Judge scolds barrister for using 'made-up cases' in her court arguments
A High Court judge has condemned a team of lawyers for basing arguments on five cases which turned out to be 'made-up'.
Barrister Sarah Forey was instructed by solicitors at Haringey Law Centre to act for a homeless man who was claiming priority housing from Haringey Council in London.
Ms Forey cited a number of cases – examples of previous legal rulings used to support an argument – in written submissions to the High Court.
Lawyers for the council said they could not find five of the cases, suggesting the only explanation would be that Ms Forey used Artificial Intelligence (AI) tools.
They asked for clarification from Haringey Law Centre, who dismissed the issue as 'cosmetic errors' and said any problems were 'easily explained'.
Haringey Law Centre lawyer Sunnelah Hussain suggested the council lawyers raised the matter 'as technicalities to avoid undertaking really serious legal research'.
The presiding judge, Mr Justice Ritchie, blasted Haringey Law Centre's response as 'grossly unprofessional'.
In his ruling on the case, he said the solicitors and Ms Forey had shown 'appalling professional misbehaviour'.
He said he was unable to reach a verdict on whether they did use AI 'because Ms Forey was not sworn in and was not cross examined'.
But he accused them of 'misleading the Court' by submitting 'fake cases' and then trying to 'finesse them into being 'minor citation errors''.
The judge also dismissed Ms Forey's claim that the error arose from filing and photocopying mistakes, saying: 'I do not accept that it is possible to photocopy a non-existent case and tabulate it.'
He said the team had presented a 'reasonable and fair' case, suggesting they would have had a strong chance to win if they hadn't used the fake cases. More Trending
Mr Justice Ritchie continued: 'The submission was a good one. The medical evidence was strong. The ground was potentially good. Why put a fake case in?
'On the balance of probabilities, I consider that it would have been negligent for this barrister, if she used AI and did not check it, to put that text into her pleading.'
The judge ordered his ruling to be sent Bar Standards Board and the Solicitors Regulation Authority, saying Ms Forey and Haringey Law Centres should self-report to the watchdogs.
The case was settled in favour of the homeless man, Frederick Ayinde, but ordered Ms Forey's team to pay wasted court costs.
Get in touch with our news team by emailing us at webnews@metro.co.uk.
For more stories like this, check our news page.
MORE: Mum wins court appeal to stop daughter having to stay overnight with rapist dad
MORE: Harry claims police protection withdrawn to 'trap' him and Meghan in UK
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Telegraph
3 hours ago
- Telegraph
Why a blank cheque won't solve Britain's policing woes
In 2023, a productivity review led by two former chief constables identified 26 ways of freeing-up 38 million hours of police time. That would equate to 20,000 extra police officers. The recommendations included cutting red tape, reducing sickness absence and using computer technology for clerical tasks. A second report from the productivity panel, in 2024, said a further 23 million hours could be saved – including through the expansion of AI. 'Modern technology is the golden key to police efficiency and effectiveness,' says Winsor. Yet, progress on technology has been painfully slow – and not helped by a failure to manage large-scale projects, such as ESN (Emergency Services Network), an upgrade on the ageing emergency services communications network Airwave, which is a decade behind schedule and £3.1 billion over budget. 'You have to lay much of it at the door of the Home Office,' says Trotter. 'The replacement of Airwave has gone on for years – it's an area that has not been a success, it's wasted a lot of money and is still not resolved. It needs an inquiry,' he adds. Failing to see 'beyond force boundaries' There are glaring inefficiencies in other areas, too. Across England and Wales, each of the 43 forces, no matter how large or small, has its own leadership team, civilian support set-up and administrative functions, such as payroll, legal affairs and human resources. Pooling some of that work would make financial sense, says Winsor. 'The back office stuff could and should be done either regionally or nationally, in the way it's done in the NHS or the military,' he says. In 2022, a report from the independent think-tank, the Police Foundation, estimated that forces in England and Wales could save 'hundreds of millions' of pounds annually by combining support teams – as well as purchasing police uniform, equipment, vehicles, forensic services and computers centrally, rather than negotiating individual contracts with suppliers, as many constabularies do. But it seems the introduction of police and crime commissioners, a decade earlier, cemented a 'localist' approach, hindering prospects for developing a more cohesive and less fragmented system of policing, with the economies of scale that would result. 'The police and crime commissioner model has some strengths but it can hold things back, because in my time there were far too many who could not see beyond their force boundaries – and crime doesn't stop at force boundaries,' says Winsor, who left the watchdog three years ago. The author of the Police Foundation report, its former director Rick Muir, is now working as a Home Office adviser, developing plans for a white paper, based around the establishment of a new National Centre of Policing. It is long overdue. Rowley and other police leaders support the case for a reorganisation. Although their immediate concern is whether they'll have enough resources over the next three years, they are aware that it is not just about the money – radical structural reform is needed to put forces on a long-term sustainable financial footing and ensure the public get the police service they deserve. As Peter Kyle, the Science and Technology Secretary, put it at the weekend, the police must 'do their bit' and 'embrace change'.
Daily Mail
6 hours ago
- Daily Mail
'Furious' pensioner falls victim to Dr Chris Brown love scam as fraudsters use AI to trick her out of $780
A New Zealand grandmother is the latest victim to be targeted by a love scam using AI-generated videos and images of Dr Chris Brown. Daana Tomlin, 73, was conned out of $786 when she was tricked into believing she had struck up a five-year long online romance with the 46-year-old Bondi Vet star. The fraudsters used emotionally manipulative messages to convince the pensioner she was in a romantic relationship with the star, reported The Daily Telegraph. They first made contact with a 'cheeky message' on Facebook while posing as Chris, before moving Daana to Telegram and WhatsApp to continue the manipulation. Daana, a semi-retired naturopath from Dunedin, said she was conned into sending the scammers almost $800 through gift cards, Apple cards and PayPal. From A-list scandals and red carpet mishaps to exclusive pictures and viral moments, subscribe to the DailyMail's new showbiz newsletter to stay in the loop. The hoaxers used sophisticated AI-generated videos of Chris to speak to Daana and convince her to hand over her cash. 'Whenever I became suspicious and tried to end contact, he'd get angry and send me a video saying he was real. It certainly sounded and looked like him,' she said. 'I'm furious that it's not the real Chris Brown, I paid a few hundred dollars for a meet and greet at New Zealand airport through Apple Cards and gift cards.' However, when Chris was a no-show at the airport, Daana asked security for help and they said 'they had not seen him'. Daana said she 'feels silly and embarrassed' for believing it was real, adding the fake Chris would call her 'his wife' and rang 'for five years at 5.30 every morning'. 'What the scammer did was evil, it was devious, exploitative and invasive,' said Daana, who was married for 19 years and has a grown son. She added she 'thought a need was being met' in her and didn't discover she was being scammed until her support worker discovered the PayPal payments. The fraudster had claimed they bought Daana a car as a present, but demanded she send several hundred dollars through PayPal to pay for the registration. Daana isn't the first to fall victim to the sophisticated and long-running love scam. Last month it was reported UK pensioner Lisa Nock was also conned out of her life savings after falling for the same AI scam. The 44-year-old from Staffordshire was browsing Instagram in 2022 when a fake account posing as Chris bombarded her with direct messages. Lisa admitted she was lonely and vulnerable at the time after losing her partner in a car crash, and had been left disabled in another traffic accident. But the avid animal lover said her life changed and she was delighted when the TV star said he wanted to meet her in England. 'I was chuffed that Chris Brown had messaged me, I'm a huge fan and hoped this might be our chance to meet,' Lisa told the Daily Telegraph at the time. The surprise messages began a chain of correspondence that spanned two-and-a-half years, but the scammers soon told her Chris needed money to visit her. They moved the conversation to WhatsApp and continued to groom her, using artificial intelligence to convince her she was in a romantic relationship with him. 'After a few months, I admit I was enamoured. He told me he loved me and wanted us to marry – of course I said no, and asked if it was a scam,' Lisa said. She tried calling the WhatsApp number, but her attempts were blocked. Scammers then used a sophisticated AI program to call Lisa via the encrypted messaging app Telegram. An AI-generated version of Chris said he hoped the call had cleared her doubts. The conmen also used AI image generators to create 'photos' of the TV doctor and shared them with Lisa, a volunteer English and drama teacher. She lives off just $1246 each month from her UK pension, two thirds of which she pays to her parents in rent. The remaining $400 however ended up being sent to the cruel scammers each month for almost three years. Lisa sent the money through gift cards, Bitcoin and Crypto information. 'I was vulnerable and wanted to believe we could be friends, we both love animals, I had lost my partner in a car crash a few years ago,' she said. Lisa finally realised it was all fake when the conmen posed as Chris' 'management' team and told her he had been kidnapped, before demanding $40 million. Lisa has now reported the scam to British police.
The Courier
15 hours ago
- The Courier
Tuesday court round-up — Bogus tradesman and £90k dealer
A Dundee father-of-three was jailed for 32 months after he was caught storing heroin and cocaine worth more than £90,000. The High Court in Edinburgh was told did not know the value of the drugs police recovered from an address at Ormiston Crescent. Judge Lord Arthurson told the 30-year-old he would have faced a four-year jail term but for his early guilty plea to two charges of being concerned in the supply of cocaine and heroin on July 17 last year. During a search, officers found more than half a kilo of heroin and three kilos of bulking agent in a holdall, along with quarter of a kilo of cocaine in a gift bag and smaller amounts of cocaine. The cocaine was assessed as having a maximum value of £50,500 and the heroin £40,000. Officers also found £460 in a jacket pocket. Defence solicitor advocate Kris Gilmartin said Ogilvie was laid off from his employment last summer. 'He accepts he was abusing drugs at the time and he was suffering financial difficulties.' He said Ogilvie agreed to store the drugs but stood to gain very little financially and 'did not know the value and did not know that heroin was also present'. He added: 'He accepts fully his involvement in these offences and appreciates that he must be punished.' 'A significant part of that punishment is letting his family down. His actions have caused misery to those closest to him.' A senior manager at power firm SSE has been banned from driving for two years after he drunkenly careered his car into a Perth woman's garden. was five times the limit when he ploughed his Land Rover Discovery through a hedge. A Fife tradesman who swindled thousands of pounds from customers has been given a hefty compensation order and told for a second time to do unpaid work. , 25, appeared at Dunfermline Sheriff Court after failing to do the 160 unpaid work hours to which he was originally sentenced about a year ago for the crime. The court heard he has only done one hour. Aitchison, of Sherbrooke Road, Rosyth, previously pled guilty to three fraud charges. On March 1 2023 at an address in Nether Currie Road, Edinburgh, he pretended he would carry out work to renovate a room in his house and obtained a £1,300 deposit by fraud, knowing he had no intention of doing the work. He fraudulently obtained a £1,400 deposit from a woman by pretending he would install a new kitchen at her home in Leadside Crescent, Wellwood, on September 28 2023. Between April 21 and September 27 of that year at an address in Goulden Place, Dunfermline, he obtained a £3,200 deposit by fraud by pretending he would carry out building work. Defence lawyer Pete Robertson said Aitchison – who remains in joinery work – started his own business but got himself into debts and ended up 'putting his head in the sand'. The lawyer said Aitchison's focus until February this year was cocaine use but that he has started to take steps to abstain, is now more pro-social and is assessed in a background report as suitable for unpaid work. Sheriff Susan Duff made a compensation order for the full amount and gave Aitchison 74 weeks to pay at £100 per week. He will be under offender supervision. The sheriff also told Aitchison to do 159 hours of unpaid work – taking account of the one hour he did – within three months. A security engineer who clambered into a fire tragedy Perth hotel to reclaim his CCTV cameras told a court how he was treated by police as a murder suspect. entered the New County Hotel through an upstairs window just weeks after the horrific blaze in January 2023 that claimed the lives of three people. After a lengthy trial he was cleared of breaking into the hotel and stealing the cameras. drunkenly dished out racist and homophobic abuse at Dundee bar, Captain's Cabin. As he was arrested, he called police 'Nazis' and 'woke'. Sheriff Tim Niven-Smith told Penman: 'If I were woke perhaps I would step back from a custodial sentence.' Dundee Sheriff Court heard how the 40-year-old approached door staff at the North Lindsay Street bar at around 11.50pm on November 23 2024 and said: 'Your venue is full of Nazis 'Why do you let all these black b******s in?' He was refused entry and became 'irate and agitated', a prosecutor said. He began shouting, 'Nazi b******s' at patrolling police and after being handcuffed and taken to the nearby police headquarters, shouted: 'You mutants, you freaks. 'Woke p**f. Transgender woke c**t. You're a f****t.' Penman kicked out repeatedly and kicked one PC on the body. Solicitor Gary McIlravey said of his client: 'He had no recollection whatsoever. 'He has not covered himself in glory with his behaviour and underpinning the offences was the excessive consumption of alcohol.' Penman was placed on a restriction of liberty order (10pm-6am) for four months. A pizza chef who smoked cannabis with a missing 12 year-old girl before raping her in Fife has been jailed for five years. exploited the youngster at his then-home in Burntisland in June 2023 and claimed in the high court he thought the child was older than she was. A 53-year-old who made a sexual remark to a 15-year-old girl at Glenrothes bus station and stole money from a pensioner has been jailed for 14 months. On other occasions at the same bus station, struck a bus service employee on the head with his crutch and was racially abusive to another man. Hamilton appeared at Kirkcaldy Sheriff Court for sentencing by video link to prison after earlier pleading guilty to separate offences of directing sexual verbal communications at a child, assault, theft, and acting in a racially aggravated manner. Prosecutor Matthew Knapp told the court the teenager was left 'alarmed and very uncomfortable' on July 31 last year when Hamilton asked her age then told her 'you have good boobs and a bum for a 15-year-old.' Defence lawyer Calum Harris said Hamilton, of Glenrothes, was under the influence at the time and has little recollection of the incident. Hamilton had already been told at the station he was banned from Stagecoach buses after leaving blood-soaked bandages on a coach on June 22 last year. He had reacted by hitting a supervisor with his crutch, cutting his head. His bus station offending also included, on August 19 2023, acting in a racially-aggravated manner by repeatedly uttering racist abuse and raising his crutch at a man in an aggressive manner. On June 15 last year at an address in Postgate, Glenrothes, Hamilton stole a 'quantity of cash' from an 81-year-old man. Referring to a previous background report, Mr Harris said his client had been sleeping rough for three years prior to his remand in March. He said Hamilton has been a drug user since the age of 13, when he was first introduced to heroin and more recently, crack cocaine.
