
Snow White: Little people feel 'erased' by Disney's use of CGI instead of real actors
Disney's use of CGI to create the seven miners at the heart of the live-action remake of Snow White And The Seven Dwarves has left little people feeling "disregarded" and "erased," according to a disability activist.
Comedian, model and content creator Fats Timbo, who has spoken about being bullied as a child, told Sky News she believes Disney has missed a golden opportunity to educate children in what is likely to be their first encounter with someone with dwarfism.
Timbo, who has dedicated her activism to raising the profile of people of short stature, has achondroplasia, a genetic condition that inhibits growth and affects around one in 27,500 people.
Award-winning actor Peter Dinklage, who has the same condition, previously criticised the film, telling the WTF With Marc Maron podcast: "It makes no sense to me. You're progressive in one way, but then you're still making that f***ing backward story about seven dwarves living in a cave together?"
Following the remarks, Disney said it consulted with members of the dwarfism community to "avoid reinforcing stereotypes from the original animated film".
It was the 1937 classic that established Disney's name as an industry leader. But the remake has been beset by controversy.
Early on it was labelled "woke" due to its casting of Latina actress Rachel Zegler, who is of Colombian-Polish descent, in the lead role.
Zegler also faced backlash after suggesting the early version of the film had content that was unsuitable for the 21st century - namely the fact the prince "literally stalks" Snow White.
There was then speculation as to whether Zegler and Israeli actress Gal Gadot, who plays the evil queen, got on as they have previously expressed very different views over the Gaza war.
Not dwarves but 'animated magical creatures'
Now the erasing of the dwarves - first from the title, then from the film, at least in human form - is proving highly divisive.
Disney used computer-generated images (CGI) to create what they called "animated magical creatures" rather than using little people in the roles.
Timbo tells Sky News: "Our representation is already small as it is - no pun intended. It's already limited. To erase that and use CGI, like we're mythical creatures or people that could be made on computers, it's disregarding us in general."
She goes on: "Let's say kids have never seen somebody that has my condition and they've seen a CGI version of me. It's going to be a bit baffling to children. It could have been a real educational piece to have actors that have the condition and give them the role they deserve."
Timbo says lack of visibility for small people has real-world consequences.
"I used to get made fun of all the time. [Kids would be] saying 'You're one of the dwarves from Snow White,' that kind of thing. I think now when somebody sees a little person, they're not going to believe it's real. They're going to see that CGI version on Snow White instead of seeing a real little person that has real character with real depth."
'Snow White And The Little People'
Timbo says other children's films were also used to taunt her, including Charlie And The Chocolate Factory: "The Oompa Loompas - I got called that all the time."
In the Snow White remake, Martin Klebba voices CGI Grumpy, while George Appleby has a physical character, playing one of a band of seven robbers - both actors are little people.
But the decision not to use people of small stature to play all seven dwarves on-screen has left many scratching their heads.
And it's not the first time small people have been edited out of movies.
Charlie And The Chocolate Factory's 2023 re-make, Wonka, used special effects to shrink down Hugh Grant to play an Oompa Loompa, while 2012 film Snow White And The Huntsman replaced its dwarves with able-bodied actors Ian McShane, Ray Winstone and Nick Frost.
Not a fan of the term dwarfism, Timbo says she thinks Disney would also have done well to tackle the title differently, too: "If they had put a different spin on it where it was Snow White And The Little People, that would have sounded great."
She says that in an attempt to avoid controversy, Disney chose "the safe option" of simply cutting the physical roles completely, and letting CGI fill the void.
It's a decision Timbo calls "upsetting," due to the fact it "reaffirms the negative stereotypes of little people not being actual people".
Disney's poisoned apple
Timbo's 2023 book Main Character Energy, about living fearlessly in the face of adversity, seems like it could be a good read for the bosses of Disney right now, as they face growing criticism over the decision.
With a muted release (no Leicester Square premiere, and a limited LA debut) it's been a less-than-fairytale opening for a movie which had been intended to rival the success of 2017 remake Beauty And The Beast. Many might say it has turned into something of a poisoned apple.
Proving controversial and polarising, the response couldn't be more removed from Disney's brand proposition if it tried. Early reviews are so far mixed.
Timbo says she will give the movie a shot: "I want to see if it lives up to the hype or the bad press."
Box office figures and audience ratings will soon deliver a verdict, and Timbo remains generous despite reservations: "I want it to surprise me, I want to enjoy it… I hope it does do well. But obviously, I think Disney could have done things a bit differently."
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Scotsman
an hour ago
- Scotsman
Film Reviews: How to Train Your Dragon Ballerina
Sign up to our Arts and Culture newsletter, get the latest news and reviews from our specialist arts writers Sign up Thank you for signing up! Did you know with a Digital Subscription to The Scotsman, you can get unlimited access to the website including our premium content, as well as benefiting from fewer ads, loyalty rewards and much more. Learn More Sorry, there seem to be some issues. Please try again later. Submitting... How to Train Your Dragon (PG) ★★★ Tornado (15) ★★ Ballerina (15) ★★★ With the bafflingly big box-office haul for Disney's current Lilo & Stitch remake once again justifying the studio's creatively dubious decision to do live-action remakes of its animation classics, it's surprising it's taken as long for other studios to follow suit. But here's DreamWorks with its own live action re-do of How to Train Your Dragon, its instant classic 2010 hit about an inventive Viking kid who rejects his dragon-slayer heritage after befriending an injured fire-breather called Toothless. How To Train Your Dragon | Universal Pictures The original film — based on the book series by Cressida Cowell — inspired two pretty decent sequels and a spin-off animated TV show; it also boasted incredible visuals and provided Gerard Butler with a rare opportunity to deploy his gruff Paisley burr as the voice of hapless hero Hiccup's burley chieftain father Stoick. Though Butler is the only returning cast member to survive the transition — he's clearly having a blast as the in-the-flesh version of his cartoon counterpoint — the film remains an oddly faithful simulacrum of the animated version. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad That's both good and bad. Good because everything that worked about the first film — the soaring visuals, the sweet bond between Hiccup and Toothless, the amusing training montages — also works this time round; bad because, well, it all feels vaguely pointless. Still, it now exists and it's not exactly a chore to sit through. After a shaky opening salvo setting up the basics of the story — the Vikings still all live on an island called Berk and are locked in an ongoing battle to protect themselves and their livestock from the dragons plundering their land for food — returning director Dean Deblois soon finds his rhythm, with Mason Thames a winning presence as the desperate-to-please Hiccup, Nico Parker feisty and fun as the more capable slayer-in-training Astrid, and Nick Frost a goofy delight as Stoick's right-hand man Gobber. But please, can we just have some new family films instead of all these redos? Jack Lowden in Tornado | Contributed It's been ten years since Scottish writer/director John Maclean's pleasingly strange debut Slow West marked the former Beta Band member out as a filmmaker with a keen sense of how to subvert classic genres like the western. Sadly, that's not quite the case with his belated follow-up film Tornado, a wilderness thriller with an intriguing samurai twist, set in an unnamed part of the British Isles in 1790, though shot primarily in Scotland. It stars Tim Roth and Jack Lowden as Sugarman and Little Sugar, the father-son leaders of a group of murderous marauders who, as the film opens, are in pursuit of a young Japanese woman. We don't yet know why, but as the film's puzzle-box structure starts to fall into place details gradually emerge: some stolen gold has gone missing during the performance of a samurai-themed touring puppet show that the woman, who goes by the name of Tornado, performs with her father Fujin, a taciturn traditionalist who wants his resistant daughter to retain a connection to their homeland (Tornado is played by rising Japanese star Kōki; Fujin by Shōgun star Takehiro Hira). Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad Sign up to our FREE Arts & Culture newsletter at Their familial tension finds a harsher parallel in the relationship between Sugarman and Little Sugar, who resents his father's insistence on giving every member of the gang an equal share of the loot he apparently did the most to procure. When the two groups' paths cross in violent fashion, these simmering generational conflicts come to the fore, but only Roth — whose character's bleeding stomach wound feels like an arch tribute to his role in Reservoir Dogs — is given enough material to imbue proceedings with any real depth. The rest of the film is so vaguely sketched there's no sense of who these characters are or what this world is. Consequently, when it eventually turns into a bloody revenge movie, the action feels frustratingly stilted and repetitive, the title character never quite becoming the force of nature her name implies. Ana de Armas as Eve in Ballerina | Courtesy of Lionsgate There's much more pulpy fun to be had in Ballerina, an entertainingly ludicrous spin-off from the John Wick franchise in which Ana De Armas makes good on the action star potential glimpsed in No Time To Die to play an orphan raised in a ballet school that doubles as a front for an elite assassin training facility. Said school was first introduced in John Wick 3: Parabellum and the movie takes place in that film's timeline, with Keanu Reeves popping up in an extended cameo to recreate some scenes from that film, and a few new ones too, as De Armas's character, Eve, is encouraged to 'fight like a girl' and embark on her own kill-crazy mission to avenge her father's murder. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad Though the back story is a bit rote — it's almost identical to Black Widow and the Jennifer Lawrence spy thriller Red Sparrow — the action builds to a suitably barmy showdown involving flamethrowers that kicks the whole thing up a gear.


Sky News
an hour ago
- Sky News
The making of The Wargame podcast with Sir Ben Wallace and Deborah Haynes
👉 Listen to Sky News Daily on your podcast app 👈 The Wargame was designed to test the state of the UK's defences and national resilience after decades of cuts to military spending following the end of the Cold War. A year in the making, the podcast was recorded in just one day with a cast of politicians and their advisers, all of whom have worked at the top levels of the British government. In today's episode, Sky's international affairs editor Dominic Waghorn talks to security and defence editor Deborah Haynes, who created and wrote The Wargame, about why she thought it was so important to make the podcast - and to former defence secretary Sir Ben Wallace, who plays the prime minister.


The Independent
2 hours ago
- The Independent
Disney to pay almost $439 million to complete takeover of Hulu
Disney is set to pay NBCUniversal, owned by Comcast, nearly $439 million to acquire its stake in Hulu, thereby assuming full control of the streaming platform. This agreement concludes an appraisal process that has been ongoing for several years. Back in November 2023, Disney announced its intentions to purchase Comcast's 33% stake in Hulu for a minimum of $27.5 billion. Disney has been managing Hulu since 2019, when Comcast relinquished its authority, becoming a silent partner in the venture. Hulu was initially established in 2007, rapidly evolving into a service supported by entertainment conglomerates aiming to combat the rise of the internet by creating an online platform for their television shows. Disney joined the partnership in 2009, with plans to offer content from ABC, ESPN, and the Disney Channel. A decade later, Disney solidified its control over the business through the acquisition of 21st Century Fox. Disney said in a regulatory filing on Monday that its appraiser arrived at a valuation below the guaranteed floor value during the initial phase of the appraisal process, while NBCUniversal's appraiser arrived at a valuation substantially in excess of the guaranteed floor value. A third appraiser was brought in and concluded that The Walt Disney Co. will pay $438.7 million for the Hulu stake. 'We are pleased this is finally resolved. We have had a productive partnership with NBCUniversal, and we wish them the best of luck," Disney CEO Bob Iger said in a statement. "Completing the Hulu acquisition paves the way for a deeper and more seamless integration of Hulu's general entertainment content with Disney+ and, soon, with ESPN's direct-to-consumer product, providing an unrivaled value proposition for consumers.' The transaction is anticipated to close by July 24. It's not expected to impact Disney's fiscal 2025 adjusted earnings forecast. Shares of Disney rose slightly in morning trading on Tuesday.