Montreal girl allegedly killed by father was drowned, initial autopsy finds
An autopsy has found that a nine-year-old Montreal girl allegedly killed by her father over the weekend was drowned.
The preliminary findings of the autopsy, which were released on Tuesday by New York State Police, found Melina Frattolin died by asphyxia due to drowning and her death was a homicide.
The results will have to be confirmed by further laboratory testing.
Melina's body was found Sunday in the shallow water of a pond in Ticonderoga, N.Y., about 50 kilometres east of Lake George, near the New York-Vermont border. Her father, 45-year-old Montrealer Luciano Frattolin, was charged on Monday with second-degree murder and concealment of a human corpse.
He appeared at the Ticonderoga town court on Monday. A not guilty plea was entered on his behalf at his arraignment, according to court officials. His case is expected to return to court on Friday.
Father 'fabricated' abduction: police
In a news conference on Monday following Frattolin's arrest, New York State Police outlined the timeline of events.
They say Frattolin first reported his daughter's disappearance to local police at around 10 p.m. last Saturday while they were travelling in the United States. An Amber Alert was triggered.
Police say he told investigators that he'd left his car to urinate in a wooded area and that his daughter was gone when he returned. He reported a white van fleeing the scene southbound.
In a subsequent interview, he mentioned two unknown men who forced Melina into the white van.
New York State Police confirmed that the father had "fabricated the initial report of the abduction."
'She will be one of us'
Details about how Melina died were released just hours before people gathered for a vigil at Percy Thompson Centennial Park in Ticonderoga — a small town of about 4,700 people located about 200 kilometres south of Montreal.
There were speeches and solemn music, while candles were lit and people joined together in prayer.
With her voice shaking, Bridgette Cruz, a Ticonderoga resident who organized the vigil, told the crowd that "no child should be left on the side of the road."
"If this is where her sweet soul was found, then this is her soul's resting place," Cruz said. "She will be one of us."
Prior to the event, Cruz told CBC News the vigil was meant to highlight the collective grief felt by people, including parents, on both sides of the border.
"I feel like we kind of need a little closure here in this town for her," she said.
Photogallery | Vigil for Melina Frattolin held in Ticonderoga, N.Y.
Open Full Embed in New Tab Loading external pages may require significantly more data usage than loading CBC Lite story pages.
Police seek public's help
In addition to the preliminary autopsy findings, police released images of a grey 2024 Toyota Prius, the car in which the father and daughter travelled.
They are urging anyone who saw it to contact authorities by calling 518-873-2750 or emailing crimetip@troopers.ny.gov.
They said they were specifically looking for people who may have come across the car driving in the areas of I-87 north between exits 28 and 20 on Saturday evening.
Details of Frattolin's financial situation began to surface on Monday.
He owes more than $150,000 to Scotiabank, according to two separate court cases. The bank alleges he entered into credit agreements between 2023 and 2024 related to his business, Gambella Coffee.
Frattolin is also seeking more than $115,000 in damages from business partners whom he says he entrusted to run an Airbnb on Bernard Street in Montreal in 2022, according to court documents.
On Monday, police said the investigation had not yet uncovered a possible motive for the alleged murder.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


CTV News
2 hours ago
- CTV News
Two people, including three-year-old, die in separate Ontario drownings Saturday: Police
An Ontario Provincial Police (OPP) patch is seen in Ottawa, on Sunday, Sept. 29, 2024. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Spencer Colby Two people, including a three-year-old, died in separate drownings in Ontario on Saturday, as one expert warns that July often sees the highest number of drownings in Canadian water. Ontario Provincial Police are investigating after emergency services were called to Mille Roches Beach in Long Sault around 5:45 p.m. regarding a child with no vital signs. A statement from police said off-duty medical professionals were attempting to resuscitate the child who was rushed to the hospital and later pronounced dead. Separately, police said emergency services responded to a residence on River Road East in Wasaga Beach at approximately 1:05 p.m. after reports of a missing kayaker. They said a 24-year-old man from Toronto had been kayaking with two others when their boat overturned. The Wasaga Beach Fire Department located the man and started resuscitation efforts before he was taken to hospital and later pronounced dead. Neither of the identities were released out of respect for the families. Police are also investigating the death of another three-year-old who drowned at Sandbanks Provincial Park on Thursday. OPP at the time said the number of drownings in eastern Ontario this year is more than double what it was by this time in 2024. Stephanie Bakalar, a spokesperson for Lifesaving Society, said in an interview that July is often the month with the highest number of drownings across the country as people look to cool down amid hotter temperatures, with most instances occurring in natural bodies of water. Saturday marked the final day of Drowning Prevention Week in Canada, and Bakalar offered some general tips for staying safe around the water. 'Depending on the different age groups, we have slightly different risk factors, but generally pretty much the same things,' she said. Bakalar said that swimming or boating alone is a significant risk factor for both older and younger adults. For those above the age of 65, she said about 70 per cent of drowning deaths happen while individuals are swimming alone. For children under the age of five, she said, drowning most often occurs while 'supervision was either absent or distracted.' 'I think it's really important for especially parents and caregivers, anyone who's taking kids near the water, to understand that drowning is fast and it is silent,' Bakalar said. She said someone supervising a child should be within an arm's reach and remain hyper vigilant. 'If you can't get to your child in a moment, if you cannot reach out and grab them, you are too far away from them, and the unthinkable can happen that quickly,' Bakalar said. When boating, she said it is always important to wear a life-jacket. 'About 90 per cent of the drowning deaths in Ontario, specifically, while people were boating, which includes powerboats, canoes, and kayaks. the victims were not wearing life-jackets,' Bakalar said. Staying sober when swimming or supervising someone else can increase safety, according to Bakalar. She also noted that swimming in a lifeguard-supervised setting can help people stay safe as they look to cool off amid hotter temperatures. 'We are never immune to drowning if we don't take layers of protection. So it's knowing how to swim. It's wearing the life-jacket. It's being with someone else,' Bakalar said. This report by The Canadian Press was first published July 27, 2025. Daniel Johnson, The Canadian Press


CBC
6 hours ago
- CBC
Montreal police investigating death of 52-year-old man in Saint-Léonard
Montreal police are investigating the death of a 52-year-old man on Sunday in Montreal's Saint-Léonard borough. Earlier in the day, police said the death was considered suspicious but later confirmed it was a homicide. It is believed that there was a break-in at a residence at around 4:30 a.m. near where the victim was found, said Montreal police spokesperson Caroline Chèvrefils. A suspect, a 31-year-old man, was arrested nearby in connection with break-in and transported to an investigation centre for questioning, Chèvrefils said. He was scheduled to appear by videoconference at the Court of Quebec on Sunday afternoon. Chèvrefils stated that the break-in could possibly be related to the man's death, but that it is too early to confirm. The investigation is ongoing and no arrest has yet been made in connection with the homicide. This is the 23rd homicide in Montreal since the beginning of the year.


CTV News
6 hours ago
- CTV News
Montreal police investigating 23rd homicide after man stabbed and killed
Montreal Watch Montreal police are investigating the 23rd homicide on the island after a 52-year-old man was stabbed and killed in Saint-Leonard.