Man who built house on his driveway after getting permission for a garage is forced to tear it down
Man who built house on his driveway after getting permission for a garage is forced to tear it down
Madam Pal Singh was given the go-ahead to build a single-storey garage at his semi detached home in 2019 - but a small two-storey house was constructed on the driveway instead
Madam Pal Singh built a small home on his driveway
(Image: Joseph Walshe / SWNS )
A man who built a house on his driveway after receiving planning permission for just a garage has been forced to demolish it, ending a peculiar six-year dispute which one neighbour described as a "long-running saga".
Madam Pal Singh was granted permission in 2019 to build a single-storey garage at his semi-detached property on Vaughton Street in Highgate, Birmingham. However, planning officials were left scratching their heads when they found a small two-storey house built on the driveway in October 2022 instead.
Despite claiming the differences from the approved plans were only 'minor' during an appeal, Mr Singh was instructed to tear down the unauthorised building.
The family insisted the structure would remain as they were utilising the 8.7m by 4.7m building as a gym. Yet, recent photographs reveal that Mr Singh has now transformed the edifice into the initially sanctioned 5.3m by 4.6m garage.
The house has now been knocked down and changed into a garage
(Image: Anita Maric / SWNS )
Local residents have expressed their relief that the "bizarre saga" has concluded after enduring years of construction work on their road. A neighbour, preferring to remain anonymous, commented: "We're glad it's finally all over now, it has been going on for years.", reports the Mirror.
Article continues below
"I dread to think what it has cost the poor bloke. To build a house, knock it down and then build a garage instead, must have cost tens of thousands of pounds at least. But he's only got himself to blame, I don't know how he thought he was ever going to get away with it."
One local resident commented, "The building work has been a bit of a pain but I'm just happy we don't have to look at that eyesore anymore. It's been a very bizarre, long-running saga."
The small house was being used as a gym
(Image: Joseph Walshe / SWNS )
However, another neighbour was sympathetic. They said: "I feel a bit sorry for him to be honest. Yes it wasn't what was entirely agreed, but it looked smart. And some of the houses around here are much more run down." Love dreamy Welsh homes? Sign up to our newsletter here .
"You would have thought they could have come to a bit of compromise with him to save a lot of time and money."
Planning permission had initially been granted for a garage, but the constructed building exceeded the approved size by several metres.
Planning Inspector Thomas Shields said in his report: "The appellant's case is that the building already benefits from planning permission granted by the council in 2019."
"He argues that although there are differences between the approved plans for the garage and the appeal building they are minor differences. The approved plans for the garage show a single storey detached garage with a footprint of 5.3m x 4.6m and a height of 3.6m."
"It was also shown having a standard garage door to the front and no windows on any elevation. In comparison with the approved garage the appeal building has a footprint of approximately 8.7m x 4.7m and a height of 5.3m Consequently, it is substantially larger than the approved building. It is not a minor difference."
Article continues below
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Wales Online
9 hours ago
- Wales Online
'Ambitious and bright' hiker died after falling from Welsh peak as friends watched on in horror
'Ambitious and bright' hiker died after falling from Welsh peak as friends watched on in horror Maria Eftimova died after falling nearly 65ft from Tryfan in Eryri Maria Eftimova tragically lost her life after falling from Tryfan in Eryri (Image: UGC ) An "ambitious and bright" hiker died after she tripped and fell from mountain in Eryri, an inquest heard. Witnesses at the inquest into the death Maria Eftimova recounted the tragic last moments of her life before she fell from Tryfan on February 22, 2025. One witness told the inquest that the 28-year-old fell off the rockface, flying over him as he "froze". Another witness said Ms Eftimova was in a "freefall". It is understood that the Ms Eftimova, who worked as a civil engineer, fell nearly 65 feet to her death, suffering severe head injuries. At an inquest hearing in Caernarfon, senior coroner for north west Wales, Kate Robertson concluded Ms Eftimova's death was accidental, reports North Wales Live. The inquest was told that Ms Eftimova was born in Sofia, Bulgaria, was a British Citizen who lived in St Helens, and had graduated from the University of Salford. Don't miss a court report by signing up to our crime newsletter here Harry Jones, who was hiking with Ms Eftimova, said in a statement that he had joined a group of 20 hikers before they set off up Tryfan at 9am that day. Tributes have since been paid to the 'ambitious, bright and cherished' woman Article continues below While on the hike, Mr Jones and Ms Eftimova, along with another five hikers, split from the rest of the group attempting to take a harder route to the summit. The rest of the group chose to take an easier route for the summit. Mr Jones said: "We travelled in single file, moving from ledge to ledge, once the person in front had vacated it." Another hiker, named Neil Oakes was ahead followed by Maria, and then Mr jones at the back. Mr Jones said: "I could see on one particular ledge Maria stopped in order to get a handhold. To pull herself up. I was six feet below her, to the left. "She swung her right leg up to pull herself up. I asked 'Got it well?' and she said 'I think so'." However, Mr Jones said that he then saw Ms Eftimova "flying over me" going down the mountain side. Mr Jones added that he "completely froze". The inquest was told that the other hikers then came down, lowering Ms Eftimova to a safer ledge, and called 999. One of the fellow hikers continued to give CPR to Ms Eftimova until Ogwen Valley Mountain Rescue Team (OVMRT) members arrived followed by a helicopter. Another fellow hiker, Neil Oakes, said in a statement he was also part of the small group which had chosen to go through the Grade 2 route. Mr Oakes was ahead of Ms Eftimova. Mr Oakes said: "I turned and saw Ms Eftimova tumbling through the air below me. She was already in freefall. I knew there was going to be an impact on the rocky outcrop below so I turned away for a split second. I was shouting 'No, no, no, no.' "When I turned back she was on the ledge below. I knew that it was serious. (Another hiker above) said 'What?" and I said 'She's gone. She's fallen'. I was in shock." Consultant histopathologist Dr Muhammad Zain Mehdi carried out a post mortem examination at Ysbyty Glan Clwyd. The doctor found that Ms Eftimova sustained severe head injuries. He said in a report that there was external damage to the brain including the brain stem which led to death. Dr Mehdi concluded that Ms Eftimova died due to a laceration to the brain, caused by a fractured skull due to a fall. The coroner concluded that Ms Eftimova's death was accidental. The coroner said: "It seems that Maria was scrambling with others when she has unintentionally and unexpectedly fallen and during the course of that fall she has sustained the injuries which have sadly led to her death." The coroner described Ms Eftimova as "bright and conscientious" and extended her sincere condolences to Ms Eftimova's family, who had joined the hearing via a video link with a Bulgarian interpreter, and her friends. The inquest had been told earlier that Ms Eftimova was a civil engineer for the Costain group, while her father Rosen Eftimov had stated that she had "snowboarded intensely", had been a surfer, and marathon runner. Ms Eftimova had trained in intensive swimming, winning awards and distinctions. This year in January, she undertook a glacier climbing course in Norway and had also practiced pole dancing, her father said. Following her death, people paid loving tributes to the "ambitious, bright and cherished" woman online. A fundraiser to raise £15,000 to bring Ms Eftimova back to her family in Bulgaria was also launched, garnering £19,389 in donations. The fundraiser's organiser Victoria Critchley said on the fundraising site: "Maria was an ambitious, bright and cherished 28-year-old, whose vibrant personality, energy and aura touched and uplifted all around her. She had a passion for engineering, having studied civil engineering at the University of Salford and a love for extreme sports. Article continues below "Her biggest passion being snowboarding, which she was super excited for and looking forward to doing again on her upcoming trip to Austria. She had an insatiable thirst for life and exploring our world's beauty. Tragically, she was taken from her family far far far too soon!"
Daily Mirror
15 hours ago
- Daily Mirror
Free school meal changes in full from today's Spending Review
The Government has announced that every pupil whose household is on Universal Credit will get free school meals from the 2026/27 academic year Hundreds of thousands more children will be eligible for free school meals in England from September 2026 following a major change to the rules. We explain who exactly will get the support, as Rachel Reeves delivers her Spending Review in the House of Commons. It marks a major victory for the Mirror's long-running Free School Meals for All campaign Nearly 2.1 million pupils - almost one in four of all pupils - in England were eligible for free school meals in January 2024. Free school meals - who gets them? The rules for free school meals depends on what part of the UK you live in. If you're in England, your child gets free school meals if they are in reception class, year 1 or year 2. After that, they are eligible only if you claim certain benefits, including Universal Credit and Child Tax Credit. Under current rules, households in England claiming Universal Credit must earn below £7,400 a year, after tax and not including benefits, to qualify for free school meals. But the Government has announced that every pupil whose household is on Universal Credit will get free school meals from the 2026/27 academic year. What about other parts of the UK? In Scotland, children from primary one to primary five get free school meals. If you're in Wales, all primary school pupils get free school meals. In Northern Ireland, free school meals are not given automatically - instead all parents claiming benefits have to apply. If your child goes to private school, you don't normally receive free school meals. How do I apply for free school meals? Depending on where you live, you have to apply through your local council, or directly through the Government. You may be asked to provide proof of your income or benefits. Here are the links for each part of the UK: England Scotland Wales Northern Ireland What has Labour said? The Department for Education says 500,000 more children will benefit from a free meal every school day as a result of the expansion, saving parents nearly £500 every year. Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer said: 'Feeding more children every day, for free, is one of the biggest interventions we can make to put more money in parents' pockets, tackle the stain of poverty, and set children up to learn. 'This expansion is a truly historic moment for our country, helping families who need it most and delivering our Plan for Change to give every child, no matter their background, the same chance to succeed.' Education Secretary Bridget Phillipson said: 'It is the moral mission of this government to tackle the stain of child poverty, and today this government takes a giant step towards ending it with targeted support that puts money back in parents' pockets. 'From free school meals to free breakfast clubs, breaking the cycle of child poverty is at the heart of our Plan for Change to cut the unfair link between background and success. 'We believe that background shouldn't mean destiny. Today's historic step will help us to deliver excellence everywhere, for every child and give more young people the chance to get on in life.'
South Wales Argus
a day ago
- South Wales Argus
How Jayne's Baby Bank helped this struggling Pontypool mum
32-year-old Samantha Arnold is a single mum to her three-year-old daughter Kiara. When she first became a mum Samantha was struggling to afford essentials for Kiara. Not knowing where to turn or what to do, Samantha eventually came across Jayne's Baby Bank on Crane Street. Samantha Arnold volunteer at Jayne's Baby Bank with daughter Kiara (Image: NQ) Samantha said: 'I'm a single parent, my daughters now three, my daughter was about 18 months at the time it was coming up to winter and she jumped a size in her clothes. 'I was just really, really, struggling. I'd been to citizens advice for help and they helped me with food, gas and electric, but there was no help out there for nappies so I just happened to find these guys on Facebook and I thought the worst they could say is no.' Thankfully for Samantha she received the support she needed. She added: 'I popped down and met Jayne myself she said all I'd need is something in writing, and she allowed me to help myself to anything that would help my daughter at the time, and it was a really big help. 'A few weeks later I saw they were desperate for volunteers, and I just said I can help but I'll have to bring my little one with me and we've been here ever since.' Essential items for babies at Jayne's Bank Pontypool (Image: NQ) Almost 12,000 babies and children in poverty across Wales have been supported by baby banks in 2023 alone. This is according to data from the Baby Bank Alliance. The same report says that nearly one in three Welsh children have experience living in poverty (29%) since 2023 and baby banks have responded by giving families over 18,700 items such as warm clothes, books, baby toiletries and equipment. Stock at Jayne's Baby Bank Pontypool (Image: NQ) Samantha had the following to say to anyone struggling. 'Pop in. "We are all mums. We've all needed help one way or another. We also support anyone with learning difficulties. You're welcome to volunteer with us. 'We need a wider range of wider volunteers here. 'If you do up to eight hours you get a £20 stock allowance and it's a great help.' Jayne's Baby Bank has shops in Pontypool, Risca Caerphilly and Blackwood. The business is currently looking for volunteers.
