Man who built house on his driveway after getting permission for a garage is forced to tear it down
Man who built house on his driveway after getting permission for a garage is forced to tear it down
Madam Pal Singh was given the go-ahead to build a single-storey garage at his semi detached home in 2019 - but a small two-storey house was constructed on the driveway instead
Madam Pal Singh built a small home on his driveway
(Image: Joseph Walshe / SWNS )
A man who built a house on his driveway after receiving planning permission for just a garage has been forced to demolish it, ending a peculiar six-year dispute which one neighbour described as a "long-running saga".
Madam Pal Singh was granted permission in 2019 to build a single-storey garage at his semi-detached property on Vaughton Street in Highgate, Birmingham. However, planning officials were left scratching their heads when they found a small two-storey house built on the driveway in October 2022 instead.
Despite claiming the differences from the approved plans were only 'minor' during an appeal, Mr Singh was instructed to tear down the unauthorised building.
The family insisted the structure would remain as they were utilising the 8.7m by 4.7m building as a gym. Yet, recent photographs reveal that Mr Singh has now transformed the edifice into the initially sanctioned 5.3m by 4.6m garage.
The house has now been knocked down and changed into a garage
(Image: Anita Maric / SWNS )
Local residents have expressed their relief that the "bizarre saga" has concluded after enduring years of construction work on their road. A neighbour, preferring to remain anonymous, commented: "We're glad it's finally all over now, it has been going on for years.", reports the Mirror.
Article continues below
"I dread to think what it has cost the poor bloke. To build a house, knock it down and then build a garage instead, must have cost tens of thousands of pounds at least. But he's only got himself to blame, I don't know how he thought he was ever going to get away with it."
One local resident commented, "The building work has been a bit of a pain but I'm just happy we don't have to look at that eyesore anymore. It's been a very bizarre, long-running saga."
The small house was being used as a gym
(Image: Joseph Walshe / SWNS )
However, another neighbour was sympathetic. They said: "I feel a bit sorry for him to be honest. Yes it wasn't what was entirely agreed, but it looked smart. And some of the houses around here are much more run down." Love dreamy Welsh homes? Sign up to our newsletter here .
"You would have thought they could have come to a bit of compromise with him to save a lot of time and money."
Planning permission had initially been granted for a garage, but the constructed building exceeded the approved size by several metres.
Planning Inspector Thomas Shields said in his report: "The appellant's case is that the building already benefits from planning permission granted by the council in 2019."
"He argues that although there are differences between the approved plans for the garage and the appeal building they are minor differences. The approved plans for the garage show a single storey detached garage with a footprint of 5.3m x 4.6m and a height of 3.6m."
"It was also shown having a standard garage door to the front and no windows on any elevation. In comparison with the approved garage the appeal building has a footprint of approximately 8.7m x 4.7m and a height of 5.3m Consequently, it is substantially larger than the approved building. It is not a minor difference."
Article continues below
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
South Wales Argus
12 hours ago
- South Wales Argus
Call for tribute to Terrence Higgins in Haverfordwest
Tuesday June 10 marks 80 years since Terrence Higgins was born in Haverfordwest, and he spent almost half of his short life in the town. His name is now synonymous with the fight against HIV and AIDS, with his partner and a friend setting up the Terrence Higgins Trust following his death at the age of 37 in July 1982, to campaign to counter prejudice against those who have the disease. As Haverfordwest Town Museum stages a new display to mark what would have been the 80th birthday of Terrence Higgins, its curator, Dr Simon Hancock said: 'I would love to see a blue plaque in his memory put up in the town. Terrence Higgins as a young man. (Image: Terrence Higgins Trust) "He was an important campaigner and social activist who deserves to be better remembered in his home town. "The national charity which bears his name has helped countless thousands of people since its inception. ' Dr Simon Hancock and Tracey Bartlett, volunteer co-ordinator Cymru for the Terrence Higgins Trust are pictured with the two portraits. (Image: Haverfordwest Town Museum) A representative of the Terrence Higgins Trust has visited the museum to present two pieces of artwork relating to his life of Terrence Higgins, who spent five years in the Royal Navy and later worked for Hansard and as a bartender in Soho, and was known to family and friends as Terry. Dr Hancock said the museum was 'very honoured' to receive the two pieces of artwork. One is a donation from the Terrence Higgins Trust to the museum - a portrait of Terry during his school days in Haverfordwest by contemporary Welsh artist Nathan Wyburn. This is a signed limited edition print. Artist Nathan Wyburn created the original portrait in 2022. (Image: PA) The original was created to mark the charity's 40th anniversary in 2022 and the image was built up with red and green stamps in the shape of the charity's heart logo. The other is a coloured pencil portrait, The Three Ages of Terry (2023) by Curtis Holder. This shows Terrence at three life stages, a navy teen, young man and towards the end of his life. The portrait has been on display at the National Portrait Gallery and is loaned to Haverfordwest Museum s until January 2026. The items were presented by Tracey Bartlett, volunteer co-ordinator Cymru for the Terrence Higgins Trust.
Wales Online
13 hours ago
- Wales Online
Explosion in Welsh town sees pub and chippy shut and people left in darkness
Explosion in Welsh town sees pub and chippy shut and people left in darkness People reported a 'big bang' and smoke was seen rising National Grid at the scene of the incident in Gorseinon on Monday night (Image: Michael Tiley ) Businesses were forced to close and households were left without power after residents heard a "big bang" and saw smoke rising from a substation. People living in the Gorseinon community of Swansea reported the incident in Lime Street shortly before 5pm on Monday night, June 9. As well as causing a power outage for residents, local businesses were also affected including Wetherspoons restaurant, The Mardy Inn, which was forced to close until the issue was resolved. A spokesman for Wetherspoons said: 'A power cut occurred at 5.48pm last night (Monday) with the pub, the High Street and surrounding areas all without power until 8.50pm. As a result, The Mardy Inn had to close but re-opened, as normal, at 9pm.' Never miss a Swansea story by signing up to our newsletter here . Some people hoping to get a takeaway for dinner were also affected, with Roma Fish Bar confirming it was among those forced to close from 5pm until the morning. SOS Shelters Wales, a food bank based in Gorseinon, which now gives out 4,500 meals every week, decided to welcome anyone affected to its base at 63 Lime Street, serving up teas, coffee and hot food. Michael Tiley, who runs the not-for-profit community organisation with his son, David, said: "A lot of people rang me up because we are right next to the substation. I was told there was a massive bang there and all the power was off. Article continues below "I shot up there just to double check everything was alright, and when I got there, I could see a lot of smoke coming from it. I contacted the fire brigade which came and I think shut the whole thing down. There was about 15 National Grid vans there then. "I popped up and asked how long they thought it was going to be. They said about three to four hours, and I thought, right, I'm going to open our gates and prepare hot food, teas and coffees for the workers and anyone affected in the community who wanted to pop along. "I make my own chicken curry, pies and chips, and I served that up too using power from our generator. "I must have been there until 11pm. I stayed there so I could give all the working men curry and chips, or pie and chips, or coffees and teas. I didn't charge for it, it's just something I wanted to do. "The catering side of what we do, that's what it's for, and we do a lot more with it too. I've got about 25 volunteers now - we do seven days a week and we're pushing out around 4,500 meals a week." A footpath was closed as National Grid worked to restore power (Image: Michael Tiley ) A National Grid Electricity Distribution spokeswoman said: 'A fault on our underground network caused a power cut affecting 87 properties on Monday. We'd like to thank customers for their patience and understanding as our engineers made repairs as quickly as possible. 'Anyone who experiences a power cut should call us on 105. Customers who need extra help and support should sign-up to our free priority services register so they can receive additional support during a power cut.' A spokesman for Mid and West Wales Fire and Rescue Service said: "At 5.02pm on Monday, June 9, the Mid and West Wales Fire and Rescue Service crews from Pontarddulais and Morriston fire station were called to an incident at Lime Street in Gorseinon. Article continues below "Crews responded following an explosion at a substation. Crews assisted National Grid personnel to isolate the substation and to manage traffic at the scene. "Crews left the scene at 5.56pm."
Western Telegraph
20 hours ago
- Western Telegraph
Call for tribute to Terrence Higgins in Haverfordwest
Tuesday June 10 marks 80 years since Terrence Higgins was born in Haverfordwest, and he spent almost half of his short life in the town. His name is now synonymous with the fight against HIV and AIDS, with his partner and a friend setting up the Terrence Higgins Trust following his death at the age of 37 in July 1982, to campaign to counter prejudice against those who have the disease. As Haverfordwest Town Museum stages a new display to mark what would have been the 80th birthday of Terrence Higgins, its curator, Dr Simon Hancock said: 'I would love to see a blue plaque in his memory put up in the town. Terrence Higgins as a young man. (Image: Terrence Higgins Trust) "He was an important campaigner and social activist who deserves to be better remembered in his home town. "The national charity which bears his name has helped countless thousands of people since its inception. ' Dr Simon Hancock and Tracey Bartlett, volunteer co-ordinator Cymru for the Terrence Higgins Trust are pictured with the two portraits. (Image: Haverfordwest Town Museum) A representative of the Terrence Higgins Trust has visited the museum to present two pieces of artwork relating to his life of Terrence Higgins, who spent five years in the Royal Navy and later worked for Hansard and as a bartender in Soho, and was known to family and friends as Terry. Dr Hancock said the museum was 'very honoured' to receive the two pieces of artwork. One is a donation from the Terrence Higgins Trust to the museum - a portrait of Terry during his school days in Haverfordwest by contemporary Welsh artist Nathan Wyburn. This is a signed limited edition print. Artist Nathan Wyburn created the original portrait in 2022. (Image: PA) The original was created to mark the charity's 40th anniversary in 2022 and the image was built up with red and green stamps in the shape of the charity's heart logo. The other is a coloured pencil portrait, The Three Ages of Terry (2023) by Curtis Holder. This shows Terrence at three life stages, a navy teen, young man and towards the end of his life. The portrait has been on display at the National Portrait Gallery and is loaned to Haverfordwest Museum s until January 2026. The items were presented by Tracey Bartlett, volunteer co-ordinator Cymru for the Terrence Higgins Trust.
