Breast cancer patients ‘denied life-extending drugs because of unfair system'
It is also calling for the NHS spending watchdog the National Institute for Health and Care Excellence (Nice) to lower the bar for what it classes as a very severe health condition.
Nice's severity modifier, introduced in 2022, gives treatment for more severe illnesses more weight, meaning the health benefits of certain drugs are valued more highly and more likely to be recommended for NHS use.
According to Nice, the process raises the threshold for what it considers to be a cost-effective treatment, meaning it can give more expensive drugs the green light.
However, a new report from Breast Cancer Now claims the system means women with incurable breast cancer with months to live may be told their condition does not qualify for the most severe rating.
The call comes after it emerged that the life-extending drug Enhertu will not be made available for women with incurable breast cancer on the NHS in England and Wales.
In November, Nice said talks with manufacturers AstraZeneca and Daiichi Sankyo over the price of the medication had broken down for the third time with no agreement.
Claire Rowney, chief executive at Breast Cancer Now, said: 'The terrifying reality is that unless urgent action is taken thousands of women in the UK with incurable secondary breast cancer could be denied access to vital life-extending treatments because of an unfair system.
'We're talking about patients missing out on access to cutting-edge, effective treatments that could give them more time to be there for special moments such as birthdays or seeing their children or grandchildren start school.
'Treatments, such as Enhertu, that patients in other countries, including Scotland, can access, giving them the chance to live longer.
'Women with secondary breast cancer tell us they feel their lives are being deprioritised by the changes to the system.
'We will not stand by and witness more drugs being rejected or not taken forward, when the devastating cost is thousands more people with secondary breast cancer across England, Wales and Northern Ireland having their lives cut short.'
Paula Van Santen, 50, was diagnosed with secondary breast cancer in July 2022, two months after her diagnosis of primary breast cancer.
The mother-of-three, from Banbury in Oxfordshire, said: 'Secondary breast cancer has changed the lives of both myself and my family beyond belief. Coming to terms with my diagnosis is the hardest part because I've had to grieve for the life I had, but also the life that I'm not going to have.
'If a new drug can give me another six months, if it gives me another year, it's worth it.
'It could allow me to see my daughter get to 21, see my children get married or meet grandchildren. Just to have a picture with a grandchild so they would know that I existed would be so precious. That's what this could give.'
Ms Rowney called for 'change' and said Mr Streeting should scrap 'opportunity-cost neutral' restraints.
Opportunity cost neutrality in the Nice severity modifier aims to ensure the new system does not require more or less overall NHS funding than the old one.
According to the Breast Cancer Now report, this is 'at the root of the issues with the modifier'.
It added: 'It pits end-of-life cancer treatments against other severe conditions like cystic fibrosis in a way that's reductive and unfair to patients. And, ultimately, it creates barriers to the approval of drugs for advanced cancers.'
Ms Rowney said: 'The system for deciding whether drugs are approved for use on the NHS must change now.
'We're calling for immediate action from Wes Streeting, Secretary of State for Health and Social Care, to urgently scrap 'opportunity-cost neutral' restraints and for Nice to lower the bar for what it defines as 'a severe condition'. And we stand ready to work with them.'
Dr Samantha Roberts, chief executive of Nice, welcomed the report from Breast Cancer Now, saying: 'The independent analysis we commissioned recently showed the new severity weighting is working as intended and expected.
'It is able to be applied more widely – for example to treatments for cystic fibrosis, hepatitis D and Duchenne muscular dystrophy – and has contributed to an increase in positive decisions for cancer medicines and non-cancer medicines.
'And other breast cancer treatments have been recommended since we introduced the severity modifier – including for advanced breast cancer.
'We remain deeply disappointed that we were unable to recommend Enhertu for HER2-low advanced breast cancer. We know this was devastating to all those hoping for a different answer.
'It remains the only breast cancer treatment we have been unable to recommend in seven years.'
A Department of Health and Social Care spokesperson said the upcoming 10-year health plan will 'transform the NHS and improve care for those facing cancer'.
'This includes rolling out DIY screening kits for cervical cancer, more radiotherapy machines in every region and opening more Community Diagnostic Centres closer to where people live,' they added.
'We know how disappointing it is to many families that the manufacturers of Enhertu are unwilling to sell this life-extending treatment to the NHS at a fair and reasonable price. Our door remains open to supporting the introduction of medicines at a cost-effective price.'
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
BBC News
30 minutes ago
- BBC News
Starmer outlines six-day a week neighbourhood health hub plan after backing Reeves
Update: Date: 07:19 BST Title: Reeves doing excellent job, PM tells BBC after Commons tears Content: The prime minister has backed Rachel Reeves to stay on as chancellor for "many years to come" after she was seen crying during PMQs. In the Commons, Starmer didn't say whether Reeves would still be in her job at the next election. But later, speaking to BBC Radio 4's Political Thinking with Nick Robinson, Starmer said he worked "in lockstep" with Reeves and that she was "doing an excellent job as chancellor". He also insisted her tearful appearance had "nothing to do with politics". You can watch a clip of the conversation below. This video can not be played Reeves will be chancellor 'for a very long time to come', says Starmer Update: Date: 07:06 BST Title: 'Deeply upsetting' to see chancellor in tears - shadow minister Content: The NHS reform plan set to be announced today comes after yesterday's PMQs, where Chancellor Rachel Reeves was seen in tears. Shadow chancellor Mel Stride tells BBC Breakfast he sent Reeves a message yesterday 'just to say I hope that she was all right'. 'I felt for her,' he says. He adds it was 'deeply upsetting to see', especially as it was 'such a public moment'. 'We are all human beings at the end of the day - politicians are human beings - they do have feelings,' he says. But on the business side, he says the welfare U-turn shows the government 'is not gripping things', and adds the bond markets 'are quite twitchy'. Update: Date: 06:53 BST Title: 'It's reform or die' for the NHS, says Starmer Content: Keir Starmer during a visit to the Elective Orthopaedic Centre at Epsom Hospital in January In comments released overnight, Keir Starmer says the health system the government has inherited is "in crisis". "That ends now," he says. "Because it's reform or die. "Our 10 Year Health Plan will fundamentally rewire and future-proof our NHS so that it puts care on people's doorsteps, harnesses game-changing tech and prevents illness in the first place." This means, Starmer says, giving everyone access to GPs, nurses and wider support all under one roof in their neighbourhood, and "rebalancing our health system so that it fits around patients' lives, not the other way round". He says it's not an overnight fix, but the government is already "turning the tide on years of decline", with four million extra NHS appointments, 1,900 more GPs and waiting lists at their lowest level for two years. "But there's more to come. This government is giving patients easier, quicker and more convenient care, wherever they live." Update: Date: 06:45 BST Title: What will the 'Neighbourhood Health Service' look like? Content: Keir Starmer says today's plan will "fundamentally rewire" the NHS in England, with a focus on three areas: moving from treatment to prevention, analogue to digital, and hospital to more community care. What does that mean in practice? Update: Date: 06:43 BST Title: Starmer sets out 10-year NHS plan amid 'tough' few days for Labour Content: This video can not be played Watch: Starmer says past few days have 'been tough' Prime Minister Keir Starmer is today setting out a 10-year plan for the NHS in England, aiming to move the health service towards prevention and community care, as well as digitalising it. The prime minister says his NHS plan will "fundamentally rewire" the service, with the aim that by 2035 most outpatient care - including eye care, cardiology and mental health - will happen outside hospitals. But while the government is selling the "Neighbourhood Health Service" as a major overhaul, others are asking how soon people will see a difference - and exactly how, and if, it will work. Today's announcement follows Starmer giving his "full backing" to Chancellor Rachel Reeves after her tearful appearance in the Commons yesterday. The last few days have been "tough" for Starmer's government, the PM said, after a major climbdown over welfare changes left a hole in Labour's spending plans. Speaking to Nick Robinson, Starmer admitted he "did not engage" properly with Labour MPs on the issue, and praised Reeves for "doing an excellent job as chancellor". We'll bring you all the latest updates, analysis and reaction to all of the above throughout the day. This video can not be played Reeves appears tearful during PMQs
The Independent
an hour ago
- The Independent
NHS plan vows to end ‘8am scramble' for GP appointment
The government announced a radical 10-year plan to overhaul the NHS, aiming to shift healthcare from hospitals to community and home-based services. The strategy outlines three major shifts: moving from analogue to digital services, prioritising prevention over treatment, and transitioning from hospital-centric care to community-based provision. By 2035, most outpatient services are expected to be delivered outside hospitals, with new neighbourhood health services providing diagnostics, post-operative care, and mental health support closer to communities. The plan includes training thousands more GPs, encouraging AI use for notes, and improving dental care access, including a requirement for newly-qualified dentists to practice in the NHS. The initiative seeks to reduce pressure on GPs and A&E, making healthcare more accessible and integrated into daily life, though experts raise concerns about funding and workforce shortages.
BBC News
an hour ago
- BBC News
NHS boss says Labour's 10-year plan for NHS is essential
A hospital boss has admitted that NHS services are struggling and said it is essential for the government's new 10-year plan to are being made as part of Labour's 10-year health strategy published today. Nick Hulme, chief executive of East Suffolk and North Essex NHS Foundation Trust (ESNEFT) said: "We are not in crisis yet, but we are in a really, really tricky situation."Part of the shake-up will lead to neighbourhood health services rolled out across the country in an attempt to bring diagnostics, mental health, post-op, rehab, and nursing to people's doorsteps. The plan has put more emphasis on community care and GP surgeries but Mr Hulme, in charge at Colchester Hospital and Ipswich Hospital, said there needs to be funding to go with told the BBC: "We can see full hospitals up and down the country, sadly, with patients still waiting in the corridors. "That is something we might have seen in the winter four or five years ago - we now see it throughout the year. "We know the NHS simply cannot cope with that level of demand with the resources we have at the moment."He said there were significant challenges in A&E and on waiting times. Prevention and support He believes the NHS needs to change what the public can expect from the service and shift the focus away from just purely hospital care. Mr Hulme said frail, elderly, people who still live independently were most likely to be brought into the hospital after a fall or infection. "We know in our communities who is at highest risk at being admitted into hospital."If we get some care and get some prevention and support those families and individuals much earlier it will prevent them coming into hospital for issues that they don't need an acute bed for, " he added. He also said the plan hopes to bring the NHS "into the 21st Century" by encouraging people to use the NHS app and booking appointments electronically. Follow East of England news on X, Instagram and Facebook: BBC Beds, Herts & Bucks, BBC Cambridgeshire, BBC Essex, BBC Norfolk, BBC Northamptonshire or BBC Suffolk.
