Is seat 11A the safest on a plane? Experts weigh in after Air India tragedy
The miraculous survival of a passenger who escaped moments after his Air India flight crashed, killing all others on board, has sparked debate over whether his seat, 11A, is the safest on a plane.
However, aviation experts say that determining the safest seat is not so simple, as aircraft configurations vary significantly and survival usually depends on a complex combination of factors.
"Each accident is different, and it is impossible to predict survivability based on seat location," Mitchell Fox, a director at the Flight Safety Foundation, a US-based nonprofit, said.
Ramesh Viswash Kumar, who was seated in 11A, recounted how his proximity to an emergency exit on the London-bound Boeing 787 Dreamliner that crashed on Thursday allowed him to walk to safety.
Sitting next to an exit door may increase a person's chances of survival in a crash. However, experts say that the specific seat number, such as 11A, is not universally the safest, as aircraft can have numerous different layouts.
'In this particular instance, because the passenger was sitting adjacent to the emergency exit, this was obviously the safest seat on the day,' Ron Bartsch, chairman at Sydney-based AvLaw Aviation Consulting, said.
"But it's not always 11A, it's just 11A on this configuration of the Boeing 787."
A Popular Mechanics study of crashes since 1971, published in 2007, found that passengers seated towards the back of the plane had better survival odds. Some experts also suggest the wing section offers more stability.
Sitting next to an exit door, like Mr Kumar, gives you an opportunity to be one of the first out of the plane, although some exits do not function after a crash. The opposite side of the plane was blocked by the wall of a building it crashed into, he said.
In January 2024, a panel missing several bolts blew off the side of a Boeing 737 MAX mid-flight, creating a gaping hole and damaging the adjacent seat. Fortunately, no one was seated there at the time, and the incident resulted in no fatalities.
Sitting by the aisle might offer you a speedier escape but it increases the likelihood of being hit in the head by luggage falling out of the overhead bins, which is a much more common occurrence than major crashes.
Paying attention to the safety briefing at the start of your flight – often dismissed as routine – is likely the best way to improve your chances of survival, experts say.
Disciplined compliance with cabin crew evacuation advice, including leaving bags behind, was a key factor in saving the lives of all 379 passengers and crew aboard a Japan Airlines flight in January 2024.
The Airbus A350 aircraft had collided with a Coast Guard plane at Tokyo's Haneda Airport, killing five of the six crew members on the smaller aircraft.
Safety briefings typically cover critical instructions such as how to fasten your seatbelt securely, adopt the correct brace position and plan your evacuation route.
A common tip is to count the number of rows between your seat and the nearest exit - vital knowledge if the cabin fills with smoke and visibility is low.
Despite disasters such as the Air India crash, plane designs have evolved to increase the likelihood of passengers walking away from a rare plane accident, Mr Fox said.
These include floor path lighting, fire detection and extinguishers, less flammable cabin materials and improved access to emergency exits.
"There have been remarkable advancements in airplane cabin design that have improved the survivability of accidents on or near the ground," Mr Fox said.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Newsweek
5 hours ago
- Newsweek
Video of Dog's Life After 770 Days in Shelter—What It Shows Is Devastating
Based on facts, either observed and verified firsthand by the reporter, or reported and verified from knowledgeable sources. Newsweek AI is in beta. Translations may contain inaccuracies—please refer to the original content. A heartbreaking viral video has revealed what "severe kennel stress" looks like in a dog that has been waiting for over 770 days in a shelter. Usopp, a six-year-old mixed-breed dog, has sparked widespread attention online, amassing over 180,000 views on TikTok in a video posted earlier this week. Lindsay Kaplan, 34, a South Florida-based shelter volunteer and founder of the Instagram account Every Dog Deserves (@everydogdeserves_), shared the video of Usopp who is currently kenneled at the Humane Society of Greater Miami. In the footage, Usopp was pacing his kennel, frantically leaping at the walls. Despite his anxiety, he remains attached to his shelter space, making it difficult for him to venture too far from his kennel without shutting down. "He is fearful of new people and struggles outside of his kennel," Kaplan told Newsweek. "When he is too far away from his kennel, he cowards, shuts down, and wants to go back inside." Pictures of Usopp the dog who is struggling with kennel stress. Pictures of Usopp the dog who is struggling with kennel stress. @fablinds/TikTok In 2024, approximately 7 million animals entered U.S. shelters and rescues, according to Shelter Animals Count—an increase of nearly 3 percent from 2023. By the end of the year, 103,000 more pets had entered shelters than had exited, contributing to an ongoing capacity crisis in U.S. shelters. Around 748,000 animals experienced non-live outcomes, including euthanasia, death in care, and being lost in care, in 2024. While this represents a 1.6 percent decrease compared to 2023 and a 20 percent drop from 2019, the number remains high. Dogs made up a growing share of these outcomes, with euthanasia rates rising to 9 percent, compared to 7 percent in 2019. What is kennel stress? Kennel stress is a term often used to describe the mental and emotional stress dogs feel after a stay in a kennel environment. This is often as a result of noise and confinement, dealing with unfamiliar people and animals and lack of familiar comforts like beds or toys. It often manifests in fear, anxiety or aggression, and can cause behaviors including shaking, whining, excessive barking, hiding and repetitive behaviors like in the video, including pacing, circling or spinning. As the video of Usopp gained more attention online, people shared their thoughts. Viewer @kariijrea, wrote: "Omg hope this baby gets a home soon!!" Following two years looking for the perfect owner, Usopp needs to find the right home. He has a history of biting on his record and would rather be the only dog in the home. "We want Usopp to find the loving home he deserves, but it will take a very special person that is willing to be patient with him learning a new routine and owner," Kaplan said. For more information on Usopp, visit the Humane Society of Greater Miami. Do you have funny and adorable videos or pictures of your pet you want to share? Send them to life@ with some details about your best friend, and they could appear in our Pet of the Week lineup.
National Geographic
6 hours ago
- National Geographic
The unlikely comeback of America's most endangered songbird
Florida grasshopper sparrow chicks peer up out of their ground nest waiting for food from their mother. Photographs by Carlton Ward Jr. On the dry prairies of the Sunshine State, there's a tiny, camouflaged bird known as the Florida grasshopper sparrow. Each one weighs about as much as three U.S. quarters yet has to survive against a backdrop of torrential floods, herds of stomping cattle, and waves of ravenous fire ants. Not to mention the humans. 'We've lost over 90 percent of their habitat,' says Fabiola 'Fabby' Baeza-Tarin, a senior conservation ecologist with a Tampa-based consulting firm known as Common Ground Ecology. A Florida grasshopper sparrow sings from its perch in the Florida prairie at dawn. Florida grasshopper sparrows and many other organisms rely on the dry prairie for their entire life cycles, not even leaving to migrate, but humans have increasingly rendered the space inhabitable by clearing and draining it to make way for development, ranching, and intensified agriculture, such as orange groves. 'So, of course, along with the loss of dry prairie, we also lost a bunch of sparrows,' says Baeza-Tarin. There are now fewer than 200 known Florida grasshopper sparrows on Earth. And that's actually a considerable step up from where things were. Over the last three decades, an Avengers-like combination of federal and state agencies, military personnel, private landowners, and contractors like Baeza-Tarin have joined forces to snatch the birds back from the brink of extinction. 'Collaboration is key,' says KT Bryden, a conservationist and filmmaker at WildPath who directed the short film, 'The Little Brown Bird', which documents the sparrow's path to recovery. 'That's the way we can move forward: making an impact through collaboration and coming together to protect something bigger than ourselves,' says Bryden. The sun rises over the Everglades Headwaters region of Central Florida. The conservation of the Florida Grasshopper Sparrow has contributed to the protection of over 180,000 acres of habitat in the region. Many of the Florida grasshopper sparrow's problems stem from the fact that, as birds adapted to a life on the open prairie, this subspecies nests on the ground. That puts the tiny avians within reach of native predators, such as snakes and skunks, as well as other, less natural threats. 'Sometimes it pours here, and then 200 meters down that way is completely dry,' says Baeza-Tarin. To combat the flooding, the team—which includes stakeholders at the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, the Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission, the Avon Park Air Force Range, the Archbold Biological Station, Common Ground Ecology, and White Oak Conservation, as well as private landowners—can actually cut the soil and vegetation around the nest, then raise the whole platform up by six to eight inches by tucking dirt underneath. They also put fencing around the nests to protect against wandering predators. And boiling-hot water, pumped into the ground by way of industrial pressure washers, helps ward off colonies of invasive fire ants, which can wipe out a nest of chicks within hours. Fabiola 'Fabby' Baeza releases a grasshopper sparrow from a mist net with technician Nicole Rita while conducting research for Archbold Biological Station. Three eggs of the endangered birds rest in their nest. A temporary fence protects the nest from ground predators. Some treatments, such as the glorified, anti-ant squirt gun, are especially useful on what Baeza-Tarin calls 'working lands,' or areas owned by ranchers that the Florida grasshoppers have recently colonized. At first, most experts considered habitats grazed by cattle to be an ecological trap for the birds, says Baeza-Tarin. The worry was that the birds would be lured to such areas but not survive well, because the composition of plants is so different than what they're used to. 'But we quickly learned that by applying the same conservation methods that were being used on the native sites, they were equally as productive,' she says. What's more, the working lands appear to be serving as a corridor between the last five remaining natural populations of sparrows. 'It just goes to show that the ranchers can be good stewards for the land, and the sparrows and the cows can coexist in some of the areas down there,' says Archer Larned, an ornithologist who studied Florida grasshopper sparrows during her PhD at the University of Maryland Baltimore County, and is not affiliated with the film. The Corrigan Ranch in Okeechobee County is a top priority for conservation by the Florida Department of Environmental Protection. Perhaps the largest source of hope for the little brown birds comes from a relatively recent effort to breed the birds in captivity and then release them back into the wild Since May 2019, experts have successfully bred and released more than 1,000 captive-reared birds into the wild across two sites, says Baeza-Tarin, who formerly assisted with releases as an employee of the Archbold Research Station. What's more, both sites—Avon Park, which is owned and managed by the Air Force, and Three Lakes Wildlife Management Area—have seen upswings in their wild sparrow populations. Avon Park Air Force Range protects more than 100,000 acres of habitat, including native dry prairie. While only 20 percent of the captive-bred birds stick around and establish their own breeding territories in release areas, experts remain hopeful that some of the birds are doing well in new areas not under observation. After all, it was only as recently as 2012 that scientists discovered the first population of Florida grasshopper sparrows surviving on working lands. 'I was down there from 2013 to 2016,' says Larned, 'and it was a pretty depressing project to work on for a while, because every time I would go down, there were fewer birds.' However, Larned says the documentary paints the birds' outlook in an uplifting light. 'It brought back a lot of memories,' she says. 'It was good to see how well the captive breeding program is doing and how it's really helped to boost the population.' For the film's executive producer Carlton Ward Jr., a National Geographic Explorer, the film is about even more than that. 'I want people to fall in love with the Florida grasshopper sparrow, but ultimately, I want them to fall in love with the prairie and the rare ecosystem it needs to survive. There's a magic to that bird that is really an emblem for small, underappreciated wildlife that are really hidden in plain sight all around us.' Ward is also the founder of the Florida Wildlife Corridor Foundation; the corridor itself is made up of 18 million acres of wilderness and working lands crucial to the survival of more than 100 imperiled species throughout the state. 'A lot of people live on the [Florida] coast, and they're not really aware of the habitats in the center of the state,' says Bryden. 'This is where the majority of Floridians are getting their drinking water from. So, protecting the sparrow also means protecting us.' Two Florida grasshopper sparrows fly our of their aviary into the wild Kissimmee prairie habitat. A total of 12 sparrows born at the conservation breeding facility were released together. While much less celebrated than coral reefs or tropical rainforests, Florida's dry prairies also sustain innumerable creatures—plants and animals that also benefit from sparrow protections. That makes it what scientists call an umbrella species, but it's also an ecosystem indicator. 'The Florida grasshopper sparrow may seem very small and unassuming, but the bird's survival is directly tied to the health of the habitat,' says Bryden. 'If this bird isn't doing well, there's something wrong. Something that we should all be paying attention to.'
New York Post
6 hours ago
- New York Post
Bandaged lone Air India survivor carries coffin of brother killed in crash
The bruised and battered sole survivor of the Air India plane tragedy helped carry his brother's coffin Wednesday after his sibling was among the more than 240 killed in last week's crash. A visibly upset Vishwash Kumar Ramesh was covered in bandages as he laid his brother, Ajay Ramesh, to rest during the funeral service in Gujarat in western India. The 40-year-old British national was spotted walking with a limp as he and the other pallbearers carried his late sibling's coffin through the streets. Vishwash Kumar Ramesh was covered in bandages as he laid his brother, Ajay Ramesh, to rest during the funeral service in Gujarat in western India on Wednesday. ViralPress Ramesh and his 35-year-old brother had been sitting near each other on the London-bound flight when it suddenly went down in a residential neighborhood in Ahmedabad last Thursday. The brothers had been returned to the UK after visiting relatives in India. In the wake of the wreckage, harrowing footage emerged of a blood-soaked Ramesh miraculously limping away from the site still clutching his boarding pass. 'The side of the plane I was in landed on the ground, and I could see that there was space outside the aircraft, so when my door broke, I tried to escape through it,' Ramesh said from his hospital bed in the aftermath. Ramesh, pictured speaking to India's Prime Minister Narendra Modi, has spent much of the last week in hospital. NARENDRA MODI YOUTUBE CHANNEL/AFP via Getty Images 'I managed to unbuckle myself, used my leg to push through that opening, and crawled out. I still can't believe how I survived. I walked out of the rubble.' Ramesh said he had been sitting in seat 11A, while his brother was seated in 11J when the plane went down. Investigators are still probing a cause of the tragedy.
