
SST on private healthcare may drive up cost
Gleneagles Hospital Johor chief executive officer and regional chief executive officer of Southern and Eastern IHH Malaysia, Dr Kamal Amzan, said that while the government maintains the tax targets medical tourists and expatriates, its ripple effects may land much closer to home.
"Healthcare is not made up of standalone bills. It's an ecosystem held together by hundreds of interdependent services," Dr Kamal said.
"By taxing services like cleaning, linen supply, lab logistics and security, which are integral to hospital operations — you are essentially taxing the cost of care itself," he told the New Straits Times.
These costs are not peripheral. They form the architecture of safe, modern healthcare.
Yet under the current tax framework, many contracted support services are now subject to SST — a move that could compound financial pressures on hospitals already grappling with medical inflation, wage hikes and post-Covid service recovery.
"Hospitals facing slimmer margins may resort to fee increases, administrative charges, or cuts in services to stay afloat. This isn't reform — it's erosion," said Dr Kamal.
This policy arrives at a time when the cost of private healthcare in Malaysia has already outpaced wage growth, with a recorded 12 per cent increase last year alone. In many hospitals, margins are tightening even as expectations for quality and safety rise.
"We are taxing the scaffolding of care while pretending the house will still stand," he added.
Contrary to popular belief, private hospitals are not the exclusive domain of the wealthy. Middle-income families often rely on them to avoid long queues at public hospitals. Employers turn to private facilities to minimise workplace absenteeism. Many cancer patients move between public and private care as public oncology services buckle under rising demand.
"Private hospitals are the pressure valve for an overstretched public system. When access narrows in the private sector due to rising costs, patients will inevitably default to public hospitals — and they're already under immense strain," said Dr Kamal.
To avoid that outcome, Dr Kamal urges the government to exempt core hospital services — such as linen supply, lab transport, cleaning and security — from SST when provided to licensed healthcare facilities.
"These aren't luxuries. They're the minimum conditions for safe care," he said.
The argument isn't about shielding providers from taxes. It's about aligning policy with national goals. The government is trying to rein in medical inflation. Yet this tax expansion works in the opposite direction — quietly raising costs, eroding efficiency and ultimately, reducing access.
"We should be reducing the cost to deliver care, not layering it. Taxing the backbone of hospital operations while asking the industry to absorb payor discounts is a contradiction we can't afford."
While the government has maintained that medicines and services for Malaysians remain tax-free, stakeholders warn that this new layer of indirect cost will ultimately find its way into patient bills — especially for those on the margins of affordability.
"If we're serious about protecting the rakyat from rising healthcare costs, then exempting services that keep hospitals running isn't charity — it's common sense," said Dr Kamal.
Because no hospital can deliver modern care without its invisible hands — the ones who clean, sterilise, transport and guard its patients and staff.
"We've exempted apples from tax. Maybe that's fitting," Dr Kamal added wryly.
"After all, an apple a day keeps the doctor away — especially when seeing one gets more expensive," he added.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


The Star
8 hours ago
- The Star
Japan discards state-acquired Covid-19 drugs worth US$1.6bil
TOKYO: (Bernama-Kyodo) The Japanese government discarded Covid-19 oral medicines believed to be worth around 240 billion yen (US$1.6 billion) in the fiscal year through March as they had passed their expiry dates, Kyodo News Agency reported, citing health ministry officials on Wednesday (July 16). While the exact purchase price remains unclear, the value was calculated in accordance with current prices. The amount is enough to treat some 2.5 million people. The government acquired the oral drugs at the height of the coronavirus pandemic and provided them free of charge to hospitals and clinics nationwide. But many of them were unused after Covid-19 was downgraded to the same category as seasonal influenza in May 2023, which required people to pay for Covid-19 treatment. Drugmakers had also started general distribution of Covid-19 medicine in Japan themselves. A Ministry of Health, Labour and Welfare official said offering the drugs to other countries was considered but legally difficult. Among the two million doses of Pfizer Inc.'s nirmatrelvir and 1.6 million doses of Merck & Co.'s molnupiravir procured by the government, about 1.75 million doses of nirmatrelvir and some 780,000 doses of molnupiravir were disposed of, according to the ministry. The government also secured two million doses of Shionogi & Co.'s ensitrelvir but about 1.77 million of them are unused, the ministry said. They are expected to be discarded after they reach their expiration dates starting next fiscal year. - Bernama-Kyodo


The Star
9 hours ago
- The Star
Getting 'creative' to reform nation's healthcare: Dr Dzul defends Rakan KKM initiative
PETALING JAYA: The controversial Rakan KKM initiative is an attempt to creatively reform the nation's healthcare system, says Datuk Seri Dr Dzulkefly Ahmad. The Health Minister said that due to government's budgetary constraints, he had no choice but to get "creative". 'If you can't give me the resource, allow me to be resourceful. 'We want to retain our specialists, reduce the bleeding, and invest back into public facilities. 'I can't keep asking for more budget - so I'm unlocking value through reforms,' said Dzulkefly. Rakan KKM is a new initiative by the Health Ministry to introduce a "premium economy" or paid service within public hospitals and clinics. Various quarters have voiced fears that the incorporation of Rakan KKM Sdn Bhd signalled a move towards the privatisation of public health services. Dzulkefly was speaking at a launch of the book titled 'Crisis and Community: Covid-19 in Malaysia' at Gerakbudaya here on Sunday (July 27). The book is a compilation of essays on the Covid-19 crisis by all levels of society, edited by Bridget Welsh. At the forum, Dzulkefly insisted that health security must be dealt with 'the same urgency as we defend our borders". 'That means sustained investment in our healthcare workforce. 'I am introducing a "game-changing" initiative where public facilities collaborate with private sector specialists, likely under a GLIC (government-linked investment company) model. 'The idea is to generate revenue through elective services (non-emergency), possibly in specialised private wings within public hospitals. 'Funds generated would cross-subsidise public health services and infrastructure,' said Dzulkefly. He also stated that Covid-19 had shown that the healthcare system has inadequate social safety nets for vulnerable groups such as the elderly and the mentally ill. 'We must never again frame public health and economic survival as rigidly opposed choices. 'Future crisis governance must be targeted, empathetic, data-informed, and inclusive. 'We must design interventions that are community-driven and flexible - not one-size-fits-all,' said Dzulkefly, revealing that Malaysia's struggle to get vaccines earlier in the pandemic exposed a global system skewed in favour of the rich.


The Star
9 hours ago
- The Star
Covid-19 exposed our healthcare system's weakness, say doctors
PETALING JAYA: The Covid-19 pandemic has revealed the fragility of the country's healthcare services, says consultant paediatrician and child disability activist Datuk Dr Amar-Singh HSS. 'It is not that we did not know that our health services had been slowly decaying for decades, but we were not allowed to speak publicly about it and always 'today, you will have to manage with what you have'. 'During the height of the pandemic, we experienced desperate cries for help to find an ICU bed for their family members. The support for carers was weak, equipment and resources were limited even in non-pandemic times, stretched thin. 'Some doctors placed their children with grandparents and did not see them for months,' said Dr Amar at a launch of the book titled 'Crisis and Community: Covid-19 in Malaysia' at Gerakbudaya here Sunday (July 27). The book is a compilation of essays on the Covid-19 crisis by all levels of society, edited by Bridget Welsh. Speaking further at the event, which was attended by Health Minister Datuk Seri Dr Dzulkefly Ahmad, Dr Amar said that there must be better preparation for the next pandemic by placing greater emphasis on building our institutional services, especially health, education and social services. Fellow panellist Ampang Hospital paediatrician Dr Tan Hui Siu narrated how the medical officers and healthcare workers trudged through the pandemic and had to make do with what they had as frontliners. 'We were giving our best in caring, but also to provide compassionate care and treatment that soothes and comforts everyone. 'So there was a gap where we were actually preparing those guidelines and with some of the clinicians, but by the time they were implemented, it was inadequate,' said Dr Tan. She talked of how she struggled to cope with the deaths of patients younger than her and how her teams had to care for patients on their deathbeds alone due to the lockdown. Meanwhile, virologist and policy analyst Dr Lyana Khairuddin called for better education on the vaccine naysayers as well as more investments to be made into vaccine research and development. She labelled the frantic search for vaccines during the pandemic as the 'Vaccine Hunger Games'. 'The Hunger Games aside, there was also the fight to actually get a slot to be jabbed,' said Dr Lyana. She said that the pandemic revealed the need for more science education among Malaysians. 'There are still people saying 'I have survived the pandemic and I am not vaccinated and I am okay and healthy'. Then, there are those who say that 'my mother died because she got the vaccine',' said Lyana. She stressed that there must be more conversations on why vaccines were given during the pandemic and more critical thinking so that people do not fall easily for 'popular traditional cures' during the next pandemic.