen by audiologists
Hearing loss can make life difficult and lead to social isolation. But with extremely loud devices in our pockets, and earbuds in near-constant use, we are at more risk than ever. How can you take care of your ears to avoid problems?
'People tend to think it's a bit of fun if someone mishears,' says Kevin Munro, a professor of audiology and director of the Manchester Centre for Audiology and Deafness at the University of Manchester. From a young age it became apparent that Munro could not hear in his right ear, and in recent years he has experienced hearing loss in his left ear and started wearing a hearing aid – 'so I have skin in the game', he says. 'Most of us don't have hearing loss when we are young, but we all need to understand the importance of being able to communicate well and not have hearing difficulty. I think that could get rid of some of the stigma that is associated with hearing loss.'
Hearing loss affects 42% of people over the age of 50, increasing to 71% of people over 70, according to the National Institute for Health and Care Excellence. 'For the majority of people, it is a gradual change over their lifetime,' says Munro. 'What happens is they'll get to the stage where they think everyone is mumbling. So they're blaming everyone else. And then the people they live with say, 'Why have you got the television so loud? And why am I always having to repeat myself?' That's the time to sit up and take notice, because it is affecting all the people you love and spend time with.'
One billion young people are at risk from avoidable hearing loss, says Dr Siobhán Brennan, Munro's colleague at the University of Manchester, a lead clinical scientist at Sheffield teaching hospitals and chair of the British Society of Audiology. This is because 'devices are so much better than they used to be in terms of the quality of the sound', she says. 'Back in the 1980s, when we had cassette players, there was a limit to how much you would turn up the volume, because it would be distorted and horrible. These days you can go louder and louder, and the quality is great. So we are finding an increase worldwide in noise-induced hearing loss.
'When I started my career,' says Munro, 'we knew one of the biggest risk factors for hearing loss was damage from noise – but that was usually occupational noise, when there were lots of factories in heavy industry. The concern nowadays is recreational noise and young people listening to music on headphones.'
'Loud noise is one of the most predominant causes of hearing loss in young people,' says Renee Almeida, the adult audiology clinical lead at Imperial Healthcare NHS Trust in London. All of us need to take care when exposed to sounds over 85 decibels (dB): for reference, a lawnmower is 90-95 dB; a concert or club around 110-120 dB. 'The louder it gets, the less time you have to be exposed for to ensure damage.' So it's best to avoid loud noise altogether. This might mean not standing next to the speakers at gigs. 'Everyone has left a concert with some ringing in the ears for a few days,' says Almeida. This, she explains, is because 'the stapedius muscle in the inner ear contracts in order to protect the cochlear – the part of the inner ear essential for hearing. The muscle ends up in spasm, which is why we end up with temporary tinnitus.'
When Brennan – who previously trained as a sound engineer – goes to see live music, she always wears earplugs: 'It is important that ear protection fits correctly. They come in different sizes, and you can get custom-made earplugs.' Munro recommends musician's earplugs, which he used himself at a recent Bruce Springsteen gig. 'The ones that have been designed for musicians have a filter in them and it just turns everything down, like lowering the volume on your television a little bit without distorting it.'
'The problem is that everybody has these really loud gadgets in their pockets and the world is a noisy place,' says Dr Jay Jindal, an audiologist and the owner of Planet Audiology, which has clinics in London, Surrey and Kent. 'You could be sensible about how loud it is in your ear in a quiet environment, but as soon as you go into a noisy environment, you inevitably put the volume high without realising that it could be too high for your ears. I spend my life telling people the 50/50 rule – which means that you listen to 50% of the volume on your headphones for 50 minutes, and that seems to be a safe limit for most things.' The World Health Organization (WHO) advises 60% for 60 minutes.
'One of the things that we really notice in audiology,' says Brennan, 'is that people are unaware of the hearing loss they may have – and are missing things without realising. It takes people on average about 10 years between developing hearing difficulties and seeking help.'
There are lots of places to take a hearing test, Brennan says, such as the WHO app or the Royal National Institute for Deaf People (RNID) site. 'There are three-minute tests that you can do. You don't need a soundproof room; you can do it at home using your own device. They will say either everything's fine, or there may be evidence here of a hearing loss.' That's when you should see a doctor for a more thorough investigation.
'If you went to bed all right, and you wake up and one ear is completely deaf or there is severe hearing loss, you should go to your GP or to a hospital,' says Munro. 'If there is inflammation in your inner ear, then getting steroids into your body as soon as you can is the best way of trying to reduce that.' Otherwise, there is a risk of permanent damage.
'Some people have ear infections more frequently than others,' says Brennan. 'If you are getting them repeatedly, there could be an underlying reason. Go along to your GP, who may refer you to an ear, nose and throat specialist.'
'Taking good care of the ears is not using cotton buds,' says Almeida. 'Leave the ears to maintain their natural oil.' This can help avoid ear infections, 'because dry skin can easily break, and even a fingernail can cause irritation and infection.' Almeida advocates drying the ears after a shower or swim, 'when the ears are a bit wet, and nobody really likes that sensation – so get a piece of toilet paper or muslin on your little finger and give it a good wipe.' Only go as far in as the finger can go. It is normal for it to come out a bit yellow, she says. 'Beyond that, leave it for nature.'
'Wax in itself is not a bad thing,' says Brennan. 'It is a protective mechanism. It keeps the ears healthy, generally speaking, and it does migrate out by itself. It is one of those phenomena that has a bad reputation, because sometimes it gets stuck.'
'Having wax in the ear doesn't mean that your ear is unhealthy or unhygienic,' adds Jindal. 'Research suggests that wax has an enzyme which can kill bacteria and viruses going into the ear, and it moisturises the skin as well. So wax is actually a more helpful thing than not.'
'Syringing is basically banned in the UK, because it can cause a lot of problems in the ears,' says Jindal. Almeida explains: 'You can apply too much pressure or too little pressure, hoping that the water is going to pass the wax and flush it out, so it is hit and miss. That's why it is dangerous, because you might have an infection and you don't know about it until it is too late, or you can cause a perforation of the eardrum with the pressure. Microsuction is much more gentle and guided; you can stop at any time.'
Brennan notes that there is availability from the NHS for wax removal: 'There are some audiology or ear, nose and throat departments that will offer it. And there are still some GP surgeries that offer it. However, it is certainly not as widespread as it used to be.' Outside the NHS, there is now not much regulation around who can carry out wax removal, so it is worth asking your GP for advice on where to get it done, the experts say.
'Having a hearing aid, you are more likely to be in tune with what is going on in the world,' says Almeida. Hearing aids that are available on the NHS are 'amazing', she says – 'I am very proud to say that.' The technology has improved a great deal, with even AI and 'invisible' models on the market now. They are a lot less prone to problems like whistling, says Brennan.
Munro says: 'Remember, you need good hearing to be able to communicate well, and hearing aids can address this. If you don't hear well, you're not able to stay socially connected to others. And if you're not socially connected and you can't have good-quality social interactions, this leads to isolation: you get anxious, you get withdrawn, you can be depressed, and that is not good for your health at all. For healthy ageing, you want to be able to remain socially connected.'
If your ear feels blocked, olive oil-based ear drops are an option. 'For some people, they work well,' Brennan says. 'But use them in moderation and according to what it says on the packet. Speaking to a GP is a good start because if your ear feels blocked, it may not be wax; it could be an infection, which you're going to want to approach in a different way.'
There are times when oil does more harm than good, says Jindal. 'Oil can close the pores of the skin, so the skin stops breathing, and if you already have an existing problem with the skin, then it doesn't go in your favour.'
'Swimming in a pool is OK for most people,' says Jindal. 'If they have ear-related issues, they will benefit from wearing earplugs. There are some over-the-counter earplugs, which are quite cheap. Or they can go to their nearest audiologist and get customised swim plugs made.'
For people prone to ear problems, swimming in open water can be more problematic than doing pool lengths, because 'the water is more contaminated rather than regulated'.
'Tinnitus is ringing or buzzing,' says Almeida. 'It is described as a perception of sound, when no external sound is around. Very rarely, it can be caused by changes in blood flow or muscle contractions, but it is ultimately generated by the brain's auditory system. Hearing loss and tinnitus go hand in hand because by lacking hearing, the brain then notices the tinnitus.' It can be related to problems with the jaw, teeth or tense muscles around the neck, Almeida adds. 'The treatment options depend on what we find. If there is a hearing loss, hearing aids are always going to be the first port of call.' A visit to the dentist might also be an idea.
Dehydration may be a factor: 'People say, 'When I wake up, the tinnitus is very loud, and the moment I have a glass of water, it's fine.' The ears are filled with liquid, and the whole body dehydrates at nighttime.'
Brennan adds that there's some evidence to suggest cognitive behavioural therapy is effective for reducing the impact of tinnitus.
'Your ear controls your hearing and your balance,' says Munro. 'So if something goes wrong with your ear, it might also affect your balance. As we get older, the balance organ in our ear will not work as well as it used to. Your inner ear, where your cochlear is for your hearing and your semicircular canals for your balance, relies on a really good blood supply – but it is where the blood vessels are the smallest in the body, which is why people might end up with a vestibular problem.'
If your ears feel blocked or painful when on an aeroplane, 'swallowing something helps, because that creates positive pressure inside the ear', says Jindal. 'Sipping a glass of water or juice, or sucking a sweet, may be helpful. There is a special balloon you can blow up with your nose rather than your mouth, which seems to help. And blowing the nose in general is a good thing.'
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


The Sun
an hour ago
- The Sun
Anti-vaxxer who ‘encouraged daughter to refuse chemo' defies belief – but toxic views are still spreading far and wide
WHAT kind of parent potentially sacrifices their child's health on the altar of their own, ill-informed beliefs? Step forward notorious conspiracy theorist Kate Shemirani, who stands accused by her two estranged sons of causing their sister's death by encouraging her to refuse chemotherapy. 8 8 Paloma Shemirani was diagnosed with 'treatable' non-Hodgkin lymphoma two years ago. But, despite being told she had an 80 per cent chance of recovery via chemo, she refused it and died just months later at the age of 23. Kate and husband Faramarz claim she 'died as a result of medical interventions' but now Paloma's brothers Sebastian and Gabriel have told BBC 's Panorama a different story. 'My sister has passed away as a direct consequence of my mum's actions and beliefs,' says Sebastian. Gabriel, who started legal action to try to ensure that Paloma got the right treatment while she was still alive, adds: 'I wasn't able to stop my sister from dying. "But it would mean the world to me if I could make it that she wasn't just another in a long line of people that die in this way.' To that end, the brothers are lobbying for social media companies to take stronger action against those who peddle medical misinformation. TikTok recently banned Kate Shemirani's profile. But she still has a sizeable social media following for her conspiracy theory views that her sons say started when her and her husband listened to recordings claiming that the US terror attack on 9/11 was staged. Then, in 2012 when Kate was diagnosed with breast cancer, she had the tumour removed through conventional surgery but credited alternative therapies for her recovery. Paloma's school friend Chantelle says: 'Paloma spoke about her mum curing herself and she believed sunscreen could cause cancer.' Son of anti-vax nurse being probed by cops for comparing NHS medics to Nazis slams 'arrogant' mum So when doctors found a mass in Paloma's lung, it perhaps explains why her mother's influence was so great that the young woman decided against conventional treatment. Indeed, Paloma's boyfriend Anders Harris alleges that, after visiting her daughter in hospital, Kate texted him to ask that he help prevent her from consenting to chemo. Kate, a former 'nurse' in a Botox clinic (injects neurotoxin but says no to vaccines? — go figure) was struck off in 2021 for sharing anti-vaccine and anti- lockdown content online. We're all adults and can agree with or ignore such content. But when a parent influences their child against the conventional medicine that could save their life, it defies belief. In the UK, if parents refuse medical treatment for a sick child (either through religious or other beliefs) and that decision puts them at risk, the law can intervene to act in the best interests of the minor and ensure the necessary treatment takes place. But Paloma was an adult clearly influenced by a mother who put her own beliefs before her daughter's best interests. And sadly, the law is a lot murkier and slower in clamping down on people like Kate Shemirani who, God forbid, charges cancer patients £195 for a consultation. WOMEN ON SIDE OF J.K. 8 SIR Stephen Fry has turned on 'friend of mine' JK Rowling, suggesting she's been 'radicalised' over trans issues and has 'very strong, difficult views' that, to him, make her 'a lost cause'. He was publicly backed by barrister Jolyon Maugham, who posted: 'Really creditable this . . . I've spoken to so many of JKR's once friends who now despair at her privately but won't do so publicly . . . ' The Harry Potter author responded to him with: 'It is a great mistake to assume that everyone who claims to have been a friend of mine was ever considered a friend by me.' Touché. As for her being a 'lost cause', this is not an opinion shared by the majority of women who believe she is simply standing up for the rights of biological females, including, as she puts it, 'being able to speak about our own bodies as we please'. And I'm afraid that Stephen and Jolyon's declarations come across as just another couple of entitled men telling women what they should be thinking and feeling. FAILING ON A.I. 8 TECHNOLOGY Secretary Peter Kyle was called a 'bit of a moron' by Sir Elton John on national television but says it's not the first time he's been described as such. Mr Kyle, who has acute dyslexia, says: 'The first person I ever recall calling me that word 'moron' was a teacher and that was in front of school friends. 'So I wouldn't say it hurt, but it was very humiliating.' Hmmm. Conflating a school bullying experience with Elton's comment seems disingenuous. It had nothing to do with his dyslexia and everything to do with the Government's failure to protect young creatives from having their content used for free by AI tech companies. SUCH A HARDY TARDI 8 AT first sight, I thought it was the latest Pixar creation for another Monsters Inc sequel. But no, turns out this, er, cute little creature is real and can be found in damp environments such as moss, lichen and wet leaves. It's called a tardigrade and, according to science author Alex Riley in his new book Super Natural: How Life Thrives in Impossible Places, it can endure the most brutal of conditions that would kill a human in seconds. Hot planet, cold planet, war, flood, famine, you name it – the 'water bear', or 'moss piglet' as it's known, can sustain the lot. Apparently, it can even withstand one of Rachel Reeves' unedited Budget announcements. LITTLE THREAT AT 90 TWO serving Metropolitan Police officers and one former one are to face a gross misconduct hearing after a 90-year-old woman with dementia was 'red-dotted' with a taser which thankfully wasn't discharged. But she was handcuffed and put in a spit hood after refusing to drop the 'kitchen utensils' she was brandishing at a carer in her South London home. A complaint has now been lodged by her family over use of force and alleged discrimination due to her age, race, sex and disability. The incident follows that of two officers who, despite a jury finding them unanimously not guilty, still face gross-misconduct proceedings over the use of a pepper spray and taser on a 92-year old amputee who had threatened staff with a butter knife at a care home in East Sussex. It later transpired that he was delirious as a result of a urinary tract infection. Look, the police do a tough job that many of us wouldn't dare sign up for. But common sense must surely dictate that an obviously distressed and delirious nonagenarian is going to present little to no threat to anyone? EVERY country has its 'pests' that patrol urban streets looking for scraps. 8 For the UK, it's mostly foxes and seagulls. In Australia, it's white ibis, otherwise known as 'bin chickens'. It's monkeys in Thailand and brown bears in Canada. And I'll never forget being in the Galapagos Islands and seeing large sea lions undulating their way along the street looking for food. Now there's been an exceptionally rare sighting of a pod of killer whales just five miles south of Plymouth. How long is it before we see Free Willy foraging in Asda's bins? RIFT-HEALING LIZ HAS THE EX FACTOR 8 I HAVE met Elizabeth Hurley several times and we once spent a weekend away together with mutual friends. During that trip, she taught me how to stand in photos, that the Mach 3 razor is a must for tackling armpit hair and spent some of her downtime looking for a new tractor for her farm. In other words, she's as uncomplicated and straightforward as they come. Which is perhaps why, after years of the Cyrus family not speaking following the demise of his 30-year marriage to her mum Trish, Miley and her father Billy Ray have seemingly reconciled after he started dating Elizabeth. Indeed, the four of them (the other attendee being Elizabeth's son Damian) went for a cosy dinner in London at the weekend. 'At first it's hard, because the little kid in you reacts before the adult in you can go, 'Yes, that's your dad, but that's just another person that deserves to be in his bliss and to be happy,' says 32- year-old Miley. Good for her. And well done Elizabeth, whose enduring friendships with her exes is also a testament to her admirable people skills.


Daily Mail
an hour ago
- Daily Mail
Gray missing in action as Scotland records its worst cancer waiting times on record
Neil Gray was declared 'missing in action' yesterday after it emerged he is on a 'junket' in Japan as Scotland records its worst cancer waiting times on record. The beleaguered SNP health secretary has been accused of letting the NHS 'spiral out of control' as delayed discharges also hit a new high. The 'appalling' figures emerged as doctors warned the health service was 'dying' as Scots increasingly raided savings to go private to avoid huge waiting lists. The Scottish Conservative Party 's health spokesman Dr Sandesh Gulhane said: 'These appalling statistics confirm Scotland is facing a ticking timebomb when it comes to cancer cases on the SNP's watch. 'Yet while cancer waiting times hit record lows and delayed discharge rates spiral out of control, Neil Gray is on a junket abroad. 'In the words of BMA Scotland, our NHS is 'dying before our eyes', but the SNP health secretary is missing in action. 'Neil Gray should be focused on fixing our health service, not globetrotting. 'While this delegation may be helpful for the industry, Neil Gray's presence looks like a jolly. 'He needs to show common sense and adopt our plans to cut bureaucracy and surge resources to the frontline.' The row exploded as a raft of official figures underlined the crisis in Scotland's NHS: * Nearly a third of Scots referred with an urgent suspicion of cancer still hadn't started their treatment by the 62-day target in the first quarter of 2025. * The number of delayed discharge patients stuck in hospital hit a record 720,000 last year, with one NHS bed in nine occupied by someone who didn't need it. * Waiting times in A&E worsened last week, with just two-thirds of patients seen on time, and 11 per cent waiting more than eight hours. * Dr Iain Kennedy, chair of BMA Scotland, accused the SNP of 'repeatedly ignoring' warnings about NHS lists, forcing patients to 'use their own hard-earned money' instead of 'languishing' in a health service 'dying before our very eyes'. There was particular anger at Holyrood over the cancer waits - and Mr Gray's absence on a Scottish healthcare 'trade mission' half-way around the world. A key NHS Scotland's standard means 95 per cent of patients should wait no longer than 62 days from an urgent suspicion of cancer referral until their first cancer treatment. But only 68.9 per cent of patients referred from January to March started treatment on time, down from 73.5 per cent the previous quarter and 70.5 per cent for the same period in 2024. Only one of Scotland's 14 regional health boards, NHS Lanarkshire, hit the target. It was the worst performance since comparable records began in 2012. A target for 95 per cent of patients to start treatment within 31 days of a new cancer diagnosis was also missed, with 94.1 per cent treated on time. Dr Sorcha Hume, of Cancer Research UK, said: 'It's unacceptable that people are waiting too long for cancer treatment - and the situation is getting worse, not improving. 'Given the rise in the number of people being diagnosed with cancer, the Scottish Government must take urgent action. We need to see a significant increase in investment in the workforce. Reforms to NHS infrastructure and services are also required.' Mr Gray was last year criticised for going on 'jollies' to Aberdeen FC games in his official limo and had to apologise to parliament for looking 'more of a fan' than a minister. This week the Airdrie & Shotts MSP is on a trip selling Scotland's 'strong international reputation for pioneering health technologies' in Japan. But it emerged yesterday that the SNP's ill-fated NHS app, which is already a decade behind England's, has been scaled back to a single function in a single health board. Hailed as a 'digital front door' to the health service by John Swinney, it will initially deal only with dermatology appointments in NHS Lanarkshire when launched. The cancer and delayed discharge figures are published at the same time each year. The Scottish Government confirmed Mr Gray would have known the timetable, but denied he knew the content, when he agreed to be overseas when they came out. The Health Secretary arrived in Japan on Sunday evening and met the trade mission's delegation at the British Embassy in Tokyo on Monday morning. He is also due at Expo 2025 in Osaka this week. He is not expected back in the UK until Friday, the day after MSPs leave Holyrood for the summer recess, letting him duck questions in the chamber about his record. Mr Gray also went on a five-day round trip to Japan in 2023 when he was Economy Secretary, when his flights and hotels cost taxpayers £7,000. Scottish Labour deputy leader Dame Jackie Baillie said: 'It is right that we engage with other nations when it comes to promoting Scotland and strengthening ties. 'However, many will question the timing of this visit by the Health Secretary when our NHS is in such a poor state after years of chronic mismanagement by SNP ministers. 'After making use of a ministerial limo to football matches, it would be wise of Neil Gray to make this trip a more productive one than his previous jaunts. 'And perhaps while he is abroad boasting about Scotland's reputation for pioneering technology, he could tell us when the long-delayed Scottish NHS app will finally launch.' Scottish Lib Dem leader Alex Cole-Hamilton added: 'A cancer time-bomb is looming. The SNP must act now to cut these dangerously long waits and deliver urgent, life-saving care. 'Nothing Neil Gray has done since being appointed health secretary has turned the tide for stressed out staff and patients. 'It's all well and good for Scotland to be advertising its excellent health technology abroad but patients facing the worst ever waits for cancer treatment and delayed discharge might well wish the Health Secretary were at home working out how to drive down waiting lists.' Mr Gray said: 'We are treating more patients with cancer on time, within both standards, compared to the same quarter six years ago - 7.7 per cent more within the 31-day standard and 0.1 per cent more within the 62-day standard. 'Cancer remains a national priority for the Scottish Government. We have directed £14.23 million of the £106 million in additional planned care funding for 2025/26 to cancer waiting times, with a focus on colorectal, urological and breast as our most challenged pathways.' A Scottish Government spokeswoman added: 'While in Japan Mr Gray is taking forward a full schedule of engagements promoting Scotland's health technology sector. This includes a meeting with the Japanese Ministry of Health to discuss the shared challenges of caring for a growing ageing population and explore potential areas for collaboration. 'International engagement like this is vital to supporting innovation, attracting investment, and delivering long-term benefits for patients and our health service.'


Daily Mail
an hour ago
- Daily Mail
DR SANDESH GULHANE: Minister is nowhere to be seen as Scots NHS is let down
During the SNP 's time in office, Scots have been hammered with the highest taxes in the UK but have been getting worse public services in return. Nowhere has this decline been more obvious than in our NHS and yesterday we had some of the most shameful and appalling figures yet seen. The worst delayed discharge figures on record and cancer statistics showing that almost a third of Scots are waiting longer than the 62-day target for treatment. Meanwhile, Health Secretary Neil Gray was in Japan 'showcasing Scotland's strengths in digital health and life sciences'. Whatever our achievements in those fields, it hardly disguises the fact that, at the most basic tasks we expect from a health service, the SNP is letting Scotland down, and the cabinet secretary isn't here to face the music. Despite being on their fifth NHS recovery plan in the past four years, the Nats are not only failing to repair the damage their policies have inflicted on the NHS. They're making matters worse. A&E waits remain high – despite it being summer, traditionally one of the quietest periods. The SNP have not met their own waiting time targets on cancer for over a decade. And it's been a decade since Shona Robison, the then health secretary, vowed to eradicate delayed discharge. Instead, the situation is worse than ever. Almost three-quarters of a million days were lost to bed-blocking – every one of them a waste of NHS resources, a source of despair to the patient stuck in hospital and a lost opportunity to treat someone else languishing on a waiting list. The equivalent of one in every six Scots is on a waiting list. As Dr Iain Kennedy, chairman of BMA Scotland, said yesterday – Scotland's NHS is 'dying before our eyes'. He pointed out that almost a third of Scots say they or someone in their household has been forced to pay to go private due to the difficulty in securing NHS treatment. The record waiting lists – with more than 63,000 people waiting over a year and, shockingly, 5,200 having waited for two years or more – are 34 per cent worse than this time last year. That is an utterly damning figure. The SNP have never once met their target that no one should wait over 12 weeks for in-care or daycare treatment – despite having passed a law making it a legal obligation. These aren't just abysmal statistics. They represent people left without timely treatment, suffering unnecessary pain, whose chances of recovery and, in the most extreme cases, survival, are being put at risk by the inability of successive SNP ministers to get a grip on this crisis. I know from my colleagues that it is also pushing dedicated NHS staff to breaking point. The SNP made the disastrous decision to cut the number of medical students by 8 per cent, nursing students by 20 per cent and trainee midwives by 40 per cent. There's a dangerous shortage of oncologists and radiologists. There are more than 450,000 extra patients registered with GP practices since 2012, but the government has little chance of meeting their target of 800 new GPs by 2027. Audit Scotland identified a 6 per cent cut in real-terms spending on GPs between 2021 and 2024. Wasteful public spending is going through the roof, yet frontline care is being starved of resources. The SNP now spends more money on the best-paid public sector fat cats than it does on paramedics. They've squandered millions on an app that should have been up and running years ago and which – if it arrives – will be inferior to the one the rest of the UK has had for a decade. Almost a million pounds a month is still being spent on preparations for a botched National Care Service, even though the SNP have abandoned most of their plans for it. The SNP cannot avoid the responsibility for this litany of failure. Over almost two decades, they have presided over a shameful decline in our health service. A string of inept ministers, each more dismal than the last, has acknowledged the system is in crisis. They've launched a series of recovery plans that have failed to produce any improvement. Patients are suffering needlessly. Staff are being pushed beyond endurance. What Scotland urgently needs now is a plan of action to repair the damage they have created, not perfunctory apologies and ever-worsening figures.