DPP mulls decision on perjury prosecution over withdrawn evidence in Conor McGregor appeal
Conor McGregor's
failed appeal against a civil jury finding that he raped Nikita Hand.
Should the Director of Public Prosecutions (DPP) decide to prosecute, it will mark only the second prosecution under a 2021 perjury law and just the sixth prosecution for perjury in the past decade.
The new evidence is
being investigated
by gardaí for possible perjury. On foot of the investigation report, the DPP will decide if there is any basis to bring a prosecution.
Ms Hand was
awarded €250,000 damages
by a High Court jury last November when it found Mr McGregor assaulted her in Dublin's Beacon Hotel on December 9th, 2018. Last month, he was ordered to pay her legal costs, estimated at more than €1.5 million, after his
appeal
against the jury finding was dismissed.
READ MORE
The Court of Appeal agreed to refer the withdrawn evidence and related material for consideration of possible perjury.
It includes sworn statements by Samantha O'Reilly and her partner Steven Cummins, who lived across the road from Ms Hand in Drimnagh, Dublin, for a time. Ms O'Reilly claimed that from a room in her house, she heard and saw what appeared to be a physical altercation between Ms Hand and her then partner, Stephen Redmond, on the night of December 9/10th 2018.
That evidence, Mr McGregor claimed, bolstered his insistence he was not responsible for extensive bruising on the body of Ms Hand, noted by a doctor on December 10th 2018.
In a replying affidavit, Ms Hand described the neighbours' claims as 'lies' and said Mr Redmond never assaulted her during their relationship.
Just one prosecution has been taken to date under the Criminal Justice (Perjury and Related Offences) Act 2021, which made perjury a criminal offence.
The Office of the DPP told The Irish Times that prosecution had resulted in a conviction but said it could not disclose details of the case.
The DPP has brought five prosecutions for perjury, including that under the 2021 Act, over the past decade. Before the 2021 Act, perjury offences were prosecuted under common law.
Of the five prosecutions since 2015, three resulted in a conviction, one in a decision not to prosecute further because the suspect had died, and one is outstanding.
Much of the motivation for the 2021 Act, aimed at making it easier to prosecute for perjury, was to help in bringing down insurance costs by deterring false or fraudulent claims.
Senior counsel Ronan Lupton said the Act sets out 'in clear terms' what perjury is – the giving by a person of a 'material' statement in evidence or on affidavit that they know to be false.
The Act introduces, for the first time, an offence of 'suborning' (inducing) perjury, he noted. That involves procuring, persuading, inducing or otherwise causing another person to commit perjury, knowing or being reckless whether the other person is committing that offence.
The Act provides for penalties of up to 12 months for conviction on a summary offence, and up to 10 years for conviction on indictment.
A legal source with experience in prosecutions over alleged false evidence, who did not wish to be identified, believes the difficulty of bringing home successful prosecutions in such cases has contributed to a reluctance within the DPP's office to prosecute them.
Whether that will change under the new Act remains to be seen, he said. 'The risk of failure, and the potential costs involved in some cases, are important factors to weigh up. In some cases, every fact could be put at issue. Proving a deliberate lie is a difficult hurdle for any prosecutor.'
Proving the offence of suborning perjury presents even more difficulty, he added.
In its 2022 post-enactment report on the 2021 Act, the Department of Justice said some people have 'all too frequently' deliberately lied in court or misrepresented the truth in affidavits and the Act was developed to create 'significant deterrents' against that.
The Act was envisaged as part of a package of government measures dealing with insurance issues, insurance fraud and exaggerated claims, it said.
The report noted that, while the offence of perjury was already provided for in common law, the historic levels of investigations and prosecutions for perjury were 'low'.
It was satisfied that the Act 'will play an important role in providing a clearer legal framework through which our law enforcement authorities may be guided in decisively taking action in the area of perjury' and expected it will, over time, have an impact on the numbers of complaints, investigations and prosecutions.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
6 hours ago
- Irish Times
‘We await with interest': Family of Sophie Toscan du Plantier supportive of fresh DNA tests in murder inquiry
The family of murdered Sophie Toscan du Plantier say they will accept whatever findings Irish forensic scientists make on foot of a series of new DNA tests on exhibits from the near 30-year-old investigation . Ms Toscan du Plantier's uncle, Jean Pierre Gazeau, said the family fully supports the decision by the Garda Serious Crime Review Team and Forensic Science Ireland (FSI) to engage US DNA collection experts irrespective of what the move yields. Mr Gazeau said he was interested to see that the Garda and FSI had decided to avail of technology provided by M-Vac Systems to examine exhibits including the stone and concrete block used to murder his niece in west Cork in 1996. 'I think it is the last chance for the Garda – unless, of course, some witness comes forward with new evidence. But even then, they may retract their story, which has happened before, but DNA evidence is objective and scientific and definitive, so it is a welcome development,' he said. READ MORE Mr Gazeau, president of the Association for the Truth about the Murder of Sophie Toscan du Plantier, said he did not want to speculate, but that the latest approach could produce a number of different scenarios. 'They may find nothing but obviously if they find DNA and it does not match that of Ian Bailey , then it has the ability to clear Bailey of any culpability,' he said. 'But even if it means the outcome is not what we expect ... it is a scientific outcome, and we must respect that finding and accept it because DNA testing is very definitive. We await with interest to hear from the Garda on what the scientists find.' Ian Bailey, the chief suspect for the murder of Sophie Toscan du Plantier, died last year aged 66. Photograph: Courts Collins Mr Bailey, an English journalist, was twice arrested in connection with the French film producer's murder, but was never charged, and repeatedly protested his innocence before his death last year at the age of 66 . He was convicted in his absence at a trial in Paris in 2019 of the voluntary homicide of Ms Toscan du Plantier and sentenced to 25 years in jail. However, attempts by French authorities to have him extradited to serve the sentence were shot down by the Irish courts . M-Vac Systems chief executive Jared Bradley and a scientist from the firm travelled to Dublin last month with their equipment and spent a week examining various exhibits gathered during the original Garda investigation into Ms Toscan du Plantier's murder. The 39-year-old's badly beaten body was found on the laneway leading to her isolated holiday home in Toormore near Schull on the morning of December 23rd, 1996. A postmortem revealed she had been bludgeoned to death with a rock and a concrete block. As well as the cavity block and rock, gardaí from the cold case review team based in Bantry brought several exhibits to the FSI laboratory for examination by the M-Vac team including Ms Toscan du Plantier's dressing gown, leggings, vest and boots. Investigators are hoping that any DNA evidence obtained will enable FSI scientists to make comparisons with DNA samples taken during the original Garda investigation from about 10 people, including Mr Bailey, identified as suspects at the time.
Irish Times
17 hours ago
- Irish Times
‘Raising my son in Dublin, I believed there was nowhere safer or more welcoming'
The riots in Dublin on November 23rd, 2023 jolted Ireland awake, sending shockwaves through communities and prompting anxious calls from relatives abroad, all seeking answers from a country renowned for its friendliness and peace. Having called Ireland home for 25 years, I've witnessed the warmth and openness that define Irish society. When I first arrived from India in my mid-20s, I was struck by how strangers would go out of their way to help, sometimes even walking me to my destination. Over time, my initial caution faded and many Irish friends became as close as family. Raising my son in Dublin , I believed there was nowhere safer or more welcoming; he grew up feeling no different from his Irish peers. But the aftermath of the riots brought a sudden, unwelcome shift. The day after, when I picked up my son from college, his Irish friends escorted him to my car, protective and wary. For the first time in 21 years, my son felt 'different', and his friends feared for the safety of their friend because of those differences. This wasn't what I knew Ireland to be. I refuse to accept the riots as an expression of true Irish sentiment. Instead, they seemed a case of opportunistic hooliganism, not racist intent. Through it all, most Irish people have stood against hate, reinforcing the values of kindness, inclusion and solidarity that make Ireland a truly special place to live and grow. Sohini De In recent years, Ireland has faced a troubling rise in racial attacks within its communities. For the longest time, few incidents were reported. Reliable statistics on racial attacks are hard to find, as such incidents remain largely unreported. Within the Indian community at least, I know they have an attitude of 'let us not draw too much attention'. Lately, the scale and frequency of attacks have stirred fresh anxieties, echoing abroad as loved ones question whether Ireland is still as safe and welcoming as it once felt. READ MORE [ 'Widespread media coverage in India' of attacks on Indian people living in Ireland Opens in new window ] The incident in Tallaght on July 19th - when a man in his early 40s, who had arrived from India three weeks earlier on a critical skills visa to join a leading international tech company in Dublin, was brutally attacked by a group of teenagers - was a stark reminder of this shift. Yet the courage shown by local resident Jennifer Murray, who not only assisted at the scene but also defended the victim against false claims, showcased the true Ireland — one that steps up for those in need rather than amplifying hateful, misinformed narratives fuelled by social media. Jennifer Murray, who came to the aid of an Indian man attacked in Tallaght, meets attendees of the United Against Racism and Dublin South-West Together demonstration against racism last month. Photograph: Dan Dennison The overwhelming majority continue to stand firmly against these acts, determined to uphold the country's values of inclusion and kindness. 'Not under my watch', many now say, drawing a line against intolerance. Ireland's story has always been one of welcoming immigrants , who now play an essential role as skilled workers, taxpayers and contributors to society and the economy. [ 'He kept saying: what wrong have I done? Why me?' An Indian man is left stripped and bloodied on an Irish street Opens in new window ] Still, a worrying minority use social media to fuel divisive and dangerous stories. The real issue is not the number or size of such incidents, but the principle: a respected doctor who has served this country for three decades, when told to 'go back to where you came from' by strangers, can be deeply demoralised. Every person deserves to go about their life in Ireland without fear. Defending this right and maintaining Ireland's spirit of solidarity is more vital now than ever. Ireland today faces a moment of reflection and action. The nation's increasing diversity is a testament to its growth — more cultures, languages and backgrounds enrich everyday life. Yet this very progress comes with challenges that require careful stewardship from all corners of society. Our educational institutions are admirable examples of inclusion, creating environments where students from every background thrive together. Still, the question stands: how do we extend this culture of learning and belonging beyond the classroom, into homes, neighbourhoods and the digital spaces where so many of our opinions are formed? Likewise, public and private organisations recognise the value of skilled migrant workers, both in bridging labour gaps and strengthening the fabric of our communities. Recent events have made clear that more, not less, must be done to support integration and mutual understanding. [ Gardaí struggle to reassure Indian community amid spate of high-profile attacks Opens in new window ] My engagement with both local Irish and migrant communities has revealed a host of practical steps that, taken together, could help Ireland confidently navigate the challenges we face. First and foremost, there's an urgent need to increase Garda presence, not just in Dublin, but nationwide. This isn't about heavy-handed policing —it's about deterring hate crimes and responding swiftly if they occur. But more gardaí alone won't solve everything. They need specialised training to recognise and address hate-driven incidents, while also working closely with IT experts and social media platforms to keep a vigilant eye on online hate speech and take appropriate actions. Transparency matters too, so regular updates on hate crime cases, within the bounds of privacy laws, will reassure the public, keep authorities accountable and deter miscreants. There are practical steps that can be taken to help Ireland navigate the challenges we face. Photograph: Alan Betson It's vital we run nationwide campaigns that celebrate the contributions migrants make to our economy and society. Business chambers can lend their influential voices to the cause, for further impact. Victims should be given easy access to counselling, legal support and safe reporting channels. Community engagement is also key — migrants joining local events, GAA clubs and neighbourhood projects enriches us all. The Indian community, among others, brings valuable expertise in Stem, digital literacy and sport. Open community events and skill-sharing programmes can foster positive connections. Most importantly, we need a clear framework for action, using national strategies such as the national action plan against racism to guide us. With collective effort, Ireland can rise above today's fears and build a future where inclusion is more than a promise — it's a way of life. While we are rightly worried about the recent developments, I have hope that in Ireland we will do the right thing. The majority of Ireland is peace-loving - a friendly place that wants to remain so. But we cannot rest on our laurels and let things get out of hand. By fostering collaboration between government, businesses and migrant communities Ireland can strengthen inclusion and diversity. Structured action plans, community engagement and educational initiatives empower migrants to contribute meaningfully, while promoting nationwide understanding of their positive impact. Together, through these efforts we build a more vibrant, inclusive and resilient Irish society for all. Sohini De is a businesswoman and mother who left India for Ireland in 2000.
Irish Daily Mirror
19 hours ago
- Irish Daily Mirror
'The Ludicrous' Conor McGregor's latest mismatch - challenging us over facts
We are happy to find ourselves in such illustrious company. With the Pint of Guinness and Paul McGrath to name just two icons And now your Irish Mirror has been ushered into this exclusive club of Irish institutions. The qualifying standard? P*ssing off the Ludicrous Conor McGregor. The former plumber and ex-UFC champion once engaged in a deluded popularity contest with the Black Pearl for calling out his online bully boy tactics. He also previously announced his second-rate porter was going to be bigger than the Black Stuff. You can still hear the echoes of the laughter from St James Gate And now in his latest mismatch he's decided to take us on in a battle of truth and facts. McGregor didn't like it when we debunked the myths he peddled to his fanboy social media followers about the findings of a civil jury that he violently raped Nikita Hand in a hotel suite on a night out in Dublin. For the crime of fact checking his rant – and maybe the polite front page headline that he was 'talking through his Aras' - he decided to aim a few of his notorious online cheap shots at our journalism. We are a 'Government sponsored rag.' Guilty of not telling the Irish people the truth about the dangers they face from a migrant crime wave. For a one-man crime wave himself – he has .. convictions for public order and traffic to add to his civil rape finding - McGregor sure has a poor grasp of the law. Nikita Hand leaving the Court of Appeal in Dublin (Image: PA Wire/PA Images) When newspapers report on crime stories we do so within the laws of contempt of court and libel and a hundred other statutes that the loudmouths on social media are illiterate in. It's why when you read something in a newspaper like this it can still be trusted. And if it's wrong we will say so and pay a price. It's why we don't go off half baked on social media platforms naming and shaming – usually the wrong people – like the keyboard Ireland-is-full warriors. But we will certainly see and raise Conor McGregor's contribution to exposing crime and criminals in Ireland. The Irish Mirror and others like it were doing it while he was still back in Dublin 12 unblocking toilets. (Those were the days). We have been doing it whether they were immigrant killers like Jozef Puska or homespun scumbags like members of the Kinahan cartel who McGregor has shown no problem rubbing shoulders with in the past. We pride ourselves in being equally prejudiced in exposing criminal low life activity regardless of race, creed or nationality. Be that an immigrant throwing a petrol bomb at a pub or a little Irelander throwing a punch at an old man inside one. Not that truth matters in the 'X' bullring, but we were also the first to write about the very incidents McGregor accused us of hiding from the Irish people. We were the first to reveal a suspected Jihadi terror link to an arson attack on his pub. No fear. No favour. The same reason we call McGregor the presidential wannabe out on lies, disinformation and hypocrisy. Conor McGregor is the perfect First Paddy for Trump's axis of Alpha Bros And on his peddling of populist solutions to real community problems that always involve punching down on someone smaller than you. It's the same playbook as his hero Donald Trump who has invented a crime wave in Washington to clear the homeless off his lawn and distract people from reality. In his role as the 'First Paddy' McGregor has also adopted the MAGA fantasies of Fox News who this week told their viewers of some imaginary Dublin that is seemingly more dangerous than Bogota. The only greater toll of death than these murder victims that litter the streets of the capital must be all the suicides the Ludicrous One attributed to the Garda traffic corps for policing the streets from maniac drivers like himself. McGregor has already had the verdict of one random jury of his peers who decided he raped a young woman for kicks on a night out. I've no doubt the decency of ordinary people would give him the resounding same result again if his name ever goes before the Irish people on a ballot paper. If it does he can be guaranteed this. Our debunking of lies and coverage of loudmouth bullies and bigshots won't be tapping out. We plan to keep doing what we've been doing for decades. Like a well-timed Paul McGrath tackle or the perfect pint of Guinness. Subscribe to our newsletter for the latest news from the Irish Mirror direct to your inbox: Sign up here
