'Make America Healthy Again' report cites nonexistent studies: authors
But it includes broken citation links and credits authors with papers they say they did not write.
The errors were first reported Thursday by NOTUS, a US digital news website affiliated with the nonprofit Allbritton Journalism Institute.
Noah Kreski, a Columbia University researcher listed as an author of a paper on adolescent anxiety and depression during the Covid-19 pandemic, told AFP the citation is "not one of our studies" and "doesn't appear to be a study that exists at all."
The citation includes a link that purports to send users to an article in peer-reviewed medical journal JAMA, but which is broken. Jim Michalski of JAMA Network Media Relations said it "was not published in JAMA Pediatrics or in any JAMA Network journal."
AFP also spoke with Harold Farber, pediatrics professor at Baylor College of Medicine, who said the paper attributed to him "does not exist" nor had he ever collaborated with the co-authors credited in the MAHA report.
Similarly, Brian McNeill, spokesperson for Virginia Commonwealth University, confirmed that professor Robert Findling did not author a paper the report says he wrote about advertising of psychotropic medications for youth.
A fourth paper on ADHD medication, was also not published in the journal Pediatrics in 2008 as claimed in the MAHA report.
"I can confirm that we didn't find that title in a site search," said Alex Hulvalchick, media relations specialist for the journal's publisher the American Academy of Pediatrics.
The Department of Health and Human Services declined to comment, referring questions on the apparent errors to the White House.
Kennedy was approved as health secretary earlier this year despite widespread alarm from the medical community over his history of promoting vaccine misinformation and denying scientific facts.
Since taking office, he has ordered the National Institutes of Health to probe the causes of autism -- a condition he has long falsely tied to the measles, mumps, and rubella (MMR) vaccine.
The report's chronic disease references appear to nod to that same disproven theory, discredited by numerous studies since the idea first aired in a late 1990s paper based on falsified data.
It also rails against the "over-medicalization" of children, citing surging prescriptions of psychiatric drugs and antibiotics, and blaming "corporate capture" for skewing scientific research.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
LeMonde
21 hours ago
- LeMonde
France says it cannot save contraceptives US plans to destroy
France said Friday, August 1, it could not seize women's contraception products estimated to be worth $9.7 million that the United States plans to destroy, after media reported the stockpile would be incinerated in the country. The contraceptives – intended for some of the world's poorest countries, particularly in sub-Saharan Africa – were purchased by the US foreign aid agency USAID under former president Joe Biden. But France's health ministry told Agence France-Presse Friday there was no legal way for it to intervene. The administration of Biden's successor Donald Trump, which has slashed USAID and pursued anti-abortion policies, confirmed last month it planned to destroy the contraceptives, which have been stored in a warehouse in the Belgian city of Geel. According to several media reports, the unexpired products were to be incinerated in France at the end of July by a company that specialises in destroying medical waste. France's government has come under pressure to save the contraceptives, with women's rights groups calling the US decision "insane." The health ministry told AFP that the government had "examined the courses of action available to us, but unfortunately there is no legal basis for intervention by a European health authority, let alone the French national drug safety authority, to recover these medical products. Since contraceptives are not drugs of major therapeutic interest, and in this case we are not facing a supply shortage, we have no means to requisition the stocks." The ministry also said it had no information on where the contraceptives would be destroyed. Leaving Belgian warehouse Sarah Durocher, head of the French women's rights group Family Planning, told AFP that some contraceptives had already left the Belgian warehouse. "We were informed 36 hours ago that the removal of these boxes of contraceptives had begun," Durocher said Thursday. "We do not know where these trucks are now – or whether they have arrived in France," she added. "We call on all incineration companies not to destroy the contraceptives and to oppose this insane decision." French company Veolia confirmed to AFP that it had a contract with the US firm Chemonics, USAID's logistics provider. But Veolia emphasized that the contract concerned "only the management of expired products, which is not the case for the stockpile" in Belgium. The products, mostly long-acting contraceptives such as IUDs and birth control implants, are reportedly up to five years away from expiring. Outrage over decision The US decision has provoked an outcry in France, where rights groups and left-wing politicians have called on their government to stop the plan. "France cannot allow itself to become the stage for such actions. A moratorium is necessary," wrote five NGOs in an op-ed in Le Monde, condemning the "absurdity" of the US decision. Among them was MSI Reproductive Choices, one of several organisations that have offered to purchase and repackage the contraceptives at no cost to the US government. All offers have been rejected. Last week, New Hampshire's Democratic Senator Jeanne Shaheen pointed to the Trump administration's stated goal of reducing government waste, saying the contraceptives plan "is the epitome of waste, fraud and abuse." A US State Department spokesperson told AFP earlier this week that the destruction of the products would cost $167,000 and "no HIV medications or condoms are being destroyed." The spokesperson pointed to a policy that prohibits providing aid to non-governmental organisations that perform or promote abortions. The Mexico City Policy, which critics call the "global gag rule," was first introduced by President Ronald Reagan in 1984. It has been reinstated under every Republican president since. Last month, the US also incinerated nearly 500 metric tons of high-nutrition biscuits that had been meant to keep malnourished children in Afghanistan and Pakistan alive.
France 24
a day ago
- France 24
HIV-positive Turkmen man fears deportation, torture
Emir -- whose name has been changed for safety reasons -- fled the ex-Soviet Central Asian country in 2018 for fear of being persecuted for his homosexuality. He then found a job in a territory in Europe that is not internationally recognised. To avoid compromising his safety and that of his relatives back home, AFP has chosen to keep his exact location secret, but was able to interview him in person in July. The 30-year-old said he tested positive for HIV in 2024. He showed the results of medical lab tests, which AFP was able to authenticate, and said he had no access to antiviral treatment. "My condition is getting worse. My body and stomach are hurting, I have pain under my ribs," he said. "I can't sleep anymore, I sleep four or five hours, thinking about my health every day. I don't want to get AIDS," he added in a faint voice. Mortal threat Because of his HIV-positive status, Emir said he had been fired from his job in his current place of residence, lost his income, and now faces deportation to his home country. In Turkmenistan, he said, he would be arrested: "Because of my illness, they will torture me, abuse me, and kill me." Emir is unable to leave the place where he is now because he would have to first return to Turkmenistan to renew his passport, a photograph of which he provided to AFP. Swiss nonprofit Life4me+ sent him six months of antiviral treatment before stopping it due to the exhaustion of their "remaining medication stocks," the organisation's president, Alex Schneider said. Emir then received a few irregular shipments of medication, but for almost four months now he has been without medication. On three occasions, the health authorities in the territory where he is based have refused to provide him with treatment. A local LGBTQ rights group said it was currently unable to provide Emir with the necessary medication for financial and legal reasons. In an email to AFP, it said it had helped find Emir a psychologist who diagnosed him with "severe anxiety and depression symptoms with thoughts of suicide". 'Place forgotten by God' In Turkmenistan, homosexuality is punishable by jail under the criminal code provision prohibiting "sodomy". HIV-positive people, instead of receiving treatment, regularly find themselves imprisoned and tortured, according to several human rights groups. The nonprofits and exiled independent media reported waves of arrests targeting LGBTQ people several times in recent years. People detained as part of the repressions have been reported to disappear into the prison system and held incommunicado. Turkmenistan -- a gas-rich desert country rich officially home to seven million people -- is considered one of the most reclusive in the world. Internet access is severely limited, and no independent nonprofits are allowed to operate there. "It's a place forgotten by God where people suffer terrible things," said Evi Chayka, founder of EQUAL PostOst, a rights group helping LGBTQ people who are victims of repression in the former communist bloc. According to reliable sources familiar with the situation on the ground, speaking on condition of anonymity, the unrecognised territory where Emir is located does not have a "formal asylum framework" which prevents him from being taken into care by international bodies. Stuck in the maze, the young man said he still hopes that someone will find a way to help him. Even if, he added, "thousands of other people are suffering" throughout the world.
Local France
2 days ago
- Local France
What's going on with France's Lumpy Skin Disease outbreak?
One month after it was first detected in France, there are now 51 recorded cases of the highly contagious cattle virus Dermatose nodulaire contagieuse (known as Lumpy Skin Disease or LSD in English) in the French Alps. As of July 31st, 24 farms in Savoie have been affected and 27 in neighbouring Haute-Savoie, both départements in the French Alps. Lumpy Skin Disease poses no risk to humans, who cannot contract it, but it is highly infectious among cattle. The virus is spread by biting flies and - as the name implies - causes lumpy skin defects on infected cattle. Advertisement In most farms only a single case has been detected, but because the virus is so infectious, culls have been carried out among the herds where a case was discovered. So far around 1,000 cows have been culled. Farmers must then observe a 45-day quarantine before they can reintroduce cattle onto their farm. The government is also carrying out a mass vaccination programme in Savoie and Haute Savoie, with around 100,000 cattle already vaccinated against Lumpy Skin Disease, and another 200,000 still waiting. For the moment, vaccination drives are only taking place in the two affected départements. The government has also, at this stage, ruled out a more widespread cull of cattle in the Alps. Farms that are affected have put quarantine measures in place, so if you are hiking or cycling in the Alps you may come across paths that are closed for health reasons. A stage of the Tour de France was re-routed because the original route was due to go very close to affected areas and local farmers were worried that the influx of fans and vehicles would break the quarantine. Sign in the French Alps, referring to the Lumpy Skin Disease outbreak and culls, reads 'To the farmers who had to sacrifice their herds, we support you'. Photo: Anne-Christine Poujalat/AFP Lumpy Skin Disease cannot be transmitted to humans so there are no restrictions on the consumption of milk, cheese or meat from the affected areas. However supplies of some artisan cheeses may be affected by the culling of herds in the Alps. The UK has banned the import of French cheeses made with unpasteurised milk because of the Lumpy Skin Disease outbreak (and also the import of Italian unpasteurised cheeses, since cases of the virus have also been reported in Italy). Advertisement Although the cheese is not harmful to humans, the UK's agriculture ministry Defra says the measure is to protect British cattle, who could theoretically contract the virus through eating French cheese. This affects all French cheeses that are made with unpasteurised milk, not only those from the infection zones, and includes some of the most famous cheeses such as Roquefort and Tomme. The cheeses can still be safely consumed in France, or the rest of the EU.
