Little girl vanishes after school concert - then sick truth unfolds
It was just a few days before Christmas when 12-year-old Jonelle Matthews vanished from her Colorado home after being dropped back after a school concert.
Jonelle had been performing in a Christmas concert while her dad was at a basketball game and her mum was away from home caring for a family member.
After getting a lift home with a friend she spoke to her father on the phone, but when he returned to the family home shortly after, he found the garage door open and an empty house.
For over 30 years, Jonelle Matthews' disappearance on December 20, 1984, remained a mystery. It wasn't until some 35 years later that her remains were discovered during a pipe installation in 2019.
A year later in 2020, Steven Pankey — a local man with ties to her church who later ran twice for the governor of Idaho — was arrested. After two trials, he was convicted of felony murder and kidnapping and sentenced to life in prison.
"During those decades, generations of Greeley police officers have never forgotten Jonelle, many living in torment over the possibilities of what may have occurred that grim evening in 1984, and what could be done to solve this mystery," the Greeley Police Department said in a statement following Pankey's arrest.
Pankey had continuously involved himself in the investigation and displayed odd behaviour regarding Jonelle's disappearance. Even his ex-wife, Angela Hicks, said in Oxygen's 2024 docuseries The Girl on the Milk Carton that she started collecting evidence against him years before his arrest. So what happened to Jonelle Matthews?
Jonelle was a 12-year-old student living in Greeley with her parents who loved to sing and cross-stitch gifts for her friends. According to The Denver Post, she had been adopted from Los Angeles when she was one month old because her birth mother was only 13 when she gave birth.
'You could tell Jonelle had been there,' her dad, Jim Matthews, said in a November 2024 episode of 48 Hours. 'I yelled out 'Hi Jonelle,' 'Jonelle, are you there?' No answer.'
After her dad called the police, investigators found footprints in the snow near the family's home. Her dad told 48 Hours that it looked like someone had tried to mess the prints up with a garden rake.
Jonelle's case caught national attention after she became one of the first kids featured in the Missing Children Milk Carton Program and president Ronald Reagan discussed her disappearance during a 1985 meeting with the National Newspaper Association.
But on the tenth anniversary of her disappearance in 1994, her family had Jonelle declared legally dead, The Denver Post reported. Her case went cold until July 2019, when a group of oil and gas workers discovered her remains while digging a pipeline less than 20 miles from the Matthews' home in Greeley.
It was only then that Jonelle's death was ruled as murder and her autopsy report revealed she had been shot in the head. Pankey was a fellow Greeley resident, living just two miles away from the Matthews' home who served as a former youth minister at the same church.
After Jonelle went missing, his former wife said her ex-husband began acting 'suspiciously' spending hours digging a hole in their yard, becoming fixated on news coverage around her case and making them leave town. She started collecting evidence against Pankey in 1999.
Pankey also involved himself in the police's search for Jonelle and repeatedly hinted to investigators that he knew what happened. When his son was shot and killed by his girlfriend in 2008, Hicks claimed that she heard him say, 'I hope God didn't allow this to happen because of Jonelle Matthews.'
Pankey was indicted by a grand jury in October 2020 on charges of murder, kidnapping and crimes of violence. According to 48 Hours, he allegedly took Jonelle from her family home and shot her some time 'during the course of the kidnapping.' The document also claimed that Pankey was aware of the rake used to blur the footprints.
He was first tried in October 2021, but it ended in a mistrial after the jury failed to reach a verdict on the murder and kidnapping charges. However, he was found guilty of false reporting.
Two years later, he was tried again and found guilty of felony murder and second-degree kidnapping. Pankey was sentenced to life in prison with the possibility of parole, reports the Greeley Tribune.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Record
11 hours ago
- Daily Record
Cocaine driver killed grandfather in car with baby in head on collision
Paul Kingcombe crashed head-on with a car carrying an 18-month-old child, killing grandfather Paul May. A driver lost control of his car and veered into oncoming traffic while high on cocaine before smashing headfirst into a car carrying a baby and killing her grandfather. Paul Kingcombe, 51, from Collin Close in Plymouth, lost control of his car whilst under the influence of cocaine and oversteered after jerking to the left and hitting the grass verge, reports Cornwall Live. As he tried to regain control, he oversteered into the opposite lane and crashed into a car driven by Paul May, who was driving his family - including his 18-month-old granddaughter - home from a Christmas party. It was later described as a "miracle" that the baby wasn't injured in the crash, but unfortunately Paul suffered injuries that he couldn't survive. A sentencing hearing at Truro Crown Court on Friday, July 25, was told that Kingcombe had been known to take drugs at work during his lunchbreaks and would "be bouncing off the walls in the afternoon" but was still allowed to drive home. The court heard from Mr May's family of the devastation his death had caused and how the "void he left in their lives can never be filled". In powerful victim impact statements, the May family expressed their immense sense of loss at losing a beloved father and grandfather who will not get the chance to play with his grandchildren as they grow. Whitney May, Paul's daughter, was seriously injured in the crash and saw her baby daughter being taken away from the crash scene to hospital as she laid helpless and hurt in the car. She said while Kingcombe has received some injuries in the collision on December 27 2022, on the A388 at St Dominick, near Callington, "the mindless decision you made that day changed our lives forever". She said: "My dad was my hero, my best friend, my everything. It didn't change your life like it changed ours. You carried on living while my dad died." Her sister said their dad was the funniest man around and had been a great father. She said he was someone who would always help and he always reminded her to be careful on the road. She added: "You have killed my dad and you have the same name. Paul May was someone you could rely on. You don't deserve the name 'Paul'. You have mentioned your mental health but you have had no thought for our own mental health and what you did to us all. I will never forgive you. You will not be part of our lives. You mean nothing to me. You are nothing. "Your actions deprived us of the most wonderful man. My dad was the glue that held our family together. The hole you left in our hearts will never be filled." His Honour Judge Carr said it had been a miracle that Whitney May's 18-month-old baby had survived unscathed from the crash. Helen May, who received long-lasting serious injuries in the collision, which have reduced the mobility in her right arm, said Kingcombe had killed her husband and her children's father. She said Kingcombe had ruined all their lives. She told the court that for a long time after the crash she did not want to go into Plymouth for fear she might bump into the man responsible for the death. She said: "I will never be able to be with Paul again. He went through cancer twice and survived. Paul was cancer-free, but his life was taken away from him just when he was supposed to be enjoying it." The court heard how Mr May had been 65 at the time of his untimely death and had been working since he was 14 to provide for his family. He had been looking forward to retirement and spending more time with his family. Kingcombe, who has a previous conviction for intent to supply cocaine for which he received a suspended sentence in 2018, was arrested after recovering from his own injuries and charged with one count of causing death by dangerous driving and three of causing serious injuries by dangerous driving. He pleaded guilty to all four charges at the earliest opportunity. The court was told that in police interviews that Kingcombe couldn't explain the crash nor why he had taken cocaine for "I didn't knowingly take cocaine in the days before the collision". He added: "I don't know how it occurred or why. My apologies and sympathies to all the people involved. I'm sorry I can't provide any explanation as I don't know myself." The court was told that Kingcombe had made comments to colleagues about taking drugs and telling them he "doesn't care if he lives or gets hurt or killed in a car crash". It was also heard that Kingcombe had tried to take his life on several occasions over the last three years because he couldn't cope with the guilt. Jason Beal, defending Kingcombe, said no words could ever express any meaningful mitigation in response to the "carnage Kingcombe's actions had caused to so many people" or could compensate for the "incalculable loss" they have suffered. He said Kingcombe cannot recall the events of that fateful day but accepted he had caused the death of Mr May and injured his family members by trying "to boost his energy levels by taking drugs" which was a "catastrophic decision" for so many other people. Mr Beal said Kingcombe's mental health had deteriorated before the collision and his sleeping pattern was non-existent. He said he was bipolar and suffered from anxiety and depression and he started drinking more and taking drugs as a result. He added: "The real victims are Mr May and his family." Judge Carr said it had taken far too long for this case to come to court. He said Mr May had been enjoying the festive season and had been happy when Kingcombe, for no apparent reason, lost control of his car and hit the Mays. While noting that Kingcombe had expressed genuine remorse for his actions, he told him: "It's a miracle an 18-month-old baby escaped unhurt from this crash. The void left by Mr May's death will never be filled." He told Kingcombe that receiving a suspended sentence for intent to supply cocaine in 2018 should have been a wake-up call, but it sadly was not. He added: "You have shown true remorse but your drug use was out of control at the time." Judge Carr sentenced Kingcombe to 12 years in prison. He is also banned from driving for five years after his release from prison and will need to take an extended driving test before being allowed back behind the wheel. Join the Daily Record WhatsApp community! Get the latest news sent straight to your messages by joining our WhatsApp community today. You'll receive daily updates on breaking news as well as the top headlines across Scotland. No one will be able to see who is signed up and no one can send messages except the Daily Record team. All you have to do is click here if you're on mobile, select 'Join Community' and you're in! If you're on a desktop, simply scan the QR code above with your phone and click 'Join Community'. We also treat our community members to special offers, promotions, and adverts from us and our partners. If you don't like our community, you can check out any time you like. To leave our community click on the name at the top of your screen and choose 'exit group'.
BreakingNews.ie
4 days ago
- BreakingNews.ie
Off-duty bouncer 'not the same' after assault by men barred from Arklow hotel, court hears
An off-duty bouncer who was violently attacked by two men whom he had previously barred from a hotel in Arklow is 'no longer the same man' after being forced into early retirement due to the severity of his injuries. A Polish national who attacked the victim near his workplace while he was off-duty on Christmas Eve five years ago was sentenced to three years in prison for the attack. Advertisement A sitting of Wicklow Circuit Criminal Court heard that the victim had suffered serious facial injuries after being struck in the head with a bottle on Main Street, Arklow, on December 24th, 2019. Mateusz Gorecki (31), of Ferrybank, Arklow, Co Wicklow, pleaded guilty to assault causing harm to Paul Lee, contrary to Section 3 of the Non-Fatal Offences Against the Person Act 1997. The unemployed male, who has been living in Ireland for 14 years, also pleaded guilty to a separate charge of production of an article capable of inflicting serious injury on the same date. Garda Emmet Furlong gave evidence that the injured man was sitting in his car outside the Royal Hotel on Main Street, Arklow, at around 10pm on Christmas Eve five years ago to collect his partner from work. Advertisement Garda Furlong said Mr Lee saw Gorecki and another male, with whom he had interactions in the past in his role as a bouncer at the hotel. The witness said the two men had been barred from the premises by Mr Lee as a result of a previous incident. He told the court that Mr Lee felt the two men, one of whom seemed to have a bottle in his hand, were glaring at him before they walked up and down past his vehicle on the other side of the road. Garda Furlong told prosecution counsel, James Kelly, BL, that the bouncer got out of his car to go to speak to the pair. Advertisement Video footage of the incident was played in court, which showed that Gorecki attempted to hit Mr Lee before throwing a bottle at his head. The accused's companion had punched and kicked the victim between the two actions by Gorecki. The court heard that Mr Lee was referred to three different hospitals over the Christmas holiday period for treatment for his injuries. Garda Furlong said the victim suffered fractures to his skull, eye socket and cheekbone and required surgery to implant three plates in his face. He told Mr Kelly that Gorecki was 'nonplussed' by what happened when arrested and claimed he had not thrown a bottle. Advertisement The witness said the accused was still of the view that the bottle had not hit Mr Lee, despite the video evidence. The court heard that Gorecki had no previous convictions at the time of the assault on the bouncer but had subsequently been convicted of two public order offences for being intoxicated in a public place. Asked under cross-examination by defence counsel, Feargal Kavanagh SC, who was the principal protagonist in the assault, Garda Furlong said Gorecki caused the most damage, but his accomplice, who received an 18-month prison sentence for his role, was 'more of a leader.' The court heard Gorecki had been drinking at a party in his sister's house in Arklow earlier on Christmas Eve. Advertisement In a victim impact statement, which was read on his behalf by his son, Mr Lee (54) said he had been a proud, hard-working man before the attack but had been forced into early retirement by an act of unprovoked violence. He told the court that the assault had not just caused him the normal physical agony but had devastated his life entirely. Mr Lee said the psychological effects were 'insidious and even more profound' and he had suffered chronic and persistent damage. The court heard he suffers from seizures and 'insufferable headaches' as well as blurred vision and post-traumatic stress disorder. 'I do not recognise myself,' said Mr Lee. He claimed that work provided him with structure, identity and pride, but he was now 'no longer the same man' as every aspect of his life had been affected. Mr Lee said his family had also suffered as they were looking at a person who had 'faded into someone unrecognisable.' 'The emotional toll is impossible to fully explain,' he added. He described the assault as not a momentary injury but 'a permanent turning point in my life.' Mr Lee urged Judge John Martin for any sentence to reflect the seriousness of Gorecki's offending, which had 'taken the remaining years of my life.' Pleading for leniency, Mr Kavanagh said Gorecki came from a relatively poor background and had suffered a lot of tragedy. The court heard his father died when he was very young, while his mother died last year, and a brother was killed in a motorcycle accident in Ireland a few years ago. Mr Kavanagh said the defendant had also expressed remorse and shame for what he described as a 'one-off incident.' He said Gorecki was assessed as being at a moderate risk of reoffending, which he believed was linked to his difficulty in finding employment. However, Mr Kavanagh said the accused had recently received the offer of a job at Arklow Golf Club. The barrister said Gorecki had also reduced his alcohol intake and had not committed any other offences since 2023. While not seeking to blame Mr Lee for what happened, Mr Kavanagh said the bouncer had stood 'toe to toe' with the accused and spoke into their faces. Sentencing Gorecki to three and a half years in prison for the assault offence, Judge Martin suspended the final six months for a period of 12 months on condition that the accused place himself under the supervision of the Probation Service on his release from prison for two years and remain free of alcohol for that period. The judge observed that the accused had only demonstrated partial responsibility for an offence that was 'quick and drink-fuelled' but whose effects were 'lasting and very significant.' He said Mr Lee had suffered most horrific injuries in an attack where Gorecki had delivered 'the first and last blow.' The judge noted that the defendant had only entered guilty pleas after a jury had been sworn in to hear his trial. He also took into account that Gorecki had made no concrete expression of remorse or any offer to make amends. The judge offered his best wishes to Mr Lee and expressed hope that the finalisation of the case would bring him some closure.
Telegraph
4 days ago
- Telegraph
White female boss dressed as Whoopi Goldberg for Oscars-themed work party
A white female executive racially harassed her black colleague when she dressed up as Whoopi Goldberg from Sister Act at an Oscar-themed work party, a tribunal heard. Jerry Logo said he experienced an 'immediate rush of anxiety' when he saw Agnes Ganswindt wearing the costume from the 1992 comedy with her face painted black at the office Christmas get-together. The accounts manager told a tribunal that it made him think of the 'dehumanisation' of black people, which caused him to suffer a panic attack. A panel found that Miss Ganswindt, a customer service agent, was 'genuinely unaware' that a white woman dressing up as a black actress might be offensive to someone who is black. Mr Logo sued for racial harassment, but his case was dismissed because he had brought the case four years after the event took place. But after hearing how his employers themselves agreed the 'black-face' event did constitute harassment, an appeal judge has now ruled that the claim should be reheard. The employment appeal tribunal (EAT) heard that Mr Logo started working in the UK for German payments firm Payone in November 2016 as an accounts manager. Some four days after he started work, while at the company's Frankfurt office for induction training, the business held a Christmas party themed as Oscars night. The tribunal said: 'Miss Ganswindt, who is white, attended the event dressed as the character played by Whoopi Goldberg in the Sister Act films.' 'Immediate rush of anxiety' Mr Logo said he felt an 'immediate rush of anxiety' when he saw the person, who he later realised was Miss Ganswindt, in 'black face paint'. The earlier employment tribunal hearing, which took place in Watford in 2023, was overseen by employment Judge Judith George. She said that the panel accepted that not only had Miss Ganswindt chosen the costume before she met Mr Logo, but she was also not aware that he would be in attendance. The judge said the black-face did occur, adding: 'It is conceded by [PayOne] that this incident would amount to race-related harassment on the basis of the unwanted conduct causing the harassing effect, and we accept that it does. '[Mr Logo] argued that this incident was harassment because Miss Ganswindt had the purpose of creating the harassing effect. 'We accept, after careful consideration, that she was genuinely unaware that a black British person would be likely to associate a white woman dressed as a black actress with an offensive and demeaning portrayal of people based on race.'
