Black Caviar and Winx to be elevated to Legend status in Australian Racing Hall of Fame
Winx or Black Caviar? Who was the greatest?
The mighty mares were both freakish champions and trying to determine who is the best is the subject of robust debate.
There is a school of thought that comparing champions of different eras is a futile exercise but racing – and other sports – is built on comparisons.
We all like to consider how Phar Lap would have gone against today's champions. Or, who is the best racehorse, Secretariat or Frankel?
It's the same in other sports. In cricket, we are forever comparing the records of modern day batters like Steve Smith to the legendary Sir Donald Bradman.
In rugby league, is Wally Lewis better than Andrew Johns? Is Reg Gasnier or John Raper the best of them all?
• PUNT LIKE A PRO: Become a Racenet iQ member and get expert tips – with fully transparent return on investment statistics – from Racenet's team of professional punters at our Pro Tips section. SUBSCRIBE NOW!
It's the same with AFL. There's plenty in Leigh Matthews' corner, Gary Ablett Senior is in the conversation, as are Ted Whitten, John Coleman and Tony Lockett.
There are always comparisons between Michael Jordan or LeBron James as the best basketballer, and does any boxer challenge Muhammad Ali as the greatest of all-time?
In tennis, there is ongoing debate about the best player of the modern era – Roger Federer, Rafael Nadal or Novak Djokovic? And how do they rate against the only man to win the Grand Slam twice, Rod Laver?
The point is comparing champion racehorses is like debating the greats of other sports – it's a fun exercise and we all do it.
But when analysing the race careers of Winx and Black Caviar, how do you split them?
This was the dilemma facing the Australian Racing Hall of Fame selection committee when determining which of these two mares would be elevated to 'Legend' status at the Hall of Fame-Racehorse of the Year awards in Brisbane on August 31.
There are only three racehorses elevated to the Legend category so far – Phar Lap, Carbine and Makybe Diva – and it is the most elite honour in Australian racing.
Winx and Black Caviar are both deserving of 'Legend'' status, it was just a matter of when.
And trying to decide who would go in first was like asking which mare would win if they clashed over 1400m at weight-for-age?
In the end, the selection panel simply couldn't split them and made the unprecedented but sensible call to elevate both Winx and Black Caviar to 'Legend' status the same year.
'It is fitting Black Caviar and Winx are going in as a 'Legend' together,'' said Peter Moody, trainer of Black Caviar.
'They are both great mares and it was only a matter of time, with all due respect, they were both going to get that honour and very deservedly so.''
Perfection! ðŸ'¯
Do yourself a favour & watch Black Caviar's 25 wins from 25 starts �
Which victory was your favourite? pic.twitter.com/ejIuDyuXEj
— Racing.com (@Racing) August 17, 2024
•
Hall of Fame chairman Jason Scott echoed the sentiments of the entire selection panel when he said: 'Debate has raged for years over which of the two champion mares is the greatest we've seen, however what is certain is that their legacies transcend far beyond the boundaries of racing.
'It's deserving that they both be bestowed 'Legend' status in the Australian Racing Hall of Fame together, befitting of their stature as two of the best we have and will ever have the (good) fortune to see'.
Winx won 37 of her 43 races, including her last 33 races in succession, featuring a world record 25 at Group 1 level. She was so good they made a movie about her.
'I always admired Winx's determination and the uncomplicated way she went about her work and racing,'' Waller said. 'She didn't require any extra fuss.
'She was a high performance athlete with an amazing amount of talent, and she captured the imagination.
'When I talk to people about Winx, there's nothing but ultimate respect for her. It is fitting she has been elevated to 'Legend' status.''
"IT'S EQUINE UTOPIA!"
It wouldn't be Cox Plate week without the four-time champion Winx - the most successful Cox Plate horse in history 🙌
If you're looking for more Cox Plate replays, you can head to https://t.co/Ga3GHuaAKJ 's Vault to watch them ðŸ'‰ https://t.co/rnwadynQhP pic.twitter.com/MnNVRdF6zU
— Racing.com (@Racing) October 24, 2024
Black Caviar was simply unbeatable. 25 starts, 25 wins, 15 at Group 1 level. Surely there has never been a better sprinter than this magnificent mare.
She won most of her races effortlessly, running fast times and breaking the hearts of her chasing rivals. Even when she wasn't at her absolute best, like the 2012 Diamond Jubilee Stakes at Royal Ascot, they still couldn't beat her.
'Black Caviar changed my life,'' Moody said. 'Every day, I still think about her and then when Royal Ascot comes each year around you relive those great memories again. She was a once-in-a-lifetime horse.''
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
News.com.au
36 minutes ago
- News.com.au
The Back Page: Australia's longest running sports show finishes after 29-year run on Fox Sports
I've only ever spoken to Kevin Sheedy twice but he lives inside my head. He's been there for 12 years since the night on Fox Sports' The Back Page when we showed a comical clip of an angry Sheedy addressing his young Greater Western Sydney side mid-match. What made it so funny was that Sheedy emphasised random WORDS at random POINTS and not NECESSARILY the RIGHT moments to provide golden fodder for panellist and master mimic Billy Birmingham who was in his ELEMENT. All these years later when someone mentions Sheedy's name, I still hear Billy going off in one of the many endearing moments from the show which finishes its 29-year run with its final episode at 7.30pm Tuesday. What better way to kick off our 'Back Page Memories' than reliving this rousing speech from Kevin Sheedy. The reaction from Gibbo, Billy, Crash and Marto is pure gold! 😆 #TheBackPage | #BackPageMemories @FOXSportsAUS @craddock_cmail @MattParslow1 â€' Best Bits of The Back Page (@backpagebestof) June 8, 2025 Twenty nine years. Among the few shows to last longer were Play School (58 years) and Here's Humphrey (45) and there is a theory among Back Page panellists that we accidentally put both out of business by stealing their audience. In that 29-year period Australia has had eight Prime Ministers and nine Test cricket captains, yet the little ol' Back Page – incredibly – has had just two main hosts, the legendary Mike Gibson and the equally talented Tony Squires. Born in early 1997, three months before the first appearance of Harry Potter, the Back Page now joins Harry in flying off into the sunset with Squires and co-host Candice Warner joined for the last show by Ryan Fitzgerald, vivacious former host Kelli Underwood who has been lured back for a cameo farewell, and myself. The team have dug through the archives to find the #Top5 embarrassing cramp moments in sport! #TheBackPage | @FOXSportsAUS â€' Best Bits of The Back Page (@backpagebestof) May 18, 2025 The 29-year run says everything about Gibbo and Squires' love of their show with Squires saying 'Gibbo felt the show was at its best when it felt like people talking in a pub and it became a big part of my social life talking to interesting people like Kelli, Candice, Brad Johnson, Kerry O'Keeffe and Ben Dixon''. Both Gibbo and Squires loathed missing an episode. Gibbo, ably supported by likes of Peter FitzSimons and the late Peter Frilingos, did 720 shows over 16 years and missed just one when he was lying flat out with a back injury. The only way they could have shot the show was with a camera on the ceiling, a stretch too far even for Gibbo. For the panelists like myself, the Back Page was the best fun of our careers. When soccer legend Robbie Slater was told that due to budget restrictions panelists may have to take a pay cut and he replied 'hey ... I'd go on for nothing ... I just enjoy it''. A few years back a former Test cricket great flew over from Perth and did an episode he so enjoyed it he didn't even put in an invoice to get paid. We were fortunate to see the late, great Andrew Symonds on the panel a few times over the years - Roy even treated us to a couple of his brilliant impersonations! #TheBackPage | #BackPageMemories @FOXSportsAUS @craddock_cmail @FitzySA @MattParslow1 â€' Best Bits of The Back Page (@backpagebestof) June 16, 2025 You never knew who was watching. Shane Warne used to tune in. Greg Chappell watched from Adelaide. Allan Langer when he was living up at Caloundra. Cricketer Ben Cutting once told me he would watch from the United Arab Emirates. They were joined by a couple of sheep farmers in the deep south of New Zealand who would send random tweets to the show aired at 9.30pm Kiwi time. One time Mark Bosnich, a long serving and popular panellist, came on and told a colourful story about a night of cross-dressing with fellow soccer star Dwight Yorke. The next day I went to Brisbane Broncos training where Andrew McCullough, a poker faced country boy who rarely shows excitement, was lined up in front of a bank of cameras for the daily press conference and turned his head towards me and said 'hey, before we start, what about Bozza last night ... I mean ... wow''. The team have dug through the archives to find the #Top5 embarrassing cramp moments in sport! #TheBackPage | @FOXSportsAUS â€' Best Bits of The Back Page (@backpagebestof) May 18, 2025 Outstanding producer Matt Parslow is widely lauded within the industry as the show's secret hero for his ability to find rare footage of sport's hidden heroes, villains and comical stumbles. In February 2017, when Kerry O'Keeffe was having a break from television, Squires sent O'Keeffe a text inviting him to come on as a guest. O'Keeffe replied 'my used-by date said best before February, 2017'' and Squires sent back 'that's ok, I like my meat a little gamey'' and on he came with a standout performance that caught the eye of Fox cricket producers and played a role in O'Keeffe joining the summer coverage where he shines annually as the game's best researched and most unique voice. Kerry O'Keeffe has been a huge part of the show over the last decade. Here's one of our favourite Skull yarns on the day he met the Queen! ðŸ'€ #TheBackPage | #BackPageMemories @FOXSportsAUS @kokeeffe49 @craddock_cmail @MattParslow1 â€' Best Bits of The Back Page (@backpagebestof) June 8, 2025 The show was at it's best when it was at its quirkiest, as proved by the fact that the highest rating Back Page ever did not come after a Test match or a State of Origin game but when Iceland – population 340,000 and at its first major tournament – beat England 1-0 at the 2016 European championships. The sports world was stunned. People could not work it out. How could this happen? They turned to us for answers. Did we provide them? Ah, well ... sort of. Some mysteries simply defy explanation, not that it stopped us slapping down some emphatic theories about the secret sauces of Iceland soccer. Kevin Sheedy eat your heart out!
ABC News
an hour ago
- ABC News
Sione Tuipulotu's rise from playing club rugby with his father to representing the British and Irish Lions
Watching Australian Sione Tuipulotu playing for the British and Irish Lions should make the Wallabies wince. But lasting regrets would belie Tuipulotu's rise from rugby backblocks to international fame. His feats deserve comparison to trailblazers like Ange Postecoglou, Minjee Lee, and Jordan Mailata. ABC Sport will have live blog coverage of the British and Irish Lions' tour of Australia this July and August. Two generations ago, Tuipulotu's family was Scottish, Tongan, and Italian. His grandmother, Anne Thompson, moved with her parents and siblings from Greenock, outside Glasgow, to North Frankston (known as The Pines), an hour's drive from Melbourne, in 1963. Her daughter, Angelina, whose father was Italian, met Fohe Tuipulotu while he was studying at RMIT in Melbourne on an AusAID scholarship from Tonga. They married and moved to Tonga before returning to Australia to raise five children: two girls, Kiesse and Keanna, and three boys, Sione, Mosese and Ottavio. Sione played soccer while attending St Francis Xavier Primary School in Frankston. His childhood was spent in the Australian football heartland, where few people knew or cared about the differences between rugby and rugby league. The ranking of football codes in popularity was Australian Rules — daylight — soccer, rugby league and rugby. Sione was in his first year at the public high school Elisabeth Murdoch College when he decided to try rugby at Southern Districts, a family club in nearby Seaford — a world away from the private school programs in Sydney and Brisbane. But 'Souths' had everything children needed to improve their skills and showcase natural abilities. Fohe put up his hand to coach. Sione recently sent a video message to his old friends: "I just want to say how much I miss it (Souths)," he said. "I've played for quite a few teams now, but I've never had more fun than when I played for Souths. I hope me and my brothers (Mosese and Ottavio) can all go back there one day and finish off our careers playing for Souths." Fohe Tuipulotu said he had always promised he would help get his boys to the top. "When we changed from soccer I was playing rugby here and I knew a lot of people in the sport anyway," he said. "We went to Southern Districts because the coach at the time — he coached me in Powerhouse (a more prominent rugby club in Melbourne) back in the day. From there, it was obvious (Sione was a standout). "When they (his sons) decided to play rugby, I promised them I would help them to get to the top. Obviously, the plan at the start was for them to play for either Australia or Tonga." Southern District's club president Karl Dix recalled refereeing many of Sione's junior games. "When he got the ball you knew he was going to break the line," Dix said. Sione and Mosese briefly joined their father in the senior team. The Tuipulutos' speed, power, and game sense also made them automatic selections in state underage carnivals. Private school St Kevin's College Toorak awarded Sione a scholarship in Year 9 and his brothers followed him to that school. "It was a massive opportunity at the time," Fohe said. Sione played for the Australian Schoolboys and Junior Wallabies (Australia Under 20) for three consecutive years, 2015-17. He became the first Victorian to debut for the Melbourne Rebels. Turmoil was caused in Australian rugby next season when the Western Force folded and many of its players came across the continent to play Super Rugby for the Rebels. Sione's opportunities became scarce. "He was doing really well," Fohe said. "That's when things changed. He was sitting on the bench and the team was already beaten by 40 points, 50 points, and they only gave him five minutes. "I can understand for a young kid, who has been good, good, good, good, and then he's hitting that kind of wall. It's going to be hard, mentally." Fohe's advice to his son was to stay with the Rebels and keep trying. "At the time, for me personally, I like to fight. Stay there and fight," he said. "And that's what I told him to do. I didn't realise his mental health was affected at the time. "But he didn't tell me because he wanted to respect my decision, which is a learning curve for me now." A circuit breaker came for Sione in 2018 with the acceptance of an invitation to play in Japan during the off season. After a frustrating stretch with the Rebels he enjoyed the two-month experience, and Yamaha Jubilo (now Shizuoka Blue Revs) liked Sione so much that they wanted him to stay. "He rang me up to come and see him and I knew there was something up," Fohe said. "And he asked me to let him go. He had an offer to go back to Japan and play for them full-time. They offered him two years. He was struggling." With Fohe's blessing, Sione stayed with the Japanese club and his game, and confidence, grew. "Those two years that he went and played in Japan he played every single game for 80 minutes," Fohe said. "And I saw the improvement in his game and I saw it quick. I think that was when Scotland was looking at him." UK officials had witnessed Sione playing for Australia's under-20s at the World Cup in Manchester in 2016, with the knowledge that his grandmother was a Scot. "I met some of the coaching staff from Scotland at the time," Fohe said. "But our focus wasn't in Scotland, our focus was for them to grow up here and play for Australia." Five years later, Sione said yes to an offer from Glasgow Warriors. The big move into the Scottish national team came via a phone call from the coach Gregor Townsend. Sione made his debut for Scotland against his father's homeland, Tonga, in 2021. Three years later he was made captain for a series that would include the Scottish debut of his brother Mosese, who had been following Sione through the ranks. "The most emotional phone call I've ever had was Gregor phoning me to tell me I'll be Scotland captain," Sione told Scottish media. "But when he phoned to say my brother would be included, that was a pretty close second." The Tuipulotu brothers opposed Australia at Murrayfield Stadium, winning 27-13. Their grandmother made the trip from Frankston to be in the grandstands. "It was an amazing moment," Sione told the BBC. "When she handed over the cup she said, 'you got 'em!'. I'm super happy and it makes the day all worthwhile." The youngest Tuipulotu brother, Ottavio, represented the Junior Wallabies in 2024. "It's unbelievable," Fohe said. "Because all of them play professional now. I knew the quality of how he (Sione) is and that determination — I knew he was going to go all the way. "To see him grow not only with his rugby but his family life, for me as a father is very humbling." Grandmother Anne, 77, was not much of a sports watcher until her three grandsons took up rugby. "I thought they were the bee's knees when they were little — very cute and very funny," she told ABC Sport. "It's very exciting to watch them playing and to be at the games." Sione and his partner, Lara, had a son last year and named him Fohe Junior. "I told them (his sons) that they have gone to represent their mum's side," Fohe Snr said. "Their kids belong to me — that's the deal. I'll pick Australia or Tonga." Sione made his British and Irish Lions debut in a loss to Argentina on Sunday morning in the midfield with New Zealand-born Irish champion Bundee Aki. His whole family will watch the series against Australia with typical humility and pride. Fohe and Angelina now live in Williamstown, a long drive from Frankston, but not all that far from the Melbourne Cricket Ground, where the Lions and Wallabies will play the second Test on July 26.
ABC News
an hour ago
- ABC News
Li Tu, Tristan Schoolkate, James McCabe and Alex Bolt begin Wimbledon qualifying with wins
Li Tu is the pick of the first wave of Australians in Wimbledon qualifying, knocking out Colombian Daniel Galan, the fourth seed, 6-3 6-2. Galan is ranked number 122 in the world, 46 places higher than Tu, and made the last 16 at Wimbledon two years ago before running into Jannik Sinner. But the 29-year-old from Adelaide played excellently to take the first step towards his first main draw appearance at the grass court grand slam. Joining him in the second round will be Tristan Schoolkate, James McCabe and Alex Bolt, who all won the first of three matches they will need to negotiate to make the Wimbledon main draw. Recent Ilkley Trophy winner Schoolkate had to work harder than expected against Argentine world number 198 Facundo Diaz Acosta before coming through 6-7 (4-7), 6-1, 6-3. Bolt had a simpler Monday afternoon at Roehampton, putting away Frenchman Harold Mayot 6-3, 6-4. McCabe had a 6-4, 7-5 win over Borna Gojo of Croatia. There was heartbreak for Jason Kubler, who was due to face a British wildcard ranked 943rd in the world. Shortly before he was due to face Oliver Bonding, Kubler had to withdraw due to a right knee injury. There was disappointment too for Omar Jasika, who fell to Czech 15th seed Dalibor Svrcina 6-1 6-2. World number one junior Emerson Jones will lead Australia's women's qualifying challenge, which begins on Tuesday. Jones, who reached the Australian Open and Wimbledon junior finals last year, is joined in the draw by Talia Gibson, Priscilla Hon, Daria Saville, Astra Sharma, Destanee Aiava, Maddison Inglis, Lizette Cabrera, Arina Rodionova and Taylah Preston. Thirteen Australians — eight men and five women — already have a place in the main draws, among them James Duckworth and Aleksandar Vukic who meet at the Eastbourne Open on the south coast on Tuesday (local time). AAP
